Guest guest Posted August 13, 2004 Report Share Posted August 13, 2004 [EthologicalEthics] Digest Number 559 Thu, 12 Aug 2004 08:34:47 -0600 (MDT) BEKOFF MARC <marc.bekoff Symposium on animal welfare to be held in Beijing, China, August 23-24, 2004 Hello - a number of you have asked about this symposium that I organized with Aster Zhang so here is the original outline - there are some changes but in general most of these topics are still going to be represented along with a symposium on the plight of moon bears headed by Jill Robinson of Animals Asia - this is a wonderful opportunity get the word out to many people who are working very hard for animals in China and all over the world - mb _____ INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON ANIMAL WELFARE, BEIJING, CHINA, 23-24 AUGUST 2004 Organized by Marc Bekoff and Aster Zhang Minding animals and wild justice: Awareness, emotions, well-being, and heart Marc Bekoff Ecology and Evolutionary Biology University of Colorado Boulder, Colorado 80309-0334 USA marc.bekoff homepage:http://literati.net/Bekoff Marc Bekoff and Jane Goodall (Ethologists For the Ethical Treatment of Animals): www.ethologicalethics.org) Abstract: In my presentation I will discuss recent information concerning the evolution and ecology of animal cognition and animal emotions and show how these data can help us to understand animals more than is possible without paying careful attention to their " intelligence " and passionate nature. I will also consider some aspects of the evolution of fairness, cooperation, trust, and morality in nonhuman animal beings ( " animals " ) under the subject that I call " wild justice. " I will also discuss how Darwinian biology - his emphasis on evolutionary continuity - helps is to understand what other animals feel, and how this information can aid us in our attempts to (re)connect with animals and with other nature from our hearts as well as from our heads. Coexisting with carnivores in the U.S.: Overcoming prejudice and persecution Camilla H. Fox of Wildlife Programs Animal Protection Institute P.O. Box 22505 Sacramento, CA 95822 E-mail: chfox Ph: 916-447-3085 x215 Abstract: In the United States, conflicts between carnivores and people have traditionally been addressed by federal and state agencies through cooperative agreements with counties, municipalities, and other entities. This top-down approach to predator conflicts has relied heavily on lethal control methods, including trapping, poisoning, and aerial gunning. Public opposition to such methods, however, and greater understanding of the ecological importance of native carnivores has led to increased demand for innovative, humane, and ecologically sound approaches to conflicts. Collaborative, community-based approaches developed at the local level with input from stakeholders and support of the general public can yield more effective and longer lasting results than the present top-down model. This presentation will consider attitudes towards predators in the United States, the ecological repercussions of widespread lethal predator control, the significance of large carnivores in maintaining ecosystem health and biodiversity, and alternative approaches to addressing carnivore conflicts. Pet Assisted Therapy and it's relevance in Asian Society Nikki Green 15, Tai Om Shan Tsuen Lam Tsuen, Tai Po. N.T. Hong Kong Tel 852 28092147 or Fax: 852 28092114 or nikgreen Abstract: I would be speaking as a practicing Cross-cultural Person-Centred Psychotherapist. In my presentation I will briefly discuss recent studies outlining the difficulties which arise when using a Western paradigm in Psychotherapy with Asian clients and how Pet-Assisted Therapy can serve as a bridge, especially when working with children and the elderly. I will discuss the fundamental characteristics of the domesticated dog and why it makes him such a suitable candidate to assist us in therapy. As a case study I will be using the Dr. Dog program, (in which one of my dogs is involved), developed by Jill Robinson of Animals Asia, based in Hong Kong. The Case for a Uniform Global Ban on the International Trade in Bear Viscera and Derivatives: A View from the United States Adam M. Roberts Senior Research Associate Animal Welfare Institute PO Box 3650 Washington, DC 20007 Tel: 703-836-4300 Fax: 703-836-0400 Web: www.awionline.org Abstract: The market demand for bear gallbladders and bile is on the rise and is negatively impacting bear populations and individual animals worldwide. Mounting evidence points to a systematic pattern of killing bears in the United States and Canada in order to satisfy the demand for bear parts in consuming nations, primarily Asian markets. The bear parts trade is international in scope and difficult to regulate and contain. The current approach of trying to regulate the legal bear parts trade on a state-by-state basis in the United States and on a country-by-country basis globally has