Guest guest Posted July 20, 2007 Report Share Posted July 20, 2007 Dear Suprakash ji, my reply in Bold****** regards Kanak Bosmia " S.Ghosh " <suprakash.ghosh wrote: Dear Kanakji I went through your article on Dr Kar's TSP Theory published in your magazine. Indeed it is an amazing finding if consistantly in gives true results.I'll also start using this theory and see the results. Your article is very lucid and well written.However I have some questions which need clarification: 1) Cases with Nodes :Example-1 :WI vs SA Test-1:Star lord of sub sub lord is Ketu.Ketu is star lord of venus.Venus is star lord lord of asc.Hence the answer should be Yes.But you have arrived at No based on Mars /Merc aspect only. Whereas in step-3 you have considered the venus as usual. In this case if venus is considered in step-1, the prediction goes wrong. Kanak: You are right, when i start pridict with TSP i use only thre main rules, when i found some pridction went wrong, then i again check with sub rules and during world cup i check all the rules.first i check for nade as per KP if any planet aspect on node or conj with node then node give first result of that planet. so in this cas when i found two planet aspect/conj with node i considet only that two, in 3rd rule deciding factore is Ven not node. so i do not follow that rules, after world cup complited i start checking again and found we have to check all node's conection, in this regard you are right if we follow all conection of node pridiction give defferant result. then why my pridiction come correct? if you notice RAH is in the star of SAT, and RAH is starlord of MOON, when SATY conection with moon result opposite, may be this iffect we found here, i am not sure abouit it, bcoze befor say anything we have to check more case. truble is Dr.Kar do not write clearly about TSP also he write nearly 25 Rules, if we follow all then we never get any result nagative. 2)What happens if moon is in sub or sub sub of Sat..is it denial or delay? Kanak: I do not check this, this point is in my considaration and i am try to look about it, i request you all to check all the peramiter in your mind with rules mention in my articles, and send me your finding. it will help me to rebilt improve more iffective rules. 3)What happens if rahu represents moon and rahu becomes sub sub of asc.Is it always positive? Kanak: relay very good question: On 18th my daughter ask me question: Will i win challange i commited with mom? Time used for analysis: 18-Jul-2007 [5:30:0]Horary no:2055/2193 ASC lords are Ju-Sa-Ke-Ra MOON lords are Su-Ve-Ve-Ve ASC SS lord is Ra. MOON is an agent of Ra. So, the expected outcome is YES. But SATURN is conjoined with MOON, negating the expected outcome. Hence according to TSP, the answer is NO. in this case three rules apply at once. you answer also in this. I am waiting for ouit come and we have to wait for some times, when result of this horary come i will inform you what happan, bocze this is first time i face this type of problem. 4)Similarly if Moon in star of Rahu/Ketu or aspected by Rahu/Ketu and Rahu/Ketu represents Saturn.Is it denial? Kanak: I think i reply in above, we have to check some exmple and i strongly request all memebrs to keep younrecord for ferther reseach on this. 5)You have given a raider point of the special rule No-2 : The relation of sun will delay only instead of negation .IS this true if rahu/ketu represents Sun and Rahu/Ketu is related like sun? Kanak: very true i never use this rule in precticly. i quated only what Dr.Kar mention. without checking this i found good result so i do not use this. one can check ifectiveness of this rules and inform group members. Regards Suprakash " A person should not be too honest. Straight trees are cut first And Honest people are screwed first. " Chanakya quotes (Indian politician, strategist and writer, 350 BC 75 BC) Get the free toolbar and rest assured with the added security of spyware protection. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 20, 2007 Report Share Posted July 20, 2007 Thanks Kanakji. I have another question.. can TSP be used along with Natal charts? I mean say some one asks me about the possibility of marriage..yes or no. If I take a number alongwith her birth data, will 7th cusp potentiality match with TSP result? What is your experience? Regards Suprakash. l [l ] On Behalf Of Kanak Bosmia Friday, July 20, 2007 9:58 AM l Re: [l] TSP Theory : Few Questions Dear Suprakash ji, my reply in Bold****** regards Kanak Bosmia " S.Ghosh " <suprakash.ghosh wrote: Dear Kanakji I went through your article on Dr Kar's TSP Theory published in your magazine. Indeed it is an amazing finding if consistantly in gives true results.I'll also start using this theory and see the results. Your article is very lucid and well written.However I have some questions which need clarification: 1) Cases with Nodes :Example-1 :WI vs SA Test-1:Star lord of sub sub lord is Ketu.Ketu is star lord of venus.Venus is star lord lord of asc.Hence the answer should be Yes.But you have arrived at No based on Mars /Merc aspect only. Whereas in step-3 you have considered the venus as usual. In this case if venus is considered in step-1, the prediction goes wrong. Kanak: You are right, when i start pridict with TSP i use only thre main rules, when