Guest guest Report post Posted December 20, 2005 Respected swamins, There was an argument on an issue relating to saathumurai. In our saathumurai, as we all know besides the two pasurams (29 and 30) of Thiruppavai and 1st and 2nd pasurams of Thiruppallandu are recited besides other things. Some old swamins maintain that these two pasurams of Thiruppallandu are not to be recited during Anandhyayanam period in Saathumurai while a few said that for saathumurai these two pasurams can be recited. Is there any firm view by scholars on this issue? Adiyen, Govindakrishnan Alagar. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest guest Report post Posted December 20, 2005 SrI: Though adiyen is not well versed on bhagavath vishayam, adiyen knows definitely that during anadhyayana kalam, for saathumurai, Thiruppallandu is not recited. Regards Dasan Srinivasan Govindakrishnan alagar wrote: >Respected swamins, There was an argument on an issue relating to >saathumurai. In our saathumurai, as we all know besides the two >pasurams (29 and 30) of Thiruppavai and 1st and 2nd pasurams of >Thiruppallandu are recited besides other things. Some old swamins >maintain that these two pasurams of Thiruppallandu are not to be >recited during Anandhyayanam period in Saathumurai while a few said >that for saathumurai these two pasurams can be recited. Is there any >firm view by scholars on this issue? Adiyen, Govindakrishnan Alagar. > Links > > > > > > > Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest guest Report post Posted December 20, 2005 Dear devotees my profound namaskarams to you all. According to the 'nithya anushtanam' book of the Ahobila mutt, the pallandu pasurams are not to be included in the Satrumurai during this period. Apart from the fact that one must meditate and glorify Godha devi during this month, why would srivaishnavas not sing even pallandu? is the restriction only for pallandu or even for all the other pasurams? adiyal geetha Oppiliappan, Srinivasan Narayanan <malaseen@o...> wrote: > > SrI: > > Though adiyen is not well versed on bhagavath vishayam, adiyen knows > definitely that during anadhyayana kalam, for saathumurai, > Thiruppallandu is not recited. > > Regards > > Dasan Srinivasan > > Govindakrishnan alagar wrote: > > >Respected swamins, There was an argument on an issue relating to > >saathumurai. In our saathumurai, as we all know besides the two > >pasurams (29 and 30) of Thiruppavai and 1st and 2nd pasurams of > >Thiruppallandu are recited besides other things. Some old swamins > >maintain that these two pasurams of Thiruppallandu are not to be > >recited during Anandhyayanam period in Saathumurai while a few said > >that for saathumurai these two pasurams can be recited. Is there any > >firm view by scholars on this issue? Adiyen, Govindakrishnan Alagar. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Links > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest guest Report post Posted December 21, 2005 Dear Sri Alagar : Different SampradhAyams follow different procedures in including and excluding specific items . At Ahobila Matam , ThiruppallANDu Paasurams are not included in SaaRRumuRai in Marghazhi and anadhyayana Kaalam . I will write about the items later in the day . NamO NaarAyaNAya , V.Sadagopan - "Govindakrishnan alagar" <alagar_g <Oppiliappan> Tuesday, December 20, 2005 1:15 AM saathumurai > Respected swamins, There was an argument on an issue relating to > saathumurai. In our saathumurai, as we all know besides the two > pasurams (29 and 30) of Thiruppavai and 1st and 2nd pasurams of > Thiruppallandu are recited besides other things. Some old swamins > maintain that these two pasurams of Thiruppallandu are not to be > recited during Anandhyayanam period in Saathumurai while a few said > that for saathumurai these two pasurams can be recited. Is there any > firm view by scholars on this issue? Adiyen, Govindakrishnan Alagar. > Links > > > > > > > Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest guest Report post Posted December 27, 2005 Dear Srimathy Geetha Rangarajan : Yes , it is the custom during the Maarghazhi Month not to sing PallANDu to highlight the glory of the message of ANDAL , the sishya and daughter of PeriyAzhwAr . PeriyAzhwAr would have liked it this way . Another reason : Since PallANDu is counted with the other Prabhandham of PeriyAzhwAr ( PeriyAzhwAr Thirumozhi) , in some sampradAyam , it is not recited along with other prabhandhams during the anadhyayanam period. Each Acharya tradition follows the path laid by its own previous AchAryAs . That is what we are to following with some attendant variations . V.Sadagopan - "geetha_rangarajan2000" <geetha_rangarajan <Oppiliappan> Tuesday, December 20, 2005 11:54 PM Re: saathumurai > Dear devotees > > my profound namaskarams to you all. According to the 'nithya > anushtanam' book of the Ahobila mutt, the pallandu pasurams are not > to be included in the Satrumurai during this period. > > Apart from the fact that one must meditate and glorify Godha devi > during this month, why would srivaishnavas not sing even pallandu? > is the restriction only for pallandu or even for all the other > pasurams? > > adiyal > > geetha > > > > Oppiliappan, Srinivasan Narayanan > <malaseen@o...