Guest guest Posted November 19, 2002 Report Posted November 19, 2002 Well , are there reports that creatine takin along with the other supplements is not effective? JoAnn, What do you feelare the best heart supplements? And for new readers , the Creatine was one of a group of supplements. Lorenzo Message: 6 Mon, 18 Nov 2002 16:29:45 -0000 " JoAnn Guest " <angelprincessjo Re: Supplements That Energize The Heart ---Lorenzo, I would differ with the author of this article on the efficacy of Creatine when used as an aid in coronary heart disease. Creatine will create other problems when taken over the long term for it is known to work by shifting bodily fluids around from one part of the body to the other (beneficial for body builders) but will eventually lead to bodily dehydration with long term use. This is one of those supplements currently under investigation by the FDA. There are so many others that one can use safely for heart problems, I wouldn't touch it nor would I advise anyone else to use it, for as we get older we need an x amount of fluids daily in order to maintain a smooth artery flow,... this is even more crucial when artery flow is compromised by excessive plaque buildup. Any benefits derived from this supplement would just not be worth in my opinion as it has proven to have so many other undesirable side effects. Just my two cents. I have an article around somewhere regarding this, but just thought I'd share the basics. Best Regards, JoAnn Guest mrsjoguest Friendsforhealthnaturally DietaryTipsForHBP http://www.geocities.com/mrsjoguest/AIM.html In Gettingwell, " Lorenzo " <lorenzo1@w...> wrote: > Supplements That Energize The Heart-------The report is at > http://www.thenutritionreporter.com/heal_a_failing_heart.html > Creatine. Used by many body builders to improve endurance, creatine plays an > important role in recycling and reusing ATP. After cells use ATP to produce > energy for muscle contractions, it is converted to ADP (adenosine > diphosphate). Creatine donates a phosphorus molecule to convert ADP back to > ATP, thus restoring energy levels. Studies on patients with heart failure > have found that creatine supplementation do not directly benefit the heart, > but it does increase energy levels in skeletal muscle, resulting in an > overall improvement. > Each of these supplements is safe when used to prevent heart disease. When > used therapeutically to treat cardiomyopathy or heart failure, some caution > is warranted, says Langsjoen. The reason is that cardiomyopathy and heart > failure are among the most serious of all heart diseases. > > Prescription drugs for these diseases work by masking symptoms or forcing > the heart to work harder. In contrast, CoQ10, carnitine, and the other > supplements naturally strengthen heart function. To avoid over- stimulating > your heart, you will likely have to reduce your risk of heart drugs. Such > adjustments in medications, says Langsjoen, should be done with the guidance > of a cardiologist or other physician skilled in nutritional therapies and > knowledgeable about drug-nutrient interactions. ______________________ --- Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). Version: 6.0.419 / Virus Database: 235 - Release 11/13/02 Quote
Guest guest Posted November 19, 2002 Report Posted November 19, 2002 --- Good Morning Lorenzo, Apparently, this Creatine supplement contributes to weight *gain*, concentrates in the *heart muscles* and assists in the *contraction* of the myofibrils (muscle fibers). " Once inside the muscle, it is phosphoylated to form creatine phosphate which is a high energy substrate that assists in the contraction of the myofibrils (muscle fibers) " . FROM THIS DESCRIPTION, IT WOULD SEEM VERY DANGEROUS FOR ANYONE TO CONSUME, especially the elderly whom are battling heart and artery disease. Going back to what I outlined previously, this is the very reason we want to get maximum amounts of magnesium in our systems each day as magnesium tends to relax the heart and arteries, whereas calcium and creatine contracts the heart muscles causing unwanted spasms ultimately contributes to heart attacks! I'm sorry but why would anyone in their right mind want to take a supplement that concentrates in the heart muscle, leading to heart and artery spasms? In my opinion, this is the very thing we're trying to avoid. Recurring spasms seem to be a huge part of our problem, expecially in those of us who have had CVD and coronary heart disease. I really wouldn't want to take the risk. It would just not be worth it in my estimation. I am engrossed in taking