(Malaysia) Johor losing another wetland

[Guest guest]

From Malaysiakini.

 

Johor losing another wetland

CK Choo

May 11, 05 12:32pm

 

 

At the Pulai River estuary, hundreds of hectares of mangroves and a huge

seagrass bed in the middle of the Johor Straits are about to make way for

development.

 

Few picnickers would dare to plunge into the silty, smelly waters at Pantai

Lido in Johor Bahru. For decades, the heavily populated city has been

discharging pollutants directly into the Johor Straits, contaminating the

waters with sewage, heavy metals, oil and all kinds of garbage.

 

But less than 50km away in the southeast corner of Johor, where the straits

meet the open sea, the water condition is significantly different.

 

In fact, one will be amazed by the richness of the marine life that abounds

in this area, and in particular, the seagrass bed over a kilometre in length

and between 80-100m wide at Tanjung Kupang. It is arguably the largest

seagrass bed in Peninsular Malaysia.

 

The seagrass bed at Tanjung Kupang is exposed at low tide, resembling a

huge, verdant carpet between Johor and Singapore. Taking advantage of the

tide, wading birds flock to the area to feed and fishermen scour the

seagrass bed for clams, sea cucumber and udang belacan.

 

The mixed sand-mud bottom is not too difficult to walk on, but it would be

impossible to wade from end-to-end on this extensive ‘carpet’ before the

tide rises again.

 

The formation of such an extensive seagrass bed is probably due to the

precipitation of nutrients carried by the nearby Pulai River estuary. The

estuary itself drains 7,633.2ha of mangrove forest, consisting of 24 species

of mangrove and boasts the largest intact tract of riverine mangrove in

Peninsular Malaysia.

 

Despite the muddy surroundings, the waters that flow through the seagrass

meadows are remarkably transparent. Giant tropical eelgrass (Enhalus

acoroides) attenuates wave and tidal energy through long, dense leaves that

can reach 1-1.5m in length, and has a complex root system that accretes

sediment and recycles nutrients from the water column.

 

There are also nine other, smaller seagrass species interspersed amongst the

thick foliage that share some of these ecological functions. The environment

also allows seaweeds and epiphytic algae to flourish. Together, this

photosynthetic marine vegetation produces rich, oxygenated waters and

nutrients that support a myriad of animals.

 

Endangered species

 

Grouper, sea perch, snapper, threadfin and white pomfret are some of the

fish in the Pulai River estuary of high commercial value, while 15 species

of juvenile prawns spend the first few months of their early life here

before migrating offshore.

 

Though the economic value of the seagrass bed at Tanjung Kupang has hardly

been evaluated locally, scientists abroad have estimated that a hectare of

seagrass bed contributes US$3,000 annually to fisheries alone.

 

The denizens of the seagrass bed at Tanjung Kupang include several

endangered species listed by the World Conservation Nation. A cryptic fish,

which is superbly camouflaged amidst the submerged canopy and popularly

known for its male pregnancy, is no other than the seahorse.

 

The mixed brackish-marine environment in the Pulai River estuary is

inhabited by one seahorse species (out of 34 species found globally),

scientifically known as Hippocampus kuda. The seahorse's vertical body

allows it to manoeuvre steadily in the dense seagrass foliage while its

prehensile tail grapples onto most substrates.

 

A close relative of the seahorse, the crocodile pipefish Syngnathus

biaculeatus, is also a seagrass-dweller. The elongated, greenish body of the

pipefish exhibits an astounding mimicry to the Giant Tropical Eelgrass,

while its facial features look somewhat like a crocodile's. What is more

interesting is that the pipefish is usually found in pairs, with each male

carrying a few hundred eggs below its abdomen.

 

Perhaps the most enigmatic creature that frequents the seagrass bed is the

seacow or dugong. Once hunted for food by the aborigines in the Pulai River

estuary, the seacow population has declined to the extent where they are now

rendered ‘critically endangered’ globally. The latest human-dugong encounter

in the Pulai River Estuary was dismal. In 2003 a 1.3m- long baby dugong was

killed when it was entangled in a drift net at Pulau Merambong.

 

Protection and development

 

The Johor government made the right move in 2002 when it designated 9,126ha

of mangrove forest along the Pulai River as a Ramsar Site. The unique

estuary fulfils the criteria for Ramsar Site selection as set by the

Convention of Wetlands. It contains representative, rare or unique wetland

types, and endemic species of conservation importance that are under threat,

as well as supports a large population of waterbirds and juvenile fish

stocks.

