Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org
Sign in to follow this  
Guest guest

Does Goddess have menstrual cycles?

Rate this topic

Recommended Posts

Guest guest

Dear Members of SS,

 

1st of all it is really a pleasure to be a part of SS. I thank the

moderater and all of you for the knowledge shared on this portal.

 

2ndly I was sitting with my Guru the day before yesterday and

mentioned that I was a member in this wonderful group where so many

devotees of the Goddess come together and share knowledge.

 

He asked me, "so you will you get the answers to any sort of queries

on the Goddess?" I said, "yes, there are people who are highly

knowledgable here".

 

He then asked me to post a question -

"Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no, then what are

the sources that have mentioned the same"

 

I asked- " ok I will, but please tell me the answer yourself first".

He said with that typical 'Guru smile' which many of you would have

expreinced with your Gurus- " bring a printout of all the postings

and then I will share my answer with all and also give them my

appreciation for the forum"

 

So dear all, awaiting your responses.

 

Your's,

Jayanth

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest guest

Well Shakti Sadhana did have her menstruation at one time.

See message :18163

 

For normal ladies its what! 28 days. Shakti Sadhana im still not

sure. hmmm sounds like a good idea : maybe I should plot the group

activity, only then we will know SS menstrual cycle. Anybody wantts

to help me?

 

 

-- In , "jayanth_garakahalli"

<jayanth_garakahalli wrote:

>

> Dear Members of SS,

>

> 1st of all it is really a pleasure to be a part of SS. I thank the

> moderater and all of you for the knowledge shared on this portal.

>

> 2ndly I was sitting with my Guru the day before yesterday and

> mentioned that I was a member in this wonderful group where so

many

> devotees of the Goddess come together and share knowledge.

>

> He asked me, "so you will you get the answers to any sort of

queries

> on the Goddess?" I said, "yes, there are people who are highly

> knowledgable here".

>

> He then asked me to post a question -

> "Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no, then what

are

> the sources that have mentioned the same"

>

> I asked- " ok I will, but please tell me the answer yourself

first".

> He said with that typical 'Guru smile' which many of you would

have

> expreinced with your Gurus- " bring a printout of all the postings

> and then I will share my answer with all and also give them my

> appreciation for the forum"

>

> So dear all, awaiting your responses.

>

> Your's,

> Jayanth

>

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest guest

My gosh! why didnt I think of it before. Indeed Shakti Sadhana have

began her menstrual cycle. Your guru started it jayanth. Read what

he asked : "Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no,

then what are the sources that have mentioned the same"

 

Your beloved guru is the source that started it all.

 

 

, "NMadasamy" <nmadasamy

wrote:

>

>

> Well Shakti Sadhana did have her menstruation at one time.

> See message :18163

>

> For normal ladies its what! 28 days. Shakti Sadhana im still not

> sure. hmmm sounds like a good idea : maybe I should plot the group

> activity, only then we will know SS menstrual cycle. Anybody

wantts

> to help me?

>

>

> -- In , "jayanth_garakahalli"

> <jayanth_garakahalli@> wrote:

> >

> > Dear Members of SS,

> >

> > 1st of all it is really a pleasure to be a part of SS. I thank

the

> > moderater and all of you for the knowledge shared on this portal.

> >

> > 2ndly I was sitting with my Guru the day before yesterday and

> > mentioned that I was a member in this wonderful group where so

> many

> > devotees of the Goddess come together and share knowledge.

> >

> > He asked me, "so you will you get the answers to any sort of

> queries

> > on the Goddess?" I said, "yes, there are people who are highly

> > knowledgable here".

> >

> > He then asked me to post a question -

> > "Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no, then what

> are

> > the sources that have mentioned the same"

> >

> > I asked- " ok I will, but please tell me the answer yourself

> first".

> > He said with that typical 'Guru smile' which many of you would

> have

> > expreinced with your Gurus- " bring a printout of all the

postings

> > and then I will share my answer with all and also give them my

> > appreciation for the forum"

> >

> > So dear all, awaiting your responses.

> >

> > Your's,

> > Jayanth

> >

>

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest guest

/message/17169

 

, "jayanth_garakahalli"

<jayanth_garakahalli wrote:

>

> Dear Members of SS,

>

> 1st of all it is really a pleasure to be a part of SS. I thank the

> moderater and all of you for the knowledge shared on this portal.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest guest

This is the pits of all question! hahaha! why does your Guru not ask the G'ss

herself? Since its her leela and above all SHE IS then you bet your boots she

has her menstrual cycle too! only G'ss alone knows why MOM invented this now!

like so many other things! But its her Leela! and right now this is your Guru's

minor leela within hers hahaha!

 

Tarini

 

 

NMadasamy <nmadasamy wrote:

My gosh! why didnt I think of it before. Indeed Shakti Sadhana have

began her menstrual cycle. Your guru started it jayanth. Read what

he asked : "Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no,

then what are the sources that have mentioned the same"

 

Your beloved guru is the source that started it all.

 

 

, "NMadasamy" <nmadasamy

wrote:

>

>

> Well Shakti Sadhana did have her menstruation at one time.

> See message :18163

>

> For normal ladies its what! 28 days. Shakti Sadhana im still not

> sure. hmmm sounds like a good idea : maybe I should plot the group

> activity, only then we will know SS menstrual cycle. Anybody

wantts

> to help me?

>

>

> -- In , "jayanth_garakahalli"

> <jayanth_garakahalli@> wrote:

> >

> > Dear Members of SS,

> >

> > 1st of all it is really a pleasure to be a part of SS. I thank

the

> > moderater and all of you for the knowledge shared on this portal.

> >

> > 2ndly I was sitting with my Guru the day before yesterday and

> > mentioned that I was a member in this wonderful group where so

> many

> > devotees of the Goddess come together and share knowledge.

> >

> > He asked me, "so you will you get the answers to any sort of

> queries

> > on the Goddess?" I said, "yes, there are people who are highly

> > knowledgable here".

> >

> > He then asked me to post a question -

> > "Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no, then what

> are

> > the sources that have mentioned the same"

> >

> > I asked- " ok I will, but please tell me the answer yourself

> first".

> > He said with that typical 'Guru smile' which many of you would

> have

> > expreinced with your Gurus- " bring a printout of all the

postings

> > and then I will share my answer with all and also give them my

> > appreciation for the forum"

> >

> > So dear all, awaiting your responses.

