Guest guest Posted April 12, 2004 Report Posted April 12, 2004 JustSayNo Mon, 12 Apr 2004 15:16:47 -0000 [sSRI-Research] Du Pont Cardiologists implanted experimental stent - 14 Babies without Informed ALLIANCE FOR HUMAN RESEARCH PROTECTION (AHRP) Du Pont Cardiologists implanted experimental stent in 14 Babies without Informed Consent-Phila Inquirer Promoting openness and full disclosure http://www.ahrp.org FYI The Philadelphia Inquirer reports that cardiologists at Du Pont Hospital for Children in Delaware, implanted an experimental device in 14 babies without approval of the FDA, without approval of the hospital's ethics review board, and without the permission of parents. " For the first time, the hospital placed clear blame on its cardiac center's director, surgeon William I. Norwood, and chief cardiologist, John D. Murphy. The doctors " were involved in the decisions to place unapproved medical devices in patients without prior notification to, and approved by our " Institutional Review Board, the hospital said in a response included in the report. " There is no law to protect babies / children that is comparable to the Animal Welfare Act of 1966 which sets forth specific protections such as: minimizing pain and forbidding unnecessary duplication of an experiment involving warm-blooded animals and maintaining accurate records of the acquisition and disposal of animal subjects. Under the Animal Welfare Act penalties are imposed on violators. No such protections exist in human research. The absence of a law--as opposed to administrative regulations--encourages adventurous medical cowboys to test experimental medicines and devices on vulnerable patients, including babies. As has recently been demonstrated--in the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Center trial and the investigation of the multi-site government funded experiment conducted on critically ill patients with lung injury (ARDS)--vulnerable patients are at risk of being subjected, without their informed consent, to medical experiments that increase the risk of death. See: http://www.ahrp.org/ARDSpages/ARDSindex.html Negligence is well defined in tort law and the Seattle jury had no difficulty finding The Hutch negligent in the death of one patient- subject due to a mix up in the hospital's laboratory. But in the absence of a law clarifying what constitutes informed consent, the jury did not rule in favor of 4 family plaintiffs who sued the Hutch on the grounds that their relatives' right to informed consent had been violated--even though jury members acknowledged that informed consent at the Hutch had been " really shoddy. " The absence of a law to specifically address informed consent to medical research encourages some physician-researchers who seek subjects for their experimental treatments, not to disclose fully the risks or the alternatives to patients. The absence of a law puts vulnerable patients at increased risk of harm with few legal remedies to compensate them (or their surviving families) when harm has been done. See: Seattle Times Friday, April 09, 2004 http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/localnews/2001899403_hutchverdic t09m.h tml The Delaware case is most unusual because Du Pont Hospital has acknowledged the culpability of the doctors on their staff. Contact: Vera Hassner Sharav Tel: 212-595-8974 e-mail: veracare ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ http://www.philly.com/mld/inquirer/news/front/8371296.htm?1c Philadelphia Inquirer Babies' doctors broke rules in use of stent, Del. says By Karl Stark and Susan FitzGerald Wed, Apr. 07, 2004 Heart doctors at Alfred I. du Pont Hospital for Children implanted an experimental device in 14 babies without obtaining full consent from their parents, a report by Delaware health officials said yesterday. Doctors also did not get the necessary approval from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration and from a hospital committee charged with protecting patients from unproven treatments, investigators said. The report, which the Wilmington hospital acknowledged yesterday as accurate, said 14 babies with a congenital heart defect had received an experimental stent at du Pont. State investigators initially were unable to find four signed parental consent forms, the state report said, and no parents knew that the doctors were performing procedures without hospital approval. The device has not yet received FDA approval. " It's an obvious violation of the regulations, " said Mary Peterson, director of the state Office of Health Facilities, Licensing and Certification. " Unfortunately, you can't have full, informed consent if the parents were not aware that the hospital had not approved this study. " For the first time, the hospital placed clear blame on its cardiac center's director, surgeon William I. Norwood, and chief cardiologist, John D. Murphy. The