failed, and has actually facilitated the illegal trade in some instances. It is time to recognize the usefulness, if not the necessity, for national legislation uniformly prohibiting commercialization of bear viscera. In addition, an international moratorium on global trade in bear parts and derivatives is long overdue and much needed. Legal Protection of Great Apes in the United States Sheryl Wolf Professor of Law University of New Mexico, School of Law 1117 Stanford NE, Albuquerque, NM 87131, USA e-mail address: wolf Abstract: This paper will examine the legal protection--and lack of protection--afforded great apes in the United States, including the Animal Welfare Act and the recently enacted Chimp Act, which allocates funding for a retirement sanctuary for chimps previously used in medical research. The paper will discuss existing protections for apes in the settings of medical and psychological research, zoos and other exhibitions, the entertainment industry, sanctuaries, and the pet trade. The recent acquisition by the Center for Chimpanzee Care of 260+ chimps from the former Coulston Foundation (a breeding facility for medical research) will be used as a case study and a focal point for examining these issues. Problems associated with the 'Free-dripping Fistula Technique' as a method of bile extraction from Asiatic Black Bears Gail M Cochrane, BVMS MRCVS (Poster) Animals Asia Foundation Room 2401 Universal Trade Centre 3 Arbuthnot Road, Central, Hong Kong www.animalsasia.org gcochrane Abstract: The Asiatic Black Bear (Ursus thibetanus) is the only species of bear currently legally allowed to be extracted for bile within China. The 'Free-dripping Fistula Technique' is the only method allowed under current regulations. Bear farmers within China believe that this technique " can ensure the health of the bears and avoid their maltreatment " . Cholecystectomies performed on Asiatic Black bears rescued from bear farms which have had the 'Free-dripping Fistula Technique' performed indicates that cholecystitis, cholelithiasis, polyp formation and the presence of foreign bodies within the gall-bladder are common problems found in these bears, which would lead to significant health problems and a reduced lifespan. China's bear farming: issues of ethics, challenges and prospects Peter J. Li, Ph.D. Assistant Professor of Political Science Social Science Department University of Houston-Downtown One Main Street, Houston, Texas 77002 (713) 217-2471 lipj Abstract: Moral questions have been raised about China's bear farming. Despite declining profits, bear farming continues. What's the perceived direction of this " business " in the eyes of wildlife policy-makers in China? How will they respond to challenges of rising societal opposition and international pressure for change? What are their perceived solutions to bear farming? This study aims to find answers to these questions through a field trip to provinces with a concentration of bear farms and by conversing with officials in charge of Central and local wildlife protection. The Plight Of Animals in a diversified socio-economic-culture-religious-secular and largest democracy - A Case Study of this region Pradeep Kumar Nath. Founder / President Hony, Visakha S.P.C.A., 26-15-200, Main Road Visakhapatnam - 530001, Andhra Pradesh, India. PHONE : +91 +0891 +2564759 ; mobile : 98481 85652; vspcanath Abstract: As we enter into the eighth year of our efforts in the protection of animals, we confront various forms of exploitations of them for the insatiable forms of human beings and the morrow seems a renewed bleak of the minimum assurances of their existence. It is a factual presentation that owes its prominence of maturity ruptured by our determination of the cause. Unless we treat them with intelligence, do not interfere, have a codified living for them and all intellectuals agreeing their significant role, there could be a massive erosion. We believe in sharing the actuals to derive solutions and consolidate the effective measures already in vogue here to reach the objectives globally if possible. The fallacy of sustainable consumptive utilization of wildlife in Africa, the link between the Bush meat crisis and the community based win-win strateg ies to Conservation. Josphat Ngonyo Youth for Conservation jngonyo Telephone number: +254 733 617286 or +254 20 606479 Abstract: While the proponents of consumptive utilization of wildlife argue that it prov ides an incentive to poor countries to conserve their wildlife, a May 2002 repor t by The Maasai Environmental Resource Coalition on the hunting operations of Or tello Business Company in Tanzania had the following to say; " The voices of the Loliondo Maasai echo those of other indigenous communities across the country, whose complaints about mistreatment and overexploitation of their natural resource by profit-driven hunting companies have continued to go u nheeded. Like the Loliondo Masai, Tarangire, Oloonkiito, and