Guest guest Posted January 22, 2004 Report Posted January 22, 2004 Hi Catherine, This is very interesting. Thanks for telling us about it! Is this database ONLY for those treating animals in Australia, or is it available for all animal practitioners all over the world to report reactions they've encountered? I've just begun to check out their web site in detail, and there is a lot to absorb. What aspects of this are you hesitant to embrace (seems that whenever a gov't body gets involved with something there are bound to be some bad points)? *Smile* Chris (list mom) http://www.alittleolfactory.com Catherine [happyhorses] Thursday, January 15, 2004 12:36 AM Re: cats and diffused oils - a possible campaign Jen often seen your posts on other lists and know this is a 'pet' subject of yours. Shame you are not in Australia. We are finally getting organised here and holistic vets with animal natural therapists now have a procedure we are encouraging others to be able to report any adverse reactions to any natural therapy or essential oil, herb etc with animals. Actually owners can also report incidents of adverse reactions (and non effect as well). The Australia National Registration Authority (NRA) for Agricultural and Veterinary Chemicals now has facilities for us to voluntarily report incidents though they have gone through a name change and now call themselves the Australian Pesticides & Veterinary Medicines Authority. This will give you an idea anyway, so eventually there will be a decent database https://services.apvma.gov.au/AerpWebApp/Welcome.jsp It is still a long way off from what you would like to see and some of me likes the idea, another part of me is still hesitant to embrace certain aspects. For those in Australia and interested in working with animals, just as an aside, natural therapy products marketed for animal use are now going through a similar process we went through with the TGA a few years ago where any product for use with animals needs to be registered to be able to be sold on by a third party. (its been a long day and not focused enough to go into the details). regards Catherine Author ~ A Healthy Horse the Natural Way http://www.catherinebird.com.au Keep up to date with natural therapies for horses with our monthly online newsletter at catherinebird/ Quote
Guest guest Posted January 23, 2004 Report Posted January 23, 2004 Arrrrggghhhhhhhh ... why did you ask this ..... I can't see why people from outside Australia could not comment. Now ... >I've just begun to check out their web site in detail, and there is a >lot to absorb. What aspects of this are you hesitant to embrace (seems >that whenever a gov't body gets involved with something there are bound >to be some bad points)? I can see where something like this is useful, however the ageing hippy inside me does get concerned. As a practitioner, I do not like seeing science fragment natural therapies in order to either explain them or find a way to control them, they have a way of then putting the fragments back together again with a very important part missing. That part being the 'soul' or philosophy, or energetic aspect that because of a patriarchal ignorance that permeates modern science, gets dismissed or is bastardised to an extent that they in their research destroy the validity of thousands of years. Wow that came out a little heavier than I intended but I suppose it sums it up for me. I do get tired of science claiming something doesn't work, just because they haven't figured out a way to prove it does, and then in turn government bodies using this ignorance to remove access to a wonderful herb. A tv program here attacked homeopathy viciously last year, and worked really hard to discount it as doing any good, and unfortunately the average person watching it could easily have agreed with them. For me if I had been presenting such an argument I would have been ashamed to display such ignorance to a national audience. Unfortunately because of the way our society is structured, this sort of approach is accepted as " IT " and then used inappropriately. HOWEVER, as rebellious as I am, I also get concerned when practitioners or suppliers do not operate from the most ethical basis they can. I think it is wonderful a company can introduce so many people to natural therapies, however when such a company encourages unsafe practices that belong in the realm of the therapist to the layperson who then misuses that information and causes harm, the greed of the original company damages so many aspects of the natural therapy industry. If for example everyone started reporting an adverse reaction to YL's raindrop therapy, who eventually suffers? The way YL is structured you can bet it is not going to be Gary Young. It is going to be the people who use his techniques AND then I am afraid it will also be anyone who uses an essential oil. My concern is something like this reporting system could see too many restrictions placed upon the use of a herb or essential oil that could see some little twit in power make a law where none of us have legal access. Now I have raised this issue with some of those involved with the policy formation of this reporting system and structuring of this government body, and they say that they want this system to dispel fear rather than engender it. I think if the information is readily available so practitioners can check if what they suspect is an adverse reaction in their own cases has been reported before, great. BUT if the information is used against practitioners then I will be distressed. I am pretty heavily involved in the development of the use of natural therapies with animals here in Australia and if I could live in my altruist pink bubble and just operate in a way I consider that to be of a responsible therapist, I would be in heaven. However, many of my cases now come to me because of the actions of another practitioner (s). In the vet clinic I am involved with for small animals, weekly !!! at the moment we have a run of cats who were being treated homeopathically by distance for a condition that results in kidney failure if not addressed appropriately, in each instance the healer who has boosted this vets business has said to the owner/carer " don't take your cat to a vet " and continued to send them remedies which in most cases have added up to $300 (now homeopathics do not cost anywhere near this), without wishing to sound harsh, but this therapist is basically murdering these cats that don't get medical care. I often inherit horses where other therapists have incorrectly diagnosed (yes we are not supposed to) the condition, and finally the horse has found its way to a vet to find the real issue. Now part of this is because they have had bad experiences with vets and they can be a hard bunch to deal with (much like some old school doctors), but from my experience, if I show the vets I am not a ratbag twit and show them a professional respect, they are only human and usually meet me at some point. Now it is not my place to " police " this, but where is my responsibility. Due to legal issues, the associations these practitioners belong to are unable to do much and these people tend to be very loud with their opinions so end up holding committee positions (similar to what we have seen with NAHA) and they then become so protective and paranoid that no one wins. The animal and it's human are the ones to suffer. Now I don't want an outsider like a vet board or another government body stop what I love doing and I hope do well, because of the actions of foolish egocentric idiots (hmmm judgement I suppose) ... and all I can do is stay within my own boundaries and ethics hoping that maybe some of these idiots realise they are dangerous and go get an office job. Dear me it is Saturday morning and I have given myself the morning off to muse and catch up with emails before a massage for me so I think I answered your question, but I have also vented rather self indulgently and may read this when it hits the digest and cringe. Time for another coffee me thinks. So yes I see this filling a need, but I also fear how its original purpose may later be used. Catherine Author ~ A Healthy Horse the Natural Way http://www.catherinebird.com.au Keep up to date with natural therapies for horses with our monthly online newsletter at catherinebird/ --- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.563 / Virus Database: 355 - Release 17/01/2004 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.