doctors " were involved in the decisions to place unapproved medical devices in patients without prior notification to, and approved by our " Institutional Review Board, the hospital said in a response included in the report. Kevin E. Charles, chief of Health Systems Protection in Delaware, said the venerable hospital could lose its license. But he acknowledged that was unlikely because du Pont was cooperating and making changes. Norwood and Murphy left Feb. 19 as part of an " administrative overhaul, " the hospital said yesterday. And the hospital said it would form a new department for Human Subject Protection to help its staff adhere to research regulations. The doctors' lawyer did not return phone calls yesterday. Misfiled consent forms Neither the state nor the hospital would say whether any babies had been injured because of the experimental care. One couple have said their son suffered complications after getting the stent, which had to be surgically removed at another hospital. The state's report also noted that the Institutional Review Board's leader said he did not learn of the experimental procedure until early December when FDA inspectors showed up unannounced at du Pont in response to a family's complaint. The FDA declined yesterday to comment on its probe. In addition, the report said four parental consent forms were not found during the inspection. Then, state inspectors said, they received a call Feb. 26 from a hospital attorney, saying three of the documents had been found in a drawer in the cardiac catheterization lab. Two were not properly executed, Peterson said. The fourth has not been found. The state cited du Pont for failing to properly file those records. The experimental care at du Pont became public in February when hospital officials said they had halted a cardiac procedure involving the use of a covered stent amid an investigation by the FDA and Delaware regulators. Treating heart defects Covered stents, tubes designed to redirect blood flow, are being tried to treat congenital heart defects, particularly one called hypoplastic left heart syndrome, in which the heart's main pumping chamber is underdeveloped. The condition was always fatal until the early 1980s when Norwood developed a treatment that requires three surgeries to reroute blood flow. The procedure is now standard. Murphy was among a small group of doctors that had recently been testing whether the final surgery could be replaced by opening a blood vessel and using a thin catheter to maneuver a stent into place. Some families at du Pont were offered this less-invasive procedure - but without a full explanation, Delaware officials said. Last month, The Inquirer reported on a sworn statement that Judith Guinan of Vineland, N.J., gave to the FDA. Guinan said she and her husband, Kevin, did not know beforehand that the covered stent used on their daughter Molly's heart defect was experimental. They said they learned that when a hospital doctor called a year later in late 2003, asking them to sign and backdate a consent form. Judith Guinan said she could not recall seeing the consent form. The state report indicated that the Guinans' consent form, one of those found in the drawer, was signed by a parent. Lawyers for the Guinans have disputed that. Philadelphia lawyer Andrew J. Stern, whose firm represents the Guinans, would not comment again yesterday on the forms. " At least A.I. du Pont has admitted that its doctors were involved in inexcusable behavior, " Stern said. The state said yesterday that the unapproved stent was used for 11 months, from June 20, 2002, to May 5, 2003, without the hospital's permission. Peterson said her state agency did not learn of the situation until Jan. 20 when a parent alerted her. State investigators went to du Pont on Jan. 22 and investigated there until Feb. 11. In the next 60 days, state inspectors will visit du Pont unannounced and conduct a full survey. If it is in compliance, the hospital will be monitored for at least three months, Peterson said. The hospital said yesterday that it had already begun making changes. Du Pont cardiologists have personally notified the parents of children who got the covered stents. Doctors will create a registry for the babies to monitor their health. Contact staff writer Karl Stark at 215-854-5363 or kstark. FAIR USE NOTICE: This may contain copyrighted (C ) material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Such material is made available for educational purposes, to advance understanding of human rights, democracy, scientific, moral, ethical, and social justice issues, etc. It is believed that this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in Title 17 U.S.C. section 107 of the US Copyright Law. This material is distributed without profit. Small Business $15K Web Design Giveaway - Enter today Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.