> >

> > Your's,

> > Jayanth

> >

>

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Traditions Divine

 

 

 

 

Visit your group "" on the web.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Jiyo cricket on India cricket

Messenger Mobile Stay in touch with your buddies all the time.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest guest

2 answers off the top of my head:

 

(a) In Kamakoti Peeth, the Yoni Peeth is reported to turn red during certain

months

(b) We only know the Goddess' form through the earthly Goddess, who, being also

one with everything is also The Goddess Mahakali Herself, so yes, obviously, the

Goddess commenses.

 

-

jayanth_garakahalli

Wednesday, March 22, 2006 1:14 AM

Does Goddess have menstrual cycles?

 

 

Dear Members of SS,

 

1st of all it is really a pleasure to be a part of SS. I thank the

moderater and all of you for the knowledge shared on this portal.

 

2ndly I was sitting with my Guru the day before yesterday and

mentioned that I was a member in this wonderful group where so many

devotees of the Goddess come together and share knowledge.

 

He asked me, "so you will you get the answers to any sort of queries

on the Goddess?" I said, "yes, there are people who are highly

knowledgable here".

He then asked me to post a question -

"Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no, then what are

the sources that have mentioned the same"

 

I asked- " ok I will, but please tell me the answer yourself first".

He said with that typical 'Guru smile' which many of you would have

expreinced with your Gurus- " bring a printout of all the postings

and then I will share my answer with all and also give them my

appreciation for the forum"

 

So dear all, awaiting your responses.

 

Your's,

Jayanth

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest guest

There are as many devis as there are sadhaks. Ask your Guru which Goddess is he

speaking of. If it is his Goddess I know ot. If it is mine, she does regularly

and no surgical intervention has been necessary to correct the cycle.

 

Can you tell this to your Guru and you can even send me the reply in private

if you do not want to post the reply in public.

 

I bow at the feet of your Guru

 

charu jagat <charu_jagat wrote:

This is the pits of all question! hahaha! why does your Guru not ask the G'ss

herself? Since its her leela and above all SHE IS then you bet your boots she

has her menstrual cycle too! only G'ss alone knows why MOM invented this now!

like so many other things! But its her Leela! and right now this is your Guru's

minor leela within hers hahaha!

 

Tarini

 

 

NMadasamy <nmadasamy wrote:

My gosh! why didnt I think of it before. Indeed Shakti Sadhana have

began her menstrual cycle. Your guru started it jayanth. Read what

he asked : "Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no,

then what are the sources that have mentioned the same"

 

Your beloved guru is the source that started it all.

 

 

, "NMadasamy" <nmadasamy

wrote:

>

>

> Well Shakti Sadhana did have her menstruation at one time.

> See message :18163

>

> For normal ladies its what! 28 days. Shakti Sadhana im still not

> sure. hmmm sounds like a good idea : maybe I should plot the group

> activity, only then we will know SS menstrual cycle. Anybody

wantts

> to help me?

>

>

> -- In , "jayanth_garakahalli"

> <jayanth_garakahalli@> wrote:

> >

> > Dear Members of SS,

> >

> > 1st of all it is really a pleasure to be a part of SS. I thank

the

> > moderater and all of you for the knowledge shared on this portal.

> >

> > 2ndly I was sitting with my Guru the day before yesterday and

> > mentioned that I was a member in this wonderful group where so

> many

> > devotees of the Goddess come together and share knowledge.

> >

> > He asked me, "so you will you get the answers to any sort of

> queries

> > on the Goddess?" I said, "yes, there are people who are highly

> > knowledgable here".

> >

> > He then asked me to post a question -

> > "Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no, then what

> are

> > the sources that have mentioned the same"

> >

> > I asked- " ok I will, but please tell me the answer yourself

> first".

> > He said with that typical 'Guru smile' which many of you would

> have

> > expreinced with your Gurus- " bring a printout of all the

postings

> > and then I will share my answer with all and also give them my

> > appreciation for the forum"

> >

> > So dear all, awaiting your responses.

> >

> > Your's,

> > Jayanth

> >

>

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Traditions Divine

 

 

 

 

Visit your group "" on the web.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Jiyo cricket on India cricket

Messenger Mobile Stay in touch with your buddies all the time.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Traditions Divine

 

 

 

 

Visit your group "" on the web.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Brings words and photos together (easily) with

PhotoMail - it's free and works with Mail.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest guest

Dear Jayanth,

 

I can probably get you the answer. But before that there is another million

dollar question.

 

How would the answer to this quesiton help me in my quest of Truth.? What is

the relevance of this question in this (spiritual) world ?

 

 

Thanks

Deep

> >

> > -- In , "jayanth_garakahalli"

> > <jayanth_garakahalli@> wrote:

> > >

> > > Dear Members of SS,

> > >

> > > 1st of all it is really a pleasure to be a part of SS. I thank

> the

> > > moderater and all of you for the knowledge shared on this portal.

> > >

> > > 2ndly I was sitting with my Guru the day before yesterday and

> > > mentioned that I was a member in this wonderful group where so

> > many

> > > devotees of the Goddess come together and share knowledge.

> > >

> > > He asked me, "so you will you get the answers to any sort of

> > queries

> > > on the Goddess?" I said, "yes, there are people who are highly

> > > knowledgable here".

> > >

> > > He then asked me to post a question -

> > > "Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no, then what

> > are

> > > the sources that have mentioned the same"

> > >

> > > I asked- " ok I will, but please tell me the answer yourself

> > first".

> > > He said with that typical 'Guru smile' which many of you would

> > have

> > > expreinced with your Gurus- " bring a printout of all the

> postings

> > > and then I will share my answer with all and also give them my

> > > appreciation for the forum"

> > >

> > > So dear all, awaiting your responses.

> > >

> > > Your's,

> > > Jayanth

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest guest

Dear Deep,

It is definitely wonderful if you have the answer. Can only request

you to share it.

 

I also understand that in this (spiritual) world any question will

lead to another question and will boil down to 'aham kim?' Who am I?

which is considered as the question of questions. That way any

question has a relevence.

 

But, it is definitly amazing to see the replies where so many people

think in so many different ways and every answer has its own

relevence in turn to lead to a different question.

 

Best Regards,

Jayanth

 

, "Dhirendra Pal Singh"

<dpal.singh wrote:

>

> Dear Jayanth,

>

> I can probably get you the answer. But before that there is

another million

> dollar question.

>

> How would the answer to this quesiton help me in my quest of

Truth.? What is

> the relevance of this question in this (spiritual) world ?

>

>

> Thanks

> Deep

>

> > >

> > > -- In , "jayanth_garakahalli"

> > > <jayanth_garakahalli@> wrote:

> > > >

> > > > Dear Members of SS,

> > > >

> > > > 1st of all it is really a pleasure to be a part of SS. I

thank

> > the

> > > > moderater and all of you for the knowledge shared on this

portal.

