Does Goddess have menstrual cycles?

[Guest guest]

Namaste

 

My apologies stepping into the thread when much has already been said. I was

away in Rishikesh, and returned to find over 300 messages which I allowed to

flow by me and taste this that ripples now.

 

I believe that life as we know it, some beings like humans do have menstrual

cycles. Now Devi being everything and everything being in Devi, sure she does

have menstrual cycles.

 

If your Guruji was refering to a picture or a statue of a form of Devi (which I

would expect he is not) ten obviously inanimate objects do not have menstrual

cycles, in which case agaain as Devi is in all and all is in her, then she des

not have a menstrual cycle.

 

If we speak of the divine form, then again the answer is yes and no, because the

divine form is this and that (above 2 scenarios). For me thhe answer is so

apparent, I wonder why the question was raised in the first instance ?

 

:-p

 

 

jayanth_garakahalli <jayanth_garakahalli wrote: Namaste,

 

You could be right. Anyways today the usual Friday meet with him is

scheduled in the evening. Will definitely post what he has to say on

all this that happened tommorow. Am now taking print outs :-).

 

Thanks you

 

 

 

, "NMadasamy" <nmadasamy

wrote:

>

> Now lets go back to Jayanth original statement :

>

> [Jayanth's Guru] then asked me to post a question -

> "Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no, then what

> are the sources that have mentioned the same"

> I asked- " ok I will, but please tell me the answer yourself

first".

> He said with that typical 'Guru smile' which many of you would have

> exprience with your Gurus- " bring a printout of all the postings

> and then I will share my answer with all and also give them my

> appreciation for the forum"

> [....]

> My question for Jeyanth is : so what have you learn from this

> experience?

[Guest guest]

, Vir Rawlley <redderred

wrote:

>

> Namaste

>

> My apologies stepping into the thread when much has already been

said. I was away in Rishikesh, and returned to find over 300

messages which I allowed to flow by me and taste this that ripples

now.

>

> I believe that life as we know it, some beings like humans do

have menstrual cycles. Now Devi being everything and everything

being in Devi, sure she does have menstrual cycles.

>

> If your Guruji was refering to a picture or a statue of a form of

Devi (which I would expect he is not) ten obviously inanimate

objects do not have menstrual cycles, in which case agaain as Devi

is in all and all is in her, then she des not have a menstrual cycle.

>

> If we speak of the divine form, then again the answer is yes and

no, because the divine form is this and that (above 2 scenarios).

For me thhe answer is so apparent, I wonder why the question was

raised in the first instance ?

 

 

The question is meant for Jayanth, and not for us. I believe Jeyanth

Guru is already aware of the responses he will get. This is his

little exercise for Jeyanth. We are waiting for Jeyanth to come back

to us.

[Guest guest]

Since all is Devi, then where is the argument, since she created menstration it

exists. In Guwhati at Kamakhya they shut the temple for 3 days saying Maa is

going through her periods.

 

Charu

 

Vir Rawlley <redderred wrote:

Namaste

 

My apologies stepping into the thread when much has already been said. I was

away in Rishikesh, and returned to find over 300 messages which I allowed to

flow by me and taste this that ripples now.

 

I believe that life as we know it, some beings like humans do have menstrual

cycles. Now Devi being everything and everything being in Devi, sure she does

have menstrual cycles.

 

If your Guruji was refering to a picture or a statue of a form of Devi (which I

would expect he is not) ten obviously inanimate objects do not have menstrual

cycles, in which case agaain as Devi is in all and all is in her, then she des

not have a menstrual cycle.

 

If we speak of the divine form, then again the answer is yes and no, because the

divine form is this and that (above 2 scenarios). For me thhe answer is so

apparent, I wonder why the question was raised in the first instance ?

 

:-p

 

 

jayanth_garakahalli <jayanth_garakahalli wrote: Namaste,

 

You could be right. Anyways today the usual Friday meet with him is

scheduled in the evening. Will definitely post what he has to say on

all this that happened tommorow. Am now taking print outs :-).

 

Thanks you

 

 

 

, "NMadasamy" <nmadasamy

wrote:

>

> Now lets go back to Jayanth original statement :

>

> [Jayanth's Guru] then asked me to post a question -

> "Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no, then what

> are the sources that have mentioned the same"

> I asked- " ok I will, but please tell me the answer yourself

first".

> He said with that typical 'Guru smile' which many of you would have

> exprience with your Gurus- " bring a printout of all the postings

> and then I will share my answer with all and also give them my

> appreciation for the forum"

> [....]

> My question for Jeyanth is : so what have you learn from this

> experience?

 

 

 

 

 

Traditions Divine

 

 

 

 

Visit your group "" on the web.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Jiyo cricket on India cricket

Messenger Mobile Stay in touch with your buddies all the time.

