bija 0 Report post Posted April 21, 2006 Here is a question and answer: Question As I understand from Bhagavad Gita As It is, long before the Gita was spoken to Arjuna it was spoken to the sun god Vivasvan. At least 120,400,000 years ago. My question is: Was the Gita that was spoken to Arjuna and Vivasvan also the same Vedic knowledge that was imparted to Lord Brahma? Could you say that the Gita was also imparted to Lord Brahma? Answer The transcendental knowledge is so unlimited with infinite angles of vision that every time the unlimited Supreme Lord imparts it to someone, His instructions are unique and may not be the same. So even though, Lord Krishna imparted the knowledge of the Gita to the sun-god Vivasvan originally, it is not necessary that it was in the same form of 700 verses of the Gita which He instructed to Arjuna. The knowledge of Gita is eternal and it can be presented by the Lord with different verses and with different angles of vision everytime He desires to impart it to someone. Same is true for the Lord's instruction to Brahma in the beginning of the creation where He instructed the knowledge in the form of four verses found in the Shrimad Bhagavatam. And to Shrila Uddhava in the 11th Canto of the Shrimad Bhagavatam, the same knowledge is imparted in a different set of verses which is known as the Uddhava Gita. The Lord can never be expected to follow a stereotype method in imparting knowledge as He is fresh, unique and ever-expanding at every moment. Could a devotee kindly direct me where in the Bhagavatam these four verses actually are? Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
gHari 0 Report post Posted April 21, 2006 Perhaps one could start reading the questions here: <a href=http://vedabase.net/sb/2/9/5/en target=new>Srimad-Bhagavatam 2.9.5</a> as summarized in this purport excerpt from SB 2.9.31p:<BLOCKQUOTE><B>Lord BrahmA is the topmost devotee of the Lord within the universe, and therefore the Personality of Godhead replied to his four principal inquiries in four important statements, which are known as the original BhAgavatam in four verses. These were BrahmA's questions: (1) What are the forms of the Lord both in matter and in transcendence? (2) How are the different energies of the Lord working? (3) How does the Lord play with His different energies? (4) How may BrahmA be instructed to discharge the duty entrusted to Him?</b> The prelude to the answers is this verse under discussion, wherein the Lord informs BrahmA that knowledge of Him, the Supreme Absolute Truth, as it is stated in the revealed scriptures, is very subtle and cannot be understood unless one is self-realized by the grace of the Lord. The Lord says that BrahmA may take the answers as He explains them. This means that transcendental knowledge of the absolute Supreme Being can be known if it is made known by the Lord Himself. </BLOCKQUOTE> Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
gHari 0 Report post Posted April 21, 2006 In the verse 2.9.36 purport, Srila Prabhupada comments "The cream of Srimad-Bhagavatam in the foregoing four shlokas" suggesting that the four famous verses are 2.9.32-35. I trust everyone got that far, for the story is steeped with import, even before God answers our Lord Brahma. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
gHari 0 Report post Posted April 21, 2006 In Srimad-Bhagavatam Canto Eleven, Chapters Seven through Twenty-nine present the conversation between Krsna and Uddhava that is known as the Uddhava-gita: http://vedabase.net/sb/11/7/en SB 11.7: Lord Kṛṣṇa Instructs Uddhava SB 11.8: The Story of Pińgalā SB 11.9: Detachment from All that Is Material SB 11.10: The Nature of Fruitive Activity SB 11.11: The Symptoms of Conditioned and Liberated Living Entities SB 11.12: Beyond Renunciation and Knowledge SB 11.13: The Haḿsa-avatāra Answers the Questions of the Sons of Brahmā SB 11.14: Lord Kṛṣṇa Explains the Yoga System to Śrī Uddhava SB 11.15: Lord Kṛṣṇa's Description of Mystic Yoga Perfections SB 11.16: The Lord's Opulence SB 11.17: Lord Kṛṣṇa's Description of the Varṇāśrama System SB 11.18: Description of Varṇāśrama-dharma SB 11.19: The Perfection of Spiritual Knowledge SB 11.20: Pure Devotional Service Surpasses Knowledge and Detachment SB 11.21: Lord Kṛṣṇa's Explanation of the Vedic Path SB 11.22: Enumeration of the Elements of Material Creation SB 11.23: The Song of the Avantī Brāhmaṇa. SB 11.24: The Philosophy of Sāńkhya SB 11.25: The Three Modes of Nature and Beyond SB 11.26: The Aila-gītā SB 11.27: Lord Kṛṣṇa's Instructions on the Process of Deity Worship SB 11.28: Jñāna-yoga SB 11.29: Bhakti-yoga Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
gHari 0 Report post Posted April 21, 2006 govindam ādi-puruṣam tam aham bhajāmi .... I worship Govinda, the Primal Lord [by Lord Brahma] . Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
theist 1 Report post Posted April 21, 2006 I would like to see the Uddhava-gita itself in book form. I think it would be good for distribution. What do you think gHari? It seems so complete as a work unto itself. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
gHari 0 Report post Posted April 21, 2006 Yes, I look forward to gaining a deeper incite into the Bhagavad-gita from it. The parts I glanced at were incredible. What a treasure has fallen into our laps. SB 11.29.22: This process is the supreme intelligence of the intelligent and the cleverness of the most clever, for by following it one can in this very life make use of the temporary and unreal to achieve Me, the eternal reality. SB 11.29.23: Thus have I related to you — both in brief and in detail — a complete survey of the science of the Absolute Truth. Even for the demigods, this science is very difficult to comprehend. SB 11.29.24: I have repeatedly spoken this knowledge to you with clear reasoning. Anyone who properly understands it will become free from all doubts and attain liberation. SB 11.29.25: Anyone who fixes his attention on these clear answers to your questions will attain to the eternal, confidential goal of the Vedas — the Supreme Absolute Truth. SB 11.29.26: One who liberally disseminates this knowledge among My devotees is the bestower of the Absolute Truth, and to him I give My very own self. SB 11.29.27: He who loudly recites this supreme knowledge, which is the most lucid and purifying, becomes purified day by day, for he reveals Me to others with the lamp of transcendental knowledge. SB 11.29.28: Anyone who regularly listens to this knowledge with faith and attention, all the while engaging in My pure devotional service, will never become bound by the reactions of material work. SB 11.29.29: My dear friend Uddhava, have you now completely understood this transcendental knowledge? Are the confusion and lamentation that arose in your mind now dispelled? . SB 11.29.48: Thus Lord Kṛṣṇa, whose lotus feet are served by all great yoga masters, spoke to His devotee this nectarean knowledge, which comprises the entire ocean of spiritual bliss. Anyone within this universe who receives this narration with great faith is assured of liberation. SB 11.29.49 I offer my obeisances to that Supreme Personality of Godhead, the original and greatest of all beings, Lord Śrī Kṛṣṇa. He is the author of the Vedas, and just to destroy His devotees' fear of material existence, like a bee He has collected this nectarean essence of all knowledge and self-realization. Thus He has awarded to His many devotees this nectar from the ocean of bliss, and by His mercy they have drunk it. PURPORT Just as a bee extracts nectar from a flower without harming the flower, Lord Śrī Kṛṣṇa extracts the essence of all Vedic knowledge without disturbing the elaborate system of Vedic advancement. In other words, Lord Śrī Kṛṣṇa establishes Himself as the goal of Vedic knowledge without destroying preliminary, inferior processes that may be applicable to grossly materialistic men. Śrī Śukadeva Gosvāmī thus concludes by offering his obeisances to the spiritual master of the entire universe, Lord Śrī Kṛṣṇa. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
bija 0 Report post Posted April 21, 2006 Thank you gHari for explaining how to approach the reading from the above pastimes. I look forward over the coming days to study the verses and purports. Some years ago I was very fortunate to gain access to some sets of Srila Prabhupada's books. By joining this forum I am finding it a good way to read and study them more. Lately in my personal reading I decided to go back to reading some of his smaller books. Upon reading them lately I have begun to realise why people call AC Bhaktivedanta by the title His Divine Grace. I am sure you may have realised such things many years ago....bija. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
