Comparision of Astrodienst, KPAstro 3.1, JHora 7.02, JHora 7.03 & JHora 7.32

[Guest guest]

Dear TinWin

In KP ASTRO 3.1, for planetary positions, you have chosen the 'Apparent position'. I am also using the apparent planetary position, though I have the True position option also.

While comparing the planetary position, you have chosen 'True position' in Jagannatha Hora. Planetary position in Jagannatha Hora 7.02 at 'Apparaent position' is almost same with KPASTRO 3.1.

It is recommended to use 'Apparent position' in Jagannatha Hora by the users.

Dhanabalan --- On Wed, 2/4/09, tw853 <tw853 wrote:

tw853 <tw853 Comparision of Astrodienst, KPAstro 3.1, JHora 7.02, JHora 7.03 & JHora 7.32 Date: Wednesday, February 4, 2009, 4:31 AM

 

 

Dear Friends,1. Having JHora 7.02 & JHora 7.03 installed in 2 computers, for curiosity JHora 7.32 is just downloaded in the 3rd computer and comparison is made as under.

G. Singh, 03-02-1962, 10:13:35 am (GMT+5:30), Ludhiana , 30N54, 75E51, Sid. Time 18:38:32, KPNA 23:14:15

 

Cuspal and Planetary Positions

 

 

 

 

Cp

Pl

 

Astrodienst

Nirayana

 

KPAstro

3.1

 

JHora

7.02

 

JHora

7.03

 

JHora

7.32

 

 

1

 

350-51-21

 

350-51-21

 

350-51-21

 

350-51-21

 

350-51-21

 

 

2

 

026-07-49

 

026-07-49

 

026-07-49

 

026-07-49

 

026-07-49

 

 

3

 

052-26-55

 

052-26-54

 

052-26-54

 

052-26-54

 

052-26-54

 

 

4

 

075-36-45

 

075-36-44

 

075-36-45

 

075-36-45

 

075-36-45

 

 

5

 

100-01-54

 

100-01-53

 

100-01-54

 

100-01-54

 

100-01-54

 

 

6

 

130-21-51

 

130-21-50

 

130-21-51

 

130-21-51

 

130-21-51

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Su

 

290-38-22

 

290-38-22

 

290-38-43

 

290-38-43

 

290-38-53

 

 

Mo

 

265-35-47

 

265-35-47

 

265-35-48

 

265-35-50

 

265-35-58

 

 

Ma

 

277-43-15

 

277-43-14

 

277-43-53

 

277-43-53

 

277-43-53

 

 

Me

 

295-45-10

 

295-45-09

 

295-44-55

 

295-44-55

 

295-45-05

 

 

Ju

 

294-56-40

 

294-56-40

 

294-57-10

 

294-57-10

 

294-57-20

 

 

Ve

 

292-15-57

 

292-15-56

 

292-16-41

 

292-16-41

 

292-16-51

 

 

Sa

 

280-21-19

 

280-21-19

 

280-21-46

 

280-21-46

 

280-21-56

 

 

Ra

 

115-01-06

 

115-01-06

 

115-01-06

 

115-01-06

 

115-01-16

 

Differerces (in sec) from Astrodienst

 

 

 

 

Cp

Pl

 

KP

Astro

 

JHora

7,02

 

JHora

7.03

 

JHora

7,32

 

 

1

 

0

 

0

 

0

 

0

 

 

2

 

0

 

0

 

0

 

0

 

 

3

 

-1

 

-1

 

-1

 

-1

 

 

4

 

-1

 

0

 

0

 

0

 

 

5

 

-1

 

0

 

0

 

0

 

 

6

 

-1

 

0

 

0

 

0

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Su

 

0

 

+23

 

+23

 

+33

 

 

Mo

 

0

 

+01

 

+03

 

+11

 

 

Ma

 

-1

 

+38

 

+38

 

+48

 

 

Me

 

-1

 

-15

 

-15

 

-5

 

 

Ju

 

0

 

+30

 

+30

 

+40

 

 

Ve

 

-1

 

+44

 

+44

 

+54

 

 

Sa

 

0

 

+27

 

+27

 

+37

 

 

Ra

 

0

 

0

 

0

 

+10

 

Dhanabalan is right that cuspal positions are the same by both JHora 7.02 & 7.32 but planetary positions are 10 seconds higher by JHora 7.32 (2009) than JHora 7.02.(2005).

 

JHora users may check and give practical comment.

 

Regards,

 

tw@gro ups.com, "tw853" <tw853 wrote:>> > Dear Dhanabalan,> > > > > It's interesting and pl see the comparison of SW results below and you> may check and add JHora 7.32 results.> > > > Regards,> > > > tw> > > > 1. To be comparable to the cuspal and planetary positions of Astrodienst> (www.astro.com <http://www.astro. com/> ), provider and user of Swiss> epemeris, the lat. & long. of Ludhiana is adjusted to the same position> used by Astrodienst and JHora and also shown by Google Earth, ie. 30N54,> 75E51.> > > > 2. For 03-02-1962, 10:13:35 am (GMT+5:30), 30N54, 75E51, the Sid. Time> 18:38:32 is the same by Astrodienst, KPAstro 3.1 and JHora 7.02 (2005> disk form the

provider).> > > > 3. In the table below, the Sayana positions of Astrodienst are converted> into Nirayana positions by abstracting the KPNA 23:14:15. By using the> same ayanamsa and birth details, the results of KPAstro 3.1 and JHora> 7.02 results are compared to the Astrodienst Nirayan results. The> differences (in seconds) are shown in RED color. [in JHora, by adjusting> Custom (user defined) ayanamsa to 5min:12.87sec less than Lahiri> ayanamsa, the KPNA 23:14:15 is got.]> > > > > > > Astrodienst> > Sayana> > Astrodienst> > Nirayana> > KPAstro> > 3.1> > JHora> > 7.02> > > > KP> > Astro> > > > JHora> > 1> > 014-05-36> >

