Shri Mohan Krity Arsh Tithi Patrak 2067

Dear Darshaneyji,

Namaste,

It is a pleasure hearing from you..

Further, I hope you will also agree that the word " Panchaanga " by definition

includes the Nakshatras as one of the five " Angas " . So in my opinion it is wrong

for Shri Kaul to say that the Hindu calendar  has to be without reference to the

Nakshatras. Thus the Hindu calendar has to be Sidereal but the Seasonal months

can be superimposed on it  and the seasonal year will begin from the month of

" Tapa " , which will start from the first shukla pratipada after the Winter

Solstice. Hope you will agree to this.

Secondly, Shri kaul probably does not know that the Atharva Jyotisha does

mention " Vara " , which is another " Anga " of Panchaanga " . He is unnecessarily says

that the Hindus borrowed the concept from the Greeks. To prove his point he will

not hesitate to lower the antiquity of our Vedas and the Vedangas. I don't know

how my other Hindu friends are tolerating him so long.

Thirdly,  he is unnecessarily harping on the issue of Rashi. Present-day  Hindu

calendars mention Rashi as the  Hindu calendar is also used by the followers of

Hindu astrology. If Shri kaul  wants to produce a Hindu calendar without Rashi

and want to ignore Hindu astrology there is no problem, except that his calendar

will not sell, but he cannot ignore the Nakshatras at all. With his Chaturai

(cunningness) he cannot convert Panchaanga to a Chaturaanga (ie.with four

" Angas " ).

Rashis are not required in Brahmana texts as the Rashis are not useful in the

rituals but the Rashis are mentioned in the Puranas (the Fifth Veda) and Vayu

Purana specially mentioned the how the 27 Nakshatras are distributed among the

12 Rashis. Even a school-boy will understand this that Rashis are by definition

Sidereal and the Tropical Rashis are fake Rashis.but Shri Kaul is unable to

understand this.

It is a pity that David Pingree's bhoot (spirit) has possessed him and you and

me cannot do anything about it. I now look forward to hearing from you.

Regards,

Sunil K. Bhattacharjya

--- On Mon, 9/7/09, darshaney lokesh <darshaneylokesh wrote:

darshaney lokesh <darshaneylokesh

Shri Mohan Krity Arsh Tithi Patrak 2067

" Sunil Bhattacharjya Bhattacharjya " <sunil_bhattacharjya

Monday, September 7, 2009, 7:37 PM

Dear Sunil Bhatacharya ji,

           Namastey. I have yet to reply your mail. I will certainly extend my

comments towards you.

Kindly keep waiting for few more days as  I am too much indulduged in the Patrak

work and  unable

in sparing that much time as it is needed   for an  elaborated reply to your

mail.

           How ever , to some larger extent I am agreeing with you.

Thanks.

                                                                                \

                        Darshaney Lokesh

Love Cricket? Check out live scores, photos, video highlights and more.

Dear Darshaneyji,Namaste,It is a pleasure hearing from you.. Further, I hope you will also agree that the word "Panchaanga" by definition includes the Nakshatras as one of the five "Angas". So in my opinion it is wrong for Shri Kaul to say that the Hindu calendar has to be without reference to the Nakshatras. Thus the Hindu calendar has to be Sidereal but the Seasonal months can be superimposed on it and the seasonal year will begin from the month of "Tapa", which will start from the first shukla pratipada after the Winter Solstice. Hope you will agree to this.Secondly, Shri kaul probably does not know that the Atharva Jyotisha does mention "Vara", which is another "Anga" of Panchaanga". He is unnecessarily says that the Hindus borrowed the concept from the Greeks. To prove his point he will not hesitate to lower the

antiquity of our Vedas and the Vedangas. I don't know how my other Hindu friends are tolerating him so long.Thirdly, he is unnecessarily harping on the issue of Rashi. Present-day Hindu calendars mention Rashi as the Hindu calendar is also used by the followers of Hindu astrology. If Shri kaul wants to produce a Hindu calendar without Rashi and want to ignore Hindu astrology there is no problem, except that his calendar will not sell, but he cannot ignore the Nakshatras at all. With his Chaturai (cunningness) he cannot convert Panchaanga to a Chaturaanga (ie.with four "Angas"). Rashis are not required in Brahmana texts as the Rashis are not useful in the rituals but the Rashis are mentioned in the Puranas (the Fifth Veda) and Vayu Purana specially mentioned the how the 27 Nakshatras are distributed among the 12 Rashis. Even a school-boy will understand this that Rashis are by definition Sidereal and the Tropical

Rashis are fake Rashis.but Shri Kaul is unable to understand this.It is a pity that David Pingree's bhoot (spirit) has possessed him and you and me cannot do anything about it. I now look forward to hearing from you.Regards,Sunil K. Bhattacharjya--- On Mon, 9/7/09, darshaney lokesh <darshaneylokesh wrote:darshaney lokesh <darshaneylokeshShri Mohan Krity Arsh Tithi Patrak 2067"Sunil Bhattacharjya Bhattacharjya" <sunil_bhattacharjyaMonday, September 7, 2009, 7:37 PMDear Sunil Bhatacharya ji, Namastey. I have yet to reply your mail. I will certainly extend my comments towards you.Kindly keep waiting for few more days as I am too much indulduged in the Patrak work and unable in sparing that much time as it is needed for an elaborated reply to your mail. How ever , to some larger extent I am agreeing with you.

Thanks. Darshaney Lokesh

Love Cricket? Check out live scores, photos, video highlights and more.

Dear All

Saturn will be in my 12 th house this day and my sadesati is starting.What is

your prediction about this situation? what is your suggestion about remedy for

sadesati. i am living in turkey and some remedies can not be performed here .I

am giving below my birth details.thank u very much.

Halil

birth time 02 april 1980 05.05 am

birth place : turkey tarsus 34E55 36N54

GMT +3

lagna starting from aquarius with merkur and ketu 2.house with sun 4.house with

venus, 7.house jup,sat, mars,rahu, 9. house with moon navamsa starting from

aquairus too with venus

_______________

With Windows Live, you can organize, edit, and share your photos.

http://www.windowslive.com/Desktop/PhotoGallery