bija 0 Report post Posted April 22, 2006 I found the following on the opening page of Bhaktivinoda's book, Sri Krsna Samhita. Published by Vrajraj Press. om tat sat satyam param dhimahi The four original Bhagavatam verses jnanam parama-guhyam me Knowledge about Me as described in the scriptures is very confidential yavan aham I Myself in My eternal form = Direct perception of the Absolute Truth aham evasam evagre nanyad yat sad-asat param pascad aham yad etac ca yo 'vasisyeta so smy aham Brahma, it is I, the Personality of Godhead, who was existing before the creation, when there was nothing but Myself. Nor was there the material nature, the cause of this creation. That which you see now is also I, the Personality of Godhead, and after annihilation what remains will also be I, the Personality of Godhead. (1) ******************************************************* yad vijnana-samanvitam It has to be realized yatha-bavo My transcendental existence = Indirect perception of the Absolute Truth rte rtham yat pratiyeta na pratiyeta catmani tad vidyad atmano mayam yathabhaso yatha tamah O Brahma, whatever appears to be of any value, if it is without relation to Me, has no reality. Know it as My illusory energy, that reflection which appears to be in darkness. (2) ******************************************************** These two verses are elaborately explained in the first two chapters of this book. ******************************************************** sarahasyam With devotional service yad-rupa-guna-karmakah My color, qualities, and activities = The activities of the living entities and the Supreme Lord, known as the science of love O Brahma, please know that the universal elements enter into the cosmos and and the same time do not enter into the cosmos; similarly, I Myself also exist within everything created, and at the same time I am outside of everything. (3) ******************************************************** tad-angam ca The necessary paraphernalia for that process tathaiva tattva-vijnanam By factual realization =The confidential science of devotional service etavad eva jijnasyam tattva-jijnasunatmanah anvaya-vyatirekabhyam yat syat sarvatra sarvada A person who is searching after the Supreme Absolute Truth, the Personality of Godhead, must certainly search for it up to this, in all circumstances, in all space and time, and both directly and indirectly. (4) grhana gaditam maya You may take it up carefully astu te mad-anugrahat Let it be awakened within you out of My causeless mercy ******************************************************** The third verse is explained in the third, fouth, fifth, sixth, and ninth chapters of this book. The fourth verse is explained in the seventh, eighth, and tenth chapters of this book. _______________ Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
gHari 0 Report post Posted April 23, 2006 Srimad-Bhagavatam 2.9.32-36 follows. It would appear from bija's post from Sri Krsna Samhita that verses 33-36 comprise the 'original'. <center> 32 yAvAn ahaM yathA-bhAvo yad-rUpa-guNa-karmakaH tathaiva tattva-vijJAnam astu te mad-anugrahAt </center> yAvAn--as I am in eternal form; aham--Myself; yathA--as much as; bhAvaH--transcendental existence; yat--those; rUpa--various forms and colors; guNa--qualities; karmakaH--activities; tathA--so and so; eva--certainly; tattva-vijJAnam--factual realization; astu--let it be; te--unto you; mat--My; anugrahAt--by causeless mercy. All of Me, namely My actual eternal form and My transcendental existence, color, qualities and activities--let all be awakened within you by factual realization, out of My causeless mercy. PURPORT The secret of success in understanding the intricacies of knowledge of the Absolute Truth, the Personality of Godhead, is the causeless mercy of the Lord. Even in the material world, the father of many sons discloses the secret of his position to the pet sons. The father discloses the confidence unto the son whom he thinks worthy. An important man in the social order can be known by his mercy only. Similarly, one must be very dear to the Lord in order to know the Lord. The Lord is unlimited; no one can know Him completely, but one's advancement in the transcendental loving service of the Lord can make one eligible to know the Lord. Here we can see that the Lord is sufficiently pleased with BrahmAjI, and therefore He offers His causeless mercy to him so that BrahmAjI may have the factual realization of the Lord by His mercy only. In the Vedas also it is said that a person cannot know the Absolute Truth Personality of Godhead simply by dint of mundane education or intellectual gymnastics. One can know the Supreme Truth if one has unflinching faith in the bona fide spiritual master as well as in the Lord. Such a faithful person, even though illiterate in the mundane sense, can know the Lord automatically by the mercy of the Lord. In the Bhagavad-gItA also, it is said that the Lord reserves the right of not being exposed to everyone, and He keeps Himself concealed from the faithless by His yoga-mAyA potency. To the faithful the Lord reveals Himself in His form, quality and pastimes. The Lord is not formless, as wrongly conceived by the impersonalist, but His form is not like one that we have experienced. The Lord discloses His form, even to the extent of measurement, to His pure devotees, and that is the meaning of yAvAn, as explained by SrIla JIva GosvAmI, the greatest scholar of SrImad-BhAgavatam. The Lord discloses the transcendental nature of His existence. The mundane wranglers make mundane conceptions of the form of the Lord. It is said in the revealed scriptures that the Lord has no mundane form; therefore persons with a poor fund of knowledge conclude that He must be formless. They cannot distinguish between the mundane form and the spiritual form. According to them, without a mundane form one must be formless. This conclusion is also mundane because formlessness is the opposite conception of form. Negation of the mundane conception does not establish a transcendental fact. In the Brahma-saMhitA it is said that the Lord has a transcendental form and that He can utilize any one of His senses for any purpose. For example, He can eat with His eyes, and He can see with His leg. In the mundane conception of form, one cannot eat with one's eyes or see with his leg. That is the difference between the mundane body and the spiritual body of sac-cid-Ananda. A spiritual body is not formless; it is a different type of body, of which we cannot conceive with our present mundane senses. Formless therefore means devoid of mundane form, or possessing a spiritual body of which the nondevotee can have no conception by the speculative method. The Lord discloses to the devotee His unlimited varieties of transcendental bodies, all identical with one another with different kinds of bodily features. Some of the transcendental bodies of the Lord are blackish, and some of them are whitish. Some of them are reddish, and some are yellowish. Some of them are four-handed and some of them two-handed. Some of them are like the fish, and some are like the lion. All these different transcendental bodies of the Lord, without any differential category, are disclosed to the devotees of the Lord by the mercy of the Lord, and thus the impersonalists' false arguments claiming the formlessness of the Supreme Truth do not appeal to a devotee of the Lord, even though such a devotee may not be very advanced in devotional service. The Lord has unlimited numbers of transcendental qualities, and one of them is His affection for His unalloyed devotee. In the history of the mundane world we can appreciate His transcendental qualities. The Lord incarnates Himself for the protection of His devotees and for the annihilation of the faithless. His activities are in relationship with His devotees. SrImad-BhAgavatam is full of such activities of the Lord in relationship with His devotees, and the nondevotees have no knowledge of such pastimes. The Lord lifted the Govardhana Hill when He was only seven years old and protected His pure devotees at VRndAvana from the wrath of Indra, who was overflooding the place with rain. Now this lifting of the Govardhana Hill by a seven-year-old boy may be unbelievable for the faithless, but for the devotees it is absolutely believable. The devotee believes in the almighty potency of the Lord, while the faithless say that the Lord is almighty but do not believe it. Such men with a poor fund of knowledge do not know that the Lord is the Lord eternally and that one cannot become the Lord by meditation for millions of years or by mental speculation for billions of years. The impersonal interpretation of the mundane wranglers is completely refuted in this verse because it is clearly stated here that the Supreme Lord has His qualities, form, pastimes and everything that a person has. All these descriptions of the transcendental nature of the Personality of Godhead are factual realizations by the devotee of the Lord, and by the causeless mercy of the Lord they are revealed to His pure devotee, and to no one else. <center> 33 aham evAsam evAgre nAnyad yat sad-asat param pazcAd ahaM yad etac ca yo 'vaziSyeta so 'smy aham </center> aham--I, the Personality of Godhead; eva--certainly; Asam--existed; eva--only; agre--before the creation; na--never; anyat--anything else; yat--all those; sat--the effect; asat--the cause; param--the supreme; pazcAt--at the end; aham--I, the Personality of Godhead; yat--all these; etat--creation; ca--also; yaH--everything; avaziSyeta--remains; saH--that; asmi--I am; aham--I, the Personality of Godhead. BrahmA, it is I, the Personality of Godhead, who was existing before the creation, when there was nothing but Myself. Nor was there the material nature, the cause of this creation. That which you see now is also I, the Personality of Godhead, and after annihilation what remains will also be I, the Personality of Godhead. PURPORT We should note very carefully that the personality of Godhead is addressing Lord BrahmA and specifying with great emphasis Himself, pointing out that it is He, the Personality of Godhead, who existed before the creation, it is He only who maintains the creation, and it is He only who remains after the annihilation of the creation. BrahmA is also a creation of the Supreme Lord. The impersonalist puts forth the theory of oneness in the sense that BrahmA, also being the same principle of "I" because he is an emanation from the I, the Absolute Truth, is identical with the Lord, the principle of I, and that there is thus nothing more than the principle of I, as explained in this verse. Accepting the argument of the impersonalist, it is to be admitted that the Lord is the creator I and that the BrahmA is the created I. Therefore there is a difference between the two "I's," namely the predominator I and the predominated I. Therefore there are still two I's, even