Guest guest Report post Posted March 24, 2008 advaitin , kuntimaddi sadananda <kuntimaddisada wrote: > > > > Anyway I understand Bhamati position. I just want to readers to make sure that > it is not necessarily the correct position of advaita - if chitta suddhi is > properly defined. That Bhamati's position is more correct than vivarana's > position is debatable. It may be suffice to state the position of the two > schools without making a judgment call. Or the best way I suggest is to present > the position of both schools and add ones personal comments underneath if one > wants to endorse one of them. But this requires an impartial position > presentation. > > Hari Om! > Sadananda Dear Sada-ji, I agree with you that we should confine ourselves to stating the different views and refrain from making any judgement. Even Appayya Dikshita who has collected the different views on many aspects in his Siddhantalesa sangraha has not given any opinion about which is correct. We are certainly not competent to judge them. Regards, S.N.Sastri > Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