Mkomanzi Maasai say the Government-sanctioned, unregulated hunting operations have detrimentally af fected their basic rights, environment and wildlife. " In addressing the community point of view and in seeking to answer the pertine nt question of the sustainability of consumptive utilization of wildlife in Africa, the presentation uses field research findings, information and powerful photos linked with: a. the Youth for Conservation's 5-year hands-on conservation work with local communities in and around Kenya's Parks and Reserves b. the Maasai Environmental Resource Coalition report on the Hunting Op erations of the Ortello Business Company in Tanzania and c. Traffic's " Food for Thought " - Research on Illegal Bushmeat Trade in East, Central and Southern Africa. d. Cropping Evaluation report of 2001 commissioned by Kenya Wildlife Se rvice and sponsored by USAID The presentation also seeks to explain the link between consumptive wildlife u tilization and the rampant illegal bush meat trade in West, Central, East and So uthern Africa while at the same time showing the impacts of consumptive utilizat ion in countries that practiced it. It is an arguable fact that conservation programs that alienate the involvemen t of local communities rarely succeed, the presentation therefore recommends pra ctical win-win community-based conservation strategies with incentives given to landowners and local communities to protect and preserve wildlife on their land. Refinement of the statistical and the ethological approaches to improve welfare of laboratory animals Maria Puopolo, Armelle Queyras, Gianni Laviola, Augusto Vitale and Enrico Alleva Section of Comparative Psychology Lab. Fisiopatologia di Organo e di Sistema Istituto Superiore di Sanit Viale Regina Elena, 299 00161 Roma, Italy Tel.: + 39-06-4990-3104 Fax: + 39-06-49387134 mpuopolo Abstract: The quality of data collected in animal research may be improved by following simple statistical and ethological rules: optimize experimental design and statistical analysis in order to reduce the number of subjects used and maximize the information obtained from the same subject; use physical and social enrichment to improve the psychophysical welfare of animals by promoting the expression of a more natural behavioural repertoire; refine the experimental procedures to minimize suffering. These rules may also prevent waste of animals. A review of the state of the art and some results obtained in our laboratory on rodents and non-human primates, will be presented. What can behavior science do for captive giant pandas management? Ronald R. Swaisgood, Ph.D. Field Biologist Center for Reproduction of Endangered Species Zoological Society of San Diego P. O. Box 120551 San Diego, CA 92112 FAX: 619-744-3346 Abstract: The historical performance of giant panda Ailuropoda melanoleuca captive breeding programs has been poor. Recent research has implicated that the lack of biological relevance of many breeding facilities has played a contributing role in reproductive failure. I will summarize efforts underway in western and Chinese institutions to enhance well-being through environmental enrichment, enclosure design, and husbandry practices, as well as potential links between well-being, biological relevance, and reproduction for the species. The focus will be on the positive role of systematic data collection and scientifically-guided management. Replacing Animals With Herbs in Traditional Oriental Medicine and Working to End Bear Farming in Asia Jill Robinson Founder & CEO Animals Asia Foundation Room 2401, Universal Trade Centre, 3 Arbuthnot Road, Central, Hong Kong SAR, China. Tel: (852) 27193340 Fax: (852) 27196716 Abstract: Whilst the worldwide demand for Traditional Medicines expands, there is growing concern surrounding the conservation and animal welfare impacts of wild and domesticated species utilised in the trade. In the past two decades, the practice of bear farming in Asia has shown that a well meaning initiative has escalated into an industry which continues to threaten wild populations of bears across the world - and which is inherently cruel. Valid research is revealing a growth in acceptable alternatives and, together with an ambitious programme which is rescuing 500 caged Moon Bears in China, is pioneering solutions for people and animals alike. The Growth of Factory Farming in China and its Associated Risks Joyce D'Silva Chief Executive Compassion In World Farming Charles House 5a Charles Street Petersfield, Hampshire GU32 3EH UK Phone: 0044 (0)1730 237377 Fax: 0044 (0)1730 260791 joyce www.ciwf.co.uk Abstract: As China's 1.3 billion people come out of poverty, they are demanding more and more meat. Meat production and consumption are both increasing massively i n China. The way the animals are reared is also being transformed rapidly. Instead of millions of people keeping one or two pigs in their backyards, commercial pig fa rms with