Guest guest Posted April 16, 2009 Report Posted April 16, 2009 Hi Phil, I have the current edition of JAMS (Journal of Acupuncture and Meridian Studies ISBN: 2005-2901) which published some of these researches as well... On Thu, Apr 16, 2009 at 9:44 AM, < wrote: > > My conclusions: Up to now, though fascinating and potentially of great > biological importance, modern research on the BHD (Bonghan Duct) and BHC > (Bonghan Corpuscle) system is fragmented and incomplete. Therefore, IMO, its > conclusions highly speculative. > I agree. The study that appears in JAMS is really more about these structures that are very difficult to visualize but with Trypan blue, that seems to help delineate them without staining the surrounding adipose tissue. The idea that these are somehow related to internal connections between meridians or something along those lines is not even discussed in the JAMS article, but the term " acupuncture " shows up in the article's keywords. Not sure why. > > It would be a great boost to acupuncture and basic research to have sound > histological evidence for an integrated 14-Channel duct + corpuscular > structure that links the body surface with the interior organs, and that > follows the same pathways and point locations as postulated by TCM Channel > Theory. However, I cannot find convincing evidence of that up to now. > Me neither. This same JAMS edition seems to be attempting to locate some histological evidence amongst the " coiled blood plexuses " in rats. The premise here is the theory that acupuncture points are actually neurovascular bundles, an idea promoted by Deke Kendall amongst others. When visualized on a rat's abdomen, the Kidney and Stomach channels did have some of these neurovascular nodes in something of a regular spacing along the trajectory of what we call the channels. However only 7 of 11 points showed this anatomical feature. Some of the points were very NEAR neurovascular nodes too. So, there may be something to this, but perhaps different points utilize different anatomy and work via unique mechanisms. This would be somewhat consistant with classical theory. I still wonder if these experiments are barking up the wrong tree. I mean, Chinese medicine theory evolved based on human perceptions at the gross level. We treat signs and symptoms that are observable at the gross level, even shen level things give rise to indications in eye movements or general demeanor. However, when we look through other instruments we may be looking at a molecule to locate an organ's function, or trying to visualize a point by observing anatomy instead of physiology. I'm trying to redefine the whole question of " is qi and/or channels real? " in favor of an observable reality that is predominately a human perception. Fortuantely, clinical results also exist within the rhelm of human perception. Perhaps CM's therapeutic strength is in the patient's wellbeing, human perceptions, etc. Its like Western medicine treats lab values, and Chinese medicine treats the human perceptions. Photography is a good analogy. Take a picture of a dog. Western medicine is focused on the dots that make up the image while Chinese medicine is more focused on the image that the dots make up - the shape of a dog. There is no dog there, this is a human perception, but just as real... -- , DAOM Pain is inevitable, suffering is optional. Quote
Guest guest Posted April 16, 2009 Report Posted April 16, 2009 Hi All, http://www.acupuncturetoday.com/mpacms/at/article.php?id=31918 ] says: " ... Korean researchers have rediscovered threadlike microscopic anatomical structures that correspond with the layout of traditional acupuncture meridians or channels. Acupuncture channels are no longer imaginary lines, but specific anatomical structures ... " The references to recent Korean research in that article were: (2007) Johng H-M, Yoo JS, Yoon T-J, et al. Use of magnetic nanoparticles to visualize threadlike structures inside lymphatic vessels of rats. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. March; 4(1):77-82. (2005) Shin HS, Johng HM, Lee BC, et al. Feulgen reaction study of novel threadlike structures (Bonghan ducts) on the surfaces of mammalian organs. Anat Rec. 284B:35-40. (2004) Soh KS. Bonghan duct and acupuncture meridian as optical channel of biophoton. Journal of the Korean Physical Society. Nov;45(5):1196-8. Other references from WWW are below. Note that: (1) The published Korean work describes thread-like microtubules on and in lymphatic and blood vessels of rats and on the surfaces of some mammalian organs, especially liver but also on omentum of experimental animals. However, http://tinyurl.com/c5oowk says " ...but the complete network, including its subcutaneous aspects, has yet to be isolated ... " (2) http://tinyurl.com/ctx7bq says: " Thus we GUESS that the threadlike structures reported here is possibly the extra-vascular Bonghan duct. According to Bonghan Kim the network of Bonghan duct consists of intra-vascular ducts, extra-vascular ducts, and superficial ducts under skin. The superficial ducts are the anatomical basis of the acupuncture meridians. However, the Bonghan ducts HAVE NOT BEEN CONFIRMED YET because the observing method was not known [until now]. " (3) http://tinyurl.com/c7q2x6 [2008 paper] says: " Together with the adrenal medulla and sympathetic ganglia, the BH system is thought to be a physical substrate of the acupuncture Meridian system and MAY REPRESENT a novel source of catecholamine synthesis, storage, and, possibly, signaling ... " See more recent papers at: http://tinyurl.com/d5oq89 http://tinyurl.com/cl2oj7 http://tinyurl.com/dln2qw Recent work showed coiled blood plexuses in rat skin that corresponded with locations of some acupoints on KI Channels. However, http://tinyurl.com/dlu42f says: " ... further studies ... need to elucidate the identification of the neurovascular plexuses with acupoints or BHCs [bonghan Corpuscles]. My conclusions: Up to now, though fascinating and potentially of great biological importance, modern research on the BHD (Bonghan Duct) and BHC (Bonghan Corpuscle) system is fragmented and incomplete. Therefore, IMO, its conclusions highly speculative. It would be a great boost to acupuncture and basic research to have sound histological evidence for an integrated 14-Channel duct + corpuscular structure that links the body surface with the interior organs, and that follows the same pathways and point locations as postulated by TCM Channel Theory. However, I cannot find convincing evidence of that up to now. I hope that future research will prove that the classical acupoints and Channel locations have a definite histological and physiological basis, mediated by the Bonghan system of corpuscles and ducts. Meanwhile, based on our training and experience, acupuncturists will continue to treat points that give us reliable clinical results. Best regards, Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.