i found some pridction went wrong, then i again check with sub rules and during world cup i check all the rules.first i check for nade as per KP if any planet aspect on node or conj with node then node give first result of that planet. so in this cas when i found two planet aspect/conj with node i considet only that two, in 3rd rule deciding factore is Ven not node. so i do not follow that rules, after world cup complited i start checking again and found we have to check all node's conection, in this regard you are right if we follow all conection of node pridiction give defferant result. then why my pridiction come correct? if you notice RAH is in the star of SAT, and RAH is starlord of MOON, when SATY conection with moon result opposite, may be this iffect we found here, i am not sure abouit it, bcoze befor say anything we have to check more case. truble is Dr.Kar do not write clearly about TSP also he write nearly 25 Rules, if we follow all then we never get any result nagative. 2)What happens if moon is in sub or sub sub of Sat..is it denial or delay? Kanak: I do not check this, this point is in my considaration and i am try to look about it, i request you all to check all the peramiter in your mind with rules mention in my articles, and send me your finding. it will help me to rebilt improve more iffective rules. 3)What happens if rahu represents moon and rahu becomes sub sub of asc.Is it always positive? Kanak: relay very good question: On 18th my daughter ask me question: Will i win challange i commited with mom? Time used for analysis: 18-Jul-2007 [5:30:0]Horary no:2055/2193 ASC lords are Ju-Sa-Ke-Ra MOON lords are Su-Ve-Ve-Ve ASC SS lord is Ra. MOON is an agent of Ra. So, the expected outcome is YES. But SATURN is conjoined with MOON, negating the expected outcome. Hence according to TSP, the answer is NO. in this case three rules apply at once. you answer also in this. I am waiting for ouit come and we have to wait for some times, when result of this horary come i will inform you what happan, bocze this is first time i face this type of problem. 4)Similarly if Moon in star of Rahu/Ketu or aspected by Rahu/Ketu and Rahu/Ketu represents Saturn.Is it denial? Kanak: I think i reply in above, we have to check some exmple and i strongly request all memebrs to keep younrecord for ferther reseach on this. 5)You have given a raider point of the special rule No-2 : The relation of sun will delay only instead of negation .IS this true if rahu/ketu represents Sun and Rahu/Ketu is related like sun? Kanak: very true i never use this rule in precticly. i quated only what Dr.Kar mention. without checking this i found good result so i do not use this. one can check ifectiveness of this rules and inform group members. Regards Suprakash " A person should not be too honest. Straight trees are cut first And Honest people are screwed first. " Chanakya quotes (Indian politician, strategist and writer, 350 BC 75 BC) Get the free toolbar and rest assured with the added security of spyware protection. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 20, 2007 Report Share Posted July 20, 2007 Dear Kanakji, Namasthe. Yesterday night I read this article and i had same question (a) and thanks for your answer. One more additional question is: I am in France and as you have explained, I need to take local meridien that is 1 hour a head of GMT. So, I have to take 1.00 as time. Now what happens with day light saving? During this period shall I take 2.00 hours and the remaining period1.00 hour? Thank you for your help Best regards Bhanu Pinnamaneni On 7/20/07, Kanak Bosmia <kanakbosmia wrote: > > Dear Suprakash ji, > my reply in Bold****** > regards > Kanak Bosmia > > " S.Ghosh " <suprakash.ghosh <suprakash.ghosh%40cesc.co.in>> > wrote: > Dear Kanakji > > I went through your article on Dr Kar's TSP Theory published in your > magazine. Indeed it is an amazing finding if consistantly in gives > true results.I'll also start using this theory and see the results. > > Your article is very lucid and well written.However I have some > questions which need clarification: > > 1) Cases with Nodes :Example-1 :WI vs SA > Test-1:Star lord of sub sub lord is Ketu.Ketu is star lord of > venus.Venus is star lord lord of asc.Hence the answer should be > Yes.But you have arrived at No based on Mars /Merc aspect only. > Whereas in step-3 you have considered the venus as usual. > > In this case if venus is considered in step-1, the prediction goes > wrong. > Kanak: You are right, when i start pridict with TSP i use only thre main > rules, when i found some pridction went wrong, then i again check with sub > rules and during world cup i check all the rules.first i check for nade as > per KP if any planet aspect on node or conj with node then node give first > result of that planet. so in this cas when i found two planet aspect/conj > with node i considet only that two, in 3rd rule deciding factore is Ven not > node. so i do not follow that rules, after world cup complited i start > checking again and found we have to check all node's conection, in this > regard you are right if we follow all conection of node pridiction give > defferant result. > then why my pridiction come correct? if you notice RAH is in the star of > SAT, and RAH is starlord of MOON, when SATY