Guest guest Posted February 8, 2009 Report Share Posted February 8, 2009 respected kulbir ji namskar with all due respect i dont think i wrote that i am going to do any upays for any body my simple question was that holy LAL KITAB says if we do any upays for mercury 12 it will effect mangal 8 adversly so how we can deal with this problem. and sir you wrote that upays can only effect any body by 2% so why we do them at all if the upays not going to help and for your kind information this is my on kundli cause i am learning and i dont mess with other people'life thanks yours truly Rajesh Bhanot phagwara , kulbir bance <kulbirbance wrote: > > Jitin ji, this question should be toched upon later. The first and > foremost question to be addressed is When does a person becomes > competent to prescribe remedies? We don't even read the book > thouroughly even once and add the tag of experts not to talk of gold > medalist that are groomed by institutions in a 6 months course. My > personal experience is that after going through the book thouroughly > each time u open the book u find a riddle in it. Had the remedies been > so simple to prescribe and alter the results, there would be much less > suffering around us and all those with the book in their hands be > billioners by now. But is it the case? The answer is right before u. > Do some atamchintan. Regards. Kulbir. > > On 2/8/09, jitinsyal82 <jitinsyal82 wrote: > > Respected kulbir ji, pranam. > > > > Your explanation is simply marvelous and educating.Your point > > no.2 " not to prescribe remedies when your own planets are weak " is a > > very interesting and very very important topic for LK students, being > > your junior and a keen learner of LK i would request you to kindly > > explain this point further i.e the logic behind it, weak means in > > varshphal or natal chart etc. > > > > yours respectfully > > jitin syal > > > > , kulbir bance <kulbirbance@> > > wrote: > >> > >> Rajesh jh, since u want to learn and knowing that u r no novice. Go > > by > >> the thumb rule that planets of 6,8,12 have to be judged together. U > >> asked about only 2 planets. U forgot to mention planet venus placed > >> alongwith mercury, aspect of 2 plandets in 6. See how the situation > >> changes. Now take up the natal chart first. Check for rin pitri etc. > >> Then take the current age into account. Then check the problem faced > >> by native or likelihood of it. Also check his vastu. Ask about > >> condition of relatives and items to planets under purview. Believe > > me > >> u will find ur upayas can help the native by not more than 2%. > > However > >> i dare say that the native will face a calamity of dire consequences > >> but will ultimately come unharmed provided no unnecessary ched chad > > is > >> done with planets. Take it as a genuine advice 1 don't fiddle with a > >> pakka ghar ka grah. 2. Don't prescribe remedies for others qua > > planets > >> that are weak in ur own horoscope. Regards. Kulbir > >> > >> On 2/3/09, kalapandit68 <kalapandit68@> wrote: > >> > , kulbir bance <kulbirbance@> > >> > wrote: > >> >>res kulbir ji namskar > >> > i am very sorry if i put any thing in the wrong way i don't know > >> > that if we need to check all the planets.as i mention i am trying > >> > to learn .so sir rest of the planets are as below > >> > 1- empty > >> > 2-empty > >> > 3-empty > >> > 4-empty > >> > 5-moon > >> > 6-saturn,rahu > >> > 7-empty > >> > 8-mars > >> > 9-jupter,sun,ketu > >> > 10-empty > >> > 11-empty > >> > 12-mercury,venus > >> > thanks > >> > rajesh > >> >> Rajesh ji, plz send in the configration of other 7 planets also > > as > >> > the > >> >> querry is specific and i hope u don't want an academic discussion > >> > on > >> >> these 2 planets only. Kulbir > >> >> > >> >> On 2/1/09, kalapandit68 <kalapandit68@> wrote: > >> >> > respected members namskar > >> >> > i am trying to study LAL KITAB for that group members are god > >> > send > >> >> > even on phone calls they will help you out. know i was stuck > > at a > >> >> > promlem i could not find any solution so i am trying to write > > it > >> > down > >> >> > for respected members > >> >> > IF MARS IS IN 8TH HOUSE WE HAVE TO DO SOME UPAYS FOR IT > >> >> > BUT IF ON THE SAME TIME MERCURY IS IN THE 12 TH HOUSE IT IS > >> > MALIFIC TOO > >> >> > KNOW IF YOU TRY ANY UPAY TO HELP MERCURY IT WILL BE BAD FOR > > MARS > >> > MY > >> >> > QUESTION IS HOW YOU CAN DEAL WITH THIS PROBLEM thanks > >> >> > yours > >> >> > rajesh > >> >> > phagwara > >> >> > > >> >> > > >> >> > > >> >> > >> >> -- > >> >> Sent from my mobile device > >> >> > >> > > >> > > >> > > >> > >> -- > >> Sent from my mobile device > >> > > > > > > > > -- > Sent from my mobile device > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted February 9, 2009 Report Share Posted February 9, 2009 Respected kulbir ji, very well said indeed, your words have very deep meaning however only to