accepting the argument of the impersonalist. But we must note carefully that these two I's are accepted in the Vedic literature (KaThopaniSad) in the sense of quality. The KaThopaniSad says: <center> nityo nityAnAM cetanaz cetanAnAm eko bahUnAM yo vidadhAti kAmAn </center> The creator "I" and the created "I" are both accepted in the Vedas as qualitatively one because both of them are nityas and cetanas. But the singular "I" is the creator "I," and the created "I's" are of plural number because there are many "I's" like BrahmA and those generated by BrahmA. It is the simple truth. The father creates or begets a son, and the son also creates many other sons, and all of them may be one as human beings, but at the same time from the father, the son and the grandsons are all different. The son cannot take the place of the father, nor can the grandsons. Simultaneously the father, the son and the grandson are one and different also. As human beings they are one, but as relativities they are different. Therefore the relativities of the creator and the created or the predominator and the predominated have been differentiated in the Vedas by saying that the predominator "I" is the feeder of the predominated "I's," and thus there is a vast difference between the two principles of "I." In another feature of this verse, no one can deny the personalities of both the Lord and BrahmA. Therefore in the ultimate issue both the predominator and predominated are persons. This conclusion refutes the conclusion of the impersonalist that in the ultimate issue everything is impersonal. This impersonal feature stressed by the less intelligent impersonalist school is refuted by pointing out that the predominator "I" is the Absolute Truth and that He is a person. The predominated "I," BrahmA, is also a person, but he is not the Absolute. For realization of one's self in spiritual psychology it may be convenient to assume oneself to be the same principle as the Absolute Truth, but there is always the difference of the predominated and the predominator, as clearly pointed out here in this verse, which is grossly misused by the impersonalists. BrahmA is factually seeing face to face his predominator Lord, who exists in His transcendental eternal form, even after the annihilation of the material creation. The form of the Lord, as seen by BrahmA, existed before the creation of BrahmA, and the material manifestation with all the ingredients and agents of material creation are also energetic expansions of the Lord, and after the exhibition of the Lord's energy comes to a close, what remains is the same Personality of Godhead. Therefore the form of the Lord exists in all circumstances of creation, maintenance and annihilation. The Vedic hymns confirm this fact in the statement vAsudevo vA idam agra AsIn na brahmA na ca zaGkara eko nArAyaNa AsIn na brahmA nezAna, etc. Before the creation there was none except VAsudeva. There was neither BrahmA nor SaGkara. Only NArAyaNa was there and no one else, neither BrahmA nor IzAna. SrIpAda SaGkarAcArya also confirms in his comments on the Bhagavad-gItA that NArAyaNa, or the Personality of Godhead, is transcendental to all creation, but that the whole creation is the product of avyakta. Therefore the difference between the created and the creator is always there, although both the creator and created are of the same quality. The other feature of the statement is that the supreme truth is BhagavAn, or the Personality of Godhead. The Personality of Godhead and His kingdom have already been explained. The kingdom of Godhead is not void as conceived by the impersonalists. The VaikuNTha planets are full of transcendental variegatedness, including the four-handed residents of those planets, with great opulence of wealth and prosperity, and there are even airplanes and other amenities required for high-grade personalities. Therefore the Personality of Godhead exists before the creation, and He exists with all transcendental variegatedness in the VaikuNThalokas. The VaikuNThalokas, also accepted in the Bhagavad-gItA as being of the sanAtana nature, are not annihilated even after the annihilation of the manifested cosmos. Those transcendental planets are of a different nature altogether, and that nature is not subjected to the rules and regulations of material creation, maintenance or annihilation. The existence of the Personality of Godhead implies the existence of the VaikuNThalokas, as the existence of a king implies the existence of a kingdom. In various places in SrImad-BhAgavatam and in other revealed scriptures the existence of the Personality of Godhead is mentioned. For example, in SrImad-BhAgavatam (2.8.10), MahArAja ParIkSit asks: <center> sa cApi yatra puruSo vizva-sthity-udbhavApyayaH muktvAtma-mAyAM mAyezaH zete sarva-guhAzayaH </center> "How does the Personality of Godhead, the cause of creation, maintenance and annihilation, who is always freed from the influence of the illusory energy and is the controller of the same, lie in everyone's heart?" Similar also is a question of Vidura's: <center> tattvAnAM bhagavaMs teSAM katidhA pratisaGkramaH tatremaM ka upAsIran ka u svid anuzerate (BhAg. 3.7.37) </center> SrIdhara SvAmI explains this in his notes: "During the annihilation of the creation, who serves the Lord lying on the SeSa, etc." This means that the transcendental Lord with all His name, fame, quality and paraphernalia exists eternally. The same confirmation is also in the KAzI-khaNDa of the Skanda PurANa in connection with dhruva-carita. It is said there: <center> na cyavante 'pi yad-bhaktA mahatyAM pralayApadi ato 'cyuto 'khile loke sa ekaH sarvago 'vyayaH </center> Even the devotees of the Personality of Godhead are not annihilated during the period of the entire annihilation of the material world, not to speak of the Lord Himself. The Lord is ever-existent in all three stages of material change. The impersonalist adduces no activity in the Supreme, but in this discussion between BrahmA and the Supreme Personality of Godhead the Lord is said to have activities also, as He has His form and quality. The activities of BrahmA and other demigods during the maintenance of the creation are to be understood as the activities of the Lord. The king, or the head executive of a state, may not be seen in the government offices, for he may be engaged in royal comforts. Yet it should be understood that everything is being done under his direction and everything is at his command. The Personality of Godhead is never formless. In the material world He may not be visible in His personal form to the less intelligent class of men, and therefore He may sometimes be called formless. But actually He is always in His eternal form in His VaikuNTha planets as well as in other planets of the universes as different incarnations. The example of the sun is very appropriate in this connection. The sun in the night may not be visible to the eyes of men in the darkness, but the sun is visible wherever it has risen. That the sun is not visible to the eyes of the inhabitants of a particular part of the earth does not mean that the sun has no form. In the BRhad-AraNyaka UpaniSad (1.4.1) there is the hymn Atmaivedam agra AsIt puruSa-vidhaH. This mantra indicates the Supreme Personality of Godhead (KRSNa) even before the appearance of the puruSa incarnation. In the Bhagavad-gItA (15.18) it is said that Lord KRSNa is PuruSottama because He is the supreme puruSa, transcendental even to the puruSa-akSara and the puruSa-kSara. The akSara-puruSa, or the MahA-ViSNu, throws His glance over prakRti, or material nature, but the PuruSottama existed even before that. The BRhad-AraNyaka UpaniSad therefore confirms the statement of the Bhagavad-gItA that Lord KRSNa is the Supreme Person (PuruSottama). In some of the Vedas it is also said that in the beginning only the impersonal Brahman existed. However, according to this verse, the impersonal Brahman, which is the glowing effulgence of the body of the Supreme Lord, may be called the immediate cause, but the cause of all causes, or the remote cause, is the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The Lord's impersonal feature is existent in the material world because by material senses or material eyes the Lord cannot be seen or perceived. One has to spiritualize the senses before one can expect to see or perceive the Supreme Lord. But He is always engaged in His personal capacity, and He is eternally visible to the inhabitants of VaikuNThaloka, eye to eye. Therefore He is materially impersonal, just as the executive head of the state may be impersonal in the government offices, although he is not impersonal in the government house. Similarly, the Lord is not impersonal in His abode, which is always nirasta-kuhakam, as stated in the very beginning of the BhAgavatam. Therefore both the impersonal and personal features of the Lord are acceptable, as mentioned in the revealed scriptures. This Personality of Godhead is very emphatically explained in the Bhagavad-gItA in connection with the verse brahmaNo hi pratiSThAham (Bg. 14.27). Therefore in all ways the confidential part of spiritual knowledge is realization of the Personality of Godhead, and not His impersonal Brahman feature. One should therefore have his ultimate aim of realization not in the impersonal feature but in the personal feature of the Absolute Truth. The example of the sky within the pot and the sky outside the pot may be helpful to the student for his realization of the all-pervading quality of the cosmic consciousness of the Absolute Truth. But that does not mean that the individual part and parcel of the Lord becomes the Supreme by a false claim. It means only that the conditioned soul is a victim of the illusory energy in her last snare. To claim to be one with the cosmic consciousness of the Lord is the last trap