many thousands of pigs are being established. Poultry production is al so being transformed with an increase in commercial battery egg production and a massive increase in intensive broiler chicken production. In factory farming systems, the animals are selectively bred for rapid growth or excessive milk or egg production, they are kept in isolation or in overcrowded sheds, are often fed an unnatural diet and are frequently prevented from carrying out their natural behaviours. Their lives are truly lives of misery - perhaps not worth living. This type of factory farming is modelled on systems currently used in Europe and North America. These cruel systems are now beginning to be phased out and banned in the European Union. Intensive systems are also environmentally polluting. Increased meat/saturated fat consumption can adversely affect human health. There are also possible risks from antibiotic resistance and bacterial contamination of meat. Compassion in World Farming is committed to ending cruel and unsustainable factory farming systems worldwide. The question is, how can China be persuaded to feed her people without resorting to the damaging techniques and systems which the West is now just beginning to abandon? Attitudes of Hong Kong Primary School age Children to Animals and Related Welfare Issues P. Grandison, W. K. Chan, A. E. James, and D. P. Johns Hong Kong (HK), is a unique city that has been influenced by both Chinese and European cultures. Chinese history and culture regards animal rights differently from the West and these traditional attitudes are still entrenched in the minds of the HKs young people, although animal welfare issues have a higher profile than in other Asian countries. This study has demonstrated that HK children who own pets are more empathetic towards animals and more supportive of animal welfare issues. Pet owning children have greater knowledge about animal care and treat animals more humanely than non-pet owner. The study has demonstrated that HK children support zoos as an educational experience. Buddhist teachings have a significant influence in the HK community, and many children believe that by performing Fong San (the Buddhist practice of releasing animals into the wild), they are respecting animal life, even though the release of the animal may not be in its natural habitat. The media is one of the main sources to pass the knowledge of animal to young people and organizations such as the SPCA and the Government should utilize these channels more effectively to pass animal welfare messages to the general public. Animal welfare in China Merritt Clifton Editor, ANIMAL PEOPLE P.O. Box 960 Clinton, Washington 98236 USA anmlpepl Telephone: 360-579-2505 Abstract: Discussion of the following topics: 1) Developing and promoting a cultural foundation for the cause, based on whatever pro-animal myths, history, philosophy, etc. can be found wherever one happens to be. In China there are the vegetarian monks of Shaolin, Buddhism, the belief in the " lucky cat, " and the tradition of keeping pet turtles, koi fish, and sometimes birds for several generations within one family. There is always something that can be researched, raised, and used to make humane values indigenous to the community. 2) Developing self-sustaining local support. Humane organizations can become self-sustaining and successful even in the most unlikely-seeming places, if they can learn to recruit and effectively use volunteers, and can avoid the frequent confusion of fundraising with begging. 3) Avoiding the shelter trap. Humane organizations frequently destroy themselves by trying to take in homeless animals and becoming overburdened, instead of sterilizing dogs and cats and educating against the attitudes that result in animals becoming homeless. This is especially important. The U.S. humane community mostly went in entirely the wrong direction for much of the 20th century, and we are still trying to undo the damage 4) Developing educational programs. Even organizations with next to nothing of material value can often do tremendous good as educators. 5) Developing communications. Selective breeding for reduced fear and distress can benefit poultry welfare Bryan Jones Roslin Institute Roslin, Midlothian EH25 9PS, Scotland Tel: + 44 (0)131 527 4466 Fax: + 44 (0)131 440 0434 E-mail: Bryan.Jones Abstract: Fear and distress can seriously damage poultry welfare, productivity and product quality. Furthermore, many consumers demand greater consideration for animal welfare. Identifying practical ways of reducing these harmful states is critical from a sustainable agriculture perspective. The Japanese quail was used as a model to determine potential benefits of a genetic approach. Selective breeding for a reduced adrenocortical response to brief restraint was associated with a non-specific attenuation of stress-responsiveness, decreased fearfulness, enhanced ability to produce stable phenotypes, greater