 

The Ramsar Convention requires the Malaysian government to take all

necessary measures to ensure the maintenance of the ecological character of

Ramsar Sites. However, the original Ramsar boundaries of the Pulai River

mangrove site have been realigned to accommodate the presence of the Port of

Tanjung Pelepas (PTP), a coal-fired power plant and a petrochemical station

on the western bank of the Pulai River.

 

These mega projects are putting tremendous pressures on the biodiversity in

the area. The port, when the second phase of its expansion is complete,

would narrow the river mouth by more than 50 percent. This could alter the

tidal prism, salinity regime and water circulation within the river thus

affecting the biotic communities. The migration pathways of estuarine fauna

could be blocked as their habitat corridors get destroyed.

 

In addition, flooding may occur upstream and worsen in the rainy season.

These situations are likely to be aggravated by a 122ha bunker built

directly on the river mouth. The power plant, occupying 361ha, may cause the

surrounding water temperature to rise through its discharge of heated water

effluent. A slight increase in water temperature is known to kill off most

marine life.

 

We may wonder why the government gave the green light for such destructive

projects to take place in such an environmentally sensitive area.

 

The construction of the petrochemical station will mean a permanent loss to

one huge area of pristine mangrove forest. In the petrochemical station's

operational phase, oil, heavy metals, PCBs, radionucleoids may be discharged

into the water. The effects of these contaminants cause both acute and

chronic toxicity to all marine fauna and flora and remain a long time in the

human food chain.

 

On the eastern bank of Pulai River Estuary, an 8km strip of mangrove

shoreline has been earmarked for the construction of a warehouse joining the

PTP to the Second Link Causeway. Have we not learned to appreciate the roles

of mangroves in saving lives and properties after the catastrophic tsunami

last December?

 

The seagrass bed at Tanjung Kupang will also be hard hit by the warehouse

construction, as the loss of mangroves acting as buffer zones may propel

sediment loading and siltation on the seagrass bed.

 

Worse, plans are in store to allow cargo vessels to navigate through the

Johor Straits. It is feared that the seagrass bed, which occurs too near the

navigation lane, will be devastated by waves generated by cargo vessels if

not dredged. Pulau Merambong, which harbours coral reefs and seaweeds, is

also likely to be affected by the shipping activities.

 

Few success stories

 

Had all such environmental impacts been accounted for, the projects would

probably have been barred by the Department of Environment. The validity of

the environmental impact assessment report on these projects is highly

questionable. Somehow, political influence reigns, as the port of Tanjung

Pelepas is the country's top priority development project.

 

It would be absurd to believe that with the advent of massive development,

the ecological character of the Ramsar Site can still be preserved. Most

damage done is irreversible. Restoration can be costly, in terms of time and

money; besides, there are few success stories to date.

 

The United States, for example, had to spend $8 billion to cope with the

environmental problems created by developmental activities in the

Everglades, Florida. For the restoration of natural mangrove forests,

experts claimed that it would cost US$9,990 per hectare per year.

 

In developed countries like the US, legislation requires developers to

compensate for wetland loss through restoration or creation of another

wetland on a hectare for hectare(s) basis. Are our developers willing to pay

the price if such a quota is also introduced in Malaysia? Proper mitigation

measures are clearly cheaper yet more effective than restoration.

 

Wetland International director Dr Sundari Ramakrishna has cautioned that,

for development to take place in the coastal areas, 500m buffer zones of

mangroves should be retained to mitigate impacts of erosion and flooding.

She said Malaysia, which is a party to the International Environment

Agreements such as the Ramsar Convention since 1994, has a responsibility

and obligation to ensure that total caution must be taken to prevent any

irreversible damage to the wetlands and to the integrity of the wetlands in

terms of its ecological functions.

 

Defiance, ignorance and lack of commitment from both developers and the

relevant authorities have led to the disappearance of a huge expanse of

seagrass at Tanjung Adang. That seagrass bed, the size of several football

fields, was reclaimed by PTP over the past two years. Now the port is

closing in on another seagrass bed lying just a couple of kilometres away at

Tanjung Kupang, the last one in the Johor Straits.

 

 

 

 

--

CK CHOO is a marine biologist at the Kolej Universiti Sains dan Teknologi

Malaysia (Kustem) whose interest is doing research on seahorses. He can be

contacted at hippocampuskuda2005.

 

_______________

Find just what you are after with the more precise, more powerful new MSN

Search. http://search.msn.com.my/ Try it now.