Guest guest Posted August 11, 2008 Report Posted August 11, 2008 Dear Barbara, Thanks for this. But what kind of nutritionist does CSPI have? CSPI senior nutritionist David Schardt said: " You'd be much better off giving up non-diet soda " .. He should have said " diet soda " because it contains aspartame and acesulfame potassium. Better still he should have said both. Won't they ever really get it all together? This will send a message. I just hope that statement doesn't have people changing from Coke to Diet Coke not realizing these sweeteners are poison. Betty www.mpwhi.com, www.dorway.com and www.wnho.net Aspartame Toxicity Center, www.holisticmed.com/aspartame 09:40 AM 8/11/2008, Fred & Barbara Metzler wrote: >The nonprofit Center for Science in the Public Interest filed suit >today against Coca-Cola and Nestle for making fraudulent claims in >marketing and labeling for Enviga, a new artificially sweetened >green tea soft drink. Labeled " the calorie burner " on cans, Enviga >is marketed as a weight-loss aid, with claims that it has " negative >calories " and [...] >Bookmark to: >Add 'Watchdog Group Sues Coke, Nestle For Bogus' to Del.icio.usAdd >'Watchdog Group Sues Coke, Nestle For Bogus' to diggAdd 'Watchdog >Group Sues Coke, Nestle For Bogus' to FURLAdd 'Watchdog Group Sues >Coke, Nestle For Bogus' to blinklistAdd 'Watchdog Group Sues Coke, >Nestle For Bogus' to redditAdd 'Watchdog Group Sues Coke, Nestle For >Bogus' to Feed Me LinksAdd 'Watchdog Group Sues Coke, Nestle For >Bogus' to TechnoratiAdd 'Watchdog Group Sues Coke, Nestle For Bogus' >to My WebAdd 'Watchdog Group Sues Coke, Nestle For Bogus' to >NewsvineAdd 'Watchdog Group Sues Coke, Nestle For Bogus' to >SocializerAdd 'Watchdog Group Sues Coke, Nestle For Bogus' to >Ma.gnoliaAdd 'Watchdog Group Sues Coke, Nestle For Bogus' to Stumble Upon >Add 'Watchdog Group Sues Coke, Nestle For Bogus' to Google >BookmarksAdd 'Watchdog Group Sues Coke, Nestle For Bogus' to >RawSugarAdd 'Watchdog Group Sues Coke, Nestle For Bogus' to >SquidooAdd 'Watchdog Group Sues Coke, Nestle For Bogus' to SpurlAdd >'Watchdog Group Sues Coke, Nestle For Bogus' to BlinkBitsAdd >'Watchdog Group Sues Coke, Nestle For Bogus' to NetvouzAdd 'Watchdog >Group Sues Coke, Nestle For Bogus' to RojoAdd 'Watchdog Group Sues >Coke, Nestle For Bogus' to BlogmarksAdd 'Watchdog Group Sues Coke, >Nestle For Bogus' to ShadowsAdd 'Watchdog Group Sues Coke, Nestle >For Bogus' to SimpyAdd 'Watchdog Group Sues Coke, Nestle For Bogus' >to Co.mmentsAdd 'Watchdog Group Sues Coke, Nestle For Bogus' to Scuttle > >The nonprofit Center for Science in the Public Interest filed suit >today against Coca-Cola and Nestle for making fraudulent claims in >marketing and labeling for Enviga, a new artificially sweetened >green tea soft drink. Labeled " the calorie burner " on cans, Enviga >is marketed as a weight-loss aid, with claims that it has " negative >calories " and that it can " keep those extra calories from building >up. " Enviga's web site also says the drink is " much smarter than >following fads, quick fixes, and crash diets. " But according to CSPI >scientists who reviewed the studies cited by Coke and Nestle, Enviga >is just a highly caffeinated and over-priced diet soda, and is >exactly the kind of faddy, phony diet aid it claims not to be. > >The suit was filed in U.S. District Court in New Jersey, part of the >region in which the beverage is being introduced. In December, CSPI >served formal notification on Coke and Nestle (and their >partnership, Beverage Partners Worldwide) that they would be sued if >they continued to use the unsubstantiated calorie-burning and >weight-loss claims on Enviga labels and ads, but the company >indicated publicly and privately that it had no plans to change the claims. > >Enviga consists of carbonated water, calcium, concentrated green tea >extract, various " natural flavors, " and ingredients typically found >in diet soda, such as caffeine (three diet colas' worth), phosphoric >acid, and the artificial sweeteners aspartame and acesulfame >potassium. The company says its green tea extracts are high in an >antioxidant called epigallocatechin gallate, or EGCG. > >Many of Enviga's claims are based on a 72-hour Nestle-funded study >of 31 people who were given a drink containing amounts of EGCG and >caffeine equivalent to three cans of Enviga. On average, those >subjects expended more energy, according to an abstract of the >unpublished study. In any event, none of the 31 were overweight or >obese - in fact all were quite lean to begin with. In other words, >the company's test may have detected some slight evidence that it >increases calorie burning slightly - but only in a short-term test >of thin people who were given a strictly controlled diet. And when >the study was presented at a conference of the Obesity Society >(publishers of the journal Obesity and also known as NAASO), the >society disputed the study's conclusions, insisting " it is improper >to state or imply that the results of this study supports any weight >loss " claim. > >No test of Enviga lasted more than three days. One European study >found that EGCG and caffeine did not increase energy expenditure >after one month and did not help people lose weight. One longer-term >Japanese study did show that a tea fortified with EGCG and caffeine >helped people lose more weight than a control tea, but then again, >the study was conducted by a tea company and the subjects of the >study were 38 of that company's male employees. > >Enviga costs between $1.29 and $1.49 per can, and the company >suggests that the maximum effect is gained by drinking three cans a >day, or about $1,500 worth of the soda per year. > > " There is no clear evidence that what's in Enviga will help you >control your weight, " said CSPI senior nutritionist David Schardt. > " You'd be much better off giving up non-diet soda, which costs >nothing to do, or by joining a gym, which is typically less >expensive than paying for 3 cans of Enviga a day. " > >CSPI will be represented by its litigation director Stephen Gardner, >and by Mark Cuker and Michael J. Quirk from the firm of Williams >Cuker Berezofsky, based in Cherry Hill, N.J. > > " This deceptive marketing campaign needs to be nipped in the bud >before many more millions of Americans get ripped off, " said Cuker. > " Enviga burns more money than calories. " > >CSPI's litigation unit, formed in 2004, seeks to stop deceptive >labeling or marketing campaigns or other practices that harm >consumers' health. It's a strategy that helped spur KFC to drop >artificial trans fats for deep-frying, and has resulted in improved >labeling of products made by Tropicana, Quaker, Frito-Lay, Procter & >Gamble, Kraft, and Cadbury-Schweppes. CSPI is soon likely to file a >major lawsuit aimed at stopping Kellogg and Viacom (parent of the >Nickelodeon television channel) from marketing junk food to young children. > > " If the Food and Drug Administration were at all credible, major >corporations like Coca-Cola and Nestle wouldn't try to take >consumers to the cleaners like this, " said CSPI executive director >Michael F. Jacobson. " Imagine - two of the companies partly >responsible for the general fattening of America are now urging us >to pay them $4 a day to slim down with Enviga. The chutzpah. " Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.