Guest guest Posted April 14, 2005 Report Share Posted April 14, 2005 Really for USA & Canadian readers: Recently, I have been alarmed at information on herbs for pregnancy finding its way onto newsgroups via people who have no sound training in the subject. Information is being taken from old herbals without a second thought being given as to if modern knowledge has indicated particular herbs might pose dangers in early pregnancy. Some herbs may well interfere with the development of a foetus in the first 3 months of development. For example, it is wise in the first 3 months to avoid any herb that might have a hormonal action. For example, Hibiscus tea has been shown to decrease male fertility - a hormonal action. Borage herb contains dangerous alkaloids that while probably having little effect on an adult, might disrupt liver formation in an early foetus. Several of the traditional Native American herbs while being fantastic for gynaecological conditions should not be used in early pregnancy. Indeed in most cases they were not used in early pregnancy in that culture; they tended to be reserved for much later in pregnancy after the early developmental processes in the foetus had ceased. Some herbs were used to overcome the effects of malnutrition and to restart the menstrual cycle so that a pregnancy could be achieved. However, once menstruation commenced, the herbs were usually stopped and nature left to do its job till closer to labour. Over the last few years I have noticed a big growth in poor information about herbal medicine coming onto the internet. The same thing is happening with herbs as happened years ago with essential oils. This is that many people think they can learn all they need to know from books; from taking low quality training courses, or from the internet. Some of these people then come onto newsgroups acting as if they are very knowledgeable when they really are not. Often these people have not even been taught how to evaluate the accuracy of what their teachers have told them, but instead have simply fallen for scam marketing. In the USA in particular, you have a tradition of spreading herbal knowledge without its real worth or origin being evaluated. With a lot of herbal medicine it is vital to know the medical and botanical sciences and to know the side effects of giving the wrong herbs at the wrong time, or for the wrong conditions. It is this aspect of the therapy which is often lacking in their own training of some big name 'erbalists' in the US and Canadian scene. When I trained in the UK in the mid 80s, we had a few American and Canadian students who came to the UK for up to 4 years. Reason they did that was because back home there were no herb training courses that taught the sciences of herbs or medicine properly. Those practitioners are now working in your countries, but they are few and far between compared to the many whose fundamental knowledge is severely lacking. Some of the advice popping up on newsgroups has the potential to cause far more harm than good. The internet has engendered a culture of grab what information you can and don't bother getting professional help. In any profession one has to pay for sound advice due partly to the length of time it takes to train. Why do you think a REAL Shaman takes up to 10 years to train? In South America you may not pay him or her in cash, but you sure do have to pay, either with a chicken, pig or a pouch of tobacco. You cannot possibly expect to get such professional advice from people who have done a few weekends courses in the subject, or who have just taken what they know out of books. On this group I have seen poor advice given on herbs, but I usually don't jump in because in adults the advice wont cause much of a problem. However, with pregnancy this is another ballgame and you must beware of taking and giving advice on this subject as far as herbs are concerned. If you happen to be on any newsgroups involving pregnancy feel free to repost this or issue your own warnings. Martin Watt http://www.aromamedical.com Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 14, 2005 Report Share Posted April 14, 2005 Thank you Martin! I agree with you wholeheartedly. Cherry , " aromamedical2003 " <aromamedical-2@l...> wrote: > > Really for USA & Canadian readers: > > Recently, I have been alarmed at information on herbs for pregnancy > finding its way onto newsgroups via people who have no sound training > in the subject.... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 15, 2005 Report Share Posted April 15, 2005 Martin- Thank you for this post- its something that has always been a concern of mine. I have similar concerns about nursing mothers. Melissa > Recently, I have been alarmed at information on herbs for pregnancy > finding its way onto newsgroups via people who have no sound training > in the subject. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.