350-51-21> > 350-51-21> > 350-51-21> > > > 0> > > > 0> > 2> > 049-22-04> > 026-07-49> > 026-07-49> > 026-07-49> > > > 0> > > > 0> > 3> > 075-41-10> > 052-26-55> > 052-26-54> > 052-26-54> > > > -1> > > > -1> > 4> > 098-51-00> > 075-36-45> > 075-36-44> > 075-36-45> > > > -1> > > > 0> > 5> > 123-16-09> > 100-01-54> > 100-01-53> > 100-01-54> > > > -1> > > > 0> >

6> > 153-36-06> > 130-21-51> > 130-21-50> > 130-21-51> > > > -1> > > > 0> > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Su> > 313-52-37> > 290-38-22> > 290-38-22> > 290-38-43> > > > 0> > > > +23> > Mo> > 288-50-02> > 265-35-47> > 265-35-47> > 265-35-48> > > > 0> > > > +01> > Ma> > 300-57-30> > 277-43-15> > 277-43-14> > 277-43-53> > > > -1> > > > +38>

> Me> > 318-59-25> > 295-45-10> > 295-45-09> > 295-44-55> > > > -1> > > > -15> > Ju> > 318-10-55> > 294-56-40> > 294-56-40> > 294-57-10> > > > 0> > > > +30> > Ve> > 315-30-12> > 292-15-57> > 292-15-56> > 292-16-41> > > > -1> > > > +44> > Sa> > 303-35-34> > 280-21-19> > 280-21-19> > 280-21-46> > > > 0> > > > +27> > Ra> > 138-15-21> > 115-01-06> > 115-01-06> > 115-01-06> > >

> 0> > > > 0> > > > 4. As usual, the results of Astrodient and KPAstro 3.1 are the same, > not more than 1 second difference in both cuspal and planetary> positions.> > > > > @gro ups.com, Dhanabalan R r.dhanabalan@> wrote:> >> > Dear TinWin> > It seems that the Jagannatha Hora 7.32 has some mistakes in handling> ayanamsa in planetary positions. For the same ayanamsa, the lagna> position for Jagannatha Hora 7.02 and 7.32 are same but there is 10> seconds difference in all planets position in 7.32. According to me,> Jagannatha Hora 7.02 is OK.> > Values in 7.02 agrees with KP ASTRO 3. Values in 7.32 is not agreeble> to KP ASTRO 3.> > Even Shadbala calculation also, there are differences. Shadbala values> in version 7.02 is

OK. Version 7.32 has to be checked further for its> reliability to use.> >> > Comparision of Mr.Singh chart uploaded in file.> > SINGH> > Jagannatha Hora 7.02> >> > Natal Chart> >> > February 3, 1962> > Time: 10:13:35> > Time Zone: 5:30:00 (East of GMT)> > Place: 75 E 53' 00", 30 N 54' 00"> > Sunrise: 7:18:56> > Ayanamsa: 23-14-14.87> > Sidereal Time: 18:38:40> >> > Body Longitude> >> > Sun - PK 20 Makar 38' 22.43"> > Moon - AmK 25 Dhanu 35' 47.49"> > Mars - DK 7 Makar 43' 15.09"> > Mercury ® - AK 25 Makar 45' 09.73"> > Jupiter - BK 24 Makar 56' 40.30"> > Venus - MK 22 Makar 15' 56.73"> > Saturn - GK 10 Makar 21' 19.43"> > Rahu 25 Kark 01' 06.39"> > Ketu 25 Makar 01' 06.39">

>> > House Cusp> >> > 1st 20 Meen 54' 14.92"> > 2nd 26 Mesh 10' 04.35"> > 3rd 22 Vrish 28' 48.71"> > 4th 15 Mith 38' 35.38"> > 5th 10 Kark 03' 56.28"> > 6th 10 Simh 24' 21.59"> >> >> > Jagannatha Hora 7.32> >> > Natal Chart> >> > February 3, 1962> > Time: 10:13:35> > Time Zone: 5:30:00 (East of GMT)> > Place: 75 E 53' 00", 30 N 54' 00"> > Sunrise: 7:17:36> > Ayanamsa: 23-14-15.35> > Sidereal Time: 18:38:40> >> > Body Longitude> >> > Sun - PiK 20 Cp 38' 32.11"> > Moon - AmK 25 Sg 35' 57.17"> > Mars - GK 7 Cp 43' 24.78"> > Mercury ® - AK 25 Cp 45' 19.41"> > Jupiter - BK 24 Cp 56' 49.98"> > Venus - MK 22 Cp 16' 06.42"> > Saturn - PK 10 Cp

21' 29.12"> > Rahu - DK 25 Cn 01' 16.07"> > Ketu 25 Cp 01' 16.07"> >> > House Cusp> >> > 1st 20 Pi 54' 14.44"> > 2nd 26 Ar 10' 03.86"> > 3rd 22 Ta 28' 48.23"> > 4th 15 Ge 38' 34.90"> > 5th 10 Cn 03' 55.80"> > 6th 10 Le 24' 21.11"> >> > Dhanabalan> >>