Guest guest Posted May 23, 2005 Report Posted May 23, 2005 Dear All, I am now suggesting an end to this thread. Its getting personal and way off topic so please no more. Regards, Angelo (moderator) Chinese Medicine , kim blankenship <kuangguiyu> wrote: > Skepticism is never lame. Questioning authority, especially arrogant authority that insists one must simply be quiet and concur with undivulged counter-measures as the only solution, is always a good idea. > > Kim Blankenship, L.Ac. > (not the opposition) > > jreidomd <jreidomd> wrote: > The May 3 additions to SB233 read in part: > Nothing in this section shall be construed to authorize an acupuncturist to > diagnose any physical or mental disorder pursuant to Sections 2038 and > 2052. > This was proposed by the CMA. That is public knowledge. But actually it is > the content that means something, not who proposes it. There is no shortage > of potential beneficiaries if it came to shutting us down. > > Request for language that limited diagnosis to certain conditions was made > by Senator Figueroa in a private meeting with reps from a few organizations. > > If you have any further question of the veracity of my assertions, I suggest you > first identify yourself (full name and affiliation) This is a public list. > > Next, skepticsm is lame, but to your credit it is better than the non-reaction of > a few thousand sheep who will contine to be lead around by chiropractors, > insurance reps, and narrow-minded educators until it is too late, and then they > will throw the i-ching and pose ill-informed questions to the wrong people. > > READ my essays. If you find some point that is debatable, come back with > some sensible discussion. Beyond that , you should simply concur and start > working toward resolution that is mutually beneficial. Unless of course you > are actually one of the opposition. > > I already stated that the attack is not about to readily go away; nor am I going > to divulge what counter-measures I know are feasible. > > Whoever has been teaching students that they can't diagnose should be > strung up. It makes no difference what state you are in - if you are practicing > acupuncture or herbs, you MUST EVALUATE. And if you don't, that is clearly > a public safety violation, and you are asking to be shut down. > > Joe Reid > http://www.jreidomd.blogspot.com > > Chinese Medicine , " Tymothy " < > jellyphish@f...> wrote: > > jreidomd, > > Is there evidence for this? > > " The latest (May 3) addition to SB233 came straight from the CMA. " I > > went through Figueroa's lobby list and she received very little from the > > CMA, why would she make such a huge deal with so little cash? > > > > Also, where is this information? > > " Sen Figueroa indicated just a few days ago she also wanted specific > > examples of scope that diagnostic authority could then be limited to. " > > > > Certainly a case could be made that there are actors at play here who > > are not easily seen, but i would see their hands in the mix before > > simple assumption, there is the tendency in my experience to do that > > when against seeming authorities and i chose not to do that here until > > the information presents itself. > > > > Regards, Tymothy > To translate this message, copy and paste it into this web link page, http://babel.altavista.com/ > > and adjust accordingly. > > Messages are the property of the author. Any duplication outside the group requires prior permission from the author. > > If you are a TCM academic and wish to discuss TCM with other academics, > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted May 24, 2005 Report Posted May 24, 2005 I agree. A lot of negative energy thrown at each other is certainly not going to help the cause. Anne Angelo DAlberto wrote: > Dear All, > > I am now suggesting an end to this thread. Its getting personal and > way off topic so please no more. > > Regards, > > Angelo (moderator) > > Chinese Medicine , kim blankenship > <kuangguiyu> wrote: > > Skepticism is never lame. Questioning authority, especially > arrogant authority that insists one must simply be quiet and concur > with undivulged counter-measures as the only solution, is always a > good idea. > > > > Kim Blankenship, L.Ac. > > (not the opposition) > > > > > jreidomd <jreidomd> wrote: > > The May 3 additions to SB233 read in part: > > Nothing in this section shall be construed to authorize an > acupuncturist to > > diagnose any physical or mental disorder pursuant to Sections 2038 > and > > 2052. > > This was proposed by the CMA. That is public knowledge. But > actually it is > > the content that means something, not who proposes it. There is no > shortage > > of potential beneficiaries if it came to shutting us down. > > > > Request for language that limited diagnosis to certain conditions > was made > > by Senator Figueroa in a private meeting with reps from a few > organizations. > > > > If you have any further question of the veracity of my assertions, > I suggest you > > first identify yourself (full name and affiliation) This is a > public list. > > > > Next, skepticsm is lame, but to your credit it is better than the > non-reaction of > > a few thousand sheep who will contine to be lead around by > chiropractors, > > insurance reps, and narrow-minded educators until it is too late, > and then they > > will throw the i-ching and pose ill-informed questions to the wrong > people. > > > > READ my essays. If you find some point that is debatable, come > back with > > some sensible discussion. Beyond that , you should simply concur > and start > > working toward resolution that is mutually beneficial. Unless of > course you > > are actually one of the opposition. > > > > I already stated that the attack is not about to readily go away; > nor am I going > > to divulge what counter-measures I know are feasible. > > > > Whoever has been teaching students that they can't diagnose should > be > > strung up. It makes no difference what state you are in - if you > are practicing > > acupuncture or herbs, you MUST EVALUATE. And if you don't, that is > clearly > > a public safety violation, and you are asking to be shut down. > > > > Joe Reid > > http://www.jreidomd.blogspot.com > > > > Chinese Medicine , " Tymothy " < > > jellyphish@f...