Guest guest Posted February 29, 2004 Report Posted February 29, 2004 StopTheInsanity Sat, 28 Feb 2004 08:46:36 -0500 [sSRI-Research] Myth of medications and " A Beautiful Mind " - schizophrenia patients have worsened over past 20 years THE FILM " A BEAUTIFUL MIND " HAS AN UGLY DISTORTION, ADVOCACY GROUP CLAIMS PUBLIC STATEMENT CALLS FOR " APOLOGY AND CLARIFICATION " FROM UNIVERSAL STUDIOS " USA TODAY " COMMENTARY REVEALS THAT JOHN NASH REFUSED TO TAKE PSYCHIATRIC DRUGS PSYCHOLOGIST SAYS FILM CAN HARM HOLLYWOOD, CALIF. -- Claiming that the film " A Beautiful Mind " distorts the life of John Nash, a coalition of 100 mental health advocacy groups issued a public statement today to Universal asking for an apology and retraction. Support Coalition International cites a guest commentary in " USA Today " (3/4/02) by author Robert Whitaker. Whitaker claims Nash refused psychiatric drugs, and this may have aided his recovery. [Whitaker's piece is copied below.] The film has Nash saying he was taking " newer medications " at the time of his Nobel Prize. Nash says that's pure fiction. Nash has also been quoted recently as wondering if the fact that one screenwriter's mother is a psychiatrist had anything to do with this distortion. Whether or not people can recover following a diagnosis of " schizophrenia " without taking psychiatric drugs is a major controversy in the mental health field. Support Coalition International says that Universal (along with Imagine and DreamWorks) apparently caved to pressure, and distorted Nash's life so as not to overly disrespect psychiatric drugs. Psychologist Barry Duncan, PhD author of the book _The Heroic Client_, says the film can actually harm people diagnosed with psychiatric disorders, and the public. Says Dr. Duncan, " By all accounts, Nash took no antipsychotic medication after 1970. The 'right message' crafted in the film and promulgated in reviews and echoed by 'experts' do those suffering and the public a great disservice. " BELOW is the Public Statement that Support Coalition International issued to Universal Studios today. BELOW THAT is the text of Robert Whitaker's commentary in _USA Today_ about John Nash and the film " A Beautiful Mind. " Whitaker is an award-winning reporter at the _Boston Globe_. AT BOTTOM is a public statement by psychologist and author Barry Duncan, PhD about this falsehood in " A Beautiful Mind, " and its implications. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ACTION: You can endorse the call for an apology and clarification by e-mailing a civil note to Universal publicity: <julie.brantley@u...>. Please bcc a copy to <office@m...>. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ PUBLIC STATEMENT - March 6, 2002 Support Coalition International Universal Studios, Imagine, and DreamWorks Pictures The film " A Beautiful Mind " has an ugly distortion: Author Robert Whitaker revealed in a USA Today commentary on March 4th that John Nash's recovery was linked to his refsual to take psychiatric drugs called " neuroleptics. " [see copy of Whitaker's column below.] Apparently bowing to political correctness, the filmmakers instead had Nash claim he was taking " newer medications " at the time he received his Nobel Prize. John Nash and his biographer have confirmed this statement is fictitious. Nash was drug free. This film is helping millions admire the resilience of psychiatric survivors. But this film also seriously misleads the public. The fact is, many people -- like Nash -- recover without taking psychiatric drugs. By caving in to pressure, the film has become an advertisement for the psychiatric drug industry. Nash himself wonders if the fact that one of the film's writers is related to a psychiatric professional played a role in this distortion. This film says it was inspired by Nash's life. But it dishonors his hard won victory. On behalf of 100 grassroots groups advocating for the human rights of people diagnosed with psychiatric disorders, we request that Universal, Imagine and DreamWorks Pictures issue a public statement of apology and clarification about this distortion. Sincerely, David Oaks, Director Support Coalition International http://www.MindFreedom.org -end - ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ " USA Today " March 4, 2002 Page 13A Mind drugs may hinder recovery By Robert Whitaker The movie A Beautiful Mind, nominated for eight Academy Awards, has brought welcome attention to the fact that people can and do recover from schizophrenia, a severely disabling disorder that affects about one in 100 Americans. Unfortunately, the film fabricates a critical detail of John Nash's recovery and in so doing, obscures a question that should concern us all: Do the medications we use to treat schizophrenia promote long-term recovery -- or hinder it? In the movie, Nash -- just before he receives a Nobel Prize -- speaks of taking ''newer medications.'' The National Alliance for the Mentally Ill has praised the film's director, Ron Howard, for showing the ''vital role of medication'' in Nash's recovery. But as Sylvia Nasar notes in her biography of Nash, on which the movie is loosely based, this brilliant mathematician stopped taking anti-psychotic drugs in 1970 and slowly recovered over two decades. Nasar concluded that Nash's refusal to take drugs ''may have been fortunate'' because their deleterious effects ''would have made his gentle re-entry into the world of mathematics a near impossibility.'' His is just one of many such cases. Most Americans are unaware that the World Health Organization (WHO) has repeatedly found that long-term schizophrenia outcomes are much worse in the USA and other ''developed'' countries than in poor ones such as India and Nigeria, where relatively few patients are on anti-psychotic medications. In ''undeveloped'' countries, nearly two-thirds of schizophrenia patients are doing fairly well five years after initial diagnosis; about 40% have basically recovered. But in the USA and other developed countries, most patients become chronically ill. The outcome differences are so marked that WHO concluded that living in a developed country is a ''strong predictor'' that a patient never will fully recover. Myth of medication There is more. In 1987, psychologist Courtenay Harding reported that a third of chronic schizophrenia patients released from Vermont State Hospital in the late 1950s completely recovered. Everyone in this ''best-outcomes'' group shared one common factor: All had weaned themselves from anti-psychotic medications. The notion that schizophrenics must spend a lifetime on these drugs, she concluded, is a ''myth.'' In 1994, Harvard Medical School researchers found that outcomes for U.S. schizophrenia patients had worsened during the past 20 years and were now no better than they were 100 years earlier, when therapy involved plunking patients into bathtubs for hours. And in 1998, University of Pennsylvania investigators reported that standard anti-psychotic medications cause a specific area of the brain to become abnormally enlarged and that this drug-induced enlargement is associated with a worsening of symptoms. Comprehensive care succeeds All of this has led a few European physicians to explore non-drug alternatives. In Finland, doctors treat newly diagnosed schizophrenia patients with comprehensive care: counseling, social-support services and the selective use of anti-psychotic medications. Some patients do better on low doses of medication, and some without it. And they report great results: A majority of patients remain free of psychotic symptoms for extended periods and hold down jobs. John Nash's recovery from schizophrenia is a moving story. But we are not well served when the movie fibs about the anti-psychotic drugs' role in his recovery. If anything, his story should inspire us to reconsider anti-psychotics' long-term efficacy with an honest, open mind. That would be a first step toward reforming our care -- and if there is one thing we can conclude from the WHO studies, it is that reform is vitally needed. Perhaps then we could even hope that schizophrenia outcomes in this country would improve to the point that they were equal to those in poor countries such as India and Nigeria. Robert Whitaker is the author of Mad in America: Bad Science, Bad Medicine, and the Enduring Mistreatment of the Mentally Ill. http://www.usatoday.com/usatonline/20020304/3909657s.htm - end - ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ SSRI-Research/ Get better spam protection with Mail Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.