Guest guest Posted March 16, 2005 Report Posted March 16, 2005 If it is western influence then it is a good example of how Chinese medicine can evolve (call it what you like). >>>>>>>>>>>>> That is all i am saying. CM has evolved to mean various ways of interpreting our environment and patient interactions. These have undoubtedly been influenced from ideas seeping in from many parts of the world. I see no reason we should stop this process at this point. The notion that practitioner today must somehow know the entire written history in order to do that, were in the past they probably had so much less excess to such materials, is to me just naive and romantic. You say So what?>>>exactly that is what I say, so what? we need to keep CM alive and life means change. Quote
Guest guest Posted March 16, 2005 Report Posted March 16, 2005 The difference, Alon, is that throughout its history CM has been able to absorb new influences and adapt them to the overall structure of the medicine until the modern era. The difference now is that the actual foundations of Chinese medicine are being diluted, weakened and mixed with biomedicine in the most influential schools and hospitals in China. Just read reports from such authorities as Paul Unschuld, Nathan Sivin, Judith Farquhar and other medical anthropologists. There are real questions as to whether true Chinese medicine can survive, or for that matter, any other traditional medical system outside of Western medicine. Continued dilution to the structure of traditional medicines may lead to their disappearance. I have no problem with studying any medical system or technique that improves people's health. I do have a problem with eclecticism when practitioners do not have a strong grounding in Chinese medicine to begin with. And I have to say, not too many of us are steeped in Chinese medicine enough to do so. On Mar 16, 2005, at 8:34 AM, wrote: > > > If it is western influence then it is a good > example of how Chinese medicine can evolve (call it what you like). >>>>>>>>>>>>>> > That is all i am saying. CM has evolved to mean various ways of > interpreting our environment and patient interactions. These have > undoubtedly been influenced from ideas seeping in from many parts of > the world. I see no reason we should stop this process at this point. > The notion that practitioner today must somehow know the entire > written history in order to do that, were in the past they probably > had so much less excess to such materials, is to me just naive and > romantic. > You say So what?>>>exactly that is what I say, so what? we need to > keep CM alive and life means change. > > > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.