Guest guest Posted November 4, 2003 Report Posted November 4, 2003 Has anyone had the clinical experience of treating a wei-qi deficient patient who gets frequent colds only to find that the moment you start to tonify (even with yu ping feng san), they get sick again. I have had two patients like this. Both female, both with some spleen qi deficiency with damp, and a tendency towards cold (either/both SP / KD Yang deficiency). Any thoughts? I wonder if the system is so deficient that there is a persistent pathological agent that does not get opposed by the righteous qi until the qi gets tonified, at which point the anti-pathogenic reaction becomes strong enough to manifest as a " cold " , but is a sign of, actually, a strengthened immune system. If this is correct, then tonification is actually appropriate, and is not " causing " a cold. The other possibility is that the SP is so weak that the tonifying agents are exacerbating a damp spleen condition, thus further weakening the wei qi and allowing a pathogen to enter. In this case, drying damp and secondarily tonifying the SP would be necessary before tonifying the wei qi or organs. I am curious to hear any other theories. Benjamin Hawes, MAOM, Lic. Ac., CORTEZ FAMILY ACUPUNCTURE 1430 E. Main Street, Suite #4 Cortez, CO 81321 (970) 565-0230 Quote
Guest guest Posted November 4, 2003 Report Posted November 4, 2003 this person is lekely to be both Blood and Chi deficient; I would try moxibustion on the obvious points (St36, Sp3, Ren 12, Bl20, Bl23) and back it up with a formula such as Si Wu Tang with Huang Chi added. It is also good to see the western point of view, that this person re-infected herself and that you have to keep strenghening her health until she is ok Regards, PJ On Tuesday, November 4, 2003, at 06:46 pm, Benjamin Hawes wrote: > Has anyone had the clinical experience of treating a wei-qi deficient > patient who gets frequent colds only to find that the moment you start > to > tonify (even with yu ping feng san), they get sick again. I have had > two > patients like this. Both female, both with some spleen qi deficiency > with > damp, and a tendency towards cold (either/both SP / KD Yang > deficiency). Any > thoughts? I wonder if the system is so deficient that there is a > persistent > pathological agent that does not get opposed by the righteous qi until > the > qi gets tonified, at which point the anti-pathogenic reaction becomes > strong > enough to manifest as a " cold " , but is a sign of, actually, a > strengthened > immune system. If this is correct, then tonification is actually > appropriate, and is not " causing " a cold. The other possibility is > that the > SP is so weak that the tonifying agents are exacerbating a damp spleen > condition, thus further weakening the wei qi and allowing a pathogen to > enter. In this case, drying damp and secondarily tonifying the SP > would be > necessary before tonifying the wei qi or organs. > > I am curious to hear any other theories. > > Benjamin Hawes, MAOM, Lic. Ac., > Director > > CORTEZ FAMILY ACUPUNCTURE > 1430 E. Main Street, Suite #4 > Cortez, CO 81321 > (970) 565-0230 > > > > > <image.tiff> > > > Membership requires that you do not post any commerical, swear, > religious, spam messages,flame another member or swear. > > To change your email settings, i.e. individually, daily digest or > none, visit the groups’ homepage: > Chinese Medicine/ click > ‘edit my membership' on the right hand side and adjust accordingly. > > To send an email to > <Chinese Medicine- > from the > email account you joined with. You will be removed automatically but > will still recieve messages for a few days. > > > Quote
Guest guest Posted November 5, 2003 Report Posted November 5, 2003 Sounds like a case of tonifying the pathogen. What are these 'colds' like? You don't mention Wind, and expelling Wind (eg cupping Bl-11/12). Is there also the possibility of the colds being more like allergic rhinitis or asthma rather than full-blown viral infections? If so, I'm reminded of the Giovanni theory of the Lu-Kid relationship where a constitutional weakness of the Kidney is responsible. (summarised in this MSC abstract: http://www.chinese-medicine.co.uk/msc/msc8.htm ) Godfrey Bartlett In Chinese Medicine , " Benjamin Hawes " <ben_laura@n...> wrote: > Has anyone had the clinical experience of treating a wei-qi deficient > patient who gets frequent colds only to find that the moment you start to > tonify (even with yu ping feng san), they get sick again. I have had two > patients like this. Both female, both with some spleen qi deficiency with > damp, and a tendency towards cold (either/both SP / KD Yang deficiency). Any > thoughts? I wonder if the system is so deficient that there is a persistent > pathological agent that does not get opposed by the righteous qi until the > qi gets tonified, at which point the anti-pathogenic reaction becomes strong > enough to manifest as a " cold " , but is a sign of, actually, a strengthened > immune system. If this is correct, then tonification is actually > appropriate, and is not " causing " a cold. The other possibility is that the > SP is so weak that the tonifying agents are exacerbating a damp spleen > condition, thus further weakening the wei qi and allowing a pathogen to > enter. In this case, drying damp and secondarily tonifying the SP would be > necessary before tonifying the wei qi or organs. > > I am curious to hear any other theories. > > Benjamin Hawes, MAOM, Lic. Ac., > Director > > CORTEZ FAMILY ACUPUNCTURE > 1430 E. Main Street, Suite #4 > Cortez, CO 81321 > (970) 565-0230 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.