Guest guest Posted July 13, 2005 Report Posted July 13, 2005 Hi Bonnie, What I posted does not attribute the passing of the EU legislation to the CAFTA. Sorry for any misunderstanding there. Also, the much opposition I've heard for this is from a lot of " lefties " and some " righties " too. Also, it was the " lefties " of Europe who passed the vitamin legislation we read about the other day, so I wouldn't jump to a " right wing conspiracy " conclusion There is a LOT of opposition to CAFTA, for a variety of reasons. Here is another big opposition campaign to CAFTA in its current form: http://www.organicconsumers.org/starbucks/cafta_fair_trade.cfm http://www.organicconsumers.org/corp/cafta051605.cfm I personally think its in the interest of all Americans to look into this further. Trade and cooperation are good things, but not all the legislation associated with them are done right and in a beneficial way. I've put together, in a nutshell, how CAFTA it is related to any international vitamin legislation and supplements ... The Free Trade agreements that have come before us (NAFTA) and the free trade agreements that are coming before us have in them a goal of " harmonizing " food safety standards. For example - when we got into NAFTA pesticides that were banned from use in American crops and on our grocery shelves were allowed back into the picture cause Mexico uses them, and since they are a poorer nation, and had a free trade agreement set up, we aren't allowed to be prejudiced against their produce, even if it was full of poisons that were deemed inedible for years " The Codex Commission was established by the UN in 1961 and it " establishes guidelines to harmonize trade in food " . With the WTO in place, the Commission now has the means to enforce its rulings that used to put out as useless bureaucratic announcements. Through the targeted use of trade sanctions, the WTO has the means to compel nations to obey its rulings. The Codex Commission has made it known that it expects all nations to " harmonize " their regulations governing dietary supplements with its new regulatory framework. CAFTA requires all signatory nations to " harmonize " their domestic food safety standards to those issued by the Codex Commission. John C. Hammell of International Advocates for Health Freedom points out that the " safety standards " imposed by the Commission in essence treat vitamins as potentially dangerous drugs, imposing " Maximum Safe Permitted Levels " of potency that would make them practically useless. " In 1994 the people of the US persuaded their legislators to enact the Dietary Supplement, Health and Education Act " because of some BS that went down with the FDA trying to ban vitamins and supplements and " in 1992 had armed FDA agents conduct a raid on the office of " vitamin doctor " Jonathan Wright MD, trashing his office, seizing records, and harassing his patients all over the use of an injectable vitamin B supplement from Germany that is free of additives for his many allergic patients, and using a natural adrenal cortical extract called ACE to treat immune disorders. ACE was sold by Eli Lilly for over 30 years before being dropped in favor of the more expensive, less effective synthetic cortisone. The FDA then declared that ACE was a " new drug " ; overnight, it became illegal. That was only one of dozens of commando-style assaults that had taken place all over the country on health food stores, holistic clinics, and nutrient distributors. Bad enough we've got our own beurocracies involved in our health choices, don't need the UN's there too ;-p We the people already made our choices known on this subject! *Smile* Chris (list mom) http://www.alittleolfactory.com On Behalf Of Bonnie Walker I think some clarification is needed here b/c it was my understanding from the original post that it was the EU that passed the " anti-vitamin C " laws and this petition Chris just posted is attributing it to the UN and Central American Free Trade Agreement (CAFTA)?? I think this is a bait and switch of the extreme right to get more people to side with their " end of American Independence and way of life " hogwash regarding international cooperation. While I do not want to see Vitamin C becoming illegal this seems like there is a bit of smoke and mirrors going on here. How exactly does the Central American Free Trade Agreemtn CAFTA have anything to do with the EU? At the very least, I would be careful about actually sending the below message to your congressional representatives as it seems to be incorrect in attributing the EU's new laws to the UN (and then trying to pass that off onto the upcoming CAFTA vote ... which seems to be a confusing stretch) .... unless I missed something and the UN actually did pass a new guideline .... is that what the EU's ruling was based on?? I guess I need to go find more articles related to this ... I don't have time right now, but I'll share anything I uncover. If anyone has any further information The whole world has gone mad. It IS something in the water, isn't it??? Quote
Guest guest Posted July 14, 2005 Report Posted July 14, 2005 I'm really impressed with your summary of the information. I've been hearing about CAFTA and been unable to find sources of information worth slogging through... that stopcafta.com site, for example, is so up in arms about other issues (perhaps related, perhaps not) that it gets in my way of learning more about CAFTA itself. Thanks for doing some of the legwork for us ;-) Best, Josh Quote
Guest guest Posted July 14, 2005 Report Posted July 14, 2005 Yes, thank you Chris and Liz for the rational summary and additional links that contained more palatable information than STOPCAFTA.com's " ...a synod of sickly Euro-socialists deciding which [supplements] you can take, or whether you'll be able to take any of them at all " . They really are not going to get as many people involved using that type of hype as they might think they are. The Organic Consumers site's rationale of " Fair Trade Not Free Trade " made a heck of a lot more sense without making broad generalizations or taking pot shots at anyone. - " Joshua Alexander " <listservs Wednesday, July 13, 2005 5:50 PM Re: What Does Free Trade Agreements Have To Do WIth Supplements ? (Was RE:Latest on vitamins-oils next?) I'm really impressed with your summary of the information. I've been hearing about CAFTA and been unable to find sources of information worth slogging through... that stopcafta.com site, for example, is so up in arms about other issues (perhaps related, perhaps not) that it gets in my way of learning more about CAFTA itself. Thanks for doing some of the legwork for us ;-) Best, Josh Quote
Guest guest Posted July 16, 2005 Report Posted July 16, 2005 Thank you for this site: http://www.healthfreedomusa.org It makes it really easy to take action against CODEX, etc, with an 'easy 6 steps' page ( http://www.healthfreedomusa.org/action/ ) There's also a blog at http://www.healthfreedomusa.org/codexblog/ to stay updated -Josh Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.