conection with moon result > opposite, may be this iffect we found here, i am not sure abouit it, bcoze > befor say anything we have to check more case. > truble is Dr.Kar do not write clearly about TSP also he write nearly 25 > Rules, if we follow all then we never get any result nagative. > > > 2)What happens if moon is in sub or sub sub of Sat..is it denial or > delay? > Kanak: I do not check this, this point is in my considaration and i am try > to look about it, i request you all to check all the peramiter in your mind > with rules mention in my articles, and send me your finding. it will help me > to rebilt improve more iffective rules. > > 3)What happens if rahu represents moon and rahu becomes sub sub of > asc.Is it always positive? > Kanak: relay very good question: > On 18th my daughter ask me question: > Will i win challange i commited with mom? > Time used for analysis: 18-Jul-2007 [5:30:0]Horary no:2055/2193 > ASC lords are Ju-Sa-Ke-Ra > MOON lords are Su-Ve-Ve-Ve > ASC SS lord is Ra. MOON is an agent of Ra. So, the expected outcome is > YES. > But SATURN is conjoined with MOON, negating the expected outcome. > Hence according to TSP, the answer is NO. > > in this case three rules apply at once. you answer also in this. I am > waiting for ouit come and we have to wait for some times, when result of > this horary come i will inform you what happan, bocze this is first time i > face this type of problem. > > 4)Similarly if Moon in star of Rahu/Ketu or aspected by Rahu/Ketu and > Rahu/Ketu represents Saturn.Is it denial? > Kanak: I think i reply in above, we have to check some exmple and i > strongly request all memebrs to keep younrecord for ferther reseach on this. > > 5)You have given a raider point of the special rule No-2 : The > relation of sun will delay only instead of negation .IS this true if > rahu/ketu represents Sun and Rahu/Ketu is related like sun? > Kanak: very true i never use this rule in precticly. i quated only what > Dr.Kar mention. without checking this i found good result so i do not use > this. one can check ifectiveness of this rules and inform group members. > > Regards > > Suprakash > > " A person should not be too honest. > Straight trees are cut first > And Honest people are screwed first. " > Chanakya quotes (Indian politician, strategist and writer, 350 BC 75 BC) > > > > > Get the free toolbar and rest assured with the added security of > spyware protection. > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 20, 2007 Report Share Posted July 20, 2007 Dear suprakash ji, No, i never mixed up two or more theory. No you can not use directly for this question , but if some one ask you a question like: ' WILL I MARRY WITH XYZ? then we use it, and get good result. I have done once, but now i am not able to find out where i save it, if i find out i will post in group. regards Kanak Bosmia Suprakash Ghosh <suprakash.ghosh wrote: Thanks Kanakji. I have another question.. can TSP be used along with Natal charts? I mean say some one asks me about the possibility of marriage..yes or no. If I take a number alongwith her birth data, will 7th cusp potentiality match with TSP result? What is your experience? Regards Suprakash. l [l ] On Behalf Of Kanak Bosmia Friday, July 20, 2007 9:58 AM l Re: [l] TSP Theory : Few Questions Dear Suprakash ji, my reply in Bold****** regards Kanak Bosmia " S.Ghosh " <suprakash.ghosh wrote: Dear Kanakji I went through your article on Dr Kar's TSP Theory published in your magazine. Indeed it is an amazing finding if consistantly in gives true results.I'll also start using this theory and see the results. Your article is very lucid and well written.However I have some questions which need clarification: 1) Cases with Nodes :Example-1 :WI vs SA Test-1:Star lord of sub sub lord is Ketu.Ketu is star lord of venus.Venus is star lord lord of asc.Hence the answer should be Yes.But you have arrived at No based on Mars /Merc aspect only. Whereas in step-3 you have considered the venus as usual. In this case if venus is considered in step-1, the prediction goes wrong. Kanak: You are right, when i start pridict with TSP i use only thre main rules, when i found some pridction went wrong, then i again check with sub rules and during world cup i check all the rules.first i check for nade as per KP if any planet aspect on node or conj with node then node give first result of that planet. so in this cas when i found two planet aspect/conj with node i considet only that two, in 3rd rule deciding factore is Ven not node. so i do not follow that rules, after world cup complited i start checking again and found we have to check all node's conection, in this regard you are right if we follow all conection of node pridiction give defferant result. then why my pridiction come correct? if you notice RAH is in the star of SAT, and RAH is starlord of MOON, when SATY conection with moon result opposite, may be this iffect we found here, i am not sure abouit it, bcoze befor say anything we have to check more case. truble is Dr.Kar do not write clearly about TSP also he write nearly 25 Rules, if we follow all then we never get any result nagative. 