Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org

Indian Obsession With Milk Causes Hideous Suffering

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

August 10, 2005

Indian Obsession With Milk Causes Hideous Suffering

 

The picture at the top of this blog is of cows in an Indian

dairy-those allowed into a small corral, which most do not experience

because they are usually chained into stalls for life. Many Indians

are addicted to dairy products, and many believe that they must eat

dairy products for health or religious reasons. Here is an eyewitness

account from a welfare worker surveying the damage after last week's

floods in Mumbai that might make soy milk seem the drink of choice

from here on out.

 

" The most affected area was Goregaon, where more than 2,000 buffaloes

have died. Now most of the dairies lie empty with no movement inside,

as the animals have died. A few dairies remained unaffected as [they

were] located in higher areas, and a few dairies had some surviving

buffaloes. [O]ne of the dairy owners ... had eight surviving buffaloes

from a total of 200, as they could release these animals, which swam

to another area and could survive. The other owner informed that ...

all his buffaloes survived the floods because the water level could

not reach beyond the neck region and the buffaloes stood with their

head up for breathing and hence could survive.

 

Source:

http://www.ingridnewkirk.com

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is true. I looove indian food.

I 've just bought an Indian vegetarian cookbook. ( I couldn't find a vegan one)

and there is a lot of milk and butter (gee)

So I find myself substituting often.

that being said,,,, Mango Lassi, tastes real good with soy yoghourt.

 

 

 

 

-

rvijay

 

8/12/2005 7:02:25 PM

Indian Obsession With Milk Causes Hideous Suffering

August 10, 2005Indian Obsession With Milk Causes Hideous SufferingThe picture at the top of this blog is of cows in an Indiandairy-those allowed into a small corral, which most do not experiencebecause they are usually chained into stalls for life. Many Indiansare addicted to dairy products, and many believe that they must eatdairy products for health or religious reasons. Here is an eyewitnessaccount from a welfare worker surveying the damage after last week'sfloods in Mumbai that might make soy milk seem the drink of choicefrom here on out."The most affected area was Goregaon, where more than 2,000 buffaloeshave died. Now most of the dairies lie empty with no movement inside,as the animals have died. A few dairies remained unaffected as [theywere] located in higher areas, and a few dairies had some survivingbuffaloes. [O]ne of the dairy owners ... had eight surviving buffaloesfrom a total of 200, as they could release these animals, which swamto another area and could survive. The other owner informed that ...all his buffaloes survived the floods because the water level couldnot reach beyond the neck region and the buffaloes stood with theirhead up for breathing and hence could survive.Source:http://www.ingridnewkirk.com

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is unbelievable. You are almost like an Indian.

 

Vijay :)

 

, " zurumato@e... " <zurumato@e...> wrote:

> This is true. I looove indian food.

> I 've just bought an Indian vegetarian cookbook. ( I couldn't find a

vegan one)

> and there is a lot of milk and butter (gee)

> So I find myself substituting often.

> that being said,,,, Mango Lassi, tastes real good with soy yoghourt.

>

>

> -

> rvijay

>

> 8/12/2005 7:02:25 PM

> Indian Obsession With Milk Causes Hideous

Suffering

>

>

> August 10, 2005

> Indian Obsession With Milk Causes Hideous Suffering

>

> The picture at the top of this blog is of cows in an Indian

> dairy-those allowed into a small corral, which most do not experience

> because they are usually chained into stalls for life. Many Indians

> are addicted to dairy products, and many believe that they must eat

> dairy products for health or religious reasons. Here is an eyewitness

> account from a welfare worker surveying the damage after last week's

> floods in Mumbai that might make soy milk seem the drink of choice

> from here on out.

>

> " The most affected area was Goregaon, where more than 2,000 buffaloes

> have died. Now most of the dairies lie empty with no movement inside,

> as the animals have died. A few dairies remained unaffected as [they

> were] located in higher areas, and a few dairies had some surviving

> buffaloes. [O]ne of the dairy owners ... had eight surviving buffaloes

> from a total of 200, as they could release these animals, which swam

> to another area and could survive. The other owner informed that ...

> all his buffaloes survived the floods because the water level could

> not reach beyond the neck region and the buffaloes stood with their

> head up for breathing and hence could survive.

>

> Source:

> http://www.ingridnewkirk.com

>

>

>

>

> To send an email to -

>

>

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My Hare Krishna friend swears there is a small part of the brain than

needs cows milk to enable people to be spiritual !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

I thought in India the cow and bull were sacred animals and should be

left to live their own lives.