set by the illusory energy, or daivI mAyA. Even in the impersonal existence of the Lord, as it is in the material creation, one should aspire for personal realization of the Lord, and that is the meaning of pazcAd ahaM yad etac ca yo 'vaziSyeta so 'smy aham. BrahmAjI also accepted the same truth when he was instructing NArada. He said: <center> so 'yaM te 'bhihitas tAta bhagavAn vizva-bhAvanaH (BhAg. 2.7.50) </center> There is no other cause of all causes than the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Hari. Therefore this verse aham eva never indicates anything other than the Supreme Lord, and one should therefore follow the path of the Brahma-sampradAya, or the path from BrahmAjI to NArada, to VyAsadeva, etc., and make it a point in life to realize the Supreme Personality of Godhead, Hari, or Lord KRSNa. This very confidential instruction to the pure devotees of the Lord was also given to Arjuna and to BrahmA in the beginning of the creation. The demigods like BrahmA, ViSNu, Mahezvara, Indra, Candra and VaruNa are undoubtedly different forms of the Lord for execution of different functions; the different elemental ingredients of material creation, as well as the multifarious energies, also may be of the same Personality of Godhead, but the root of all of them is the Supreme Personality of Godhead, SrI KRSNa. One should be attached to the root of everything rather than bewildered by the branches and leaves. That is the instruction given in this verse. <center> 34 Rte 'rthaM yat pratIyeta na pratIyeta cAtmani tad vidyAd Atmano mAyAM yathAbhAso yathA tamaH </center> Rte--without; artham--value; yat--that which; pratIyeta--appears to be; na--not; pratIyeta--appears to be; ca--and; Atmani--in relation to Me; tat--that; vidyAt--you must know; AtmanaH--My; mAyAm--illusory energy; yathA--just as; AbhAsaH--the reflection; yathA--as; tamaH--the darkness. O BrahmA, whatever appears to be of any value, if it is without relation to Me, has no reality. Know it as My illusory energy, that reflection which appears to be in darkness. PURPORT In the previous verse it has already been concluded that in any stage of the cosmic manifestation--its appearance, its sustenance, its growth, its interactions of different energies, its deterioration and its disappearance--all has its basic relation with the existence of the Personality of Godhead. And as such, whenever there is forgetfulness of this prime relation with the Lord, and whenever things are accepted as real without being related to the Lord, that conception is called a product of the illusory energy of the Lord. Because nothing can exist without the Lord, it should be known that the illusory energy is also an energy of the Lord. The right conclusion of dovetailing everything in relationship with the Lord is called yoga-mAyA, or the energy of union, and the wrong conception of detaching a thing from its relationship with the Lord is called the Lord's daivI mAyA, or mahA-mAyA. Both the mAyAs also have connections with the Lord because nothing can exist without being related to Him. As such, the wrong conception of detaching relationships from the Lord is not false but illusory. Misconceiving one thing for another thing is called illusion. For example, accepting a rope as a snake is illusion, but the rope is not false. The rope, as it exists in the front of the illusioned person, is not at all false, but the acceptance is illusory. Therefore the wrong conception of accepting this material manifestation as being divorced from the energy of the Lord is illusion, but it is not false. And this illusory conception is called the reflection of the reality in the darkness of ignorance. Anything that appears as apparently not being "produced out of My energy" is called mAyA. The conception that the living entity is formless or that the Supreme Lord is formless is also illusion. In the Bhagavad-gItA (2.12) it was said by the Lord in the midst of the battlefield that the warriors standing in front of Arjuna, Arjuna himself, and even the Lord had all existed before, they were existing on the Battlefield of KurukSetra, and they would all continue to be individual personalities in the future also, even after the annihilation of the present body and even after being liberated from the bondage of material existence. In all circumstances, the Lord and the living entities are individual personalities, and the personal features of both the Lord and living beings are never abolished; only the influence of the illusory energy, the reflection of light in the darkness, can, by the mercy of the Lord, be removed. In the material world, the light of the sun is also not independent, nor is that of the moon. The real source of light is the brahmajyoti, which diffuses light from the transcendental body of the Lord, and the same light is reflected in varieties of light: the light of the sun, the light of the moon, the light of fire, or the light of electricity. So the identity of the self as being unconnected with the Supreme Self, the Lord, is also illusion, and the false claim "I am the Supreme" is the last illusory snare of the same mAyA, or the external energy of the Lord. The VedAnta-sUtra in the very beginning affirms that everything is born from the Supreme, and thus, as explained in the previous verse, all individual living entities are born from the energy of the supreme living being, the Personality of Godhead. BrahmA himself was born from the energy of the Lord, and all other living entities are born from the energy of the Lord through the agency of BrahmA; none of them has any existence without being dovetailed with the Supreme Lord. The independence of the individual living entity is not real independence, but is just the reflection of the real independence existing in the Supreme Being, the Lord. The false claim of supreme independence by the conditioned souls is illusion, and this conclusion is admitted in this verse. Persons with a poor fund of knowledge become illusioned, and therefore the so-called scientists, physiologists, empiric philosophers, etc., become dazzled by the glaring reflection of the sun, moon, electricity, etc., and deny the existence of the Supreme Lord, putting forward theories and different speculations about the creation, maintenance and annihilation of everything material. The medical practitioner may deny the existence of the soul in the physiological bodily construction of an individual person, but he cannot give life to a dead body, even though all the mechanisms of the body exist even after death. The psychologist makes a serious study of the physiological conditions of the brain, as if the construction of the cerebral lump were the machine of the functioning mind, but in the dead body the psychologist cannot bring back the function of the mind. These scientific studies of the cosmic manifestation or the bodily construction independent of the Supreme Lord are different reflective intellectual gymnastics only, but at the end they are all illusion and nothing more. All such advancement of science and knowledge in the present context of material civilization is but an action of the covering influence of the illusory energy. The illusory energy has two phases of existence, namely the covering influence and the throwing influence. By the throwing influence the illusory energy throws the living entities into the darkness of ignorance, and by the covering influence she covers the eyes of men with a poor fund of knowledge about the existence of the Supreme Person who enlightened the supreme individual living being, BrahmA. The identity of BrahmA with the Supreme Lord is never claimed herein, and therefore such a foolish claim by the man with a poor fund of knowledge is another display of the illusory energy of the Lord. The Lord says in the Bhagavad-gItA (16.18–20) that demoniac persons who deny the existence of the Lord are thrown more and more into the darkness of ignorance, and thus such demoniac persons transmigrate life after life without any knowledge of the Supreme Personality of Godhead. The sane man, however, is enlightened in the disciplic succession from BrahmAjI, who was personally instructed by the Lord, or in the disciplic succession from Arjuna, who was personally instructed by the Lord in the Bhagavad-gItA. He accepts this statement of the Lord: <center> ahaM sarvasya prabhavo mattaH sarvaM pravartate iti matvA bhajante mAM budhA bhAva-samanvitAH (Bg. 10.8) </center> The Lord is the original source of all emanations, and everything that is created, maintained and annihilated exists by the energy of the Lord. The sane man who knows this is actually learned, and therefore he becomes a pure devotee of the Lord, engaged in the transcendental loving service of the Lord. Although the reflectory energy of the Lord displays various illusions to the eyes of persons with a poor fund of knowledge, the sane person knows clearly that the Lord can act, even from far, far beyond our vision, by His different energies, just as fire can diffuse heat and light from a distant place. In the medical science of the ancient sages, known as the Ayur-veda, there is definite acceptance of the Lord s supremacy in the following words: <center> jagad-yoner anicchasya cid-Anandaika-rUpiNaH puMso 'sti prakRtir nityA praticchAyeva bhAsvataH acetanApi caitanya- yogena paramAtmanaH akarod vizvam akhilam anityam nATakAkRtim </center> There is one Supreme Person who is the progenitor of this cosmic manifestation and whose energy acts as prakRti, or the material nature, dazzling like a reflection. By such illusory action of prakRti, even dead matter is caused to move by the cooperation of living energy of the Lord, and the material world appears like a dramatic performance to the ignorant eyes. The ignorant person, therefore, may even be a scientist or physiologist in the drama of