2)What happens if moon is in sub or sub sub of Sat..is it denial or delay? Kanak: I do not check this, this point is in my considaration and i am try to look about it, i request you all to check all the peramiter in your mind with rules mention in my articles, and send me your finding. it will help me to rebilt improve more iffective rules. 3)What happens if rahu represents moon and rahu becomes sub sub of asc.Is it always positive? Kanak: relay very good question: On 18th my daughter ask me question: Will i win challange i commited with mom? Time used for analysis: 18-Jul-2007 [5:30:0]Horary no:2055/2193 ASC lords are Ju-Sa-Ke-Ra MOON lords are Su-Ve-Ve-Ve ASC SS lord is Ra. MOON is an agent of Ra. So, the expected outcome is YES. But SATURN is conjoined with MOON, negating the expected outcome. Hence according to TSP, the answer is NO. in this case three rules apply at once. you answer also in this. I am waiting for ouit come and we have to wait for some times, when result of this horary come i will inform you what happan, bocze this is first time i face this type of problem. 4)Similarly if Moon in star of Rahu/Ketu or aspected by Rahu/Ketu and Rahu/Ketu represents Saturn.Is it denial? Kanak: I think i reply in above, we have to check some exmple and i strongly request all memebrs to keep younrecord for ferther reseach on this. 5)You have given a raider point of the special rule No-2 : The relation of sun will delay only instead of negation .IS this true if rahu/ketu represents Sun and Rahu/Ketu is related like sun? Kanak: very true i never use this rule in precticly. i quated only what Dr.Kar mention. without checking this i found good result so i do not use this. one can check ifectiveness of this rules and inform group members. Regards Suprakash " A person should not be too honest. Straight trees are cut first And Honest people are screwed first. " Chanakya quotes (Indian politician, strategist and writer, 350 BC 75 BC) Get the free toolbar and rest assured with the added security of spyware protection. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 20, 2007 Report Share Posted July 20, 2007 Dear Bhanu ji, YES you have to follow DST or War time which is applicable time to time. in other word take GMT 00 Hrs. hope this help regards Kanak Bosmia Astro Paris <bhanuparis wrote: Dear Kanakji, Namasthe. Yesterday night I read this article and i had same question (a) and thanks for your answer. One more additional question is: I am in France and as you have explained, I need to take local meridien that is 1 hour a head of GMT. So, I have to take 1.00 as time. Now what happens with day light saving? During this period shall I take 2.00 hours and the remaining period1.00 hour? Thank you for your help Best regards Bhanu Pinnamaneni On 7/20/07, Kanak Bosmia <kanakbosmia wrote: > > Dear Suprakash ji, > my reply in Bold****** > regards > Kanak Bosmia > > " S.Ghosh " <suprakash.ghosh <suprakash.ghosh%40cesc.co.in>> > wrote: > Dear Kanakji > > I went through your article on Dr Kar's TSP Theory published in your > magazine. Indeed it is an amazing finding if consistantly in gives > true results.I'll also start using this theory and see the results. > > Your article is very lucid and well written.However I have some > questions which need clarification: > > 1) Cases with Nodes :Example-1 :WI vs SA > Test-1:Star lord of sub sub lord is Ketu.Ketu is star lord of > venus.Venus is star lord lord of asc.Hence the answer should be > Yes.But you have arrived at No based on Mars /Merc aspect only. > Whereas in step-3 you have considered the venus as usual. > > In this case if venus is considered in step-1, the prediction goes > wrong. > Kanak: You are right, when i start pridict with TSP i use only thre main > rules, when i found some pridction went wrong, then i again check with sub > rules and during world cup i check all the rules.first i check for nade as > per KP if any planet aspect on node or conj with node then node give first > result of that planet. so in this cas when i found two planet aspect/conj > with node i considet only that two, in 3rd rule deciding factore is Ven not > node. so i do not follow that rules, after world cup complited i start > checking again and found we have to check all node's conection, in this > regard you are right if we follow all conection of node pridiction give > defferant result. > then why my pridiction come correct? if you notice RAH is in the star of > SAT, and RAH is starlord of MOON, when SATY conection with moon result > opposite, may be this iffect we found here, i am not sure abouit it, bcoze > befor say anything we have to check more case. > truble is Dr.Kar do not write clearly about TSP also he write nearly 25 > Rules, if we follow all then we never get any result nagative. > > > 2)What happens if moon is in sub or sub sub of Sat..is it denial or > delay? > Kanak: I do not check this, this point is in my considaration and i am try > to look about it, i request you all to check all the peramiter in your mind > with rules mention in my articles, and send me your finding. it will help me > to rebilt improve more iffective rules. > > 3)What happens if rahu represents moon and rahu becomes sub sub of > asc.Is it always positive? > Kanak: relay very good question: > On 18th my daughter ask me question: > Will i win challange i commited with mom? > Time used for analysis: 18-Jul-2007 [5:30:0]Horary no:2055/2193 > ASC lords are Ju-Sa-Ke-Ra > MOON lords are Su-Ve-Ve-Ve > ASC SS lord is Ra. MOON is an agent of Ra. So, the expected outcome is > YES. > But SATURN is conjoined with MOON, negating the expected outcome. > Hence according to TSP, the answer is NO. > > in this case three rules apply at once. you answer also in this. I am > waiting for ouit come and we have to wait for some times, when result of > this horary come i will inform you what happan, bocze this is first time i > face this type of problem. > > 4)Similarly if Moon in star of Rahu/Ketu or aspected by Rahu/Ketu and > Rahu/Ketu represents Saturn.Is it denial? > Kanak: I think i reply in above, we have to check some exmple and i > strongly request all memebrs to keep younrecord for ferther reseach on this. > > 5)You have given a raider point of the special rule No-2 : The > relation of sun will delay only instead of negation .IS this true if > rahu/ketu represents Sun and Rahu/Ketu is related like sun? > Kanak: very true i never use this rule in precticly. i quated only what > Dr.Kar mention. without checking this i found good result so i do not use > this. one can check ifectiveness of this rules and inform group members. > > Regards > > Suprakash > > " A person should not be too honest. > Straight trees are cut first > And Honest people are screwed first. " > Chanakya quotes (Indian politician, strategist and writer, 350 BC 75 BC) > > > > > Get the free toolbar and rest assured with the added security of > spyware protection. > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 22, 2007 Report Share Posted July 22, 2007 Dear Kanakji Hello I am going through the interesting articles TSP theory and few yrs back I read on Dr Keshava R.Kar's TSP theory in K P astro general but that time I found it very complicated as it is based on subsub so I didn't continue reading.Now I am reading articles and want to go through it but I don't remember all the rules and vol no of k p astro journals. So I request if u can give me the names of the journal where u published TSP theory and also tell me the name/vol no of other journals so that I can collect them to read in detail. I will be highly obliged Thanx Dr Sheetal On 7/19/07, S.Ghosh <suprakash.ghosh wrote: > > Dear Kanakji > > I went through your article on Dr Kar's TSP Theory published in your > magazine. Indeed it is an amazing finding if consistantly in gives > true results.I'll also start using this theory and see the results. > > Your article is very lucid and well written.However I have some > questions which need clarification: > > 1) Cases with Nodes :Example-1 :WI vs SA > Test-1:Star lord of sub sub lord is Ketu.Ketu is star lord of > venus.Venus is star lord lord of asc.Hence the answer should be > Yes.But you have arrived at No based on Mars /Merc aspect only. > Whereas in step-3 you have considered the venus as usual. > > In this case if venus is considered in step-1, the prediction goes > wrong. > > 2)What happens if moon is in sub or sub sub of Sat..is it denial or > delay? > > 3)What happens if rahu represents moon and rahu becomes sub sub of > asc.Is it always positive? > > 4)Similarly if Moon in star of Rahu/Ketu or aspected by Rahu/Ketu and > Rahu/Ketu represents Saturn.Is it denial? > > 5)You have given a raider point of the special rule No-2 : The > relation of sun will delay only instead of negation .IS this true if > rahu/ketu represents Sun and Rahu/Ketu is related like sun? > > Regards > > Suprakash > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 22, 2007 Report Share Posted July 22, 2007 Dear sheetal ji, You can found in KP and astrology yearly megazine i do not remember all year but i think last one is in 2004, Dr.kar gives so many rules, so i select only iffective, and write with detaile in KPEzine June issue. I hope you have this issue with you. if you follow all the rules givan in my article you do not need to read more on this subject. hope this help regards kanak Bosmia Sheetal <ratnamalag wrote: Dear Kanakji Hello I am going through the interesting articles TSP theory and few yrs back I read on Dr Keshava R.Kar's TSP theory in K P astro general but that time I found it very complicated as it is based on subsub so I didn't continue reading.Now I am reading articles and want to go through it but I don't remember all the rules and vol no of k p astro journals. So I request if u can give me the names of the journal where u published TSP theory and also tell me the name/vol no of other journals so that I can collect them to read in detail. I will be highly obliged Thanx Dr Sheetal On 7/19/07, S.Ghosh <suprakash.ghosh wrote: > > Dear Kanakji > > I went through your article on Dr Kar's TSP Theory published in your > magazine. Indeed it is an amazing finding if consistantly in gives > true results.I'll also start using this theory and see the results. > > Your article is very lucid and well written.However I have some > questions which need clarification: > > 1) Cases with Nodes :Example-1 :WI vs SA > Test-1:Star lord of sub sub lord is Ketu.Ketu is star lord of > venus.Venus is star lord lord of asc.Hence the answer should be > Yes.But you have arrived at No based on Mars /Merc aspect only. > Whereas in step-3 you have considered the venus as usual. > > In this case if venus is considered in step-1, the prediction goes > wrong. > > 