> > > >

> > > > 2ndly I was sitting with my Guru the day before yesterday and

> > > > mentioned that I was a member in this wonderful group where

so

> > > many

> > > > devotees of the Goddess come together and share knowledge.

> > > >

> > > > He asked me, "so you will you get the answers to any sort of

> > > queries

> > > > on the Goddess?" I said, "yes, there are people who are

highly

> > > > knowledgable here".

> > > >

> > > > He then asked me to post a question -

> > > > "Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no, then

what

> > > are

> > > > the sources that have mentioned the same"

> > > >

> > > > I asked- " ok I will, but please tell me the answer yourself

> > > first".

> > > > He said with that typical 'Guru smile' which many of you

would

> > > have

> > > > expreinced with your Gurus- " bring a printout of all the

> > postings

> > > > and then I will share my answer with all and also give them

my

> > > > appreciation for the forum"

> > > >

> > > > So dear all, awaiting your responses.

> > > >

> > > > Your's,

> > > > Jayanth

>

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest guest

Dear Kochu,

 

 

I had called the Guru and gave him an overview of the responses

coming in. When asked which devi you are speaking of, he said "a

rose is beautiful and has many petals/thorns. Each petal and thorn

together bring the beauty of the rose. If I ask you where is the

beauty of the rose coming from? would you ask which petal are you

asking about?'

 

My interpretation is he is asking about the the very concept of the

Goddess.

 

Thanks a Lot,

Jayanth

, sankara menon <kochu1tz

wrote:

>

> There are as many devis as there are sadhaks. Ask your Guru which

Goddess is he speaking of. If it is his Goddess I know ot. If it is

mine, she does regularly and no surgical intervention has been

necessary to correct the cycle.

>

> Can you tell this to your Guru and you can even send me the

reply in private if you do not want to post the reply in public.

>

> I bow at the feet of your Guru

>

> charu jagat <charu_jagat wrote:

> This is the pits of all question! hahaha! why does your Guru not

ask the G'ss herself? Since its her leela and above all SHE IS then

you bet your boots she has her menstrual cycle too! only G'ss alone

knows why MOM invented this now! like so many other things! But its

her Leela! and right now this is your Guru's minor leela within hers

hahaha!

>

> Tarini

>

>

> NMadasamy <nmadasamy wrote:

> My gosh! why didnt I think of it before. Indeed Shakti Sadhana

have

> began her menstrual cycle. Your guru started it jayanth. Read what

> he asked : "Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no,

> then what are the sources that have mentioned the same"

>

> Your beloved guru is the source that started it all.

>

>

> , "NMadasamy" <nmadasamy@>

> wrote:

> >

> >

> > Well Shakti Sadhana did have her menstruation at one time.

> > See message :18163

> >

> > For normal ladies its what! 28 days. Shakti Sadhana im still not

> > sure. hmmm sounds like a good idea : maybe I should plot the

group

> > activity, only then we will know SS menstrual cycle. Anybody

> wantts

> > to help me?

> >

> >

> > -- In , "jayanth_garakahalli"

> > <jayanth_garakahalli@> wrote:

> > >

> > > Dear Members of SS,

> > >

> > > 1st of all it is really a pleasure to be a part of SS. I thank

> the

> > > moderater and all of you for the knowledge shared on this

portal.

> > >

> > > 2ndly I was sitting with my Guru the day before yesterday and

> > > mentioned that I was a member in this wonderful group where so

> > many

> > > devotees of the Goddess come together and share knowledge.

> > >

> > > He asked me, "so you will you get the answers to any sort of

> > queries

> > > on the Goddess?" I said, "yes, there are people who are highly

> > > knowledgable here".

> > >

> > > He then asked me to post a question -

> > > "Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no, then

what

> > are

> > > the sources that have mentioned the same"

> > >

> > > I asked- " ok I will, but please tell me the answer yourself

> > first".

> > > He said with that typical 'Guru smile' which many of you would

> > have

> > > expreinced with your Gurus- " bring a printout of all the

> postings

> > > and then I will share my answer with all and also give them my

> > > appreciation for the forum"

> > >

> > > So dear all, awaiting your responses.

> > >

> > > Your's,

> > > Jayanth

> > >

> >

>

> Traditions Divine

>

>

>

>

>

> Visit your group "" on the web.

>

>

>

>

> Terms of

Service.

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

> Jiyo cricket on India cricket

> Messenger Mobile Stay in touch with your buddies all the

time.

>

>

> Traditions Divine

>

>

>

>

>

> Visit your group "" on the web.

>

>

>

>

> Terms of

Service.

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

> Brings words and photos together (easily) with

> PhotoMail - it's free and works with Mail.

>

>

>

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest guest

Hi Charu,

 

U haven't got the point correctly. This was asked not becoz he is

unaware of the answer. And for any question there cannot be one

single right answer . It is our perception of looking at it, that

comes forward. If all questions were to be asked to the Goddess

directly, what is the necessity of a forum where we share

knowledge? And also Goddess anwers through people like u and me.

Just think about it before laughing it off as leela. Becoz every

leela has a purpose behind it. One of it is to acquire knowledge.

 

Thanks a lot,

Jayanth

 

-- In , charu jagat <charu_jagat

wrote:

>

> This is the pits of all question! hahaha! why does your Guru not

ask the G'ss herself? Since its her leela and above all SHE IS then

you bet your boots she has her menstrual cycle too! only G'ss alone

knows why MOM invented this now! like so many other things! But its

her Leela! and right now this is your Guru's minor leela within hers

hahaha!

>

> Tarini

>

>

> NMadasamy <nmadasamy wrote:

> My gosh! why didnt I think of it before. Indeed Shakti Sadhana

have

> began her menstrual cycle. Your guru started it jayanth. Read what

> he asked : "Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no,

> then what are the sources that have mentioned the same"

>

> Your beloved guru is the source that started it all.

>

>

> , "NMadasamy" <nmadasamy@>

> wrote:

> >

> >

> > Well Shakti Sadhana did have her menstruation at one time.

> > See message :18163

> >

> > For normal ladies its what! 28 days. Shakti Sadhana im still not

> > sure. hmmm sounds like a good idea : maybe I should plot the

group

> > activity, only then we will know SS menstrual cycle. Anybody

> wantts

> > to help me?

> >

> >

> > -- In , "jayanth_garakahalli"

> > <jayanth_garakahalli@> wrote:

> > >

> > > Dear Members of SS,

> > >

> > > 1st of all it is really a pleasure to be a part of SS. I thank

> the

> > > moderater and all of you for the knowledge shared on this

portal.