 

Jo

 

, " rvijay " <rvijay07@m...> wrote:

> August 10, 2005

> Indian Obsession With Milk Causes Hideous Suffering

>

> The picture at the top of this blog is of cows in an Indian

> dairy-those allowed into a small corral, which most do not experience

> because they are usually chained into stalls for life. Many Indians

> are addicted to dairy products, and many believe that they must eat

> dairy products for health or religious reasons. Here is an eyewitness

> account from a welfare worker surveying the damage after last week's

> floods in Mumbai that might make soy milk seem the drink of choice

> from here on out.

>

> " The most affected area was Goregaon, where more than 2,000 buffaloes

> have died. Now most of the dairies lie empty with no movement inside,

> as the animals have died. A few dairies remained unaffected as [they

> were] located in higher areas, and a few dairies had some surviving

> buffaloes. [O]ne of the dairy owners ... had eight surviving buffaloes

> from a total of 200, as they could release these animals, which swam

> to another area and could survive. The other owner informed that ...

> all his buffaloes survived the floods because the water level could

> not reach beyond the neck region and the buffaloes stood with their

> head up for breathing and hence could survive.

>

> Source:

> http://www.ingridnewkirk.com

Link to comment
Share on other sites

mmmmmmmmmmmmm Mango Lassi. I also like pistachio lassi.

 

Jo

 

, " zurumato@e... " <zurumato@e...> wrote:

> This is true. I looove indian food.

> I 've just bought an Indian vegetarian cookbook. ( I couldn't find a

vegan one)

> and there is a lot of milk and butter (gee)

> So I find myself substituting often.

> that being said,,,, Mango Lassi, tastes real good with soy yoghourt.

>

>

> -

> rvijay

>

> 8/12/2005 7:02:25 PM

> Indian Obsession With Milk Causes Hideous

Suffering

>

>

> August 10, 2005

> Indian Obsession With Milk Causes Hideous Suffering

>

> The picture at the top of this blog is of cows in an Indian

> dairy-those allowed into a small corral, which most do not experience

> because they are usually chained into stalls for life. Many Indians

> are addicted to dairy products, and many believe that they must eat

> dairy products for health or religious reasons. Here is an eyewitness

> account from a welfare worker surveying the damage after last week's

> floods in Mumbai that might make soy milk seem the drink of choice

> from here on out.

>

> " The most affected area was Goregaon, where more than 2,000 buffaloes

> have died. Now most of the dairies lie empty with no movement inside,

> as the animals have died. A few dairies remained unaffected as [they

> were] located in higher areas, and a few dairies had some surviving

> buffaloes. [O]ne of the dairy owners ... had eight surviving buffaloes

> from a total of 200, as they could release these animals, which swam

> to another area and could survive. The other owner informed that ...

> all his buffaloes survived the floods because the water level could

> not reach beyond the neck region and the buffaloes stood with their

> head up for breathing and hence could survive.

>

> Source:

> http://www.ingridnewkirk.com

>

>

>

>

> To send an email to -

>

>

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sure shocked me. I thought the same thing. So, anyone know when that

changed?

 

Lynda

-

" heartwerk " <heartwork

 

> My Hare Krishna friend swears there is a small part of the brain than

> needs cows milk to enable people to be spiritual !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

>

> I thought in India the cow and bull were sacred animals and should be

> left to live their own lives.

>

> Jo

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

, " Lynda " <lurine@s...> wrote:

> Sure shocked me. I thought the same thing. So, anyone know when that

> changed?

>

> Lynda

 

They are spiritual and are treated with great respect and very nicely.

However, nothing wrong against using them in agriculture and for dairy

products. (They seem to truly enjoy this interaction with nature and

humans.) This is sort of like considered like the sacred duty of cows.

Lord Krishna is also portrayed as liking milk and butter in all the

legends. Hence, India likes milk. It was always like that.

 

Vijay

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I thought though that you could take a little milk from a wild cow, as long

as you left enough for the calf. Surely if they are kept in farms the

calves have to be killed off or removed so the milk can be sold. I don't

see how this fits into anything spiritual!

 

Jo

 

-

" rvijay " <rvijay07

 

Saturday, August 13, 2005 5:05 PM

Re: Indian Obsession With Milk Causes Hideous

Suffering

 

 

> , " Lynda " <lurine@s...> wrote:

> > Sure shocked me. I thought the same thing. So, anyone know when that

> > changed?

> >

> > Lynda

>

> They are spiritual and are treated with great respect and very nicely.

> However, nothing wrong against using them in agriculture and for dairy

> products. (They seem to truly enjoy this interaction with nature and

> humans.) This is sort of like considered like the sacred duty of cows.

> Lord Krishna is also portrayed as liking milk and butter in all the

> legends. Hence, India likes milk. It was always like that.

