Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org

How bath, relaxing herbs for yin deficiency?

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Guest guest

Is a hot bath with relaxing herbs in it contraindicated for someone with yin

deficiency. Someone asked me that question and reported how much better the

person felt in the morning. I was interested in any of your opinions?

 

 

 

I remember Miriam Less once said, " no heat, no yin efficiency " - I've

wondered about that. Can one have yin deficiency without heat.

 

 

 

What if both yin and yang are deficient?

 

 

 

Michael Tierra

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Supplementary to this, I have often wondered precisely what a Sauna (and part

II, followed traditionally by jumping in the snow or ice cold water naked) does

in terms of Chinese Medical physiology. Obviously, it very powerfully opens the

pores and triggers sweating, followed, in the case of jumping in the snow, with

closing the pores. It must invigorate the Wei Qi circulation mechanism. Any

other thoughts. When might one consider it particularly indicated,

contraindicated?

 

, " Michael Tierra " <mtierra wrote:

>

> Is a hot bath with relaxing herbs in it contraindicated for someone with yin

> deficiency. Someone asked me that question and reported how much better the

> person felt in the morning. I was interested in any of your opinions?

>

>

>

> I remember Miriam Less once said, " no heat, no yin efficiency " - I've

> wondered about that. Can one have yin deficiency without heat.

>

>

>

> What if both yin and yang are deficient?

>

>

>

> Michael Tierra

>

>

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

I'd say that it does more then just invigorate the wei qi (or yang qi). I did my

master's thesis on the effect of sauna on male fertility. We had twelve

volunteers take a sauna two times per week and for a period of three weeks. We

had a control group as well. Sperm motility and count decreased significantly

during the sauna period compared to the control group. The effect was temporary

and cleared during the follow-up period.

 

I'm puzzled as to how to explain this phenomenon in terms of chinese medicine,

but still it is a good thing to know and tell to the infertility couples that

you treat. Obviously it has to do with the rise in temperature of the testes,

but I don't know if tcm has an explanation for this. It can't be wei qi that

does the damage, maybe heat that scorches the tissues of the testes leading to

local stagnation and stasis?

 

I also interned in Finland for three months and took lots of sauna and rolled in

the snow there :-) I'd say that sauna is contra-indicated with qi vacuity. Try

it when you're tired, you won't feel well.

 

Can't think of anything else to add now.

 

best,

 

Tom.

 

, " daniel.schulman "

<daniel.schulman wrote:

>

>

> Supplementary to this, I have often wondered precisely what a Sauna (and part

II, followed traditionally by jumping in the snow or ice cold water naked) does

in terms of Chinese Medical physiology. Obviously, it very powerfully opens the

pores and triggers sweating, followed, in the case of jumping in the snow, with

closing the pores. It must invigorate the Wei Qi circulation mechanism. Any

other thoughts. When might one consider it particularly indicated,

contraindicated?

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

I was told by my Chinese doctor that taking Bikram yoga, where there is high

heat and a lot of sweating, would not be good for me. The reasoning from a

CM perspective was that the sweating would deplete Stomach Fluids, which are

the source of Blood. In the Classical CM line of thinking, the ST is in

charge of Blood, the LI in charge of Jin fluids and SI in charge of Ye. But

all fluids are seen to come from the ST. I'm speculating, but perhaps the

Ye (hormones) might be damaged by profuse sweating as well.

 

I am reminded of the first cloning experiments with Dolly, the sheep. I

think I remember reading that the cloning experiments failed until the

scientists began to pay attention to not only the cellular components they

were working with, but also the fluid environment of the cells. When they

retained the proper fluid matrix for the cells, the cloning succeeded. (not

advocating cloning!)

 

And we say Qi follows sweat out of the pores, so it makes sense that a Qi

def person would not feel good after a sauna.

 

In my own experiments with this high heat and profuse sweating of Bikram

Yoga, I would say, yes, the body bounces back if you stop. But also the

body adapts to the demands if you continue - you don't sweat so much, and

the body seems to retain more fluids than normal. (Only talking about

retaining more fluids here, not speaking to the fertility issue.)

 

RoseAnne

 

 

 

2010/4/28 verhaeghe_tom <tom.verhaeghe

 

> I'd say that it does more then just invigorate the wei qi (or yang qi). I

> did my master's thesis on the effect of sauna on male fertility. We had

> twelve volunteers take a sauna two times per week and for a period of three

> weeks. We had a control group as well. Sperm motility and count decreased

> significantly during the sauna period compared to the control group. The

> effect was temporary and cleared during the follow-up period.