> > >

> > > 2ndly I was sitting with my Guru the day before yesterday and

> > > mentioned that I was a member in this wonderful group where so

> > many

> > > devotees of the Goddess come together and share knowledge.

> > >

> > > He asked me, "so you will you get the answers to any sort of

> > queries

> > > on the Goddess?" I said, "yes, there are people who are highly

> > > knowledgable here".

> > >

> > > He then asked me to post a question -

> > > "Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no, then

what

> > are

> > > the sources that have mentioned the same"

> > >

> > > I asked- " ok I will, but please tell me the answer yourself

> > first".

> > > He said with that typical 'Guru smile' which many of you would

> > have

> > > expreinced with your Gurus- " bring a printout of all the

> postings

> > > and then I will share my answer with all and also give them my

> > > appreciation for the forum"

> > >

> > > So dear all, awaiting your responses.

> > >

> > > Your's,

> > > Jayanth

> > >

> >

>

> Traditions Divine

>

>

>

>

>

> Visit your group "" on the web.

>

>

>

>

> Terms of

Service.

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

> Jiyo cricket on India cricket

> Messenger Mobile Stay in touch with your buddies all the

time.

>

>

>

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest guest

You don't seem to have understood my statement. I said "There are as many devis

as there are sadhaks" bercause each Devi to whom an upasaka is attached is

special to THAT sadhaka. Though ultimately all powers west in Adi Paraashakti,

the same adi parashakti when prayed to by a sadhaka manifests a form that is

SPECIAL to that sadhaka.

That i think answers your interpretation "My interpretation is he is asking

about the the very concept of the Goddess.".

Namaste

 

 

jayanth_garakahalli <jayanth_garakahalli wrote:

Dear Kochu,

 

 

I had called the Guru and gave him an overview of the responses coming in. When

asked which devi you are speaking of, he said "a rose is beautiful and has many

petals/thorns. Each petal and thorn together bring the beauty of the rose. If I

ask you where is the

beauty of the rose coming from? would you ask which petal are you asking about?'

 

My interpretation is he is asking about the the very concept of the Goddess.

 

Thanks a Lot,

Jayanth

, sankara menon <kochu1tz

wrote:

>

> There are as many devis as there are sadhaks. Ask your Guru which Goddess is

he speaking of. If it is his Goddess I know not. If it is mine, she does

regularly and no surgical intervention has been necessary to correct the cycle.

>

> Can you tell this to your Guru and you can even send me the reply in private

if you do not want to post the reply in public.

>

> I bow at the feet of your Guru

>

> charu jagat <charu_jagat wrote:

> This is the pits of all question! hahaha! why does your Guru not

ask the G'ss herself? Since its her leela and above all SHE IS then

you bet your boots she has her menstrual cycle too! only G'ss alone

knows why MOM invented this now! like so many other things! But its

her Leela! and right now this is your Guru's minor leela within hers

hahaha!

>

> Tarini

>

>

> NMadasamy <nmadasamy wrote:

> My gosh! why didnt I think of it before. Indeed Shakti Sadhana

have

> began her menstrual cycle. Your guru started it jayanth. Read what

> he asked : "Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no,

> then what are the sources that have mentioned the same"

>

> Your beloved guru is the source that started it all.

>

>

> , "NMadasamy" <nmadasamy@>

> wrote:

> >

> >

> > Well Shakti Sadhana did have her menstruation at one time.

> > See message :18163

> >

> > For normal ladies its what! 28 days. Shakti Sadhana im still not

> > sure. hmmm sounds like a good idea : maybe I should plot the

group

> > activity, only then we will know SS menstrual cycle. Anybody

> wantts

> > to help me?

> >

> >

> > -- In , "jayanth_garakahalli"

> > <jayanth_garakahalli@> wrote:

> > >

> > > Dear Members of SS,

> > >

> > > 1st of all it is really a pleasure to be a part of SS. I thank

> the

> > > moderater and all of you for the knowledge shared on this

portal.

> > >

> > > 2ndly I was sitting with my Guru the day before yesterday and

> > > mentioned that I was a member in this wonderful group where so

> > many

> > > devotees of the Goddess come together and share knowledge.

> > >

> > > He asked me, "so you will you get the answers to any sort of

> > queries

> > > on the Goddess?" I said, "yes, there are people who are highly

> > > knowledgable here".

> > >

> > > He then asked me to post a question -

> > > "Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no, then

what

> > are

> > > the sources that have mentioned the same"

> > >

> > > I asked- " ok I will, but please tell me the answer yourself

> > first".

> > > He said with that typical 'Guru smile' which many of you would

> > have

> > > expreinced with your Gurus- " bring a printout of all the

> postings

> > > and then I will share my answer with all and also give them my

> > > appreciation for the forum"

> > >

> > > So dear all, awaiting your responses.

> > >

> > > Your's,

> > > Jayanth

> > >

> >

>

> Traditions Divine

>

>

>

>

>

> Visit your group "" on the web.

>

>

>

>

> Terms of

Service.

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

> Jiyo cricket on India cricket

> Messenger Mobile Stay in touch with your buddies all the

time.

>

>

> Traditions Divine

>

>

>

>

>

> Visit your group "" on the web.

>

>

>

>

> Terms of

Service.

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

> Brings words and photos together (easily) with

> PhotoMail - it's free and works with Mail.

>

>

>

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Visit your group "" on the web.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

New Messenger with Voice. Call regular phones from your PC and save big.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest guest

ok. So you mean the answer to the original question of " Does Goddess

have menstrual cycles?" is "it depends on who the Sadhaka is"?

 

 

Thanks,

Jayanth

 

, sankara menon <kochu1tz

wrote:

>

> You don't seem to have understood my statement. I said "There are

as many devis as there are sadhaks" bercause each Devi to whom an

upasaka is attached is special to THAT sadhaka. Though ultimately all

powers west in Adi Paraashakti, the same adi parashakti when prayed

to by a sadhaka manifests a form that is SPECIAL to that sadhaka.

> That i think answers your interpretation "My interpretation is he

is asking about the the very concept of the Goddess.".

> Namaste

>

>

> jayanth_garakahalli <jayanth_garakahalli wrote:

> Dear Kochu,

>

>

> I had called the Guru and gave him an overview of the responses

coming in. When asked which devi you are speaking of, he said "a rose

is beautiful and has many petals/thorns. Each petal and thorn

together bring the beauty of the rose. If I ask you where is the

> beauty of the rose coming from? would you ask which petal are you

asking about?'

>

> My interpretation is he is asking about the the very concept of the

Goddess.

