Guest guest Posted June 7, 2004 Report Share Posted June 7, 2004 Hi Laura, > Butch, > I hear what you are saying (and I know I have heard you say it > before ; ), but I got the impression from your and Christa's > replies that eo's were *not* effective against virus'. I expect mebbe we were being cautious enough to NOT say it can KILL a virus .. I didn't mean to say it would not be effective. Catnip oil will not KILL mosquitos .. but it is effective against them. Tear gas will not kill rioters .. but it can make them go away. ;-) >>>>We can't kill a virus but we can make it wanna go into retrograde >>>>by doing all we can to increase our weakened immune system. > > So, if I am understanding you correctly, you believe that they > may not kill a virus, but slow it down? We can't kill something that is not alive .. viruses are not complete critters .. they lack the RNA structure to survive and replicate on their own .. they must combine with the RNA of living cells .. so its not only safe but technically correct to say that we can't kill them. But they are also capable of replicating at an alarming rate and it is safe to say that we can stop that replication. The virus itself can only mutate so many times .. each one of the dudes has a relatively short shelf life .. note I avoid the word " life " . Its hard to find information on viruses today because all searches refer us to PC problems. But here is one useful definition: " A biological virus infects a (prokaryotic or eukaryotic) cell by injecting its own DNA into the cell. The injected DNA " hijacks " the infected cell's replication mechanism, and results in replication of the viral DNA. After many viral copies are created, the cell wall lyses (dissolves) and the new virus copies emerge and infect yet other cells. " So .. the trick is to stop the viral invader from collapsing the human cell and replicating. Some more information here .. http://www.ucmp.berkeley.edu/alllife/virus.html > I'm just a bit confused and trying to understand. This is a science unto itself .. and one where the scientists spend a lot of time scratching their heads. Even classifying them is tough as the only distinguishing features are shape .. and that requires very sophisticated electron microscope. Examples of shape identification is the Ebola virus .. its called the Shepherd's Crook because its looks like the old staffs traditionally used by shepherds. Antiviral therapy is tough .. its not like finding a way to create a simple vaccine to kill LIVE bacteria .. the two basic requirements for antiviral therapy run hand in hand with what we are talking about here: 1. That the process targeted be essential for virus replication. 2. That the therapeutic agent is active against the virus while having " acceptable toxicity " to the host organism. So .. again we are talking about stopping replication and not killing the host of the virus. The latter point is crucial because we can stop the replication of viruses by killing the host .. and unfortunately, a few cases of killing folks who had Ebola have been reported from some villages in Africa. It worked .. and with Ebola the death rate is 80% within 10 days anyway and the manner of death is horrible. But we in the West do things differently than some other folks. If anyone wants to do a lot of reading .. here is one source .. http://www.tulane.edu/~dmsander/Big_Virology/BVHomePage.html > When I took an at course, we were taught that certain oils were > antiviral. Why? Because they were made up of alcohols of terpenes > which were antiviral. And how did these affect a virus in the > body? Well, I guess we didn't get that far. This is taught by folks who are either too lazy to do their own research or are sloppy and put out unreferenced rumors .. and its a norm in the cottage industry of Aromatherapy. Though I 'm qualified as a so-called AT Practitioner I DO NOT want to be known as one because I strongly dislike the way it is practiced. Essential oils smell great and they work .. but the practice of AT in general stinks! Martin has been saying for years that teachers are putting out incorrect information .. and he is right. They are doing no favors for AT .. in fact, its such misinformation that harms efforts to legitimize AT. IF one wants to start an AT course they can just do it .. like that sorry, idiotic, phony criminal Nicole .. from Canada. Many of you remember her. She has since faded away but it was not before she took a lotta young folks for a ride. She knew as much about AT as I do brain surgery and she falsely called herself a Naturopathic Doctor till we tracked down the alleged source of her training and found out it did not exist. > I was taught that if you have a viral infection, choose oils > that are antiviral to help combat that infection. Makes sense .. huh? ;-) But what antiviral oils are proven to be so? And .. what is antiviral? They are taking the easy way out. All AT teachers are not stupid .. but some are lazy. Though I often argue with Martin because he is sometimes a bit too cautious .. for sure he does not put out unsubstantiated information .. his course can be viewed at http://www.av-at.com/coursedetails.html > Leading me to believe that these oils were used specifically to kill, > stop, slow down, or disable a virus. IF you stick to the last two points above you are on track. Stopping or killing a virus is a bit extreme .. slowing it down and disabling it is possible .. and Oregano does that for many of them. But there are over 1,600 viruses identified now and they mutate to create other identities if they are allowed to proceed beyond 3 or so generations. Another bit of info I found follows: " Other troubling areas of current taxonomy of viruses include the concept that viruses are abstract entities. How comforting will it be to patients with serious diarrhea caused by Norwalk virus to learn that their illness is caused by an abstract entity? Viruses cause disease just as parasites and bacteria cause disease, and we do not consider them abstract. Because parasites or bacteria are different from viruses in composition, life cycle, and the like does not make a virus an abstract entity. " UNQUOTE Antibiotics are effective against a wide range of bacterial critters .. and Oregano is too. I can fill a hard drive with information on the magnificent abilities of Oregano to totally destroy a WIDE RANGE of bacterial critters .. I used to put out such information .. it was then called my " Oregano Files " .. but I don't do that now because it became a full time job .. plus when I retire I am thinking of writing a book on the Origanums. I will send a couple to the list in a few minutes. But .. there is absolutely no proof that ANY essential oil or vaccine or medicine KILLS viruses .. there are vaccines to prevent some viruses and even they are controversial .. in most cases they help relieve symptoms and its really symptoms that are the problem if we are not dealing with a virus than can cause death - right? As for some flu vaccines .. I found the following: " Amantadine and rimantadine are thought to interfere with influenza A virus M2 protein, a membrane ion channel protein, and inhibit virus uncoating, which inhibits virus replication, resulting in decreased viral shedding. " So .. we are again dealing with stopping replication .. not killing! But there are side effects to the known anti-viral drugs .. http://www.cdc.gov/flu/protect/antiviral/sideeffects.htm > I personally know they have worked for me. I just haven't > questioned why. If by " they " you mean some EO .. and particular if you mean Oregano .. I agree that they seem to work for me too. But odds are that the viruses we are controlling are merely going into retrograde .. they have stopped replicating .. and they are lying dormant in our bods waiting for the next time it looks good for them to come back. > Thanks for helping clarify! My pleasure. > I have learned things from you that I know I would never > find in a book......... That might be cause I am not selling books. ;-) But .. I do believe with all my heart and intellect that the use of Oregano is effective in stopping the replication of many viruses .. and in helping the immune system to become stronger so it can do the same job. And I'm ABSOLUTELY certain that Oregano can kick a laundry list of Big Bad Bug Butts when we are dealing with bacterial critters .. there is too much scientific support for this statement .. not opinion .. not psudo-science .. but well conducted, replicated, peer reviewed and published data. > Laura Y'all keep smiling. :-) Butch http://www.AV-AT.com Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.