prakRti, while the sane person knows prakRti as the illusory energy of the Lord. By such a conclusion, as confirmed by the Bhagavad-gItA, it is clear that the living entities are also a display of the Lord's superior energy (parA prakRti), just as the material world is a display of the Lord's inferior energy (aparA prakRti). The superior energy of the Lord cannot be as good as the Lord, although there is very little difference between the energy and the possessor of the energy, or the fire and the heat. Fire is possessed of heat, but heat is not fire. This simple thing is not understood by the man with a poor fund of knowledge who falsely claims that the fire and heat are the same. This energy of the fire (namely heat) is explained here as a reflection, and not directly fire. Therefore the living energy represented by the living entities is the reflection of the Lord, and never the Lord Himself. Being the reflection of the Lord, the existence of the living entity is dependent on the Supreme Lord, who is the original light. This material energy may be compared to darkness, as actually it is darkness, and the activities of the living entities in the darkness are reflections of the original light. The Lord should be understood by the context of this verse. Nondependence of both the energies of the Lord is explained as mAyA, or illusion. No one can make a solution of the darkness of ignorance simply by the reflection of light. Similarly, no one can come out of material existence simply by the reflected light of the common man; one has to receive the light from the original light itself. The reflection of sunlight in the darkness is unable to drive out the darkness, but the sunlight outside the reflection can drive out the darkness completely. In darkness no one can see the things in a room. Therefore a person in the dark is afraid of snakes and scorpions, although there may not be such things. But in the light the things in the room can be clearly seen, and the fear of snakes and scorpions is at once removed. Therefore one has to take shelter of the light of the Lord, as in the Bhagavad-gItA or the SrImad-BhAgavatam, and not the reflective personalities who have no touch with the Lord. No one should hear Bhagavad-gItA or SrImad-BhAgavatam from a person who does not believe in the existence of the Lord. Such a person is already doomed, and any association with such a doomed person makes the associater also doomed. According to the Padma PurANa, within the material compass there are innumerable material universes, and all of them are full of darkness. Any living being, beginning from the BrahmAs (there are innumerable BrahmAs in innumerable universes) to the insignificant ant, are all born in darkness, and they require factual light from the Lord to see Him directly, just as the sun can be seen only by the direct light of the sun. No lamp or man-made torchlight, however powerful it may be, can help one see the sun. The sun reveals itself. Therefore the action of different energies of the Lord, or the Personality of Godhead Himself, can be realized by the light manifested by the causeless mercy of the Lord. The impersonalists say that God cannot be seen. God can be seen by the light of God and not by man-made speculations. Here this light is specifically mentioned as vidyAt, which is an order by the Lord to BrahmA. This direct order of the Lord is a manifestation of His internal energy, and this particular energy is the means of seeing the Lord face to face. Not only BrahmA but anyone who may be graced by the Lord to see such merciful direct internal energy can also realize the Personality of Godhead without any mental speculation. <center> 35 yathA mahAnti bhUtAni bhUteSUccAvaceSv anu praviSTAny apraviSTAni tathA teSu na teSv aham </center> yathA--just as; mahAnti--the universal; bhUtAni--elements; bhUteSu ucca-avaceSu--in the minute and gigantic; anu--after; praviSTAni--entered; apraviSTAni--not entered; tathA--so; teSu--in them; na--not; teSu--in them; aham--Myself. O BrahmA, please know that the universal elements enter into the cosmos and at the same time do not enter into the cosmos; similarly, I Myself also exist within everything created, and at the same time I am outside of everything. PURPORT The great elements of material creation, namely earth, water, fire, air and ether, all enter into the body of all manifested entities--the seas, mountains, aquatics, plants, reptiles, birds, beasts, human beings, demigods and everyone materially manifested--and at the same time such elements are differently situated. In the developed stage of consciousness, the human being can study both physiological and physical science, but the basic principles of such sciences are nothing but the material elements and nothing more. The body of the human being and the body of the mountain, as also the bodies of the demigods, including BrahmA, are all of the same ingredients--earth, water, etc.--and at the same time the elements are beyond the body. The elements were created first, and therefore they entered into the bodily construction later, but in both circumstances they entered the cosmos and also did not enter. Similarly, the Supreme Lord, by His different energies, namely the internal and external, is within everything in the manifested cosmos, and at the same time He is outside of everything, situated in the kingdom of God (VaikuNThaloka) as described before. This is very nicely stated in the Brahma-saMhitA (5.37) as follows: <center> Ananda-cinmaya-rasa-pratibhAvitAbhis tAbhir ya eva nija-rUpatayA kalAbhiH goloka eva nivasaty akhilAtma-bhUto govindam Adi-puruSaM tam ahaM bhajAmi </center> "I worship the Personality of Godhead, Govinda, who, by expansion of His internal potency of transcendental existence, knowledge and bliss, enjoys in His own and expanded forms. Simultaneously He enters into every atom of the creation." This expansion of His plenary parts is also more definitely explained in the same Brahma-saMhitA (5.35) as follows: <center> eko 'py asau racayituM jagad-aNDa-koTiM yac-chaktir asti jagad-aNDa-cayA yad-antaH aNDAntara-stha-paramANu-cayAntara-sthaM govindam Adi-puruSaM tam ahaM bhajAmi </center> "I worship the Personality of Godhead, Govinda, who, by one of His plenary portions, enters into the existence of every universe and every particle of the atoms and thus unlimitedly manifests His infinite energy all over the material creation." The impersonalists can imagine or even perceive that the Supreme Brahman is thus all-pervading, and therefore they conclude that there is no possibility of His personal form. Herein lies the mystery of His transcendental knowledge. This mystery is transcendental love of Godhead, and one who is surcharged with such transcendental love of Godhead can without difficulty see the Personality of Godhead in every atom and every movable or immovable object. And at the same time he can see the Personality of Godhead in His own abode, Goloka, enjoying eternal pastimes with His eternal associates, who are also expansions of His transcendental existence. This vision is the real mystery of spiritual knowledge, as stated by the Lord in the beginning (sarahasyaM tad-aGgaM ca). This mystery is the most confidential part of the knowledge of the Supreme, and it is impossible for the mental speculators to discover by dint of intellectual gymnastics. The mystery can be revealed through the process recommended by BrahmAjI in his Brahma-saMhitA (5.38) as follows: <center> premAJjana-cchurita-bhakti-vilocanena santaH sadaiva hRdayeSu vilokayanti yaM zyAmasundaram acintya-guNa-svarUpaM govindam Adi-puruSaM tam ahaM bhajAmi </center> "I worship the original Personality of Godhead, Govinda, whom the pure devotees, their eyes smeared with the ointment of love of Godhead, always observe within their hearts. This Govinda, the original Personality of Godhead, is SyAmasundara with all transcendental qualities." Therefore, although He is present in every atom, the Supreme Personality of Godhead may not be visible to the dry speculators; still the mystery is unfolded before the eyes of the pure devotees because their eyes are anointed with love of Godhead. And this love of Godhead can be attained only by the practice of transcendental loving service of the Lord, and nothing else. The vision of the devotees is not ordinary; it is purified by the process of devotional service. In other words, as the universal elements are both within and without, similarly the Lord's name, form, quality, pastimes, entourage, etc., as they are described in the revealed scriptures or as performed in the VaikuNThalokas, far, far beyond the material cosmic manifestation, are factually being televised in the heart of the devotee. The man with a poor fund of knowledge cannot understand, although by material science one can see things far away by means of television. Factually, the spiritually developed person is able to have the television of the kingdom of God always reflected within his heart. That is the mystery of knowledge of the Personality of Godhead. The Lord can award anyone and everyone liberation (mukti) from the bondage of material existence, yet He rarely awards the privilege of love of Godhead, as confirmed by NArada (muktiM dadhAti karhicit sma na bhakti-yogam). This transcendental devotional service of the Lord is so wonderful that the occupation keeps the deserving devotee always rapt in psychological activities, without deviation from the absolute touch. Thus love of Godhead, developed in the heart of the devotee, is a great mystery. BrahmAjI previously told NArada that the desires of BrahmAjI are never unfulfilled because he is always absorbed in the transcendental loving service of the Lord; nor has he any desire in his heart save and except the transcendental service of the Lord. That is the beauty and mystery of the