>

> Thanks a Lot,

> Jayanth

> , sankara menon <kochu1tz@>

> wrote:

> >

> > There are as many devis as there are sadhaks. Ask your Guru which

Goddess is he speaking of. If it is his Goddess I know not. If it is

mine, she does regularly and no surgical intervention has been

necessary to correct the cycle.

> >

> > Can you tell this to your Guru and you can even send me the

reply in private if you do not want to post the reply in public.

> >

> > I bow at the feet of your Guru

> >

> > charu jagat <charu_jagat@> wrote:

> > This is the pits of all question! hahaha! why does your Guru

not

> ask the G'ss herself? Since its her leela and above all SHE IS then

> you bet your boots she has her menstrual cycle too! only G'ss alone

> knows why MOM invented this now! like so many other things! But its

> her Leela! and right now this is your Guru's minor leela within

hers

> hahaha!

> >

> > Tarini

> >

>

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest guest

The beauty of the rose is the rose itself.

 

Tarini

 

jayanth_garakahalli <jayanth_garakahalli wrote:

Dear Kochu,

 

 

I had called the Guru and gave him an overview of the responses

coming in. When asked which devi you are speaking of, he said "a

rose is beautiful and has many petals/thorns. Each petal and thorn

together bring the beauty of the rose. If I ask you where is the

beauty of the rose coming from? would you ask which petal are you

asking about?'

 

My interpretation is he is asking about the the very concept of the

Goddess.

 

Thanks a Lot,

Jayanth

, sankara menon <kochu1tz

wrote:

>

> There are as many devis as there are sadhaks. Ask your Guru which

Goddess is he speaking of. If it is his Goddess I know ot. If it is

mine, she does regularly and no surgical intervention has been

necessary to correct the cycle.

>

> Can you tell this to your Guru and you can even send me the

reply in private if you do not want to post the reply in public.

>

> I bow at the feet of your Guru

>

> charu jagat <charu_jagat wrote:

> This is the pits of all question! hahaha! why does your Guru not

ask the G'ss herself? Since its her leela and above all SHE IS then

you bet your boots she has her menstrual cycle too! only G'ss alone

knows why MOM invented this now! like so many other things! But its

her Leela! and right now this is your Guru's minor leela within hers

hahaha!

>

> Tarini

>

>

> NMadasamy <nmadasamy wrote:

> My gosh! why didnt I think of it before. Indeed Shakti Sadhana

have

> began her menstrual cycle. Your guru started it jayanth. Read what

> he asked : "Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no,

> then what are the sources that have mentioned the same"

>

> Your beloved guru is the source that started it all.

>

>

> , "NMadasamy" <nmadasamy@>

> wrote:

> >

> >

> > Well Shakti Sadhana did have her menstruation at one time.

> > See message :18163

> >

> > For normal ladies its what! 28 days. Shakti Sadhana im still not

> > sure. hmmm sounds like a good idea : maybe I should plot the

group

> > activity, only then we will know SS menstrual cycle. Anybody

> wantts

> > to help me?

> >

> >

> > -- In , "jayanth_garakahalli"

> > <jayanth_garakahalli@> wrote:

> > >

> > > Dear Members of SS,

> > >

> > > 1st of all it is really a pleasure to be a part of SS. I thank

> the

> > > moderater and all of you for the knowledge shared on this

portal.

> > >

> > > 2ndly I was sitting with my Guru the day before yesterday and

> > > mentioned that I was a member in this wonderful group where so

> > many

> > > devotees of the Goddess come together and share knowledge.

> > >

> > > He asked me, "so you will you get the answers to any sort of

> > queries

> > > on the Goddess?" I said, "yes, there are people who are highly

> > > knowledgable here".

> > >

> > > He then asked me to post a question -

> > > "Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no, then

what

> > are

> > > the sources that have mentioned the same"

> > >

> > > I asked- " ok I will, but please tell me the answer yourself

> > first".

> > > He said with that typical 'Guru smile' which many of you would

> > have

> > > expreinced with your Gurus- " bring a printout of all the

> postings

> > > and then I will share my answer with all and also give them my

> > > appreciation for the forum"

> > >

> > > So dear all, awaiting your responses.

> > >

> > > Your's,

> > > Jayanth

> > >

> >

>

> Traditions Divine

>

>

>

>

>

> Visit your group "" on the web.

>

>

>

>

> Terms of

Service.

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

> Jiyo cricket on India cricket

> Messenger Mobile Stay in touch with your buddies all the

time.

>

>

> Traditions Divine

>

>

>

>

>

> Visit your group "" on the web.

>

>

>

>

> Terms of

Service.

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

> Brings words and photos together (easily) with

> PhotoMail - it's free and works with Mail.

>

>

>

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Visit your group "" on the web.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Jiyo cricket on India cricket

Messenger Mobile Stay in touch with your buddies all the time.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest guest

Jayanth,

 

there is no right or wrong, no correct view or false, all emerges from the

ground. I responded spontaneously, as words welled up.

 

Charu

 

jayanth_garakahalli <jayanth_garakahalli wrote:

Hi Charu,

 

U haven't got the point correctly. This was asked not becoz he is

unaware of the answer. And for any question there cannot be one

single right answer . It is our perception of looking at it, that

comes forward. If all questions were to be asked to the Goddess

directly, what is the necessity of a forum where we share

knowledge? And also Goddess anwers through people like u and me.

Just think about it before laughing it off as leela. Becoz every

leela has a purpose behind it. One of it is to acquire knowledge.

 

Thanks a lot,

Jayanth

 

-- In , charu jagat <charu_jagat

wrote:

>

> This is the pits of all question! hahaha! why does your Guru not

ask the G'ss herself? Since its her leela and above all SHE IS then

you bet your boots she has her menstrual cycle too! only G'ss alone

knows why MOM invented this now! like so many other things! But its

her Leela! and right now this is your Guru's minor leela within hers

hahaha!

>

> Tarini

>

>

> NMadasamy <nmadasamy wrote:

> My gosh! why didnt I think of it before. Indeed Shakti Sadhana

have

> began her menstrual cycle. Your guru started it jayanth. Read what

> he asked : "Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no,

> then what are the sources that have mentioned the same"

>

> Your beloved guru is the source that started it all.

>

>

> , "NMadasamy" <nmadasamy@>

> wrote:

> >

> >

> > Well Shakti Sadhana did have her menstruation at one time.

> > See message :18163

> >

> > For normal ladies its what! 28 days. Shakti Sadhana im still not

> > sure. hmmm sounds like a good idea : maybe I should plot the

group

> > activity, only then we will know SS menstrual cycle. Anybody

> wantts

> > to help me?

