Guest guest Posted August 22, 2003 Report Posted August 22, 2003 We will just all have to learn to hold our breath and not breath any more ....seems logical ... ************************* > Draft of Air Rule Is Said to Exempt Many Old Plants > > By KATHARINE Q. SEELYE > > WASHINGTON, Aug. 21 After more than two years of internal deliberation and > intense pressure from industry, the Bush administration has settled on a > regulation that would allow thousands of older power plants, oil refineries > and industrial units to make extensive upgrades without having to install > new anti-pollution devices, according to those involved in the deliberations. > > The new rule, a draft of which was made available to The New York Times by > the Natural Resources Defense Council, an environmental group, would > constitute a sweeping and cost-saving victory for industries, exempting > thousands of indus trial plants and refineries from part of the Clean Air > Act. The acting administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency could > sign the new rule as soon as next week, administration officials have told > utility representatives. > > The exemption would let industrial plants continue to emit hundreds of > thousands of tons of pollutants into the atmosphere and could save the > companies millions, if not billions, of dollars in pollution equipment > costs, even if they increase the amounts of pollutants they emit. > > The action could also spare Gov. Michael O. Leavitt of Utah, if he is > confirmed as the new E.P.A. administrator, from having to make a decision > on a highly contentious issue. > > The current rule requires plant owners to install pollution-control devices > if they undertake anything more than " routine maintenance " on their plants. > Industries have long argued that the standard is too vague and hinders > substantial investment in cleaner, more efficient equipment. > > The new rule says that as much as 20 percent of the cost of replacing a > plant's essential production equipment a boiler, generator or turbine could > be spent and the owner would still be exempt from installing any pollution > controls, according to people involved in the deliberations. > > Together, such equipment can cost hundreds of millions of dollars, > sometimes more than $1 billion, to replace. A utility or factory could thus > make tens of millions of dollars worth of improvements without being > required to install pollution controls. > > At the end of last year, the administration proposed that the current > standards be eased, saying that the threshhold for requiring pollution > control devices could be anywhere from nothing to 50 percent of the cost of > replacing major equipment. Members of Congress protested that the public > could not meaningfully comment on such a range, and 225,000 people objected > to the rule before the comment period ended on May 31, according to John > Walke of the Natural Resources Defense Council. > > Only in the last few weeks have officials settled on the 20 percent figure, > which had been a closely held secret within the administration. The draft > of the new rule, in fact, describes the point at which pollution-control > devices must be installed only as " X percent, " but officials and several > others in contact with those who wrote the rule said that the level was 20 > percent, though they warned that the percentage could change before being > made final. > > Officials said that Marianne Horinko, the acting administrator of the > Environmental Protection Agency, would probably sign the rule before Labor > Day. It would go into effect shortly thereafter, without further review or > public comment. > > The only way to stop it would be through court action, which critics of the > new rule are threatening. > > Eliot Spitzer, the attorney general of New York, said he would file a > challenge to the new rule as soon as it was signed. > > " A rule that creates a 20 percent threshold eviscerates the statute, " he > said of the Clean Air Act. " This makes it patently clear that the Bush > administration has meant all along to repeal the Clean Air Act by > administrative fiat. " > > Administration officials, including Ms. Horinko, declined to comment. > Jarrod Agen, a spokesman for the E.P.A., said that officials could not > comment because the matter was still under review. " But I can say that we > are working on this final rule, " he said, adding that it would " encourage > facilities to improve their efficiency, reliability and safety. " > > Spokesmen for industry groups reacted positively to the new rule. Scott > Segal, executive director of the Electric Reliability Coordinating Council, > representing utilities, said that industries would appreciate having a > " bright line. " He said that the 20 percent, though he did not know > precisely how it would be calculated, " is not an unreasonable number. " > > Mr. Walke of the Natural Resources Defense Council called the 20 percent > standard " a grotesque accounting gimmick " that would " let companies > completely overhaul their plants over time and spew even more pollution > than now. " > > Clarifying the rule and making it more lenient has been a central goal of > industry for more than a decade, and the administration has been reviewing > it since President Bush came into office more than two years ago. > > While industry and many of Mr. Bush's political and financial backers have > supported a broad exemption like 20 percent, many state and local > officials, including Governor Leavitt's director of air quality in Utah, > have strongly opposed the concept. > > Governor Leavitt is still likely to encounter harsh criticism on the matter > during his confirmation hearings, which are expected to begin shortly after > Congress returns from its summer recess on Sept. 2. Democrats have > indicated they plan to challenge him to defend the rule, which would put > him in opposition to his own state's air experts. > > Determining when a plant must install pollution-control devices has been > one of the thorniest and most controversial environmental decisions facing > the Bush administration. > > The new rule also appears to run counter to the stance the administration > has taken in several lawsuits against polluters across the country, trying > to enforce more rigorous standards under the Clean Air Act. > > The Justice Department during the Clinton administration initiated lawsuits > against dozens of oil refineries and about 50 coal-fired power plants for > their failures to install pollution controls under the requirement of > routine maintenance. > > The Justice Department during the Bush administration has continued to > prosecute those cases, but only after an internal dispute. > > Oil, coal and electric companies had lobbied the administration to drop the > suits; Christie Whitman, the former E.P.A. administrator, resisted. As a > result, Vice President Dick Cheney's energy task force directed the Justice > Department to analyze whether to continue the suits. In January 2002, the > department decided to do so. > > And in a striking counterpoint to the administration's new rule, the > department won a landmark victory two weeks ago in federal court against an > Ohio Edison plant in Jefferson County, Ohio. > > That decision, which found that Ohio Edison violated the Clean Air Act when > it failed to install pollution controls, could set a precedent for the > other cases and puts the administration on a collision course with itself > because of its new rule. > > Senator James M. Jeffords, the Vermont independent who is the ranking > minority member of the Environment and Public Works Committee, called the > new rule " just one more flagrant violation of the Clean Air Act and every > court's opinion on this matter. " He added: " Its publication will amount to > malfeasance. " > > Mr. Cheney's energy task force also directed the E.P.A. to review the > regulations regarding routine maintenance and report to Mr. Bush within 90 > days. That deadline slipped repeatedly as the administration mulled how to > respond. > > The current trigger point of " routine maintenance " was set by Congress in a > 1977 amendment to the Clean Air Act. The idea was to avoid shutting at once > all plants that might be in violation of the Clean Air Act. > > Instead, Congress said, when old plants were refurbished, they had to add > the best available air-pollution control equipment. The amendment became > known as " new source review " because it required review when a plant added > new power sources that could raise emissions. > > During the preparation of its report on energy policy, Mr. Cheney's task > force was visited often by officials from several industry groups and > companies seeking to alter the new source provisions. > > According to documents obtained through the Freedom of Information Act by > the Natural Resources Defense Council, those visitors included officials > from the Edison Electric Institute, the North American Electric Reliability > Council, the National Mining Association, the American Petroleum Institute > and the Southern Company. > > http://www.nytimes.com/2003/08/22/national/22AIR.html?th= & pagewanted=all & pos ition= > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.