Guest guest Posted March 16, 2005 Report Posted March 16, 2005 This would take some research to determine. Otherwise, we are speculating. My understanding is that the Chinese physicians, as great observers of natural phenomena, carefully noted the progression of 'warm diseases' and compared their development to cold damage and wind strike diseases. Because the warm evils progressed much more quickly than cold damage, it was postulated that the disease evil entered through the nose and mouth, because the exterior pattern quickly moved inwards when compared to cold damage, which was said to enter through the skin, pores and body hair. >>>>>I was told by a wen bing Dr in china that its most likely a western incorporated idea Quote
Guest guest Posted May 16, 2005 Report Posted May 16, 2005 > >>>>>I was told by a wen bing Dr in china that its most likely a western incorporated idea Ok, take the wen bing as an example, it is of course more complex even from your view point then what you state above. Since many times you have clearly stated just because so and so says this does not mean... (when it is convenient for you) Z'ev has elaborated on some of the possibilities how wen bing in part evolved, apart from that lets then see how wen bing is practice in Asian countries and else where. If it is western influence then it is a good example of how Chinese medicine can evolve (call it what you like). Now, some things that are relevant is that Chinese people at least some say it is western influence i.e. acknowledge other sources. I have seen Chinese medicine acknowledge other sources, but often see western people (what ever that means) not acknowledging what they are doing is a complex origin from a another place of origin then there's. So what? The focus here, can be a very good example of something practical for the human kind (whish in this case happens to be Chinese medicine and its complexities that it inevitably develops within and around it). Lets focus on that. It is obvious to practice wen bing one needs to practice study i.e. contemplate think more then say just 200 hours and now you are a specialist. I probably do not know how to interpretate interpretate e mail conversations and often wonder do you and others actually listen to each others, or is it just a aim of trying to be right all the time? (what ever that means?) Marco Bergh Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.