> >

> >

> > -- In , "jayanth_garakahalli"

> > <jayanth_garakahalli@> wrote:

> > >

> > > Dear Members of SS,

> > >

> > > 1st of all it is really a pleasure to be a part of SS. I thank

> the

> > > moderater and all of you for the knowledge shared on this

portal.

> > >

> > > 2ndly I was sitting with my Guru the day before yesterday and

> > > mentioned that I was a member in this wonderful group where so

> > many

> > > devotees of the Goddess come together and share knowledge.

> > >

> > > He asked me, "so you will you get the answers to any sort of

> > queries

> > > on the Goddess?" I said, "yes, there are people who are highly

> > > knowledgable here".

> > >

> > > He then asked me to post a question -

> > > "Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no, then

what

> > are

> > > the sources that have mentioned the same"

> > >

> > > I asked- " ok I will, but please tell me the answer yourself

> > first".

> > > He said with that typical 'Guru smile' which many of you would

> > have

> > > expreinced with your Gurus- " bring a printout of all the

> postings

> > > and then I will share my answer with all and also give them my

> > > appreciation for the forum"

> > >

> > > So dear all, awaiting your responses.

> > >

> > > Your's,

> > > Jayanth

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest guest

Namaste

 

"A rose by any other name is still a rose"...Williamm Shakespeare

 

And a rose is still a rose whether it has thorns or not (some roses

don't have thorns), whether it has great beauty but no fragrance, or

whether it has just 6 petals and a scent that fills a whole house let

alone the room it is in....

 

It is a Rose. If one "type" appeals to you, you will think it is the

only one...till you discover another and another..and finally

well...there are lots n lots but still classification: "Rose". Which

will appeal to you or draw you will depend upon your attributes not

the rose's...

 

Ummm...also..a rose growning in a particular environment will show an

attribute it may not show grown in another....this could also

translate to each individual's devotion to Her...

 

As for where the beauty of the rose comes from...well...I think it was

still our Wills Shakespeare who said...

 

"Beauty is in the eye of the beholder" So maybe the "concept" of the

Goddess is wholly dependent upon your conceptual perception and where

your devotion to Her leads you...

 

Maybe if we can answer.."what is the basic concept of a rose?" This

other question will be easier...

 

Hey!! Maybe we could also discuss if William Shakespeare was a Shakta

without realising it??!!

Sorry... ;)

 

kind regards

 

her_asha

 

 

-- In , "jayanth_garakahalli"

<jayanth_garakahalli wrote:

>

> Dear Kochu,

>

>

> I had called the Guru and gave him an overview of the responses

> coming in. When asked which devi you are speaking of, he said "a

> rose is beautiful and has many petals/thorns. Each petal and thorn

> together bring the beauty of the rose. If I ask you where is the

> beauty of the rose coming from? would you ask which petal are you

> asking about?'

>

> My interpretation is he is asking about the the very concept of the

> Goddess.

>

> Thanks a Lot,

> Jayanth

> , sankara menon <kochu1tz@>

> wrote:

> >

> > There are as many devis as there are sadhaks.

> Ask your Guru which

> Goddess is he speaking of. [....]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest guest

so why not ask your Guru? *smile*

 

jayanth_garakahalli <jayanth_garakahalli wrote:

 

ok. So you mean the answer to the original question of " Does Goddess

have menstrual cycles?" is "it depends on who the Sadhaka is"?

 

 

Thanks,

Jayanth

 

, sankara menon <kochu1tz

wrote:

>

> You don't seem to have understood my statement. I said "There are

as many devis as there are sadhaks" bercause each Devi to whom an

upasaka is attached is special to THAT sadhaka. Though ultimately all

powers west in Adi Paraashakti, the same adi parashakti when prayed

to by a sadhaka manifests a form that is SPECIAL to that sadhaka.

> That i think answers your interpretation "My interpretation is he

is asking about the the very concept of the Goddess.".

> Namaste

>

>

> jayanth_garakahalli <jayanth_garakahalli wrote:

> Dear Kochu,

>

>

> I had called the Guru and gave him an overview of the responses

coming in. When asked which devi you are speaking of, he said "a rose

is beautiful and has many petals/thorns. Each petal and thorn

together bring the beauty of the rose. If I ask you where is the

> beauty of the rose coming from? would you ask which petal are you

asking about?'

>

> My interpretation is he is asking about the the very concept of the

Goddess.

>

> Thanks a Lot,

> Jayanth

> , sankara menon <kochu1tz@>

> wrote:

> >

> > There are as many devis as there are sadhaks. Ask your Guru which

Goddess is he speaking of. If it is his Goddess I know not. If it is

mine, she does regularly and no surgical intervention has been

necessary to correct the cycle.

> >

> > Can you tell this to your Guru and you can even send me the

reply in private if you do not want to post the reply in public.

> >

> > I bow at the feet of your Guru

> >

> > charu jagat <charu_jagat@> wrote:

> > This is the pits of all question! hahaha! why does your Guru

not

> ask the G'ss herself? Since its her leela and above all SHE IS then

> you bet your boots she has her menstrual cycle too! only G'ss alone

> knows why MOM invented this now! like so many other things! But its

> her Leela! and right now this is your Guru's minor leela within

hers

> hahaha!

> >

> > Tarini

> >

>

 

 

 

 

 

Traditions Divine

 

 

 

 

Visit your group "" on the web.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

New Messenger with Voice. Call regular phones from your PC for low, low

rates.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest guest

Much of the beauty of the rose is not what's seen ;)

 

 

-

charu jagat

Thursday, March 23, 2006 2:03 AM

Re: Re: Does Goddess have menstrual cycles?

 

 

The beauty of the rose is the rose itself.

 

Tarini

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest guest

Namaste:

 

I tend to espouse a fairly Advaitic view of the Devi, so here is my reply to

the question.

 

Yes, of course the Goddess has Menstrual Cycles. She is *all* Cycles, all

life, all experience. She is Mahamaya, everything we can possibly hope to

experience. Though all women are made in Her Image, we men are too made by

Her, and She pervades all existence. As some have said, there are places,

yoni peethas, like blessed Kamakhya in Assam, where the Goddess is

worshipped in that form.

 

Much of the time this question is asked, it us out of disgust or negative

emotions. We attach such stigmas and taboos to menstruation and birth in

our culture, and we reflect these onto our spiritual life.

 

Jai Maa.

 

--

-Santo

"Aum Shanti Shanti Shantih."

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest guest

Dear jayant,

I have a big short comming :) and that is I cant make politically correct

statement but then I can't take them either.