> wrote: >> >> SrI: >> >> Though adiyen is not well versed on bhagavath vishayam, adiyen > knows >> definitely that during anadhyayana kalam, for saathumurai, >> Thiruppallandu is not recited. >> >> Regards >> >> Dasan Srinivasan >> >> Govindakrishnan alagar wrote: >> >> >Respected swamins, There was an argument on an issue relating to >> >saathumurai. In our saathumurai, as we all know besides the two >> >pasurams (29 and 30) of Thiruppavai and 1st and 2nd pasurams of >> >Thiruppallandu are recited besides other things. Some old swamins >> >maintain that these two pasurams of Thiruppallandu are not to be >> >recited during Anandhyayanam period in Saathumurai while a few > said >> >that for saathumurai these two pasurams can be recited. Is there > any >> >firm view by scholars on this issue? Adiyen, Govindakrishnan > Alagar. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest guest Report post Posted December 28, 2005 DEAR ALL, Let me add that during MARGAZHI, instead of PALLANDU,during SATRUMURAI,the THIRUPPAVAI PASURAM of that day is recited with KARPOORA HARATHI without BELL for example on the 14th day of MARGAZHI i.e on 29-12-2005 UNGAL PUZHAKADAI will be recited instead of PALLANDU DASAN, N.PADMANABAN sgopan <sgopan wrote: Dear Srimathy Geetha Rangarajan : Yes , it is the custom during the Maarghazhi Month not to sing PallANDu to highlight the glory of the message of ANDAL , the sishya and daughter of PeriyAzhwAr . PeriyAzhwAr would have liked it this way . Another reason : Since PallANDu is counted with the other Prabhandham of PeriyAzhwAr ( PeriyAzhwAr Thirumozhi) , in some sampradAyam , it is not recited along with other prabhandhams during the anadhyayanam period. Each Acharya tradition follows the path laid by its own previous AchAryAs . That is what we are to following with some attendant variations . V.Sadagopan - "geetha_rangarajan2000" <geetha_rangarajan <Oppiliappan> Tuesday, December 20, 2005 11:54 PM Re: saathumurai > Dear devotees > > my profound namaskarams to you all. According to the 'nithya > anushtanam' book of the Ahobila mutt, the pallandu pasurams are not > to be included in the Satrumurai during this period. > > Apart from the fact that one must meditate and glorify Godha devi > during this month, why would srivaishnavas not sing even pallandu? > is the restriction only for pallandu or even for all the other > pasurams? > > adiyal > > geetha > > > > Oppiliappan, Srinivasan Narayanan > <malaseen@o...> wrote: >> >> SrI: >> >> Though adiyen is not well versed on bhagavath vishayam, adiyen > knows >> definitely that during anadhyayana kalam, for saathumurai, >> Thiruppallandu is not recited. >> >> Regards >> >> Dasan Srinivasan >> >> Govindakrishnan alagar wrote: >> >> >Respected swamins, There was an argument on an issue relating to >> >saathumurai. In our saathumurai, as we all know besides the two >> >pasurams (29 and 30) of Thiruppavai and 1st and 2nd pasurams of >> >Thiruppallandu are recited besides other things. Some old swamins >> >maintain that these two pasurams of Thiruppallandu are not to be >> >recited during Anandhyayanam period in Saathumurai while a few > said >> >that for saathumurai these two pasurams can be recited. Is there > any >> >firm view by scholars on this issue? Adiyen, Govindakrishnan > Alagar. Visit your group "Oppiliappan" on the web. Oppiliappan Send instant messages to your online friends http://in.messenger. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest guest Report post Posted December 31, 2005 Dear Srivishnava Bhakthas, in response to the interesting mail by Shri. N. Padmanabhan, I want to add during Srivilliuttur Sir Andal an all the days will visit the Gopuram entrance of Sri Vatapatra sayee and the "naal paattu" (thiruppavai of that day} would be recited by Araiyar swamy. Adiyen, Srivilliputtur Govindakrishnan alagar. ________ DSL – Something to write home about. Just $16.99/mo. or less. dsl. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