2)What happens if moon is in sub or sub sub of Sat..is it denial or > delay? > > 3)What happens if rahu represents moon and rahu becomes sub sub of > asc.Is it always positive? > > 4)Similarly if Moon in star of Rahu/Ketu or aspected by Rahu/Ketu and > Rahu/Ketu represents Saturn.Is it denial? > > 5)You have given a raider point of the special rule No-2 : The > relation of sun will delay only instead of negation .IS this true if > rahu/ketu represents Sun and Rahu/Ketu is related like sun? > > Regards > > Suprakash > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 22, 2007 Report Share Posted July 22, 2007 Dear Kanakj I dont have KPEzine June issue or any of it so plz guide me from where I can get it. Is it a monthly or yearly magazine/ issue? Plz let me know. Thanx Sheetal On 7/22/07, Kanak Bosmia <kanakbosmia wrote: > > Dear sheetal ji, > You can found in KP and astrology yearly megazine i do not remember all > year but i think last one is in 2004, > Dr.kar gives so many rules, so i select only iffective, and write with > detaile in KPEzine June issue. I hope you have this issue with you. if you > follow all the rules givan in my article you do not need to read more on > this subject. > hope this help > regards > kanak Bosmia > > > Sheetal <ratnamalag <ratnamalag%40gmail.com>> wrote: > Dear Kanakji > > Hello > > I am going through the interesting articles TSP theory and few yrs back I > read on Dr Keshava R.Kar's TSP theory in K P astro general but that time I > found it very complicated as it is based on subsub so I didn't continue > reading.Now I am reading articles and want to go through it but I don't > remember all the rules and vol no of k p astro journals. So I request if u > can give me the names of the journal where u published TSP theory and also > tell me the name/vol no of other journals so that I can collect them to > read > in detail. > > I will be highly obliged > > Thanx > > Dr Sheetal > > On 7/19/07, S.Ghosh <suprakash.ghosh<suprakash.ghosh%40cesc.co.in>> > wrote: > > > > Dear Kanakji > > > > I went through your article on Dr Kar's TSP Theory published in your > > magazine. Indeed it is an amazing finding if consistantly in gives > > true results.I'll also start using this theory and see the results. > > > > Your article is very lucid and well written.However I have some > > questions which need clarification: > > > > 1) Cases with Nodes :Example-1 :WI vs SA > > Test-1:Star lord of sub sub lord is Ketu.Ketu is star lord of > > venus.Venus is star lord lord of asc.Hence the answer should be > > Yes.But you have arrived at No based on Mars /Merc aspect only. > > Whereas in step-3 you have considered the venus as usual. > > > > In this case if venus is considered in step-1, the prediction goes > > wrong. > > > > 2)What happens if moon is in sub or sub sub of Sat..is it denial or > > delay? > > > > 3)What happens if rahu represents moon and rahu becomes sub sub of > > asc.Is it always positive? > > > > 4)Similarly if Moon in star of Rahu/Ketu or aspected by Rahu/Ketu and > > Rahu/Ketu represents Saturn.Is it denial? > > > > 5)You have given a raider point of the special rule No-2 : The > > relation of sun will delay only instead of negation .IS this true if > > rahu/ketu represents Sun and Rahu/Ketu is related like sun? > > > > Regards > > > > Suprakash > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 22, 2007 Report Share Posted July 22, 2007 Dear Sheetal ji, KPezine is free to all up to end of each month. past issue are paid and For Rs 200 per month. you have to register your self at www.loger.com and download currant july month issue. for old issue contact at kpezine regards Kanak Bosmia Sheetal <ratnamalag wrote: Dear Kanakj I dont have KPEzine June issue or any of it so plz guide me from where I can get it. Is it a monthly or yearly magazine/ issue? Plz let me know. Thanx Sheetal On 7/22/07, Kanak Bosmia <kanakbosmia wrote: > > Dear sheetal ji, > You can found in KP and astrology yearly megazine i do not remember all > year but i think last one is in 2004, > Dr.kar gives so many rules, so i select only iffective, and write with > detaile in KPEzine June issue. I hope you have this issue with you. if you > follow all the rules givan in my article you do not need to read more on > this subject. > hope this help > regards > kanak Bosmia > > > Sheetal <ratnamalag <ratnamalag%40gmail.com>> wrote: > Dear Kanakji > > Hello > > I am going through the interesting articles TSP theory and few yrs back I > read on Dr Keshava R.Kar's TSP theory in K P astro general but that time I > found it very complicated as it is based on subsub so I didn't continue > reading.Now I am reading articles and want to go through it but I don't > remember all the rules and vol no of k p astro journals. So I request if u > can give me the names of the journal where u published TSP theory and also > tell me the name/vol no of other journals so that I can collect them to > read > in detail. > > I will be highly obliged > > Thanx > > Dr Sheetal > > On 7/19/07, S.Ghosh <suprakash.ghosh<suprakash.ghosh%40cesc.co.in>> > wrote: > > > > Dear Kanakji > > > > I went through your article on Dr Kar's TSP Theory published in your > > magazine. Indeed it is an amazing finding if consistantly in gives > > true results.I'll also start using