>

> I'm puzzled as to how to explain this phenomenon in terms of chinese

> medicine, but still it is a good thing to know and tell to the infertility

> couples that you treat. Obviously it has to do with the rise in temperature

> of the testes, but I don't know if tcm has an explanation for this. It can't

> be wei qi that does the damage, maybe heat that scorches the tissues of the

> testes leading to local stagnation and stasis?

>

> I also interned in Finland for three months and took lots of sauna and

> rolled in the snow there :-) I'd say that sauna is contra-indicated with qi

> vacuity. Try it when you're tired, you won't feel well.

>

> Can't think of anything else to add now.

>

> best,

>

> Tom.

>

> , " daniel.schulman "

> <daniel.schulman wrote:

> >

> >

> > Supplementary to this, I have often wondered precisely what a Sauna (and

> part II, followed traditionally by jumping in the snow or ice cold water

> naked) does in terms of Chinese Medical physiology. Obviously, it very

> powerfully opens the pores and triggers sweating, followed, in the case of

> jumping in the snow, with closing the pores. It must invigorate the Wei Qi

> circulation mechanism. Any other thoughts. When might one consider it

> particularly indicated, contraindicated?

> >

>

>

>

>

> ---

>

> Chinese Herbal Medicine offers various professional services, including a

> practitioner's directory and a moderated discussion forum.

>

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

I remember when I posited that the stomach is the seat of yin because fluid

and blood is what creates yin. Lots of arguments about that. It was only a

thought and a perspective. May not be strict TCM theory.

 

 

I've spent decades trying to master TCM theory and I must confess that while

my understanding has deepened certain aspects of it complete eludes. It

seems that TCM is circular reasoning par excellence meaning that there is

always a way out of every paradox usually with another paradox.

 

 

 

 

 

Despite the effort to standardize or believe that there is an orthodoxy -

there are so many schools of thought with many of the contradicting each

other.

 

 

 

 

How many times have I heard that moxa is contraindicated for yin deficiency

for instance only to attend a so-called authority who emphatically claims it

is not?

 

 

 

Then there is the depletion of qi or yin when we sweat? Then we can say that

sweating depletes blood and exhausts yang.

 

 

 

Don't you ever feel confused by these pronouncements as I do sometimes?

 

 

 

So I think we should occasionally risk our ignorance to ask questions so we

can learn from each other's experience.

 

 

 

Michael

 

 

>

>

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

It seems that TCM is circular reasoning par excellence meaning that there is

always a way out of every paradox usually with another paradox.

Despite the effort to standardize or believe that there is an orthodoxy there

are so many schools of thought with many of the contradicting each

other.

 

Lonny: I look at CM as a science of tendencies. The contradictions are often,

though not always, resolved in the specific case in front of me. When the

conflict is not resolved I assume the confusion lies within me, not in the

reality presenting itself. Conflicting theories and perspectives are, like

language, context sensitive. I don't need a rule that covers all situations, I

need to recognize the context and then know which principle to apply.

 

In Western science and medicine, which is largely based on deductive reasoning,

we apply an immutable principle to all cases. But CM is rooted in deductive

reasoning and here we select the principle that fits the reality.

 

" The patient is sweating and yang is depleted and hence the appropriate response

is XYZ. " " The patient is sweating and yin is depleted and hence the appropriate

response is pdq. "

 

The only rule I've ever found that covers all scenarios is " do the right thing " .

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Alon,

isn't sweat " ying " , which is exuded through the pores because the yang of

the heart

" steams " the nutritive of the pericardium ? Therefore the heart governing

sweat, not the lungs ?

How is it more yang than yin? If we lose sweat, we lose yang, but don't

we also lose yin?

 

K

 

 

 

 

On Thu, Apr 29, 2010 at 11:22 AM, alon marcus <alonmarcus wrote:

 

>

>

> From SHL perspective sweat is yang

>

>

> 400 29th St. Suite 419

> Oakland Ca 94609

>

>

>

> alonmarcus <alonmarcus%40wans.net>

>

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

I know that sweating is thought to damage the yang, but the " sweat " itself

is yang? Not really sure what this means, where does it say this in the SHL?