 

 

[Guest guest]

Yes, this is interesting. Men also have cycles though they are not menses.

 

-

Vir Rawlley

Sunday, March 26, 2006 11:26 AM

Re: Re: Does Goddess have menstrual cycles?

 

 

I believe that life as we know it, some beings like humans do have menstrual

cycles. Now Devi being everything and everything being in Devi, sure she does

have menstrual cycles.

[Guest guest]

that was last friday. what happened Jayanth?

 

jayanth_garakahalli <jayanth_garakahalli wrote: Namaste,

 

You could be right. Anyways today the usual Friday meet with him is

scheduled in the evening. Will definitely post what he has to say on

all this that happened tommorow. Am now taking print outs :-).

 

Thanks you

 

 

 

 

, "NMadasamy" <nmadasamy

wrote:

>

> Now lets go back to Jayanth original statement :

>

> Jeyanth wrote : 2ndly I was sitting with my Guru the day before

> yesterday and mentioned that I was a member in this wonderful group

> where so many devotees of the Goddess come together and share

> knowledge. He asked me, "so you will you get the answers to any

sort

> of queries on the Goddess?" I said, "yes, there are people who are

> highly knowledgable here". He then asked me to post a question -

> "Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no, then what

> are the sources that have mentioned the same"

> I asked- " ok I will, but please tell me the answer yourself

first".

> He said with that typical 'Guru smile' which many of you would have

> exprience with your Gurus- " bring a printout of all the postings

> and then I will share my answer with all and also give them my

> appreciation for the forum"

>

>

> I see something when I first read this statement. And I personally

> belief this all is meant for Jeyanth and not for us. We never admit

> being "highly knowledeable" and we never admit being able to give

> all the answers to any sort of queries on the Goddess. Its Jeyanth

> own interpretation or I would say assumption. His Guru is trying to

> tell him something through us. His Guru knows who we are, and he

> wants Jeyanth to learn from experience. He could have easily give

> Jeyath the answers, why didnt he?

>

> My question for Jeyanth is : so what have you learn from this

> experience?

>

>

>

> , "Dhirendra Pal Singh"

> <dpal.singh@> wrote:

> >

> > Dear jayant,I have a big short comming and that is I cant make

> politically correct statement but then I can't take them either.

>

> You have very nicely skipped my question and brought me back to

> your ground.Let me put it this way...Let me try to summarise what I

> had said in my previous email

>

> A) I said I can probalby get you the answer, that doesnt mean I

> know it right now. I have no hesitation in accepting what I dont

> know. Heck no one knows everything in this world (off course there

> are some exceptions )

> B) But then if I have invest some time in it, I want to know why I

> want to do that. I am short on time. It has never been on my

side...

> Hence if you started this question and cant prove why it is imp for

> me it wouldnt go anywhere.

> C) Please dont take everything to the one question question? Who

> am i? At least as of now I cant see it related to your quesiton.

> Feel free toenlightment me and be a little detailed.

>

> Now I was trying to analyse why you took the liberty to start this

> thread.If I type all the things it would be a very long email, I

> will try to summarise

> A) if you know the answer and wnated to just share you email would

> have "I know this and wanted to share with every one"

> B) Now I know sometimes guru's do special things which are beyond

> my comprehension but still its kind of interesting that your guru

is

> kind of wanting to challange us, or trying to find out knowledge

> level of people on this list. Again my old question, what would be

> he get out of it. Why would he want to do that.? Posslily to

> establish his and/or yours supremacy. Again if that thats the case

I

> will drop out of discussion.

> C) Well I can go on and on .. but then again time is short.

>

> But I do appreciate that you took the time to answeres all the

> people question.. interesting. very interesting. This means

>

> A) either the answer to this question is not know to a lot of time

> and hence you are enjoying the confustion

> B) or the answere will help us all evolve us all..

>

> Hence I will be waiting for a detailed explanation from you as to

> why at least myself needs to know the answere to this quesiton.

What

> will it get me.?

>

> Thanks and Regards

> Dp PS I didnt mean to dis-respect any Guru. What I have learned

from

> both of my masters that if there is a debate there is no one

younger

> and no one is older. Its just a debate and you can always put your

> point, off course with respect...

> >

> > Har Har Mahadev.

> >

>

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Visit your group "" on the web.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

New Messenger with Voice. Call regular phones from your PC and save big.

 

 

[Guest guest]

yooooooooo hhhhhhhhhoooooooooo JAYANT!!!

 

Did your computer refuse to connect to SS or did the Church tell you that this

is not the place to get the ammunition for conversion antics?

 

Or did your Guru just disappear to the Himalayas when you went with the print

outs? Or did he just enter into a mauna vruta for 108 years??

 

What happened??

 

Or am I completly wrong that you have a good explanation??