>

> Vijay

>

>

>

>

>

> To send an email to -

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Who enjoys the interaction? The cows? The people?

 

I just keep picturing a whole slew of cows chained into a space and

drowning. Even the worst of the corporate farms here they would have had a

chance to break down a fence or two and get away from the rising waters.

 

Lynda

-

" rvijay " <rvijay07

 

Saturday, August 13, 2005 9:05 AM

Re: Indian Obsession With Milk Causes Hideous

Suffering

 

 

> , " Lynda " <lurine@s...> wrote:

> > Sure shocked me. I thought the same thing. So, anyone know when that

> > changed?

> >

> > Lynda

>

> They are spiritual and are treated with great respect and very nicely.

> However, nothing wrong against using them in agriculture and for dairy

> products. (They seem to truly enjoy this interaction with nature and

> humans.) This is sort of like considered like the sacred duty of cows.

> Lord Krishna is also portrayed as liking milk and butter in all the

> legends. Hence, India likes milk. It was always like that.

>

> Vijay

>

>

>

>

>

> To send an email to -

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

well..except fer the thousands being rounded up as we speak in New Dehli by

stick weilding *cowboys* on motorbikes

 

on the flip side...i've heard of absolute riots breaking out after said

" cowboys " mishandled a cow

 

tho...dunno how sacred i would feel if someone chased me around with a stick

well..guess depends on who is weilding the stick....

ahem...

fraggle

 

 

rvijay <rvijay07

Aug 13, 2005 9:05 AM

 

Re: Indian Obsession With Milk Causes Hideous Suffering

 

, " Lynda " <lurine@s...> wrote:

> Sure shocked me. I thought the same thing. So, anyone know when that

> changed?

>

> Lynda

 

They are spiritual and are treated with great respect and very nicely.

However, nothing wrong against using them in agriculture and for dairy

products. (They seem to truly enjoy this interaction with nature and

humans.) This is sort of like considered like the sacred duty of cows.

Lord Krishna is also portrayed as liking milk and butter in all the

legends. Hence, India likes milk. It was always like that.

 

Vijay

 

 

 

 

 

To send an email to -

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

, " Jo Cwazy " <heartwork@c...> wrote:

> I thought though that you could take a little milk from a wild cow,

as long

> as you left enough for the calf. Surely if they are kept in farms the

> calves have to be killed off or removed so the milk can be sold. I

don't

> see how this fits into anything spiritual!

>

> Jo

>

 

Yes, enough was left for the Calf. Unlike in factory farms, the Cows

got a lot of Fresh air, time out with their family and friends, graze

etc., etc., Also they were not killed.

 

My late Grandfather had cows on his farm and all were very well taken

care off. Several, even appreciated human company.

 

As the cow ploughs the soil which provides the food, it is very spiritual.

 

Vijay :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

, fraggle <EBbrewpunx@e...> wrote:

> well..except fer the thousands being rounded up as we speak in New

Dehli by stick weilding *cowboys* on motorbikes

>

> on the flip side...i've heard of absolute riots breaking out after

said " cowboys " mishandled a cow

>

> tho...dunno how sacred i would feel if someone chased me around with

a stick

> well..guess depends on who is weilding the stick....

> ahem...

> fraggle

>

 

 

The stick was meant to guide in olden days. Men hardly hit the cows.

They obeyed commands with the stick, so it was a very positive and

interactive experience.

 

Vijay

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Vijay! Do you know how confused this sounds?

 

Jo

 

>

> The stick was meant to guide in olden days. Men hardly hit the cows.

> They obeyed commands with the stick, so it was a very positive and

> interactive experience.

>

> Vijay

Link to comment
Share on other sites

, " Jo Cwazy " <heartwork@c...> wrote:

> Vijay! Do you know how confused this sounds?

>

> Jo

>

> >

> > The stick was meant to guide in olden days. Men hardly hit the cows.

> > They obeyed commands with the stick, so it was a very positive and

> > interactive experience.

> >

> > Vijay

 

 

They gently touch the cow with the stick on the right side so that it

turns in the desired direction. That is all.

 

Vijay

Link to comment
Share on other sites

, " Lynda " <lurine@s...> wrote:

> Who enjoys the interaction? The cows? The people?

>

> I just keep picturing a whole slew of cows chained into a space and

> drowning. Even the worst of the corporate farms here they would

have had a

> chance to break down a fence or two and get away from the rising waters.

>

> Lynda

 

 

Factory farming and chaining cows is different. In rural India,

specially in those days, tehre was a lot of greenery around, people

took their cows/goats out and allowed them to graze in the open.