 

 

 

-Jason

 

 

 

 

On Behalf Of alon marcus

Thursday, April 29, 2010 12:23 PM

 

Re: How bath, relaxing herbs for yin deficiency?

 

 

 

 

 

From SHL perspective sweat is yang

 

 

400 29th St. Suite 419

Oakland Ca 94609

 

 

 

alonmarcus <alonmarcus%40wans.net>

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Lonny wrote:

In Western science and medicine, which is largely based on deductive

reasoning, we apply an immutable principle to all cases. But CM is rooted in

deductive reasoning and here we select the principle that fits the reality.

 

Lonny, do you mean that CM is rooted in " inductive " reasoning or " deductive "

reasoning?

or both?

K

 

 

 

 

On Thu, Apr 29, 2010 at 7:27 AM, Lonny <revolution wrote:

 

>

>

> It seems that TCM is circular reasoning par excellence meaning that there

> is always a way out of every paradox usually with another paradox.

> Despite the effort to standardize or believe that there is an orthodoxy

> there are so many schools of thought with many of the contradicting each

> other.

>

> Lonny: I look at CM as a science of tendencies. The contradictions are

> often, though not always, resolved in the specific case in front of me. When

> the conflict is not resolved I assume the confusion lies within me, not in

> the reality presenting itself. Conflicting theories and perspectives are,

> like language, context sensitive. I don't need a rule that covers all

> situations, I need to recognize the context and then know which principle to

> apply.

>

> In Western science and medicine, which is largely based on deductive

> reasoning, we apply an immutable principle to all cases. But CM is rooted in

> deductive reasoning and here we select the principle that fits the reality.

>

> " The patient is sweating and yang is depleted and hence the appropriate

> response is XYZ. " " The patient is sweating and yin is depleted and hence the

> appropriate response is pdq. "

>

> The only rule I've ever found that covers all scenarios is " do the right

> thing " .

>

>

>

 

 

 

--

 

 

""

 

 

www.tcmreview.com

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

> Lonny, do you mean that CM is rooted in " inductive " reasoning or " deductive "

> reasoning?

> or both?

>

 

Hi John, Yes I meant " inductive " . Thanks!

 

IN CM we fit the theory to the facts. In Western medicine we fit the facts to

the theory.

 

A.Western Medicine: " John has one sided neck pain, a sour taste in his mouth,

and yellow palms but his liver enzymes are fine and, therefore, so is his

liver. "

 

B. CM: " Mary and Jack will be great for each other, her metal compliments his

fire " . " Of course they are getting divorced his fire over controls her metal " .

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

" isn't sweat " ying " , which is exuded through the pores because the yang of

the heart

" steams " the nutritive of the pericardium ? Therefore the heart governing

sweat, not the lungs ?

How is it more yang than yin? If we lose sweat, we lose yang, but don't

we also lose yin? "

 

 

 

My reply:

 

I'm not disagreeing with you only pointing out some of the problems trying

to understand things based on the Chinese idea that something is defined by

what it does. Still what exactly does the TCM pericardium do that

distinguished it from the heart. In fact as you all know some TCM

authorities consider the Pericardium as the extension of the heart.

 

 

 

We know what the pericardium is in Western physiology and it has nothing to

do with how that term is used in TCM. I've been trying to figure out -

perhaps one of you can help me with this - how the Chinese came to name and

associated specific anatomical organs and then are so hit and miss in terms

of the actual physiological function of the some of the organs. A huge

question for me -- help?

 

 

 

The TCM spleen for instance has little to do with the physiological spleen -

thought it does encompass some of the functions of the pancreas - so why is

it called " spleen " - does the Chinese " Pi " actually mean western Spleen or

was this some kind of Soulie de Morant interpretation. To take this on would

be a major overhall of TCM language.

 

 

 

So maybe Bob Flaws is right, we can never understand TCM on its own terms

without knowing the language but still does " shen " actually mean " kidneys " ?

does " Pi " actually mean " Spleen " etc.

 

 

 

So the conversation gets confusing when we know that 'sweat' in TCM actually

means what the word is but " pericardium " doesn't. So we are left with

something a little more solid than belief in TCM when we say that something

is because it is because it is because it is -- without, to quote Bill

Clinton, a clear concrete definition of what " it " is.