 

You have very nicely skipped my question and brought me back to your ground.

Let me put it this way...

Let me try to summarise what I had said in my previous email

 

A) I said I can probalby get you the answer, that doesnt mean I know it

right now. I have no hesitation in accepting what I dont know. Heck no one

knows everything in this world (off course there are some exceptions :) )

B) But then if I have invest some time in it, I want to know why I want to

do that. I am short on time. It has never been on my side... Hence if you

started this question and cant prove why it is imp for me it wouldnt go

anywhere.

C) Please dont take everything to the one question question? Who am i? At

least as of now I cant see it related to your quesiton. Feel free to

enlightment me and be a little detailed.

 

 

Now I was trying to analyse why you took the liberty to start this thread.

If I type all the things it would be a very long email, I will try to

summarise

A) if you know the answer and wnated to just share you email would have "I

know this and wanted to share with every one"

B) Now I know sometimes guru's do special things which are beyond my

comprehension but still its kind of interesting that your guru is kind of

wanting to challange us, or trying to find out knowledge level of poeple on

this list. Again my old question, what would be he get out of it. Why would

he want to do that.? Posslily to establish his and/or yours supremacy. Again

if that thats the case I will drop out of discussion.

C) Well I can go on and on .. :) but then again time is short.

 

But I do appreciate that you took the time to answeres all the people

question.. interesting. very interesting. This means

 

A) either the answer to this question is not know to a lot of time and hence

you are enjoying the confustion

B) or the answere will help us all evolve us all..

 

Hence I will be waiting for a detailed explanation from you as to why at

least myself needs to know the answere to this quesiton. What will it get

me.?

 

Thanks and Regards

Dp

PS I didnt mean to dis-respect any Guru. What I have learned from both of my

masters that if there is a debate there is no one younger and no one is

older. Its just a debate and you can always put your point, off course with

respect... :)

 

Har Har Mahadev.

 

 

 

On 3/22/06, jayanth_garakahalli <jayanth_garakahalli wrote:

>

> Dear Deep,

> It is definitely wonderful if you have the answer. Can only request

> you to share it.

>

> I also understand that in this (spiritual) world any question will

> lead to another question and will boil down to 'aham kim?' Who am I?

> which is considered as the question of questions. That way any

> question has a relevence.

>

> But, it is definitly amazing to see the replies where so many people

> think in so many different ways and every answer has its own

> relevence in turn to lead to a different question.

>

> Best Regards,

> Jayanth

>

> , "Dhirendra Pal Singh"

> <dpal.singh wrote:

> >

> > Dear Jayanth,

> >

> > I can probably get you the answer. But before that there is

> another million

> > dollar question.

> >

> > How would the answer to this quesiton help me in my quest of

> Truth.? What is

> > the relevance of this question in this (spiritual) world ?

> >

> >

> > Thanks

> > Deep

> >

> > > >

> > > > -- In , "jayanth_garakahalli"

> > > > <jayanth_garakahalli@> wrote:

> > > > >

> > > > > [....]

> > > > > He then asked me to post a question -

> > > > > "Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? [....]

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest guest

It seems to me there's a kind of lovely

e-group serendipity at work here....

Sometimes even an odd or awkward

question (not saying that this one

was either) will elicit an amazing

gem of a response.

 

Thank you and bless you, gentlemen!

 

[santo Sengupta wrote:]

> I tend to espouse a fairly Advaitic view

> of the Devi, so here is my reply to

> the question.

>

> Yes, of course the Goddess has Menstrual Cycles.

> She is *all* Cycles, all life, all experience.

> She is Mahamaya, everything we can possibly hope to

> experience. Though all women are made in Her Image,

> we men are too made by

> Her, and She pervades all existence.

> As some have said, there are places,

> yoni peethas, like blessed Kamakhya in Assam,

> where the Goddess is

> worshipped in that form.

>

> Much of the time this question is asked,

> it us out of disgust or negative

> emotions. We attach such stigmas and

> taboos to menstruation and birth in

> our culture, and we reflect these onto

> our spiritual life.

>

------------

> [in an earlier post, Kochu wrote:]

> [....] "There are as many devis

> as there are sadhaks" because each Devi to

> whom an upasaka is attached is

> special to THAT sadhaka. Though ultimately

> all powers vest in Adi Paraashakti,

> the same adi parashakti when prayed to by a

> sadhaka manifests a form that is

> SPECIAL to that sadhaka.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest guest

Ok im serious mood today. No clowning around!!

 

 

I like to share my conversation with my guru looooooooooong time

ago. NM is me, GU is my Guru.[This conversation is a repost]

 

NM : During my earlier days in nursing, I have this tendency that

once I put on the nursing uniform, Nora ceases to exist. A new

identity is born. and I became a very different person. Do you

consider that as Bhootasuddhi? I am trying to connect this.

 

GU : That is not Bhootasuddhi. It is called Taadaatmya. Its being

one with the role you are playing.

 

NM : It is a wonderful feeling. I sense freedom. No boundaries. I am

not bounded with any religious or political affliations, but what I

represent : The Nurse.

 

GU : When you sit for Japa, you ARE Devi. It must become an

enjoyable experience.

 

 

So lets rationalise all this after reading the above conversation.

 

You see in my spiritual practice [ read the word MY and not others

bec there are many and each have their own distinctive features], we

do not have any troubles with menstruation. Im being told you can

still do your pooja as per normal even if ure having your menses. So

we do not see the fuss. Thus when it is said :"when you sit for

Japa, you ARE devi", When im having my menses, sitting down

for pooja and doing Japa, Devi too having menses. yes! How can it

not?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest guest

Now lets go back to Jayanth original statement :

 

Jeyanth wrote : 2ndly I was sitting with my Guru the day before

yesterday and mentioned that I was a member in this wonderful group

where so many devotees of the Goddess come together and share

knowledge. He asked me, "so you will you get the answers to any sort

of queries on the Goddess?" I said, "yes, there are people who are

highly knowledgable here". He then asked me to post a question -

"Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no, then what

are the sources that have mentioned the same"

I asked- " ok I will, but please tell me the answer yourself first".

He said with that typical 'Guru smile' which many of you would have

exprience with your Gurus- " bring a printout of all the postings

and then I will share my answer with all and also give them my

appreciation for the forum"

 

 

I see something when I first read this statement. And I personally

belief this all is meant for Jeyanth and not for us. We never admit

being "highly knowledeable" and we never admit being able to give

all the answers to any sort of queries on the Goddess. Its Jeyanth

own interpretation or I would say assumption. His Guru is trying to

tell him something through us. His Guru knows who we are, and he

wants Jeyanth to learn from experience. He could have easily give

Jeyath the answers, why didnt he?

