Guest guest Posted May 12, 2006 Report Posted May 12, 2006 does anyone know a good and complete traditional chinese herbal medicine book or encyclopedia with all of the natural medicines discribed in good detail? thank you, Joel Quote
Guest guest Posted May 13, 2006 Report Posted May 13, 2006 Hi Joel If you're looking for English-language texts then Bensky's " Materia Medica " 3rd Edition and " Formulas & Strategies " (Eastland Press) have been the standard for decades. But in my view they are sometimes very difficult to understand (obscure and self-contradictory). I feel this is because they were mostly 'pieced together' by Bensky and friends from a small number of Chinese texts - and inevitably that method of writing will produce synchretistic anomalies. Nonetheless, I think they are the only English-language texts that deal with materia medica and formulae in this depth - and they are my first point of reference. I also like Jiao Shu-de's " Medicinals " and " Formulas " (recently brought out by Paradigm Publications) for an occasionaly slightly different angle and sometimes better understanding. And Z'ev has sung the praises of " Clinical Handbook of Internal Medicine " (vols 1 and 2) by Will Maclean and Jane Lyttleton (University of Western Syndney). It's sitting on my bookshelp, though I haven't had the time to use it yet. But it looks good - very clear writing and some useful pathomechanistic explanations - very readable, so could be read from cover. Doesn't give much background regarding the herbs and formulae's construction, but really useful clinical guide for the learning practioner working in clinic. Let me know if you're looking for Chinese-language - the answer to that is more long-winded. David --- In Chinese Medicine , " froggie333z " <froggie333z wrote: > > does anyone know a good and complete traditional chinese herbal medicine > book or encyclopedia with all of the natural medicines discribed in good > detail? > > thank you, > Joel > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted May 13, 2006 Report Posted May 13, 2006 Oh, I forgot to mention " Fluid Physiology and Pathology in Traditional " by Steven Clavey (Churchill Livingston). A book primarily dealing with herbal interventions - amazingly useful and cogent explanations of how to use herbal medicines to treat body fluid pathologies - with masses of pathomechanistic information. I'm currently reading it - and loving it. David Chinese Medicine , " David Gordon " <junhengclinic wrote: > > Hi Joel > > If you're looking for English-language texts then Bensky's " Materia > Medica " 3rd Edition and " Formulas & Strategies " (Eastland Press) have > been the standard for decades. > > But in my view they are sometimes very difficult to understand > (obscure and self-contradictory). I feel this is because they were > mostly 'pieced together' by Bensky and friends from a small number of > Chinese texts - and inevitably that method of writing will produce > synchretistic anomalies. > > Nonetheless, I think they are the only English-language texts that > deal with materia medica and formulae in this depth - and they are my > first point of reference. > > I also like Jiao Shu-de's " Medicinals " and " Formulas " (recently > brought out by Paradigm Publications) for an occasionaly slightly > different angle and sometimes better understanding. > > And Z'ev has sung the praises of " Clinical Handbook of Internal > Medicine " (vols 1 and 2) by Will Maclean and Jane Lyttleton > (University of Western Syndney). It's sitting on my bookshelp, though > I haven't had the time to use it yet. But it looks good - very clear > writing and some useful pathomechanistic explanations - very > readable, so could be read from cover. Doesn't give much background > regarding the herbs and formulae's construction, but really useful > clinical guide for the learning practioner working in clinic. > > Let me know if you're looking for Chinese-language - the answer to > that is more long-winded. > > David > > > --- In > Chinese Medicine , " froggie333z@ " > <froggie333z@> wrote: > > > > does anyone know a good and complete traditional chinese herbal > medicine > > book or encyclopedia with all of the natural medicines discribed in > good > > detail? > > > > thank you, > > Joel > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.