process of bhakti-yoga. As the Lord's desire is infallible because He is acyuta, similarly the desires of the devotees in the transcendental service of the Lord are also acyuta, infallible. This is very difficult, however, for the layman to understand without knowledge of the mystery of devotional service, as it is very difficult to know the potency of touchstone. As touchstone is rarely found, a pure devotee of the Lord is also rarely to be seen, even amongst millions of liberated souls (koTiSv api mahAmune). Out of all kinds of perfections attained by the process of knowledge, yoga perfection in devotional service is the highest of all and the most mysterious also, even more mysterious than the eight kinds of mystic perfection attained by the process of yogic performances. In the Bhagavad-gItA (18.64) the Lord therefore advised Arjuna about this bhakti-yoga: <center> sarva-guhyatamaM bhUyaH zRNu me paramaM vacaH </center> "Just hear from Me again about the most confidential part of the instructions in Bhagavad-gItA." The same was confirmed by BrahmAjI to NArada in the following words: <center> idaM bhAgavataM nAma yan me bhagavatoditam saGgraho 'yaM vibhUtInAM tvam etad vipulIkuru </center> BrahmAjI said to NArada, "Whatever I have spoken to you about the BhAgavatam was explained to me by the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and I am advising you to expand these topics nicely so that people may easily understand the mysterious bhakti-yoga by transcendental loving service to the Lord." It is to be noted here that the mystery of bhakti-yoga was disclosed to BrahmAjI by the Lord Himself. BrahmAjI explained the same mystery to NArada, NArada explained it to VyAsa, VyAsa explained it to Sukadeva GosvAmI, and that same knowledge is coming down in the unalloyed chain of disciplic succession. If one is fortunate enough to have received the knowledge in the transcendental disciplic succession, surely he will have the chance to understand the mystery of the Lord and that of the SrImad-BhAgavatam, the sound incarnation of the Lord. <center> 36 etAvad eva jijJAsyaM tattva-jijJAsunAtmanaH anvaya-vyatirekAbhyAM yat syAt sarvatra sarvadA </center> etAvat--up to this; eva--certainly; jijJAsyam--is to be inquired; tattva--the Absolute Truth; jijJAsunA--by the student; AtmanaH--of the Self; anvaya--directly; vyatirekAbhyAm--indirectly; yat--whatever; syAt--it may be; sarvatra--in all space and time; sarvadA--in all circumstances. A person who is searching after the Supreme Absolute Truth, the Personality of Godhead, most certainly search for it up to this, in all circumstances, in all space and time, and both directly and indirectly. PURPORT To unfold the mystery of bhakti-yoga, as it is explained in the previous verse, is the ultimate stage of all inquiries or the highest objective for the inquisitive. Everyone is searching after self-realization in different ways--by karma-yoga, by jJAna-yoga, by dhyAna-yoga, by rAja-yoga, by bhakti-yoga, etc. To engage in self-realization is the responsibility of every living entity developed in consciousness. One who is developed in consciousness certainly makes inquiries into the mystery of the self, of the cosmic situation and of the problems of life, in all spheres and fields--social, political, economic, cultural, religious, moral, etc.--and in their different branches. But here the goal of all such inquiries is explained. The VedAnta-sUtra philosophy begins with this inquiry about life, and the BhAgavatam answers such inquiries up to this point, or the mystery of all inquiries. Lord BrahmA wanted to be perfectly educated by the Personality of Godhead, and here is the answer by the Lord, finished in four nutshell verses, from aham eva to this verse, etAvad eva. This is the end of all self-realization processes. Men do not know that the ultimate goal of life is ViSNu, or the Supreme Personality of Godhead, due to being bewildered by the glaring reflection in the darkness, and as such everyone is entering into the darkest region of material existence, driven by the uncontrolled senses. The whole material existence has sprung up because of sense gratification, desires based principally on the sex desire, and the result is that in spite of all advancement of knowledge, the final goal of all the activities of the living entities is sense gratification. But here is the real goal of life, and everyone should know it by inquiries put before a bona fide spiritual master expert in the science of bhakti-yoga, or from a living personality of BhAgavatam life. Everyone is engaged in various kinds of scriptural inquiries, but the SrImad-BhAgavatam gives answers to all of the various students of self-realization: this ultimate objective of life is not to be searched out without great labor or perseverance. One who is imbued with such sincere inquiries must ask the bona fide spiritual master in the disciplic succession from BrahmAjI, and that is the direction given here. Because the mystery was disclosed before BrahmAjI by the Supreme Personality of Godhead, the mystery of all such inquiries regarding self-realization must be put before such a spiritual master, who is directly the representative of the Lord, acknowledged in that disciplic succession. Such a bona fide spiritual master is able to clear up the whole thing by evidence from the revealed scriptures, both direct and indirect. Although everyone is free to consult the revealed scriptures in this connection, one still requires the guidance of a bona fide spiritual master, and that is the direction in this verse. The bona fide spiritual master is the most confidential representative of the Lord, and one must receive direction from the spiritual master in the same spirit that BrahmAjI received it from the Personality of Godhead, Lord KRSNa. The bona fide spiritual master in that bona fide chain of disciplic succession never claims to be the Lord Himself, although such a spiritual master is greater than the Lord in the sense that he can deliver the Lord by his personally realized experience. The Lord is not to be found simply by education or by a good fertile brain, but surely He can be found by the sincere student through the transparent medium of the bona fide spiritual master. The revealed scriptures give directions directly to this end, but because the bewildered living entities are blinded by the glaring reflection in the darkness, they are unable to find the truth of the revealed scriptures. For example, in the Bhagavad-gItA the whole direction is targeted toward the personality of Godhead Lord SrI KRSNa, but for want of a bona fide spiritual master in the line of BrahmAjI or the direct hearer, Arjuna, there are different distortions of the revealed knowledge by many unauthorized persons who just want to satisfy their own whims. Undoubtedly the Bhagavad-gItA is accepted as one of the most brilliant stars in the horizon of the spiritual sky, yet the interpretations of this great book of knowledge have so grossly been distorted that every student of the Bhagavad-gItA is still in the same darkness of glaring material reflections. Such students are hardly enlightened by the Bhagavad-gItA. In the GItA practically the same instruction is imparted as in the four prime verses of the BhAgavatam, but due to wrong and fashionable interpretations by unauthorized persons, one cannot reach the ultimate conclusion. In the Bhagavad-gItA (18.61) it is clearly said: <center> IzvaraH sarva-bhUtAnAM hRd-deze 'rjuna tiSThati bhrAmayan sarva-bhUtAni yantrArUDhAni mAyayA </center> The Lord is situated in the hearts of all living beings (as ParamAtmA), and He is controlling all of them in the material world under the agency of His external energy. Therefore it is clearly mentioned that the Lord is the supreme controller and that the living entities are controlled by the Lord. In the same Bhagavad-gItA (18.65) the Lord directs as follows: <center> man-manA bhava mad-bhakto mad-yAjI mAM namaskuru mAm evaiSyasi satyaM te pratijAne priyo 'si me </center> It is clear from this verse of the Bhagavad-gItA that the direction of the Lord is that one should be God-minded, a devotee of the Lord, a worshiper of the Lord, and must offer all obeisances unto Lord KRSNa. By so doing, the devotee will undoubtedly go back to Godhead, back to home. Indirectly it is said that the whole Vedic social construction of human society is so made that everyone acts as a part and parcel of the complete body of the Lord. The intelligent class of men, or the brAhmaNas, are situated on the face of the Lord; the administrative class of men, the kSatriyas, are situated on the arms of the Lord; the productive class of men, the vaizyas, are situated on the belt of the Lord; and the laborer class of men, the zUdras, are situated on the legs of the Lord. Therefore the complete social construction is the body of the Lord, and all the parts of the body, namely the brAhmaNas, the kSatriyas, the vaizyas and the zUdras, are meant to serve the Lord's whole body conjointly; otherwise the parts become unfit to be coordinated with the supreme consciousness of oneness. Universal consciousness is factually achieved by coordinated service of all concerned to the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and that alone can insure total perfection. Therefore even the great scientists, the great philosophers, the great mental speculators, the great politicians, the great industrialists, the great social reformers, etc., cannot give any relief to the restless society of the material world because they do not know the secret of success as mentioned in this verse of the BhAgavatam, namely that one must know the mystery of bhakti-yoga. In the Bhagavad-gItA (7.15) also it is said: <center> na mAM duSkRtino mUDhAH prapadyante narAdhamAH mAyayApahRta-jJAnA AsuraM bhAvam AzritAH </center> Because the