 

jayanth_garakahalli <jayanth_garakahalli wrote:

Namaste,

 

You could be right. Anyways today the usual Friday meet with him is

scheduled in the evening. Will definitely post what he has to say on

all this that happened tommorow. Am now taking print outs :-).

 

Thanks you

 

 

 

 

, "NMadasamy" <nmadasamy

wrote:

>

> Now lets go back to Jayanth original statement :

>

> Jeyanth wrote : 2ndly I was sitting with my Guru the day before

> yesterday and mentioned that I was a member in this wonderful group

> where so many devotees of the Goddess come together and share

> knowledge. He asked me, "so you will you get the answers to any

sort

> of queries on the Goddess?" I said, "yes, there are people who are

> highly knowledgable here". He then asked me to post a question -

> "Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no, then what

> are the sources that have mentioned the same"

> I asked- " ok I will, but please tell me the answer yourself

first".

> He said with that typical 'Guru smile' which many of you would have

> exprience with your Gurus- " bring a printout of all the postings

> and then I will share my answer with all and also give them my

> appreciation for the forum"

>

>

> I see something when I first read this statement. And I personally

> belief this all is meant for Jeyanth and not for us. We never admit

> being "highly knowledeable" and we never admit being able to give

> all the answers to any sort of queries on the Goddess. Its Jeyanth

> own interpretation or I would say assumption. His Guru is trying to

> tell him something through us. His Guru knows who we are, and he

> wants Jeyanth to learn from experience. He could have easily give

> Jeyath the answers, why didnt he?

>

> My question for Jeyanth is : so what have you learn from this

> experience?

>

>

>

> , "Dhirendra Pal Singh"

> <dpal.singh@> wrote:

> >

> > Dear jayant,I have a big short comming and that is I cant make

> politically correct statement but then I can't take them either.

>

> You have very nicely skipped my question and brought me back to

> your ground.Let me put it this way...Let me try to summarise what I

> had said in my previous email

>

> A) I said I can probalby get you the answer, that doesnt mean I

> know it right now. I have no hesitation in accepting what I dont

> know. Heck no one knows everything in this world (off course there

> are some exceptions )

> B) But then if I have invest some time in it, I want to know why I

> want to do that. I am short on time. It has never been on my

side...

> Hence if you started this question and cant prove why it is imp for

> me it wouldnt go anywhere.

> C) Please dont take everything to the one question question? Who

> am i? At least as of now I cant see it related to your quesiton.

> Feel free toenlightment me and be a little detailed.

>

> Now I was trying to analyse why you took the liberty to start this

> thread.If I type all the things it would be a very long email, I

> will try to summarise

> A) if you know the answer and wnated to just share you email would

> have "I know this and wanted to share with every one"

> B) Now I know sometimes guru's do special things which are beyond

> my comprehension but still its kind of interesting that your guru

is

> kind of wanting to challange us, or trying to find out knowledge

> level of people on this list. Again my old question, what would be

> he get out of it. Why would he want to do that.? Posslily to

> establish his and/or yours supremacy. Again if that thats the case

I

> will drop out of discussion.

> C) Well I can go on and on .. but then again time is short.

>

> But I do appreciate that you took the time to answeres all the

> people question.. interesting. very interesting. This means

>

> A) either the answer to this question is not know to a lot of time

> and hence you are enjoying the confustion

> B) or the answere will help us all evolve us all..

>

> Hence I will be waiting for a detailed explanation from you as to

> why at least myself needs to know the answere to this quesiton.

What

> will it get me.?

>

> Thanks and Regards

> Dp PS I didnt mean to dis-respect any Guru. What I have learned

from

> both of my masters that if there is a debate there is no one

younger

> and no one is older. Its just a debate and you can always put your

> point, off course with respect...

> >

> > Har Har Mahadev.

> >

>

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Visit your group "" on the web.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Blab-away for as little as 1¢/min. Make PC-to-Phone Calls using

Messenger with Voice.

 

 

[Guest guest]

)))))

 

Maybe he had agni-samadhi or went alive to svarga-loka? Or to Trishanku-svarga?

 

 

, sankara menon <kochu1tz wrote:

>

> yooooooooo hhhhhhhhhoooooooooo JAYANT!!!

>

> Did your computer refuse to connect to SS or did the Church tell you that

this is not

the place to get the ammunition for conversion antics?

>

> Or did your Guru just disappear to the Himalayas when you went with the

print outs?

Or did he just enter into a mauna vruta for 108 years??

>

> What happened??

>

> Or am I completly wrong that you have a good explanation??

>

> jayanth_garakahalli <jayanth_garakahalli wrote:

> Namaste,

>

> You could be right. Anyways today the usual Friday meet with him is

> scheduled in the evening. Will definitely post what he has to say on

> all this that happened tommorow. Am now taking print outs :-).

>

> Thanks you