 

 

 

Michael Tierra

 

 

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Is it that the reasoning is circular, or that different methods of logic are

being used (as Lonny suggests)? Or it it simply that in different eras of

the medicine, different theories prevailed and we have the living legacies

of many of these different versions today.

 

It seems to me, though, that one could make the case for the Stomach being

the seat or source of 'post-natal' Yin, if one believed the ST to be the

source of Fluids and Blood. (I think that belief comes from the SP/ST

School. But please someone correct me if I am wrong.)

 

RA

 

On Wed, Apr 28, 2010 at 1:32 PM, Michael Tierra <mtierrawrote:

 

> I remember when I posited that the stomach is the seat of yin because fluid

> and blood is what creates yin. Lots of arguments about that. It was only a

> thought and a perspective. May not be strict TCM theory.

>

>

> I've spent decades trying to master TCM theory and I must confess that

> while

> my understanding has deepened certain aspects of it complete eludes. It

> seems that TCM is circular reasoning par excellence meaning that there is

> always a way out of every paradox usually with another paradox.

>

>

>

>

>

> Despite the effort to standardize or believe that there is an orthodoxy -

> there are so many schools of thought with many of the contradicting each

> other.

>

>

>

>

> How many times have I heard that moxa is contraindicated for yin deficiency

> for instance only to attend a so-called authority who emphatically claims

> it

> is not?

>

>

>

> Then there is the depletion of qi or yin when we sweat? Then we can say

> that

> sweating depletes blood and exhausts yang.

>

>

>

> Don't you ever feel confused by these pronouncements as I do sometimes?

>

>

>

> So I think we should occasionally risk our ignorance to ask questions so we

> can learn from each other's experience.

>

>

>

> Michael

>

>

> >

> >

>

>

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

PMPH press recently released a good book called Clinical Reasoning in Chinese

Medicine by Hu Zhen and Dong Fei-xia. It is a study of the methodology of

and have it useful in teaching Principles of Treatment and the

Fundamentals classes. Chapter 2, relevant to this conversation, has descriptions

of reasoning involving deductive, inductive, analogical, dialectical,

associative, assumptive, instinct, inspiration, and insight.

 

doug

 

 

, " Lonny " <revolution wrote:

>

>

> > Lonny, do you mean that CM is rooted in " inductive " reasoning or " deductive "

> > reasoning?

> > or both?

> >

>

> Hi John, Yes I meant " inductive " . Thanks!

>

> IN CM we fit the theory to the facts. In Western medicine we fit the facts to

the theory.

>

> A.Western Medicine: " John has one sided neck pain, a sour taste in his mouth,

and yellow palms but his liver enzymes are fine and, therefore, so is his

liver. "

>

> B. CM: " Mary and Jack will be great for each other, her metal compliments his

fire " . " Of course they are getting divorced his fire over controls her metal " .

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Yes Koko but when u look at most references in SHL you can see that

sweat can deplete yang and be caused by yang def. From what i

understand JJZ almost always cleared heat in order to preserve yang

 

 

400 29th St. Suite 419

Oakland Ca 94609

 

 

 

alonmarcus

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Jason u are right, it more about damage to yang and resulting from

yang def.

 

 

400 29th St. Suite 419

Oakland Ca 94609

 

 

 

alonmarcus

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

, " Michael Tierra " <mtierra wrote:

> So the conversation gets confusing when we know that 'sweat' in TCM actually

> means what the word is but " pericardium " doesn't.

 

Sweating is an obvious phenomenon that will be perceived similarly by any

culture at any point in history. However, something like the liver's function

(biomedically) requires specialized technology. The Chinese had a lot of

experience looking at animal tissues, but let's face it, if you don't even have

a microscope then looking at the liver or spleen provides little clue as to

function. How would the ancient Chinese possibly have ascribed similar

functions to those that we observe today with biomedicine? They just created

hypotheses and therapies, and bent the theory to fit the therapeutic response

that they observed.

 

Technology brings new concepts and theories that weren't fully developed before.

In ancient times, common people could rarely waste enough fuel to create a hot

bath, and ice was unknown except when it occurred naturally in winter or in

glaciers. China didn't have the sauna culture of Northern Europe, so why would

we expect the ancient Chinese to have been experts on the effects of saunas?

East Asian cultures love hot springs and they now use hot-cold contrast, but our

modern views on hydrotherapy often depend upon having access to conditions and

technologies that simply weren't widespread back in the day.

 

Eric

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...