Guest guest Posted March 19, 2004 Report Share Posted March 19, 2004 Hi, >It is not up to us to judge meat eaters. They reap enough punishment as it is, with more to >follow after death. <big snip> Yes, but for those of us who do not believe in god, an afterlife, or the existence of a soul, we often believe that it is up to humans to make the conditions of the world better in this life, not hope that justice will be meted out in the next. So I believe it is up to us - and hopefuly eventually society - to judge meat eaters, just as it is up to society to judge murders, rapists, torturers, etc. Besides, even if you do believe in god and an afterlife, surely that is no excuse to let this life go to hell for fear of judging those who, according to your framework of right and wrong, are wrong? As for meat-eaters being unhappy, I can safely say that I was a lot happier when I was eating meat in blissful ignorance. Meat tastes good. Not feeling guilt whenever you inadvertantly cause suffering feels good. Not finding your relationships with friends and family strained because of veganism is an easy out. Most meat eaters go through life enjoying their meat, and die without having suffered in any way because of this. And, to judge by the amount of people out there who wilfully deny any evidence put before them regarding the conditions of animals used for meat and products, I would say that most people enjoy their state of ignorance. As an aside, I hope this doesn't come across as anti-religious. That is not really my intent, other than where being religious serves as an excuse not to act in this life, which clearly does not apply to you. So apologies in advance if it sounded that way. And now, since I've filled up my last half hour of work on a Friday reading private emails, I'd best go make the dinner! Cheers, John Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.