supplements that promote heart health. This supplement just doesn't seem to fit that description. In my opinion it would be very detrimental even for a young person to take this, for acording to what I've read, the creatine stays in the system (heart) long after you stop taking it. As I say, it works by drawing unwanted fluids into muscle mass. Do we really want more fluids in our muscles? Isn't this why older people take diuretics (God forbid)? So how would any of us actually derive any benefit from this? " More fluid inside muscle cells makes your muscles feel fuller and gives you a harder, more defined look. " A high price for a good physique, I'd say! And...from various internet sources, it doesn't work all that well unless you engage in prolonged strenuous exercise...not at all good for the heart, in my opinion! This is mainly for those who are trying to project an image of a healthy body! From all the hype regarding creatine out there, I'm just wondering what the long term *benefits* actually will be! This is just my two cents worth. Take it for what it's worth, please. Best Regards, JoAnn Guest mrsjogeust Friendsforhealthnaturally DietaryTipsForHBP http://www.geocities.com/mrsjoguest/Botanicals.html In Gettingwell, " Lorenzo " <lorenzo1@w...> wrote: > Well , are there reports that creatine takin along with the other > supplements is not effective? > > JoAnn, > > What do you feelare the best heart supplements? > > And for new readers , the Creatine was one of a group of supplements. > > Lorenzo > > > > Message: 6 > Mon, 18 Nov 2002 16:29:45 -0000 > " JoAnn Guest " <angelprincessjo> > Re: Supplements That Energize The Heart > > ---Lorenzo, I would differ with the author of this article on the > efficacy of Creatine when used as an aid in coronary heart disease. > Creatine will create other problems when taken over the long term for > it is known to work by shifting bodily fluids around from one part of > the body to the other (beneficial for body builders) but will > eventually lead to bodily dehydration with long term use. > This is one of those supplements currently under investigation by the > FDA. There are so many others that one can use safely for heart > problems, I wouldn't touch it nor would I advise anyone else to use > it, for as we get older we need an x amount of fluids daily in order > to maintain a smooth artery flow,... this is even more crucial when > artery flow is compromised by excessive plaque buildup. > Any benefits derived from this supplement would just not be worth in > my opinion as it has proven to have so many other undesirable side > effects. > Just my two cents. > I have an article around somewhere regarding this, > but just thought I'd share the basics. > > Best Regards, > JoAnn Guest > mrsjoguest@s... > Friendsforhealthnaturally > DietaryTipsForHBP > http://www.geocities.com/mrsjoguest/AIM.html > > > In Gettingwell, " Lorenzo " <lorenzo1@w...> wrote: > > Supplements That Energize The Heart-------The report is at > > http://www.thenutritionreporter.com/heal_a_failing_heart.html > > > Creatine. Used by many body builders to improve endurance, creatine > plays an > > important role in recycling and reusing ATP. After cells use ATP > > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 21, 2002 Report Posted November 21, 2002 ---Lorenzo, Heart-Smart Nutrients 1.Vitamin E----1,000 mgs 2. Magnesium -400-1,200 mgs 3. Potassium---99-300 mgs 4. B-complex---B-6, B-12 5. Vitamin C---2,000 mgs daily minimum 1. Hawthorne Berry 2. CO-Q10 3. Cayenne Pepper 4. Non-gmo Soy, Beans, Lentils & Legumes 5. Norwegian Fish oil(n-3s,n-6s,n-9s) 6. Garlic 7. Ginger root Ya Gotta Have Heart Foods... 1. Red Grapes & Wine 2. Almonds, Cashews, Brazil Nuts 3. Blackstrap Molasses 4. Blueberries 5. Oat Bran JoAnn Guest mrsjoguest Friendsforhealthnaturally DietaryTipsForHBP http://www.geocities.com/mrsjoguest/Botanicals.html In Gettingwell, " Lorenzo " <lorenzo1@w...> wrote: > JoAnn, > > What do you feelare the best heart supplements? > Lorenzo > Message: 6 > Mon, 18 Nov 2002 16:29:45 -0000 > " JoAnn Guest " <angelprincessjo> > Re: Supplements That Energize The Heart > > ---Lorenzo, I would differ with the author of this article on the > efficacy of Creatine when used as an aid in coronary heart disease. > Creatine will create other problems when taken over the long term for > it is known to work by shifting bodily fluids around from one part of > the body to the other (beneficial for body builders) but will > eventually lead to bodily dehydration with long term use. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.