Guest guest Posted September 5, 2008 Report Posted September 5, 2008 Bill C-51 - The Amendments Don't Deliver: MP Lunney to Health Minister http://www.jameslunneymp.ca/speeches_detail.php?recordID=563 June 30, 2008 The Honourable Tony Clement, PC, MP Minister of Health House of Commons Ottawa, ON K1A 0A6 Dear Minister Clement, Re: Bill C-51 / Natural Health Products Further to comments directed through your personal staff the last week of the Parliamentary session, I am writing to clarify concerns about Bill C-51 and the amendments put forward to address issues raised by producers and consumers of Natural Health Products (NHPs). At the outset, I must commend your willingness to address the concerns of the NHP community; for too long, previous administrations have neglected to recognize the importance of NHPs to Canadians. That being said, I have serious reservations about the legislation, the accompanying amendments and the way NHPs are currently being regulated. From a policy perspective: the Conservative Party (2005 Policy Declaration) “supports enhanced freedom for Canadians in their choice of natural health products and complementary treatments, with proper safeguards for public safety.” Our party (and legacy parties) have worked hard to champion the cause of natural products and therapies, and many Canadians supported our position on these issues. First, one major concern of the NHP community has been the lack of a legal or ‘third’ category, as recommended by the Standing Committee on Health in their 1998 report Natural Health Products: A New Vision. The tabled version of Bill C-51 did not include a legal definition of Natural Health Products; the amendments address this concern. However, rather than provide a separate category for NHPs, the definition of an NHP falls under the umbrella of therapeutic products, putting them in the same category as drugs, devices, cells and tissues, or any combination of the above. This is contrary to what the Standing Committee and the Transition Team that created the Office of Natural Health Products’ (OHNP) recommended; both were clear that NHPs should be distinct from both food and drugs. Furthermore, a second amendment grants, notwithstanding the fact that a product meets the definition of a Natural Health Product, the power to designate that product as not an NHP; this clause effectively gives Health Canada the power to classify any NHP as a pharmaceutical drug or prescription product. Minister, if it is not the government’s intention to restrict access to NHPs or remove products from the market, why do we need a notwithstanding clause that permits a product that meets the legal definition of an NHP to be classed as a drug and thus removed from the public domain? The search and seizure powers in C-51 are also troubling. Inspectors seizing or ordering recalls of products that Canadians rely upon for their health and well-being amounts to making health decisions that inspectors are not qualified to make; surely it is not too much to ask to have inspectors justify their enforcement decisions to a judge before proceeding. Risk/benefit analysis must also consider the risk of removing a product that Canadians depend on to maintain their health. Concerns about C-51 are exacerbated by very real concerns with the way in which NHPs are currently being regulated. Of the approximately 13,000 NHPs that have gone through the product licensing process since 2001, about 50% of those products are being rejected or withdrawn. The Health Committee recently heard that products are not being rejected because of safety concerns; rather, they are not making it through mostly because of “paperwork deficiencies.” Given that the vast majority of product applications are the simpler, single-ingredient monographs, it is doubtful that the failure rate of the more difficult, multiple-ingredient product applications will improve. In the past two weeks I have had representations from two more BC-based companies, both of whom have worked extensively with Health Canada to see their well-researched products, with no safety concerns, held up or denied after extensive delays, questionable demands for more information and what clearly appears to be obstructionist tactics from Natural Health Productsate (NHPD) regulators. This amounts to restricted product access, due not to safety concerns but to ill-defined red tape, moving targets and what is perceived to be a hostile or incompetent regulator. The Transition Team had a vision that the Minister of Health would be a champion of Natural Health Products and a new paradigm of wellness promotion and disease prevention, taking us away from the paternalistic, disease-management model of the last century. Canadians are looking to government to protect access to the products they value, not strangle access and innovation. By embracing the original vision embodied in Standing Committee and Transition Teams reports from a decade ago, we could create an opportunity to advance a regulatory model that will satisfy safety, choice and quality product availability. It is worth the time and effort to get this right. Sincerely, James Lunney, M.P. Nanaimo-Alberni -- Forwarding.... please forward to Canadians.... Canada's " Charter of Health Freedom " Launch, September 10, 2008. Please attend! --- History in the Making --- When: 1:00 pm - 2:00 pm (get there a bit early) The Charter of Health Freedom website is: www.charterofhealthfreedom.org Questions related to the Vancouver launch!? HANS - (604) 435-0512 or lorna Founded in 1984, Health Action Network Society is a membership-based, non-profit charitable organization dedicated to gathering and disseminating health promotion information.Most Canadians believe that individuals are responsible for their own health and wellness decisions. Now, as a result of the insights gleaned from Bills C51 and C52, uniquely positive legislation to support that concept has been created. It is called the Charter of Health Freedom, and it is for Canada. " The Charter represents responsible legislation, covering issues of safety for the public, while still ensuring an individual's freedom to choose, " says Lorna Hancock, Executive Director of HANS - Health Action Network Society (1984), one of the numerous Canadian consumer groups involved in the Charter launch. " We're very excited to be involved. In the history of Canada's natural health movement, this is the first time that a united, grassroots, consumer-driven initiative of such proportions has been created. " Since 2004, regulations better suited to higher-risk pharmaceutical products have burdened the natural health products industry, resulting in less innovation, reduced product availability and a regulatory backlog, with no realistic end in sight. While not everybody within the industry has agreed upon the best strategy to address Bills C51 and C52, the Bills' introduction was the wake-up call that the industry needed to realize our shared challenges. " What this launch does is introduce a positive solution for legislators, regulators, and the Canadian people in the way it handles natural health products, " says Hancock. " This is history in the making. " The Charter of Health Freedom, available online on September 10th, was created by constitutional lawyer Shawn Buckley, President of the Natural Health Products Protection Association, and on Sept 10, 2008, it is being introduced to the public for their consideration and endorsement. Public events will be taking place in Winnipeg, Kelowna, Toronto, Calgary and Vancouver. For details, visit www.charterofhealthfreedom.org. Please show your support by attending! Where: Steps of Robson St Plaza (at Vancouver Art Gallery, corner of Robson & Howe) Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.