so-called great leaders of human society are ignorant of this great knowledge of bhakti-yoga and are always engaged in ignoble acts of sense gratification, bewildered by the external energy of the Lord, they are stubborn rebels against the supremacy of the Supreme Personality of Godhead, and they never agree to surrender unto Him because they are fools, miscreants and the lowest type of human beings. Such faithless nonbelievers may be highly educated in the material sense of the term, but factually they are the greatest fools of the world because by the influence of the external, material nature all their so-called acquisition of knowledge has been made null and void. Therefore all advancement of knowledge in the present context of things is being misused by cats and dogs fighting with one another for sense gratification, and all acquisition of knowledge in science, philosophy, fine arts, nationalism, economic development, religion and great activities are being spoiled by being used as dresses for dead men. There is no utility in the dresses used for covering a coffin of a dead body save getting false applause from the ignorant public. The SrImad-BhAgavatam therefore says again and again that without attainment of the status of bhakti-yoga, all the activities of human society are to be considered absolute failures only. It is said: <center> parAbhavas tAvad abodha-jAto yAvan na jijJAsata Atma-tattvam yAvat kriyAs tAvad idaM mano vai karmAtmakaM yena zarIra-bandhaH (BhAg. 5.5.5) </center> As long as one is blind to inquiring after self-realization, all material activities, however great they may be, are all different kinds of defeat because the aim of human life is not fulfilled by such unwanted and profitless activities. The function of the human body is to attain freedom from material bondage, but as long as one is fully absorbed in material activities, his mind will be overwhelmed in the whirlpool of matter, and thus he will continue to be encaged in material bodies life after life. <center> evaM manaH karma-vazaM prayuGkte avidyayAtmany upadhIyamAne prItir na yAvan mayi vAsudeve na mucyate deha-yogena tAvat (BhAg. 5.5.6) </center> It is one's mind that generates different kinds of bodies for suffering different kinds of material pangs. Therefore as long as the mind is absorbed in fruitive activities, the mind is understood to be absorbed in nescience, and thus one is sure to be subjected to material bondage in different bodies again and again until one develops a transcendental love for Godhead, VAsudeva, the Supreme Person. To become absorbed in the transcendental name, quality, form and activities of the Supreme Person, VAsudeva, means to change the temper of the mind from matter to absolute knowledge, which leads one to the path of absolute realization and thus frees one from the bondage of material contact and encagements in different material bodies. SrIla JIva GosvAmI PrabhupAda therefore comments on the words sarvatra sarvadA in the sense that the principles of bhakti-yoga, or devotional service to the Lord, are apt in all circumstances; i.e., bhakti-yoga is recommended in all the revealed scriptures, it is performed by all authorities, it is important in all places, it is useful in all causes and effects, etc. As far as all the revealed scriptures are concerned, he quotes from the Skanda PurANa on the topics of BrahmA and NArada as follows: <center> saMsAre 'smin mahA-ghore janma-mRtyu-samAkule pUjanaM vAsudevasya tArakaM vAdibhiH smRtam </center> In the material world, which is full of darkness and dangers, combined with birth and death and full of different anxieties, the only way to get out of the great entanglement is to accept loving transcendental devotional service to Lord VAsudeva. This is accepted by all classes of philosophers. SrIla JIva GosvAmI also quotes another common passage, which is found in three PurANas, namely the Padma PurANa, Skanda PurANa and LiGga PurANa. It runs as follows: <center> AloDya sarva-zAstrAni vicArya ca punaH punaH idam ekaM suniSpannaM dhyeyo nArAyaNaH sadA </center> "By scrutinizingly reviewing all the revealed scriptures and judging them again and again, it is now concluded that Lord NArAyaNa is the Supreme Absolute Truth, and thus He alone should be worshiped." The same truth is also indirectly described in the GaruDa PurANa as follows: <center> pAraM gato 'pi vedAnAM sarva-zAstrArtha-vedy api yo na sarvezvare bhaktas taM vidyAt puruSAdhamam </center> "Even though one may have gone to the other side of all the Vedas, and even though one is well versed in all the revealed scriptures, if one is not a devotee of the Supreme Lord, he must be considered the lowest of mankind." Similarly, it is also stated in SrImad-BhAgavatam (5.18.12) indirectly as follows: <center> yasyAsti bhaktir bhagavaty akiJcanA sarvair guNais tatra samAsate surAH harAv abhaktasya kuto mahad-guNA mano-rathenAsati dhAvato bahiH </center> One who has unflinching devotion unto the Supreme Personality of Godhead must have all the good qualities of the demigods, and contrarily one who is not a devotee of the Lord must be hovering in the darkness of mental speculation and thus must be engaged in material impermanence. SrImad-BhAgavatam (11.11.18) says: <center> zabda-brahmaNi niSNAto na niSNAyAt pare yadi zramas tasya zrama-phalo hy adhenum iva rakSataH </center> "One may be well versed in all the transcendental literature of the Vedas, but if he fails to be acquainted with the Supreme, then it must be concluded that all of his education is like the burden of a beast or like one's keeping a cow without milking capacity." Similarly, the liberty of discharging loving transcendental service to the Lord is invested in everyone, even the women, the zUdras, the forest tribes, or any other living beings born in sinful conditions. <center> te vai vidanty atitaranti ca deva-mAyAM strI-zUdra-hUNa-zabarA api pApa-jIvAH yady adbhuta-krama-parAyaNa-zIlazikSAs tiryag-janA api kimu zruta-dhAraNA ye (BhAg. 2.7.46) </center> The lowest of human beings can be elevated to the highest stage of devotional life if they are trained by the bona fide spiritual master well versed in the transcendental loving service of the Lord. If the lowest can be so elevated, then what to speak of the highest, who are well versed in the Vedic knowledge? The conclusion is that devotional service to the Lord is open for all, regardless of who they are. That is the confirmation of its application for all kinds of performers of the service. Therefore the devotional service of the Lord with perfect knowledge through the training of a bona fide spiritual master is advised for everyone, even if one happens not to be a human being. This is confirmed in the GaruDa PurANa as follows: <center> kITa-pakSi-mRgANAM ca harau sannyasta-cetasAm UrdhvAm eva gatiM manye kiM punar jJAninAM nRNAm </center> "Even the worms, birds and beasts are assured of elevation to the highest perfectional life if they are completely surrendered to the transcendental loving service of the Lord, so what to speak of the philosophers amongst the human beings?" Therefore there is no need to seek properly qualified candidates for discharging devotional service to the Lord. Let them be either well behaved or ill trained, let them be either learned or fools, let them be either grossly attached or in the renounced order of life, let them be liberated souls or desirous of salvation, let them be inexpert in the discharge of devotional service or expert in the same, all of them can be elevated to the supreme position by discharging devotional service under the proper guidance. This is also confirmed in the Bhagavad-gItA (9.30,32) as follows: <center> api cet su-durAcAro bhajate mAm ananya-bhAk sAdhur eva sa mantavyaH samyag vyavasito hi saH mAM hi pArtha vyapAzritya ye 'pi syuH pApa-yonayaH striyo vaizyAs tathA zUdrAs te 'pi yAnti parAM gatim </center> Even if a person is fully addicted to all sorts of sinful acts, if he happens to be engaged in the loving transcendental service of the Lord under proper guidance, he is to be considered the most perfect holy man without a doubt. And thus any person, whatsoever and whosoever he or she may be--even the fallen woman, the less intelligent laborer, the dull mercantile man, or even a man lower than all these--can attain the highest perfection of life by going back home, back to Godhead, provided he or she takes shelter of the lotus feet of the Lord in all earnestness. This sincere earnestness is the only qualification that can lead one to the highest perfectional stage of life, and unless and until such real earnestness is aroused, there is a difference between cleanliness or uncleanliness, learning or nonlearning, in the material estimation. Fire is always fire, and thus if someone touches the fire, knowingly or unknowingly, the fire will act in its own way without discrimination. The principle is: harir harati pApAni duSTa-cittair api smRtaH. The all-powerful Lord can purify the devotee of all sinful reactions, just as the sun can sterilize all sorts of infections by its powerful rays. "Attraction for material enjoyment cannot act upon a pure devotee of the Lord." There are hundreds and thousands of aphorisms in the revealed scriptures. AtmArAmAz ca munayaH: "Even the self-realized souls are also attracted by the transcendental loving service of the Lord." Kecit kevalayA bhaktyA vAsudeva-parAyaNAH: [sB 6.1.15] "Simply by hearing and chanting, one becomes a great devotee of Lord VAsudeva." Na calati bhagavat-padAravindAl lavanimiSArdham api sa vaiSNavAgryaH: "A person who does not move from the lotus feet of the Lord even for a moment or a second is to be considered the greatest of all VaiSNava s." Bhagavat-pArSadatAM prApte mat-sevayA pratItaM te: "The pure devotees are convinced of attaining the association of the Personality of Godhead, and