Guest guest Posted June 6, 2006 Report Posted June 6, 2006 Dear Ash, I need some clarification about SD's. Kindly help. Consider the following scenarios: 1) X is in 4th position from Y. Y has 3 points and X has 6 points. Here X becomes a strong samadharmi to Y. 2) Say X and Y are natural SD to each other. Now if X is conjunct with Y in Navamsa they also become functional SD to each other. If both 1) and 2) scenarios occur in the same chart, should we consider Y as SD to X or not (because Y is controlling X)? Thanks Gita Quote
Guest guest Posted June 6, 2006 Report Posted June 6, 2006 Dear Gita, Based on current understanding, both will be SD to each other. According to me, X will be a stronger SD to Y than Y being SD to X. Thanks & Regards, Manu , " kaslearner " <kaslearner wrote: > > Dear Ash, > > I need some clarification about SD's. Kindly help. > > Consider the following scenarios: > > 1) X is in 4th position from Y. Y has 3 points and X has 6 points. > Here X becomes a strong samadharmi to Y. > > 2) Say X and Y are natural SD to each other. Now if X is conjunct with > Y in Navamsa they also become functional SD to each other. > > If both 1) and 2) scenarios occur in the same chart, should we consider > Y as SD to X or not (because Y is controlling X)? > > Thanks > Gita > Quote
Guest guest Posted June 6, 2006 Report Posted June 6, 2006 Dear Manu, Thanks for the response. I thought too. Just wanted to confirm!! Regards Gita , " Manu Batura " <manubatura wrote: > > Dear Gita, > > Based on current understanding, both will be SD to each other. > According to me, X will be a stronger SD to Y than Y being SD to X. > > Thanks & Regards, > Manu > > > , " kaslearner " > <kaslearner@> wrote: > > > > Dear Ash, > > > > I need some clarification about SD's. Kindly help. > > > > Consider the following scenarios: > > > > 1) X is in 4th position from Y. Y has 3 points and X has 6 points. > > Here X becomes a strong samadharmi to Y. > > > > 2) Say X and Y are natural SD to each other. Now if X is conjunct with > > Y in Navamsa they also become functional SD to each other. > > > > If both 1) and 2) scenarios occur in the same chart, should we consider > > Y as SD to X or not (because Y is controlling X)? > > > > Thanks > > Gita > > > Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.