Guest guest Posted August 17, 2003 Report Posted August 17, 2003 Do Americans Have a First Amendment Right to Become " Human Shields " and to > Criticize Their Government? > The Case of Faith Fippinger > By JULIE HILDEN > <julhiljulhil > ---- > Thursday, Aug. 14, 2003 > > Faith Fippinger, who is now sixty-two years old, was once a schoolteacher. > More recently, during the Iraq War, she was a " human shield. " In Iraq, she > was part of a large group of protesters - only about 20 of whom, she says, > were Americans - who spread out across the country to protest the war. > > During the war, Fippinger spoke out against it. She told a reporter from > The Christian Science Monitor, " The biggest shock is that America continues > to pursue war in this way, and that's just impossible to believe: to choose > war, to choose death, to choose murder ... killing hope, killing future. " > And she told another reporter, " I may die here. But my death is no more or > less important than the Iraqi lives that will be lost. " > > Now, the U.S. government is going after Fippinger with a vengeance, saying > she owes at least $10,000 in fines for violating U.S. sanctions that > prohibit " virtually all direct or indirect commercial, financial or trade > transactions with Iraq. " But Fippinger has refused to pay the fines, > claiming that the only money she spent while in Iraq was for food and > emergency supplies - hardly major international trade. > > Fippinger has also - unwisely - invited the government to use the other > available punishment for violation of the sanctions: imprisonment. Or, as > Fippinger politely put it in her response to the government, since she will > never pay the fines, " perhaps the alternative should be considered. " > > But Fippinger shouldn't be so quick to give in - or to be jailed as a > martyr. Powerful, though circumstantial, evidence suggests she has been > targeted because of her choice to speak out about the recent Iraq War. > Already under heavy criticism - in part for its failure to produce the > weapons of mass destruction that were a major justification for the war - > the Bush Administration cannot be happy that Fippinger and others are > drawing on their firsthand knowledge of the war to add to the chorus. > > If so, then Fippinger is facing criminal charges largely because she > availed herself of her First Amendment rights. Accordingly, she may be able > to convince a court to dismiss these charges on the ground that they > violate the Constitution. > > A Court Would Be Unlikely to Hold that the First Amendment Protects Human > Shields > > To begin, is there a First Amendment right for a citizen like Fippinger to > protest war by traveling abroad and becoming a human shield? The answer a > court would reach is almost certainly no. > > As Phillip Carter has explained in a column for this site, the military > enjoys substantial judicial deference when it comes to First Amendment > disputes, and other instances in which military objectives clash with civil > liberties. And it's hard to imagine a more acute clash that one between a > military division trying to attack a target, and civilians standing in > front of it as " human shields, " refusing to leave. > > In such a situation, a court would doubtless side with the military. In > doing so, it could also invoke the speech/conduct distinction. Although > becoming a human shield is a form of symbolic speech, it is also an > obstructing action, getting in the way of military movements and attacks - > and the First Amendment, fundamentally, protects speech, not action. > > Despite this argument's poor chances of prevailing in court, however, it's > not as weak as it might seem. Being a " human shield " is a form of > nonviolent political protest, in the tradition of sit-ins, and non-violent > resistance generally. As such, it typically sends a symbolical political > message. Fippinger's message, for instance, was the one she subsequently > voiced: " [M]y death is no more or less important than the Iraqi lives that > will be lost. " > > Such a message is inherently political. It threatens governments' > distinctions between citizen civilians (who must be protected at all cost) > and noncitizen civilians (who can't be directly targeted, but might be > acceptable " collateral damage " ). > > Thus, becoming a human shield is virtually always a form of symbolic > speech. It is also an exceptionally powerful one: One's very life is > literally at stake, and that forces the media, and hopefully also the > government, to take notice. > > Nevertheless, because the human shield's adversary is the military, and > under U.S. law, the military almost always wins, the outcome of this First > Amendment argument is a foregone conclusion: It's a loser. > > That doesn't mean, however, that Fippinger has no First Amendment case. To > the contrary, she may have a strong one. > > Why It Seems Likely that the Government Is Bothered By Fippinger's Speech, > Not Her " Trade " > > It seems extremely unlikely that the government is actually applying the > Iraq sanctions to Fippinger based on her supposed " trade " with Iraq, as it > claims. Her tiny purchases are simply not the kind of trade the