thus they are always engaged in the transcendental loving service of the Lord." Therefore in all continents, in all planets, in all universes, devotional service to the Lord, or bhakti-yoga, is current, and that is the statement of the SrImad-BhAgavatam and allied scriptures. Everywhere means in every part of the creation of the Lord. The Lord can be served by all the senses, or even simply by the mind. The South Indian brAhmaNa who served the Lord simply on the strength of his mind also factually realized the Lord. Success is guaranteed for a devotee who fully engages any one of his senses in the mode of devotional service. The Lord can be served by any ingredient, even the most common commodity--a flower, a leaf, a fruit or a little water, which are available in any part of the universe and without cost--and thus the Lord is served universally by the universal entities. He can be served simply by hearing, He can be served simply by chanting or reading about His activities, He can be served simply by adoring Him and accepting Him. In the Bhagavad-gItA it is stated that one can serve the Lord by offering the result of one's own work; it does not matter what one does. Generally men may say that whatever they are doing is inspired by God, but that is not all. One should actually work on behalf of God as a servant of God. The Lord says in the Bhagavad-gItA (9.27): <center> yat karoSi yad aznAsi yaj juhoSi dadAsi yat yat tapasyasi kaunteya tat kuruSva mad-arpaNam </center> Do whatever you like or whatever may be easier for you to do, eat whatever you may eat, sacrifice whatever you can sacrifice, give whatever you may give in charity, and do whatever you may undertake in penance, but everything must be done for Him only. If you do business or if you accept some employment, do so on behalf of the Lord. Whatever you may eat, you may offer the same to the Lord and be assured that He will return the food after eating it Himself. He is the complete whole, and therefore whatever He may eat as offered by the devotee is accepted because of the devotee's love, but again it is returned as prasAda for the devotee so that he can be happy by eating. In other words, be a servant of God and live peacefully in that consciousness, ultimately returning home, back to Godhead. It is said in the Skanda PurANa: <center> yasya smRtyA ca nAmoktyA tapo-yajJa-kriyAdiSu nUnaM sampUrNatAm eti sadyo vande tam acyutam </center> "I offer my obeisances unto Him, the infallible, because simply by either remembering Him or vibrating His holy name one can attain the perfection of all penances, sacrifices or fruitive activities, and this process can be universally followed." It is enjoined (BhAg. 2.3.10): <center> akAmaH sarva-kAmo vA mokSa-kAma udAra-dhIH tIvreNa bhakti-yogena yajeta puruSaM param </center> Though a person be full of desires or have no desires, he may follow this path of infallible bhakti-yoga for complete perfection." One need not be anxious to propitiate each and every demigod and goddess because the root of all of them is the Personality of Godhead. As by pouring water on the root of the tree one serves and enlivens all the branches and leaves, so by rendering service unto the Supreme Lord one automatically serves every god and goddess without extraneous effort. The Lord is all-pervading, and therefore service unto Him is also all-pervading. This fact is corroborated in the Skanda PurANa as follows: <center> arcite deva-deveze zaGkha-cakra-gadA-dhare arcitAH sarva-devAH syur yataH sarva-gato hariH </center> When the Supreme Lord, the personality of Godhead, who carries in His hands a conchshell, wheel, club and lotus flower, is worshiped, certainly all other demigods are worshiped automatically because Hari, the personality of Godhead, is all-pervading. Therefore, in all cases, namely nominative, objective, causative, dative, ablative, possessive and supportive, everyone is benefited by such transcendental loving service to the Lord. The man who worships the Lord, the Lord Himself who is worshiped, the cause for which the Lord is worshiped, the source of supply, the place where such worship is done, etc.--everything is benefited by such an action. Even during the annihilation of the material world, the process of bhakti-yoga can be applied. KAlena naSTA pralaye vANIyam: the Lord is worshiped in devastation because He protects the Vedas from being annihilated. He is worshiped in every millennium or yuga. As it is said in SrImad-BhAgavatam (12.3.52): <center> kRte yad dhyAyato viSNuM tretAyAM yajato makhaiH dvApare paricaryAyAM kalau tad dhari-kIrtanAt </center> In the ViSNu PurANa it is written: <center> sa hAnis tan mahac chidraM sa mohaH sa ca vibhramaH yan-muhUrtaM kSaNaM vApi vAsudevaM na cintayet </center> "If even for a moment remembrance of VAsudeva, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, is missed, that is the greatest loss, that is the greatest illusion, and that is the greatest anomaly." The Lord can be worshiped in all stages of life. For instance, even in the wombs of their mothers MahArAja PrahlAda and MahArAja ParIkSit worshiped the Lord; even in his very childhood, at the age of only five years, Dhruva MahArAja worshiped the Lord; even in full youth, MahArAja AmbarISa worshiped the Lord; and even at the last stage of his frustration and old age MahArAja DhRtarASTra worshiped the Lord. AjAmila worshiped the Lord even at the point of death, and Citraketu worshiped the Lord even in heaven and in hell. In the NarasiMha PurANa it is said that as the hellish inhabitants began to chant the holy name of the Lord they began to be elevated from hell towards heaven. DurvAsA Muni has also supported this view: mucyeta yan-nAmny udite nArako 'pi. "Simply by chanting the holy name of the Lord the inhabitants of hell became released from their hellish persecution." So the conclusion of SrImad-BhAgavatam, as given by Sukadeva GosvAmI to MahArAja ParIkSit, is: <center> etan nirvidyamAnAnAm icchatAm akuto-bhayam yoginAM nRpa nirNItaM harer nAmAnukIrtanam </center> "O King, it is finally decided that everyone, namely those in the renounced order of life, the mystics, and the enjoyers of fruitive work, should chant the holy name of the Lord fearlessly to achieve the desired success in their pursuits." (BhAg. 2.1.11) Similarly, as indicated indirectly in various places in revealed scriptures: 1. Even though one is well versed in all the Vedas and scriptures, if one is not a devotee of the Supreme Lord, the Personality of Godhead, he is considered to be the lowest of mankind. 2. In the GaruDa PurANa, BRhan-nAradIya PurANa and Padma PurANa, the same is repeated: What is the use of Vedic knowledge and penances for one who is devoid of devotional service to the Lord? 3. What is the comparison of thousands of prajApatis to one devotee of the Lord? 4. Sukadeva GosvAmI said (BhAg. 2.4.17) that neither the ascetic, nor one who is greatly munificent, nor one who is famous, nor the great philosopher, nor the great occultist, nor anyone else can achieve the desired result without being engaged in the service of the Lord. 5. Even if a place is more glorious than heaven, if there is no glorification of the Lord of VaikuNTha or His pure devotee, it should at once be quitted. 6. The pure devotee refuses to accept all the five different types of liberation in order to be engaged in the service of the Lord. The final conclusion, therefore, is that the glories of the Lord must be always and everywhere proclaimed. One should hear about His glories, one should chant about His glories, and one should always remember His glories because that is the highest perfectional stage of life. As far as fruitive work is concerned, it is limited to an enjoyable body; as far as yoga is concerned, it is limited to the acquirement of mystic power; as far as empiric philosophy is concerned, it is limited to the attainment of transcendental knowledge; and as far as transcendental knowledge is concerned, it is limited to attainment of salvation. Even if they are adopted, there is every chance of discrepancies in discharging the particular type of functions. But adoption of the transcendental devotional service of the Lord has no limit, nor is there fear of falling down. The process automatically reaches the final stage by the grace of the Lord. In the preliminary stage of devotional service there is an apparent requisite for knowledge, but in the higher stage there is no necessity of such knowledge. The best and guaranteed path of progress is therefore engagement in bhakti-yoga, pure devotional service. The cream of SrImad-BhAgavatam in the foregoing four zlokas is sometimes squeezed out by the impersonalist for different interpretations in their favor, but it should be carefully noted that the four zlokas were first described by the Personality of Godhead Himself, and thus the impersonalist has no scope to enter into them because he has no conception of the Personality of Godhead. Therefore, the impersonalist may squeeze out any interpretations from them, but such interpretations will never be accepted by those who are taught in the disciplic succession from BrahmA, as will be cleared up in the following verses. Besides that, the zruti confirms that the Supreme Truth Absolute Personality of Godhead never reveals Himself to anyone who is falsely proud of his academic knowledge. The zruti-mantra clearly says (KaTha UpaniSad 1.2.23): <center>nAyam AtmA pravacanena labhyo na medhayA na bahudhA zrutena yam evaiSa vRNute tena labhyas tasyaiSa AtmA vivRNute tanuM svAm </center> The whole matter is explained by the Lord Himself, and one who has no approach to the Lord in His personal feature can rarely understand the PURPORT of SrImad-BhAgavatam without being taught by the bhAgavatas in the disciplic succession. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
