Guest guest Posted July 31, 2009 Report Posted July 31, 2009 Hi Does anyone have experience with patients (or self) using Dr. Katu Tateishi's Veggie broth recipes? I have a patient who swears it helped cure her cancer. Just looking for more evidence before sharing it with others. Link is below. Thanks th. http://ancientpathweb.com/VegeBroth.aspx " Lose your mind so you can come to your senses.You cannot do all the good the world needs,thus the world needs all the good you can do. " Dr.Twyla Hoodah, D.O.M., A.P. SpiritcareAcupuncture.org Quote
Guest guest Posted July 31, 2009 Report Posted July 31, 2009 I'm skeptical of claims that promise so much & supposedly suitable for everyone despite how different our bodies are. It's one reason we're encouraged to see a reputable Traditional Oriental Medicine practitioner rather than trying to come up with our own concoction. Training to be a good doctor in this field takes many years. That said, I looked up more about Kazu Tateishi (not Katu). He's NOT a doctor & never took any training. He was a taxi driver before he tacked the Dr. on his name & starting selling the soup. Because he practiced medicine, examining & prescribing for patients, he was charged & jailed. Okay, that would make me skeptical right there but a comment on the website you gave the link to made me question him even more. It said that his stomach & duodenum had already been removed & now the cancer has spread to his lungs so he " researched, studied and tested over 1,500 kinds of herbs/plants. Eventually he discovered the right combination of ingredients... " If cancer has already metastasized, how long would be have had before he could research, study AND test over 1,500 plants? He was able to do this in such a short time before he'd die from the spreading cancer? Admittedly, the ingredients are innocuous but I can think of a number of other plants that would correspond to the organs by colour better & I'm no expert! And colour isn't the only thing that matters in the 5 Element Theory! I can't see this soup being harmful - it actually doesn't sound bad. But healing? And as he claimed, killing individual cancer cells within a few hours? I'm waiting to see what someone like Al Stone says about this. Judy On Friday 31 July 2009 08:36:00 Twyla wrote: > Does anyone have experience with patients (or self) using Dr. Katu > Tateishi's Veggie broth recipes? I have a patient who swears it helped cure > her cancer. Just looking for more evidence before sharing it with others. > Link is below. > Thanks > http://ancientpathweb.com/VegeBroth.aspx > > Dr.Twyla Hoodah, D.O.M., A.P. Quote
Guest guest Posted July 31, 2009 Report Posted July 31, 2009 On Fri, Jul 31, 2009 at 11:46 AM, Judy Wilkins <isomorphix wrote: > > > > Admittedly, the ingredients are innocuous but I can think of a number of > other > plants that would correspond to the organs by colour better & I'm no > expert! > And colour isn't the only thing that matters in the 5 Element Theory! I > can't > see this soup being harmful - it actually doesn't sound bad. But healing? > And > as he claimed, killing individual cancer cells within a few hours? > > I'm waiting to see what someone like Al Stone says about this. > I was just waiting for you to do the heavy lifting, Judy. I'm really with you on all counts. This diet is benign, but the claims are based on a simplistic understanding of cancer. Also, he doesn't seem to be selling anything on the page in question, so I let it through to this list, but otherwise, it doesn't move me too much at least medically speaking. > > > Judy > > On Friday 31 July 2009 08:36:00 Twyla wrote: > > Does anyone have experience with patients (or self) using Dr. Katu > > Tateishi's Veggie broth recipes? I have a patient who swears it helped > cure > > her cancer. Just looking for more evidence before sharing it with others. > > Link is below. > > Thanks > > http://ancientpathweb.com/VegeBroth.aspx > > > > Dr.Twyla Hoodah, D.O.M., A.P. > -- , DAOM Pain is inevitable, suffering is optional. Quote
Guest guest Posted August 1, 2009 Report Posted August 1, 2009 Actually, I was told this brew was being sold for $200.00 at some point, not sure if it was from this particular website......not sure why or how or in what form or quantity./th --- On Fri, 7/31/09, Al Stone <al wrote: Al Stone <al Re: [Chinese Traditional Medicine] Dr Katu Tateishi's Vege Broth Chinese Traditional Medicine Friday, July 31, 2009, 3:55 PM On Fri, Jul 31, 2009 at 11:46 AM, Judy Wilkins <isomorphix (AT) shaw (DOT) ca> wrote: > > > > Admittedly, the ingredients are innocuous but I can think of a number of > other > plants that would correspond to the organs by colour better & I'm no > expert! > And colour isn't the only thing that matters in the 5 Element Theory! I > can't > see this soup being harmful - it actually doesn't sound bad. But healing? > And > as he claimed, killing individual cancer cells within a few hours? > > I'm waiting to see what someone like Al Stone says about this. > I was just waiting for you to do the heavy lifting, Judy. I'm really with you on all counts. This diet is benign, but the claims are based on a simplistic understanding of cancer. Also, he doesn't seem to be selling anything on the page in question, so I let it through to this list, but otherwise, it doesn't move me too much at least medically speaking. > > > Judy > > On Friday 31 July 2009 08:36:00 Twyla wrote: > > Does anyone have experience with patients (or self) using Dr. Katu > > Tateishi's Veggie broth recipes? I have a patient who swears it helped > cure > > her cancer. Just looking for more evidence before sharing it with others. > > Link is below. > > Thanks > > http://ancientpathw eb.com/VegeBroth .aspx > > > > Dr.Twyla Hoodah, D.O.M., A.P. > -- , DAOM Pain is inevitable, suffering is optional. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.