 

My question for Jeyanth is : so what have you learn from this

experience?

 

 

 

, "Dhirendra Pal Singh"

<dpal.singh wrote:

>

> Dear jayant,I have a big short comming :) and that is I cant make

politically correct statement but then I can't take them either.

 

You have very nicely skipped my question and brought me back to

your ground.Let me put it this way...Let me try to summarise what I

had said in my previous email

 

A) I said I can probalby get you the answer, that doesnt mean I

know it right now. I have no hesitation in accepting what I dont

know. Heck no one knows everything in this world (off course there

are some exceptions :) )

B) But then if I have invest some time in it, I want to know why I

want to do that. I am short on time. It has never been on my side...

Hence if you started this question and cant prove why it is imp for

me it wouldnt go anywhere.

C) Please dont take everything to the one question question? Who

am i? At least as of now I cant see it related to your quesiton.

Feel free toenlightment me and be a little detailed.

 

Now I was trying to analyse why you took the liberty to start this

thread.If I type all the things it would be a very long email, I

will try to summarise

A) if you know the answer and wnated to just share you email would

have "I know this and wanted to share with every one"

B) Now I know sometimes guru's do special things which are beyond

my comprehension but still its kind of interesting that your guru is

kind of wanting to challange us, or trying to find out knowledge

level of people on this list. Again my old question, what would be

he get out of it. Why would he want to do that.? Posslily to

establish his and/or yours supremacy. Again if that thats the case I

will drop out of discussion.

C) Well I can go on and on .. :) but then again time is short.

 

But I do appreciate that you took the time to answeres all the

people question.. interesting. very interesting. This means

 

A) either the answer to this question is not know to a lot of time

and hence you are enjoying the confustion

B) or the answere will help us all evolve us all..

 

Hence I will be waiting for a detailed explanation from you as to

why at least myself needs to know the answere to this quesiton. What

will it get me.?

 

Thanks and Regards

Dp PS I didnt mean to dis-respect any Guru. What I have learned from

both of my masters that if there is a debate there is no one younger

and no one is older. Its just a debate and you can always put your

point, off course with respect... :)

>

> Har Har Mahadev.

>

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest guest

Namaste,

 

You could be right. Anyways today the usual Friday meet with him is

scheduled in the evening. Will definitely post what he has to say on

all this that happened tommorow. Am now taking print outs :-).

 

Thanks you

 

 

 

 

, "NMadasamy" <nmadasamy

wrote:

>

> Now lets go back to Jayanth original statement :

>

> Jeyanth wrote : 2ndly I was sitting with my Guru the day before

> yesterday and mentioned that I was a member in this wonderful group

> where so many devotees of the Goddess come together and share

> knowledge. He asked me, "so you will you get the answers to any

sort

> of queries on the Goddess?" I said, "yes, there are people who are

> highly knowledgable here". He then asked me to post a question -

> "Does the Goddess have menstrual cycles? if yes or no, then what

> are the sources that have mentioned the same"

> I asked- " ok I will, but please tell me the answer yourself

first".

> He said with that typical 'Guru smile' which many of you would have

> exprience with your Gurus- " bring a printout of all the postings

> and then I will share my answer with all and also give them my

> appreciation for the forum"

>

>

> I see something when I first read this statement. And I personally

> belief this all is meant for Jeyanth and not for us. We never admit

> being "highly knowledeable" and we never admit being able to give

> all the answers to any sort of queries on the Goddess. Its Jeyanth

> own interpretation or I would say assumption. His Guru is trying to

> tell him something through us. His Guru knows who we are, and he

> wants Jeyanth to learn from experience. He could have easily give

> Jeyath the answers, why didnt he?

>

> My question for Jeyanth is : so what have you learn from this

> experience?

>

>

>

> , "Dhirendra Pal Singh"

> <dpal.singh@> wrote:

> >

> > Dear jayant,I have a big short comming :) and that is I cant make

> politically correct statement but then I can't take them either.

>

> You have very nicely skipped my question and brought me back to

> your ground.Let me put it this way...Let me try to summarise what I

> had said in my previous email

>

> A) I said I can probalby get you the answer, that doesnt mean I

> know it right now. I have no hesitation in accepting what I dont

> know. Heck no one knows everything in this world (off course there

> are some exceptions :) )

> B) But then if I have invest some time in it, I want to know why I

> want to do that. I am short on time. It has never been on my

side...

> Hence if you started this question and cant prove why it is imp for

> me it wouldnt go anywhere.

> C) Please dont take everything to the one question question? Who

> am i? At least as of now I cant see it related to your quesiton.

> Feel free toenlightment me and be a little detailed.

>

> Now I was trying to analyse why you took the liberty to start this

> thread.If I type all the things it would be a very long email, I

> will try to summarise

> A) if you know the answer and wnated to just share you email would

> have "I know this and wanted to share with every one"

> B) Now I know sometimes guru's do special things which are beyond

> my comprehension but still its kind of interesting that your guru

is

> kind of wanting to challange us, or trying to find out knowledge

> level of people on this list. Again my old question, what would be

> he get out of it. Why would he want to do that.? Posslily to

> establish his and/or yours supremacy. Again if that thats the case

I

> will drop out of discussion.

> C) Well I can go on and on .. :) but then again time is short.

>

> But I do appreciate that you took the time to answeres all the

> people question.. interesting. very interesting. This means

>

> A) either the answer to this question is not know to a lot of time

> and hence you are enjoying the confustion

> B) or the answere will help us all evolve us all..

>

> Hence I will be waiting for a detailed explanation from you as to

> why at least myself needs to know the answere to this quesiton.

What

> will it get me.?

>

> Thanks and Regards

> Dp PS I didnt mean to dis-respect any Guru. What I have learned

from

> both of my masters that if there is a debate there is no one

younger

> and no one is older. Its just a debate and you can always put your

> point, off course with respect... :)

> >

> > Har Har Mahadev.

> >

>

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest guest

The beauty of the rose is only known.....felt.....drunk in draughts.

 

Tarini

 

Llundrub <llundrub wrote:

Much of the beauty of the rose is not what's seen ;)

 

 

-

charu jagat

Thursday, March 23, 2006 2:03 AM

Re: Re: Does Goddess have menstrual cycles?

 

 

The beauty of the rose is the rose itself.

 

Tarini

 

 

 

 

 

Traditions Divine

 

 

 

 

Visit your group "" on the web.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Jiyo cricket on India cricket

Messenger Mobile Stay in touch with your buddies all the time.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...