sanctions > contemplate. > > Rather, these sanctions were meant to be enforced against those who > illegally exported to, imported from, and did business with Saddam > Hussein's government, thus propping it up. They were meant, that is, to > primarily target corporations, businesses, and business persons. Fippinger > is none of these. > > The sanctions were also meant to primarily target transactions in > significant amounts. If Fippinger is correct that all she bought was food > and emergency supplies, then her supposed violation was de minimis legal > jargon for " too small for the government to bother with. " > > To apply trade sanctions to Fippinger, therefore seems at best absurd, and > at worst, pretextual. What really bothers the government can't be the few > bandages or meals she bought. Instead, it must be what she said, and the > fact that the media has listened to her. > > It's an irresistible story, after all: A retired schoolteacher - and a very > photogenic one, who resembles a cross between Katharine Hepburn and an > old-time suffragette - felt so strongly about the Iraq War that she got on > a plane, went there, and did what she could to help suffering people there, > risking her own life. > > Even worse - from the government's perspective - is that, in addition to > speaking out as a human shield in Iraq, Fippinger kept right on speaking to > the media even after she returned to her home in Sarasota, Florida. In her > interview with The Washington Post, she talked about conditions at Baghdad > hospitals: " It's just sobbing doctors, " she said, " because there was so > much death, so much horror. . . . It was just death after death after > death. From babies to old men and women, the whole range. Amputees. Arms > gone, legs gone. Children filled with shrapnel from cluster bombs. " She > remarked, " I've never seen in all my life such horrors . . . . But I'm sure > I'll see them for the rest of my life. " > > More evidence that Fippinger is being targeted for speaking out comes from > the poor fit between the sanctions invoked to go after her, and what she > actually did. Whenever the government invokes a law that so poorly fits the > crime alleged, you can be sure that something else is going on. > > When the government went after Al Capone for tax evasion, it wasn't worried > about taxes; it simply knew it would have a hard time winning other cases > against him. In going after Fippinger for trade sanctions violations, the > government doesn't really care about her negligible " trade with Iraq " ; but > it knows it can't directly go after her for speaking out, because that > would be a blatant First Amendment violation (as well as terrible public > relations.) > > U.S. citizens have a First Amendment right to criticize their government, > whether they are in the U.S. or abroad. (Indeed, even enlisted soldiers > have that right - as explained in a column by Dean Falvy for this site.) > Fippinger should not be punished for availing herself of that right. > > Fippinger's Legal Battle Would Be Uphill, But Is One That Is Worth Fighting > > Before packing her bag for prison, Fippinger should visit a lawyer. Her > lawyer should then move to have the charges against her dismissed, among > other reasons, because they violate the First Amendment. The government's > treatment of Fippinger may well outrage a judge enough to grant that motion. > > Fippinger might also have a claim against the government - either under the > federal civil rights statute that allows citizens to sue for damages when > their constitutional rights are violated, or under the theory that she > suffered from selective prosecution. Were other Americans who spent minimal > money in Iraq, and did not speak out against the government, pursued under > the unconvincing " trade violation " theory? If not, then Fippinger may have > a strong case against the government. > > Selective prosecution arguments are always hard to win. But this case might > be an exception: It seems so obvious that it's Fippinger's speaking out > that has made her a target. Why else would the government bother to enforce > obsolete sanctions against a retired schoolteacher who did no real harm > with her tiny purchases, and plainly lacks the money to easily pay the fines? > > Many nonviolent protesters before this have gone to jail for their beliefs. > But Fippinger need not necessarily be one of them. > > Julie Hilden, a FindLaw columnist, practiced First Amendment law at the > D.C. law firm of Williams & Connolly from 1996-99. Hilden's first novel, 3, > was just released > <http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/0452284430/qid=1060805218/sr= 8-1/ref=sr_8_1/002-8386049-7510453?v=glance & s=books & n=507846>in > the U.S. and the U.K.. It will also be published, in French translation, by > Actes Sud. Kirkus Reviews wrote about 3, " When tragedy intervenes, it's no > surprise but shocking nonetheless -- testament to Hilden's rather uncanny > abilities. " Hilden maintains a website at www.juliehilden.com that includes > MP3 and text downloads of the novel's first chapter. > > http://writ.news.findlaw.com/hilden/20030814.html > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.