Mysty/Homeopathic

[Guest guest]

Sorry Misty, You are right. I just didn't want to get in a long discussion

or explanation on how they work for me. I just wanted to let people know

that they do work. I didn't mean to sound like I was attacking you, that

wasn't my point and I am sorry that it sounded like that. I am just not

good at writing long post.

 

Shawn

 

-

" Misty L. Trepke " <mistytrepke

 

Sunday, December 07, 2003 1:41 AM

[s-A] Re: Mysty/Homeopathic

 

 

> Dear Shawn...

>

> Let me address your concerns and offer a few suggestions...

>

> First of all, when did I say that I am always correct?

>

> This is my experience and my beliefs, and yes, I have been very

> fortunate to train and study under a master homeopath for many, many

> years... Information that I freely and openly share with the

> group... As such, I explained why I felt this was not homeopathy in

> it's best form, and gave an alternative solution to the problem, a

> brief lay out as to how I approach homeopathy- which other lay out

> can I offer?...

>

> Not that I want to start a debate between methods, but instead of

> saying, " you aren't always correct " , perhaps it would be more

> constructive to relate to me your experiences with oscillococcinum,

> and how you have used it, for which symptoms and rubrics... And

> perhaps actually answer the concerns I have raised regarding

> oscillococcinum...

>

> As of now, you have not said anything constructive, only attacking

> me for a perception that you have that I think I am always correct.

> An assumption that you seem to be actually demonstrating yourself at

> the moment, since you do not even find it worthwhile to help us

> understand your support of these remedies, except for general

> statements of, " they work for me... " Are you always correct, that

> we should take this at face value, without thought, rhyme or reason?

>

> Likewise, you may use traditional homeopathic remedies and not get

> results, but let's discuss how you use them. I don't always use

> remedies traditionally, classically if you will, and if you would

> like to discuss the limitations of the use of classical remedies

> that is a fine subject to toss around. But again, to just

> say, " they don't work for me " , and act as if you have the definitive

> word on traditional remedies- a term you did not even define,

> without any futher elucidation, offers extremely little to those who

> are trying to learn from this board- and the complex subject of

> homeopathy at that. Instead of being an asset to this board,

> messages like this set you in the light of being not just a little

> egotistical, self-absorbed, and unwilling or more likely, unable, to

> help assist those around you...

>

> I say this to you with the best intentions to assist you in refining

> how you are perceived, as a fellow teacher and homeopath. Now as

> the moderator of this group, I strongly urge you to keep in mind

> posting etiquette and encourage you to disagree with me, but with

> some substance behind it, so perhaps the disagreement, instead of

> being confusing and devisive, can be educational to all- not least

> of which, being me... And I must warn you, another personal attack

> such as this will not be tolerated, you will be banned.

>

> Sincerely,

> Misty L. Trepke

> http://www..com

>

>

> , " Shawn Sieracki "

> <info@p...> wrote:

> > I disagree with you completely Misty, I have been using

> Oscillococcinum in

> > my practice for years, with tremendous results. I like using the

> > combination homeopathic remedies. When the flu season kicks in, I

> will

> > always be recommending the Oscillococcinum. In my practice the

> traditional

> > homeopathics don't always work.

> >

> > You do know what you are talking about and I do respect your

> thoughts, but

> > you aren't always correct.

> >

> > Take Care

> >

> > Shawn

> >

>

>

>

>

>