this theory and see the results. > > > > Your article is very lucid and well written.However I have some > > questions which need clarification: > > > > 1) Cases with Nodes :Example-1 :WI vs SA > > Test-1:Star lord of sub sub lord is Ketu.Ketu is star lord of > > venus.Venus is star lord lord of asc.Hence the answer should be > > Yes.But you have arrived at No based on Mars /Merc aspect only. > > Whereas in step-3 you have considered the venus as usual. > > > > In this case if venus is considered in step-1, the prediction goes > > wrong. > > > > 2)What happens if moon is in sub or sub sub of Sat..is it denial or > > delay? > > > > 3)What happens if rahu represents moon and rahu becomes sub sub of > > asc.Is it always positive? > > > > 4)Similarly if Moon in star of Rahu/Ketu or aspected by Rahu/Ketu and > > Rahu/Ketu represents Saturn.Is it denial? > > > > 5)You have given a raider point of the special rule No-2 : The > > relation of sun will delay only instead of negation .IS this true if > > rahu/ketu represents Sun and Rahu/Ketu is related like sun? > > > > Regards > > > > Suprakash > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 25, 2007 Report Share Posted July 25, 2007 Dear Kanakji Being inspired by your lessons I'm working with TSP seriously.I'll let you know my study report after sufficient cases have been analysed. Another thing I want clarification from you is when you consider aspect in TSP, what aspect to be considered : a)All Western aspects. b)Mejor Western Aspects c)Vedic aspect d)vedic aspect with orb (3.33 deg as told by Mr Raichur) e)Both Vedic and Western If western aspect is used, is there any diff of result in good and bad aspect between moon and Sat? Regards Suprakash l [l ] On Behalf Of Kanak Bosmia Friday, July 20, 2007 9:58 AM l Re: [l] TSP Theory : Few Questions Dear Suprakash ji, my reply in Bold****** regards Kanak Bosmia " S.Ghosh " <suprakash.ghosh wrote: Dear Kanakji I went through your article on Dr Kar's TSP Theory published in your magazine. Indeed it is an amazing finding if consistantly in gives true results.I'll also start using this theory and see the results. Your article is very lucid and well written.However I have some questions which need clarification: 1) Cases with Nodes :Example-1 :WI vs SA Test-1:Star lord of sub sub lord is Ketu.Ketu is star lord of venus.Venus is star lord lord of asc.Hence the answer should be Yes.But you have arrived at No based on Mars /Merc aspect only. Whereas in step-3 you have considered the venus as usual. In this case if venus is considered in step-1, the prediction goes wrong. Kanak: You are right, when i start pridict with TSP i use only thre main rules, when i found some pridction went wrong, then i again check with sub rules and during world cup i check all the rules.first i check for nade as per KP if any planet aspect on node or conj with node then node give first result of that planet. so in this cas when i found two planet aspect/conj with node i considet only that two, in 3rd rule deciding factore is Ven not node. so i do not follow that rules, after world cup complited i start checking again and found we have to check all node's conection, in this regard you are right if we follow all conection of node pridiction give defferant result. then why my pridiction come correct? if you notice RAH is in the star of SAT, and RAH is starlord of MOON, when SATY conection with moon result opposite, may be this iffect we found here, i am not sure abouit it, bcoze befor say anything we have to check more case. truble is Dr.Kar do not write clearly about TSP also he write nearly 25 Rules, if we follow all then we never get any result nagative. 2)What happens if moon is in sub or sub sub of Sat..is it denial or delay? Kanak: I do not check this, this point is in my considaration and i am try to look about it, i request you all to check all the peramiter in your mind with rules mention in my articles, and send me your finding. it will help me to rebilt improve more iffective rules. 3)What happens if rahu represents moon and rahu becomes sub sub of asc.Is it always positive? Kanak: relay very good question: On 18th my daughter ask me question: Will i win challange i commited with mom? Time used for analysis: 18-Jul-2007 [5:30:0]Horary no:2055/2193 ASC lords are Ju-Sa-Ke-Ra MOON lords are Su-Ve-Ve-Ve ASC SS lord is Ra. MOON is an agent of Ra. So, the expected outcome is YES. But SATURN is conjoined with MOON, negating the expected outcome. Hence according to TSP, the answer is NO. in this case three rules apply at once. you answer also in this. I am waiting for ouit come and we have to wait for some times, when result of this horary come i will inform you what happan, bocze this is first time i face this type of problem. 4)Similarly if Moon in star of Rahu/Ketu or aspected by Rahu/Ketu and Rahu/Ketu represents Saturn.Is it denial? Kanak: I think i reply in above, we have to check some exmple and i strongly request all memebrs to keep younrecord for ferther reseach on this. 5)You have given a raider point of the special rule No-2 : The relation of sun will delay only instead of negation .IS this true if rahu/ketu represents Sun and Rahu/Ketu is related like sun? Kanak: very true i never use this rule in precticly. i quated only what Dr.Kar mention. without checking this i found good result so i do not use this. one can check ifectiveness of this rules and inform group members. Regards Suprakash " A person should not be too honest. Straight trees are cut first And Honest people are screwed first. " Chanakya quotes (Indian politician, strategist and writer, 350 BC 75 BC) Get the free toolbar and rest assured with the added security of spyware protection. