Guest guest Posted August 26, 2003 Report Share Posted August 26, 2003 Here it is- section 5 of my Go Vegan series. You can find the other sections on previous posts. Hope you enjoy it Hugs, Tek Go Vegan 5: Protein Enriched " Hey!!!! Where do you get your protein from????? " The question that all veggies get asked over and over again. Will it ever end? If I ate a gram of protein every time I got asked that question, I would have cancer by now. Since the protein issue seems to be one that every veggie can relate to, I decided to make it the topic of the 5th section of my Go Vegan series. How much protein do we need? Do we get enough eating a vegan diet? I, like all veggies, hear these questions constantly. I hope this essay will address them adequately. This paper gets off track a little from my other Go Vegan essays since this topic is not about my personal upgrade to veganism. However, my goal was to write essays that other vegans can relate to, and to offer encouragement to those considering going vegan. I think this paper falls into that category. First, let me say that I am not a doctor, and I have no formal training in the field of medicine, nutrition, or health. (I almost took a nutrition class once, but I thought I would disagree with a lot of what the teacher said, and blow my grade). I consider lack of any formal training to be of no consequence; doctors do not agree with each other. It seems that no matter what your opinion is on health, nutrition, or diet, you can always find an army of doctors who have the same viewpoint as you do, and you can find just as many with the opposite view. However, it does not take an expert to understand proper nutrition; it only takes one to cipher through all of the misleading information and marketing. Proper nutrition, for the most part, follows general common sense. I will do my best in this paper to show that protein is no exception to that rule. Hopefully, I can accomplish that in just a few pages. Whole books have been written on this subject, so this will for the most part just touch the surface of discussing protein. Perhaps down the road I will write another Go Vegan on protein that will go more in depth. But for now, off we go into a brief discussion about what is probably the most widely misunderstood aspect of going vegan- Protein. The Big P! Critics of vegans usually claim that one will have a shortage of protein in a diet that does not contain meat. However, the truth is that we get plenty of protein from eating plants. A vegan diet provides more than the required daily amount of protein, despite common misconceptions. The myth that, to be healthy, meat is required is proven wrong by millions of healthy vegans everyday. We are mammals, and like all mammals, we require protein to live. In general, it would probably be safe to assume that the larger the mammal, the more protein that it needs. A cow needs more protein than we do, but all of the protein that it eats comes from plants. An elephant needs more protein than a human as well, yet all that it eats is leaves. If plants did not provide enough protein, would not these animals have protein deficiencies as well? There is no more of a shortage of protein in a vegan's diet than there is in an elephant's. Have you ever seen anyone with a protein shortage? Think about it. Have you even seen even one person with some sort of disease or ailment caused by a deficiency of protein? They simply do not exist. (I am not talking about people who are starving, drug addicts, or anyone who does not eat enough food in general). Here is one conversation you are NEVER going to hear- " Hey Joe, how ya doing? " " Ahh great now Frank, but I wasn't so good a few weeks ago. " " Yeah Joe? What happened? " " Well Frank, I was feeling run down and kind of sick, so I went to see my doctor. He said I had a protein shortage, so I went home and ate a couple of steaks. Now I feel super. " If a vegan diet does not provide enough protein, wouldn't hospitals be overflowing with vegans suffering from protein deficiency related illnesses? Where are all of these protein-starved vegans hiding? The fact is that, on average, vegans live a much more healthy, and longer life than that of meat eaters. There is no shortage of protein in a vegan diet; it provides exactly the right amount. How much protein is the proper amount? According to the Vegetarian Resource Group website, the U.S. RDA (United States Recommended Daily Allowance) is 0.36 grams of protein for each pound of weight (4/5s of a gram of protein daily for every kilogram of weight). This means a 180 pound man would need a daily protein intake of about 65 grams, and a 130 pound woman would need a daily protein intake of about 47 grams. However, the RDA always includes a generous safety factor, meaning that the amount of protein really needed is actually a little less than that amount. It is very easy to get the recommend daily amount of protein eating a vegan diet. Dr. Reed Mangels illustrates this in an article about protein on the Vegetarian Resource Group website. Dr. Mangels uses the following example to show that eating a simple vegan diet consisting of way less food that I eat provides more than an adequate supply of protein- Breakfast: Grams of protein 1 cup oatmeal 6 1 cup soy milk 9 1 bagel 9 Lunch: 2 slices whole wheat bread 5 1 cup vegan baked beans 12 Dinner: 5 oz firm tofu 16 1 cup cooked broccoli 5 1 cup brown rice 5 2 Tbsp Almonds 3 Snack: 2 Tbsp Peanut Butter 8 6 crackers 2 Total: 80 Grams Although this is not the diet that I would recommend for people to eat, it clearly shows that even very simple and basic vegan foods provide more protein than needed. My weight is in the low 180s, so this example shows that I would get plenty of protein eating this menu. The problem with this example is that when I am really hungry, I probably eat this much food in a meal, not in a day, which makes me a little bit nervous. This example also shows that a meat eating diet contains way too much protein. Adding a couple of servings of meat to the above menu would raise the total protein consumption for that day to a quantity close to 3 times the daily amount for an average woman, and twice the daily amount for an average man. Studies confirm this by showing that people who live on the typical American meat eating diet, on average, consume 2-3 times the amount of needed protein each day. People do not realize that there is protein in almost everything that they eat, and it all adds up. This is a widely misunderstood concept, so I will state it again- there is protein in almost everything that you eat, and it all adds up. The problem is not that vegans do not get enough protein; the problem is that meat eaters are getting way too much. Too much protein causes kidney problems, and leeches calcium from the body. In addition, animal protein comes from meat, which has no fiber, no complex carbohydrates, and is high in fat and Cholesterol. No fiber makes animal protein harder to digest, and really damages the system over the long term. A high meat/high protein diet has been related to a number of illnesses, including cancer, heart disease, stroke, and high blood pressure. Among the elderly who spent their lives following a typical American diet, these diseases are a literal plague. How much protein is misunderstood was recently demonstrated to me at a street fair. I volunteered to talk to people, and pass out literature about vegetarianism/veganism and animal rights at a local street fair for the group Last Chance for Animals. They have a nice booth they put up here in San Diego at local events. I was only there a couple of hours, but in that short amount of time, I received the " Big P Inquiry " several times. Most of the time it came from some protein flooded weight lifter type guy. What Testosterone Tom doesn't realize though is that having muscles is not necessarily a sign of being healthy. Intense weight lifting is very stressful and straining on the muscles, and on the rest of the body. Toss in a diet high in protein, and the heart, liver, digestive system, and colon will be stressed as well. Eating a high protein diet and power lifting may make one muscular, but it also makes one a good candidate for an early death. The best choice to live a long healthy life is to go vegan. A vegan diet provides the correct amount of protein- not too much, causing health problems, and certainly not too little. For over 20 years, I have seen attitudes toward a veggie diet slowly change. I can remember, years ago, if you told people you were a veggie, they looked at you like you were destined to die soon. Now it seems like most of the meat eating population will at least acknowledge that a veggie diet is a healthy one. Many are just having trouble letting go of the perception that protein must come from meat. Although it will be a slow process, I believe we are ushering in a new era. Some day, years from now, all or most people will eat a vegan diet. People will embrace compassion for animals, and will live in harmony with them. People then will look back on the vegans from today, and they will consider us pioneers. They will think of us as elitists. Go vegan- join the elite. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.