sociality, accelerated puberty and increased egg production. Abandoned dogs living in italian rescue shelters: behaviour, stress and welfare Dr. Paola Valsecchi, F. Mondelli, and E. Prato Previde Dr. Paola Valsecchi Dipartimento di Biologia Evolutiva e Funzionale Universit degli Studi di Parma Parco Area delle Scienze 11/A 43100 Parma - Italy ph. 0039 0521 905671 fax: 0039 0521 905657 e-mail: valsecchi Abstract: In Italy, abandoned dogs once captured and sheltered cannot be euthanized unless they have untreatable diseases or unless they are dangerous. Every year the number of dogs living in shelters increases because adoptions do not counterbalance abandons, thus most dogs will stay there until they die. In shelters, dogs have to face a condition of social deprivation and a situation of boredom and frustration. Our study aimed to the evaluation of: dogs' behavior to describe their temperament and to define rehoming criteria; dogs stress through behavioural observations and physiological parameters; effects of an environmental enrichment program on dogs welfare. Animal welfare in the lab for research, study or education Kai Xue Lab of Environmental biotechnology P.O. BOX 2871,Beijing, 100085, China Phone: +86-10-62923562(O) +8610-62849014(D) Abstract: In middle school, all the students must anatomize frogs or other animals in the course of biology. In university, many students, whose major is medicine, biology, and soon, must cut animals in lab. Many scientists whose research area is biology related use animals in experiments without considering the animals welfare. I think we must reconsider such phenomenon. Maybe it is not necessary to use animals in some cases. Maybe there is a non-animal alternative. Now 70%-80% medical schools in the States dont cut animals for education purpose. We should try not to cause unnecessary pain and suffering for animals. Behavioural abnormalities in zoo carnivores and primates in India; Welfare issues with regard to their management in captivity Avanti Mallapur C/o Dr. Anindya Sinha, National Institute of Advanced Studies, Indian Institute of Science campus, Bangalore 560012 Karnataka, India Phone: +91 80 658 4036 Email: amallapur Abstract: Studies on wild animals in captivity have well documented the influence of captive environments on the behavioural repertoire and welfare of these animals. Similar studies conducted in Indian zoos have shown that a variety of factors influence the development of abnormal behaviour. For example, a study on leopards revealed that animals housed in enclosures with elevated resting sites exhibited lower levels of stereotypic pacing than those housed in barren enclosures. This paper will discuss the welfare issues regarding animals in Indian zoos and will emphasise the significance of behavioural and welfare studies to managing wild animals in captivity A need for zoo evaluations in China to improve standards of ethics and animal welfare Prof G. Agoramoorthy Affiliation and Full Address: Wildlife Reserves Singapore, 80 Mandai Lake Road, Singapore moorthy agoram Telephone number: 65-96759916 Abstract: The on-going illegal trade and uninterrupted habitat destruction have been forcing a variety of wildlife species to local extinction in many countries in Asia. Confiscated and abandoned wild animals in Asia are increasing in recent years, which boost over crowding, and also damage the quality of life in captive facilities such as zoos, recreational parks, and rehabilitation centers. As a result, the basic principals of animal welfare such as, freedom from hunger and thirst, freedom from thermal and physical discomfort, freedom from pain, disease and injury, freedom to express normal behavior, and freedom from fear and distress are being ignored. Public concern for captive animal welfare is evident in many countries in Asia. It is important to understand the ethical and animal welfare problems facing captive wild animals in Asian zoos today in order to make significant improvement to manage them. Being the Chairman of the South East Asian Zoos Association, I carry out zoo evaluations to assess ethics and animal welfare in member zoos in the region. During the evaluations, several major and minor problems are identified and constructive suggestions to zoo authorities are provided, which in turn significantly improve the standards of animal welfare. Thus the procedures tested in South East Asian zoos to assess ethics and welfare problems could serve as a model to be followed for zoos in China to improve captive animal welfare standards in general. On the origin and therapeutic efficacy of traditional animal-derived medicines Zu Shu-Xian, MD, MSc Founder, Educational Group for the Protection of Environment & Animals Anhui Medical University Hefei, Anhui 230032 Abstract: One thousand and fifty traditional animal medicines are included in an official book, Traditional Chinese Materia Medica, comprising in ten volumes published in 