 

Vijay

Link to comment
Share on other sites

, " Jo Cwazy " <heartwork@c...> wrote:

> How is this spiritual - for either humans or cows?

>

> Jo

 

 

Very spiritual. Food is holy and the cow helps in the vital process of

getting this food. Since, Cow does a very important job life

sustaining, it is also Holy.

 

Vijay

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I meant the comment on positive and interactive experience.

 

Jo

 

-

" rvijay " <rvijay07

 

Saturday, August 13, 2005 10:40 PM

Re: Indian Obsession With Milk Causes Hideous

Suffering

 

 

> , " Jo Cwazy " <heartwork@c...> wrote:

> > Vijay! Do you know how confused this sounds?

> >

> > Jo

> >

> > >

> > > The stick was meant to guide in olden days. Men hardly hit the cows.

> > > They obeyed commands with the stick, so it was a very positive and

> > > interactive experience.

> > >

> > > Vijay

>

>

> They gently touch the cow with the stick on the right side so that it

> turns in the desired direction. That is all.

>

> Vijay

>

>

>

>

>

> To send an email to -

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think people are assuming a lot on behalf of the cow here.

 

I presume there is something in the Baghavad-Gita saying that cows are

willing participants as my Hare Krishna friend seems to think the same as

this. He reckons milk from the Krishna herds here is not cruel because the

cows are treated well. He hadn't thought about what happened to the baby

males.

 

Jo

 

-

" rvijay " <rvijay07

 

Saturday, August 13, 2005 10:44 PM

Re: Indian Obsession With Milk Causes Hideous

Suffering

 

 

, " Jo Cwazy " <heartwork@c...> wrote:

> How is this spiritual - for either humans or cows?

>

> Jo

 

 

Very spiritual. Food is holy and the cow helps in the vital process of

getting this food. Since, Cow does a very important job life

sustaining, it is also Holy.

 

Vijay

 

 

 

 

 

To send an email to -

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm sorry but cattle aren't that obliging. I've seen them herded here and

there and they give em a good sound whack! And being the stubborn beasts

that they are, it frequently takes more than one whack.

 

Lynda

-

rvijay <rvijay07

 

Saturday, August 13, 2005 2:40 PM

Re: Indian Obsession With Milk Causes Hideous

Suffering

 

 

> , " Jo Cwazy " <heartwork@c...> wrote:

> > Vijay! Do you know how confused this sounds?

> >

> > Jo

> >

> > >

> > > The stick was meant to guide in olden days. Men hardly hit the cows.

> > > They obeyed commands with the stick, so it was a very positive and

> > > interactive experience.

> > >

> > > Vijay

>

>

> They gently touch the cow with the stick on the right side so that it

> turns in the desired direction. That is all.

>

> Vijay

>

>

>

>

>

> To send an email to -

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

, fraggle <EBbrewpunx@e...> wrote:

> i doubt they can do that nowadays when they are chasin them around

on motorcycles....

>

 

 

Stray cows and factory problem are a true issue these days.

 

Vijay

Link to comment
Share on other sites

, " Jo Cwazy " <heartwork@c...> wrote:

> I meant the comment on positive and interactive experience.

>

> Jo

>

 

 

The positive/interactive experience is for both the cow as well as the

human.

 

Vijay

Link to comment
Share on other sites

, " Jo Cwazy " <heartwork@c...> wrote:

> I think people are assuming a lot on behalf of the cow here.

>

> I presume there is something in the Baghavad-Gita saying that cows are

> willing participants as my Hare Krishna friend seems to think the

same as

> this. He reckons milk from the Krishna herds here is not cruel

because the

> cows are treated well. He hadn't thought about what happened to the

baby

> males.

>

> Jo

 

 

The baby cows (calf) also get enough milk. The mother produces a lot

in excess.

 

Vijay :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

, " Lynda " <lurine@s...> wrote:

> So what do they do with the bull calves? To get milk you have to

breed the

> beasties and you only have a finite amount of space. You can't just

keep

> doubling the population of cattle every year.

>

> Lynda

 

 

They were used for ploughing the soil.

 

Vijay

Link to comment
Share on other sites

, " Lynda " <lurine@s...> wrote:

> I'm sorry but cattle aren't that obliging. I've seen them herded

here and

> there and they give em a good sound whack! And being the stubborn

beasts

> that they are, it frequently takes more than one whack.

>

> Lynda

 

 

Horses are trained in a very friendly manner in several places. With

cows it was similar. Besides religion was also a motivation for

treating them very well.

 

A picture is worth a thousand words. If you could see things for

yourself you will understand, otherwise it will be hard to

believe/understand. This is natural.

 

Vijay

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...