Guest guest Posted December 5, 2003 Report Posted December 5, 2003 http://www.redflagsweekly.com/second_opinion/2003_dec06.php HYPOCHONDRIA - AN IGNORANCE-BASED MEDICAL WEAPON OF MASS DEVASTATION USED AGAINST LARGE NUMBERS OF PATIENTS WITH SYMPTOMS NOT EASY TO DIAGNOSE By RFD Editor, Nicholas Regush When I wrote the “Second Opinion” column for ABCNews.com during the last two years of my work at World News Tonight With Peter Jennings, I faced a regular stream of email from readers who complained bitterly that their doctors often did not take their physical complaints seriously; that they wrote them off as “in the mind” or as “hypochondria.” One reason I suppose that my column attracted so much of this kind of attention was due to my fierce defense of those who were suffering from chronic fatigue syndrome, fibromyalgia, or chemical sensitivities and related complaints. Just because medicine had little understanding of how these illnesses developed, this was no reason for doctors to write off these people as malcontents, complainers, and so on. It made me very angry to think that those practicing what will be considered in the future to be “primitive medicine,” had the audacity to either humiliate their patients or cause them emotional pain – along with the physical pain they were experiencing. Just thinking about this made me mad as hell. And it still does. I read an interview in NEW SCIENTIST today that got me thinking again about the arrogance expressed by so many who practice medicine, or, at least, think they do. Here is an actual definition offered by psychiatrist Brian Fallon who has been studying hypochondriacs for 15 years: Hypochondria is the fear of disease that persists even after a doctor’s examination and reassurance. A person with hypochondria might be reassured initially, but later in the day a nagging uncertainty re-emerges and leads the patient to wonder, “Did I really explain my symptoms adequately?” Fallon goes on to advise that hypochondriacs will “spend large parts of the day thinking about their symptoms and discussing them. They will track down numerous experts and will find the loopholes in every medical test, and seek more sensitive ones to make sure that the last doctor hasn’t missed something.” So? If you have symptoms and a doctor does not resolve them or a test does not reveal a specific problem, does that mean there is no problem? Does that mean that the symptoms are being created through force of “mind,” whatever that is? Unfortunately, rather than consider the likelihood that there are always forms of organic disease in process in the body to one degree or another, Fallon typically decides that emotional needs, such as the desire for attention, will generate the symptoms. No doubt emotions are part of a complex package of events in process at any given time, but why single them out? Why? Because that’s what too many psychiatrists tend to do. Then, it’s on to drugs, such as Prozac, or whatever. And then when the symptoms clear, the usual tendency is to assume that the drug did the job. How utterly stupid this is. But unfortunately in the era of “primitive medicine,” such leaps of the imagination are common. I particularly note one of Fallon’s comments about patients who apparently are harder to treat: They feel they have a multitude of symptoms, and they worry that they have a serious disease. Those patients in my experience have done less well with drugs. Is there a clue for us in the above statement? Might it suggest that those who do not clear up with mind drugs actually have more serious physical components underlying their symptoms? The point here is that, sure, there are some very difficult people who see doctors, and I’m sure that if I had to deal with some of them, I’d be looking for my prescription pad, just to get rid of them. But that would say more about me than whatever might be ailing them. The fact that many people behave wildly when their symptoms are not given due respect is no reason to assume that they match some simplistic criteria of what is defined arbitrarily as “hypochondria.” Many may display bizarre behavior because they hurt and no one can tell them why. That might be enough for some to engage in so-called “compulsive” behavior. Until medicine takes a giant leap from its current primitive state, no doctor should be characterizing anyone as a “hypochondriac.” Fallon gives us some extreme cases of what he calls “hypochondria,” but what he is basically describing are people who may not know how to handle uncertainty, who are fearful because their pain does not go away, or who become increasingly disoriented. All they need on top of that is a dumb label – hypochondria. Hypochondria is a trash concept in medicine because it assumes that the doctor knows what he/she is talking about. That simply is not the case. NEW WEB MESSAGE BOARDS - JOIN HERE. Alternative Medicine Message Boards.Info http://alternative-medicine-message-boards.info New Photos - easier uploading and sharing Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.