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 25, 2007 Report Share Posted July 25, 2007 Dear Suprakash ji, i use aspect only in two condition,1) if i have to analyses Node or 2) SAT_Moon conection. I take only veidc aspect rasi to rasi aspect only. hope this help regards kanak Bosmia Suprakash Ghosh <suprakash.ghosh wrote: Dear Kanakji Being inspired by your lessons I'm working with TSP seriously.I'll let you know my study report after sufficient cases have been analysed. Another thing I want clarification from you is when you consider aspect in TSP, what aspect to be considered : a)All Western aspects. b)Mejor Western Aspects c)Vedic aspect d)vedic aspect with orb (3.33 deg as told by Mr Raichur) e)Both Vedic and Western If western aspect is used, is there any diff of result in good and bad aspect between moon and Sat? Regards Suprakash l [l ] On Behalf Of Kanak Bosmia Friday, July 20, 2007 9:58 AM l Re: [l] TSP Theory : Few Questions Dear Suprakash ji, my reply in Bold****** regards Kanak Bosmia " S.Ghosh " <suprakash.ghosh wrote: Dear Kanakji I went through your article on Dr Kar's TSP Theory published in your magazine. Indeed it is an amazing finding if consistantly in gives true results.I'll also start using this theory and see the results. Your article is very lucid and well written.However I have some questions which need clarification: 1) Cases with Nodes :Example-1 :WI vs SA Test-1:Star lord of sub sub lord is Ketu.Ketu is star lord of venus.Venus is star lord lord of asc.Hence the answer should be Yes.But you have arrived at No based on Mars /Merc aspect only. Whereas in step-3 you have considered the venus as usual. In this case if venus is considered in step-1, the prediction goes wrong. Kanak: You are right, when i start pridict with TSP i use only thre main rules, when i found some pridction went wrong, then i again check with sub rules and during world cup i check all the rules.first i check for nade as per KP if any planet aspect on node or conj with node then node give first result of that planet. so in this cas when i found two planet aspect/conj with node i considet only that two, in 3rd rule deciding factore is Ven not node. so i do not follow that rules, after world cup complited i start checking again and found we have to check all node's conection, in this regard you are right if we follow all conection of node pridiction give defferant result. then why my pridiction come correct? if you notice RAH is in the star of SAT, and RAH is starlord of MOON, when SATY conection with moon result opposite, may be this iffect we found here, i am not sure abouit it, bcoze befor say anything we have to check more case. truble is Dr.Kar do not write clearly about TSP also he write nearly 25 Rules, if we follow all then we never get any result nagative. 2)What happens if moon is in sub or sub sub of Sat..is it denial or delay? Kanak: I do not check this, this point is in my considaration and i am try to look about it, i request you all to check all the peramiter in your mind with rules mention in my articles, and send me your finding. it will help me to rebilt improve more iffective rules. 3)What happens if rahu represents moon and rahu becomes sub sub of asc.Is it always positive? Kanak: relay very good question: On 18th my daughter ask me question: Will i win challange i commited with mom? Time used for analysis: 18-Jul-2007 [5:30:0]Horary no:2055/2193 ASC lords are Ju-Sa-Ke-Ra MOON lords are Su-Ve-Ve-Ve ASC SS lord is Ra. MOON is an agent of Ra. So, the expected outcome is YES. But SATURN is conjoined with MOON, negating the expected outcome. Hence according to TSP, the answer is NO. in this case three rules apply at once. you answer also in this. I am waiting for ouit come and we have to wait for some times, when result of this horary come i will inform you what happan, bocze this is first time i face this type of problem. 4)Similarly if Moon in star of Rahu/Ketu or aspected by Rahu/Ketu and Rahu/Ketu represents Saturn.Is it denial? Kanak: I think i reply in above, we have to check some exmple and i strongly request all memebrs to keep younrecord for ferther reseach on this. 5)You have given a raider point of the special rule No-2 : The relation of sun will delay only instead of negation .IS this true if rahu/ketu represents Sun and Rahu/Ketu is related like sun? Kanak: very true i never use this rule in precticly. i quated only what Dr.Kar mention. without checking this i found good result so i do not use this. one can check ifectiveness of this rules and inform group members. Regards Suprakash " A person should not be too honest. Straight trees are cut first And Honest people are screwed first. " Chanakya quotes (Indian politician, strategist and writer, 350 BC 75 BC) Get the free toolbar and rest assured with the added security of spyware protection. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.