1997 and edited by an authoritative committee. However, assessment of the efficacy of almost all of the medicines derived from natural materials is generally based on the ancient works, which described individual experiences and anecdotes without any basis in deliberate scientific examination. It is recorded that even animal and human excreta are effective in the treatment of various diseases according to traditional Chinese medicine. In fact, traditional Chinese animal-derived medicines are essentially the same as other age-old medicines used in such as ancient Egypt, Greece, and India. Medicine originated in every culture from witchcraft, and the use of animals in remedies by primitive humans was based mainly on the perception that consuming particular parts of animals could magically convey the qualities of those animals into humans, that is the law of similarity or signature of homeopathic or imitative magic. The reasons based in the use of animal-derived medicines described in ancient classics may strike us as even ridiculous. Modern medicine came along when the newly active chemical drugs, sulfonamides and penicillin, were discovered and clinically used in around 1940. There were only few genuinely effective drugs that could be prescribed for treatment before these years. Clinical trial are now recognized as the only truly reliable method for assessing the efficacy of drugs and other medical treatments. Any drug to be used today should be evaluated by randomized controlled clinical trial. However, most of the traditional Chinese medicines, particularly those containing animal products, including tiger bone, rhinoceros horn, bear bile, musk and antler velvet as tonics or for the treatment of ailments, have never been assessed by well designed clinical trials, and no active ingredients of such items have ever been identified or tested using recognized scientific standards at all to support their use in the treatment of the illnesses and other conditions for which they are commonly used. Only two useful drugs,ursodeoxycholic acid (UDCA) and chenodeoxycholic acid (CDCA), have been derived from animal bile, for example, but these drugs are now produced by chemical semisynthesis, and are used for the dissolution of cholesterol gallstones. This current usage is completely different from the uses described in the ancient medicinal literature. Although the clinical indications and the effectiveness of UDCA are limited, bear bile remains incomparable with it, since no sound trial was done on bear bile at all. Unfortunately, the preparations containing bear bile continue to be promoted to treat a number of diseases and as tonics by bear farm. Therefore, using this kind of ineffective medicines from wildlife does not only threaten the survival of animals, but also puts a heavily burden to our national health care system. Why do people believe in these ineffective animal-derived medicines? Basically, they have their roots in traditional culture, and have also been encouraged by the authorities for more than fifty years. Now the use of traditional animal-derived medicines is additionally being promoted for profit by medicinal animal farms and the manufacturer of traditional medicines. There are several reasons why an ineffective drug or treatment can be mistakenly thought to be effective with out undergoing a well-designed clinical trial. First, there is a possibility of poor diagnosis. It is self-evident that an accurate diagnosis is essential to successfully treat a patient, particularly in a clinical trial. But in traditional Chinese medicine, only the symptoms are treated or a set of syndromes loosely identified, which may be caused by a series of conditions ranging from the very mild to the fatal. Secondly, most diseases are self-limiting, and even cancer may also undergo spontaneous remission. This is why a control group comparable to the group tested should be included in any clinical trial. Thirdly, an effective result may be merely a placebo effect. Therefore a placebo should be used in the control group. Traditional Chinese medicines have never subjected to critical assessment. As a rule, any drug or treatment should be considered as ineffective, unless it is proven to be effective. This rule protects the interests of patients, and is now enshrined in the laws of most nations. REHABILITATION OF SLOTH BEARS RESCUED FROM ILLEGAL WILDLIFE TRADE Geeta Seshamani Wildlife O. S. D-210,DEFENCE COLONY, NEW DELHI - 110 024. INDIA wsos Telephone number: 00 91 11 246 21939 / 00 91 9810000254 SLOTH BEAR CONSERVATION - EXPOSING BEAR CUB POACHING WITH ANTIPOACHING MEASURES & POACHER / TRADER REHABILITATION Kartick Satyanarayan Wildlife O. S. D-210,DEFENCE COLONY, NEW DELHI - 110 024. INDIA wsos / karticksatyanarayan Telephone number: 00 91 11 246 21939 / 00 91 981011 4563 The China Dogs (Poster) Ellie Maynard PO Box 642 Tauranga, New Zeland conectus Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.