> wrote: > > > jreidomd, > > > Is there evidence for this? > > > " The latest (May 3) addition to SB233 came straight from the > CMA. " I > > > went through Figueroa's lobby list and she received very little > from the > > > CMA, why would she make such a huge deal with so little cash? > > > > > > Also, where is this information? > > > " Sen Figueroa indicated just a few days ago she also wanted > specific > > > examples of scope that diagnostic authority could then be limited > to. " > > > > > > Certainly a case could be made that there are actors at play here > who > > > are not easily seen, but i would see their hands in the mix before > > > simple assumption, there is the tendency in my experience to do > that > > > when against seeming authorities and i chose not to do that here > until > > > the information presents itself. > > > > > > Regards, Tymothy > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > To translate this message, copy and paste it into this web link > page, http://babel.altavista.com/ > > > > > and > adjust accordingly. > > > > Messages are the property of the author. Any duplication outside > the group requires prior permission from the author. > > > > If you are a TCM academic and wish to discuss TCM with other > academics, > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted May 24, 2005 Report Posted May 24, 2005 SB 233 died in the Senate Appropriations Committee. Matt - Anne Crowley Chinese Medicine Tuesday, May 24, 2005 2:16 PM Re: Re: SB 233 - End of Thread Please I agree. A lot of negative energy thrown at each other is certainly not going to help the cause. Anne Angelo DAlberto wrote: > Dear All, > > I am now suggesting an end to this thread. Its getting personal and > way off topic so please no more. > > Regards, > > Angelo (moderator) > > Chinese Medicine , kim blankenship > <kuangguiyu> wrote: > > Skepticism is never lame. Questioning authority, especially > arrogant authority that insists one must simply be quiet and concur > with undivulged counter-measures as the only solution, is always a > good idea. > > > > Kim Blankenship, L.Ac. > > (not the opposition) > > > > > jreidomd <jreidomd> wrote: > > The May 3 additions to SB233 read in part: > > Nothing in this section shall be construed to authorize an > acupuncturist to > > diagnose any physical or mental disorder pursuant to Sections 2038 > and > > 2052. > > This was proposed by the CMA. That is public knowledge. But > actually it is > > the content that means something, not who proposes it. There is no > shortage > > of potential beneficiaries if it came to shutting us down. > > > > Request for language that limited diagnosis to certain conditions > was made > > by Senator Figueroa in a private meeting with reps from a few > organizations. > > > > If you have any further question of the veracity of my assertions, > I suggest you > > first identify yourself (full name and affiliation) This is a > public list. > > > > Next, skepticsm is lame, but to your credit it is better than the > non-reaction of > > a few thousand sheep who will contine to be lead around by > chiropractors, > > insurance reps, and narrow-minded educators until it is too late, > and then they > > will throw the i-ching and pose ill-informed questions to the wrong > people. > > > > READ my essays. If you find some point that is debatable, come > back with > > some sensible discussion. Beyond that , you should simply concur > and start > > working toward resolution that is mutually beneficial. Unless of > course you > > are actually one of the opposition. > > > > I already stated that the attack is not about to readily go away; > nor am I going > > to divulge what counter-measures I know are feasible. > > > > Whoever has been teaching students that they can't diagnose should > be > > strung up. It makes no difference what state you are in - if you > are practicing > > acupuncture or herbs, you MUST EVALUATE. And if you don't, that is > clearly > > a public safety violation, and you are asking to be shut down. > > > > Joe Reid > > http://www.jreidomd.blogspot.com > > > > Chinese Medicine , " Tymothy " < > > jellyphish@f...> wrote: > > > jreidomd, > > > Is there evidence for this? > > > " The latest (May 3) addition to SB233 came straight from the > CMA. " I > > > went through Figueroa's lobby list and she received very little > from the > > > CMA, why would she make such a huge deal with so little cash? > > > > > > Also, where is this information? > > > " Sen Figueroa indicated just a few days ago she also wanted > specific > > > examples of scope that diagnostic authority could then be limited > to. " > > > > > > Certainly a case could be made that there are actors at play here > who > > > are not easily seen, but i would see their hands in the mix before > > > simple assumption, there is the tendency in my experience to do > that > > > when against seeming authorities and i chose not to do that here > until > > > the information presents itself. > > > > > > Regards, Tymothy > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > To translate this message, copy and paste it into this web link > page, http://babel.altavista.com/ > > > > > and > adjust accordingly. > > > > Messages are the property of the author. Any duplication outside > the group requires prior permission from the author. > > > > If you are a TCM academic and wish to discuss TCM with other > academics, > > > > > > > > > > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.