be understood by learned individuals like yourself.A person of my caliber would have been happy with your further explanation and my education. As per my opinion a doctor can't diagnose and prescribe remedies until he completes MBBS.Even after that one needs to be in touch with changing nature of diseases and drugs by studying and reading different books, hence i don't think one can master LK at any stage of his or her life and be 100% sure about prescribing remedies. anyways coming back to the original question i will try to find the answer of " not prescribing remedies of weak planets " by myself and if i can't then i always have big brother in yourself to refer to. Please keep sharing your valuable knowledge like this. yours respectfully jitin syal , kulbir bance <kulbirbance wrote: > > Jitin ji, this question should be toched upon later. The first and > foremost question to be addressed is When does a person becomes > competent to prescribe remedies? We don't even read the book > thouroughly even once and add the tag of experts not to talk of gold > medalist that are groomed by institutions in a 6 months course. My > personal experience is that after going through the book thouroughly > each time u open the book u find a riddle in it. Had the remedies been > so simple to prescribe and alter the results, there would be much less > suffering around us and all those with the book in their hands be > billioners by now. But is it the case? The answer is right before u. > Do some atamchintan. Regards. Kulbir. > > On 2/8/09, jitinsyal82 <jitinsyal82 wrote: > > Respected kulbir ji, pranam. > > > > Your explanation is simply marvelous and educating.Your point > > no.2 " not to prescribe remedies when your own planets are weak " is a > > very interesting and very very important topic for LK students, being > > your junior and a keen learner of LK i would request you to kindly > > explain this point further i.e the logic behind it, weak means in > > varshphal or natal chart etc. > > > > yours respectfully > > jitin syal > > > > , kulbir bance <kulbirbance@> > > wrote: > >> > >> Rajesh jh, since u want to learn and knowing that u r no novice. Go > > by > >> the thumb rule that planets of 6,8,12 have to be judged together. U > >> asked about only 2 planets. U forgot to mention planet venus placed > >> alongwith mercury, aspect of 2 plandets in 6. See how the situation > >> changes. Now take up the natal chart first. Check for rin pitri etc. > >> Then take the current age into account. Then check the problem faced > >> by native or likelihood of it. Also check his vastu. Ask about > >> condition of relatives and items to planets under purview. Believe > > me > >> u will find ur upayas can help the native by not more than 2%. > > However > >> i dare say that the native will face a calamity of dire consequences > >> but will ultimately come unharmed provided no unnecessary ched chad > > is > >> done with planets. Take it as a genuine advice 1 don't fiddle with a > >> pakka ghar ka grah. 2. Don't prescribe remedies for others qua > > planets > >> that are weak in ur own horoscope. Regards. Kulbir > >> > >> On 2/3/09, kalapandit68 <kalapandit68@> wrote: > >> > , kulbir bance <kulbirbance@> > >> > wrote: > >> >>res kulbir ji namskar > >> > i am very sorry if i put any thing in the wrong way i don't know > >> > that if we need to check all the planets.as i mention i am trying > >> > to learn .so sir rest of the planets are as below > >> > 1- empty > >> > 2-empty > >> > 3-empty > >> > 4-empty > >> > 5-moon > >> > 6-saturn,rahu > >> > 7-empty > >> > 8-mars > >> > 9-jupter,sun,ketu > >> > 10-empty > >> > 11-empty > >> > 12-mercury,venus > >> > thanks > >> > rajesh > >> >> Rajesh ji, plz send in the configration of other 7 planets also > > as > >> > the > >> >> querry is specific and i hope u don't want an academic discussion > >> > on > >> >> these 2 planets only. Kulbir > >> >> > >> >> On 2/1/09, kalapandit68 <kalapandit68@> wrote: > >> >> > respected members namskar > >> >> > i am trying to study LAL KITAB for that group members are god > >> > send > >> >> > even on phone calls they will help you out. know i was stuck > > at a > >> >> > promlem i could not find any solution so i am trying to write > > it > >> > down > >> >> > for respected members > >> >> > IF MARS IS IN 8TH HOUSE WE HAVE TO DO SOME UPAYS FOR IT > >> >> > BUT IF ON THE SAME TIME MERCURY IS IN THE 12 TH HOUSE IT IS > >> > MALIFIC TOO > >> >> > KNOW IF YOU TRY ANY UPAY TO HELP MERCURY IT WILL BE BAD FOR > > MARS > >> > MY > >> >> > QUESTION IS HOW YOU CAN DEAL WITH THIS PROBLEM thanks > >> >> > yours > >> >> > rajesh > >> >> > phagwara > >> >> > > >> >> > > >> >> > > >> >> > >> >> -- > >> >> Sent from my mobile device > >> >> > >> > > >> > > >> > > >> > >> -- > >> Sent from my mobile device > >> > > > > > > > > -- > Sent from my mobile device > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.