Guest guest Posted September 18, 2002 Report Posted September 18, 2002 > By the way, this is the reason why more men than women post on this list -> or any other list. The reasoning of this statement makes me uncomfortable in its relationship to the yang as masculine tendency to teach while yin as feminine to nurture. (and please note, my understanding of English keeps me from saying "male" and "female" when describing yang and yin.) I see it this way. Yang communication on the internet tends to be when someone has an idea and they want the world to have that idea the same way because they know this idea to be true. Yin communication on the internet tends to be, Oh, so that is how you understand an idea and this is way here is how I understand an idea. I understand that your understanding might be different. That we both might have different understandings isn't wrong. (Once again to the picture of many "fingers pointing to the moon".) Knowing how I or you think, even though it might be different from each other's, gives us insight into each other's true nature so we can accommodate each other within our communications with each other. (There is nothing more female than male about this statement. It is more feminine however. Males can be quite naturally in touch with their feminine side.) Yang might seem more teaching though not totally devoid of nurturing because to have what might be the correct concept could be beneficial. (Oh gosh, I can't even explain Yang without going extremely yin!) Nurturing is done with acknowledgement to the receptor's nature. That a lesson is be being taught might not be as obvious. Very yang internet communication can be very frustrating. I try not to go there. When people refuse to give up their own understanding of a subject (hinting at their own tendency to the yang) and adopt how the yang writer wants them to think ... that's when "flaming" could kick in. Very Yin communication on the internet is at its most extreme point when folks just "lurk". Both yin and yang carried to the extreme can only occur to the point of unsubscribing, at which point they no longer exist because yang and yin can not exist without their relationship to each other. Penel Quote
Guest guest Posted September 18, 2002 Report Posted September 18, 2002 interesting statement, i would disagree and agree with you at the very same time the fact is just as with anything else interpretation of any subject is a personal one, as you have stated " the fingers pointing at the moon " theory that not one person will come up with the very same explanation of the same thing, similar, but not the same......that being said i take teaching and nurtering to be similar, and can be both yin and yang.....now the one misconception of the whole yin and yang theory lies in the fact that its viewed 2 dimensionally, that is flat and round, black and white, good and evil, male and female.......it is that and more.....when taken in whole it means the balance that is achieved by the interaction of all these things, but not specific to the thing within itself. Your looking at the radical or extreme point of view, saying that if " it " is not " that " then " it " must be " this " . This is a fallacy most people (including myself at times) have....i agree that from what i understand most of what traditional chinese medicine deals with occurs within the realm of balancing out extremes, but what most individuals fail to see (please i mean this in the general sense) is that there were a whole range of things that dealt within the concept of belief. That is they believed in a whole range of things, and they felt it affected not only the person, but everything as a whole. Its almost on the verge of chaos theory (a butterfly flaps its wings on one side of the world causing a hurricane on the other side)where they felt that certain " things " or " conditions " where caused and to balance that " thing " or " condition " steps needed to be taken. you have a stomach ache, a doctor would come by and feed you an herb, maybe poke you with a pin or 2 you feel fine...ok, what happened? well if you would ask the doctor he would say that he saw that your pain came from a deficiency of yin or yang in your system caused by diet, or external conditions such as the weather, planetary alingnment, or time of day......he being the wise person that he is would take actions that would set you straight and off you went...part of the healing process there primarily dealt with the belief of both individuals, yes i would say that the fact that the herb which was a mint (which aids in minor digestive problems)and the fact that he told the person not to eat those fried pork ears anymore (which caused the stomach ache in the first place) helped, but like i said there is more to that healing than meets the eye........anyway, something for you to chew on (heheh, pun intended), enjoyed your post!! Warrior Chinese Traditional Medicine, " Penel Eynde LeGrand " <penel@s...> wrote: > > By the way, this is the reason why more men than women post on this list - > > or any other list. > > The reasoning of this statement makes me uncomfortable in its relationship to the yang as masculine tendency to teach while yin as feminine to nurture. > (and please note, my understanding of English keeps me from saying " male " and " female " when describing yang and yin.) > > I see it this way. > Yang communication on the internet tends to be when someone has an idea and they want the world to have that idea the same way because they know this idea to be true. > > Yin communication on the internet tends to be, Oh, so that is how you understand an idea and this is way here is how I understand an idea. > I understand that your understanding might be different. > That we both might have different understandings isn't wrong. (Once again to the picture of many " fingers pointing to the moon " .) > > Knowing how I or you think, even though it might be different from each other's, gives us insight into each other's true nature so we can accommodate each other within our communications with each other. > (There is nothing more female than male about this statement. It is more feminine however. Males can be quite naturally in touch with their feminine side.) > > Yang might seem more teaching though not totally devoid of nurturing because to have what might be the correct concept could be beneficial. > (Oh gosh, I can't even explain Yang without going extremely yin!) > Nurturing is done with acknowledgement to the receptor's nature. That a lesson is be being taught might not be as obvious. > > Very yang internet communication can be very frustrating. I try not to go there. When people refuse to give up their own understanding of a subject (hinting at their own tendency to the yang) and adopt how the yang writer wants them to think ... that's when " flaming " could kick in. > Very Yin communication on the internet is at its most extreme point when folks just " lurk " . > > Both yin and yang carried to the extreme can only occur to the point of unsubscribing, at which point they no longer exist because yang and yin can not exist without their relationship to each other. > > Penel Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.