Wnen is a pandemic, not pandemic?

[Guest guest]

http://tinyurl.com/q8ejje

UK swine flu toll is really 30,000, says leading scientist

 

True extent of the outbreak is claimed to be 300 times worse than government

agency admits

 

By Geoffrey Lean, Environment Editor

 

 

Sunday, 24 May 2009

 

 

 

Thirty thousand people in Britain are likely to have been already infected by

swine flu, one of the country's leading authorities has told The Independent on

Sunday. This would mean that the virus is 300 times more widespread than the

Health Protection Agency (HPA) admits.

 

 

The startling estimate by top virologist Professor John Oxford comes as leading

scientists are warning that the agency's announcements on the spread of the

disease are " meaningless " and hiding its true extent. And it tallies with

official estimates made in the United States.

 

Yet the World Health Organisation (WHO) late last week changed its rules in

order to avoid declaring that the flu has become a pandemic after pleas from

governments, led by Britain.

 

Professor Oxford, of Queen Mary, University of London, believes that thousands

of people have caught the virus and suffered only the most minor symptoms, or

none at all, over the past weeks, as the new strain of H1N1 has spread

nationwide - welcome testimony to the mildness of the epidemic to date.

 

He also thinks that some 100,000 people will have been infected in the US - the

same number as is being privately estimated by experts at the US Centers for

Disease Control and Prevention - and another 30,000 in Japan, where swine flu

was spreading rapidly last week.

 

This contrasts with the number of officially tested and confirmed cases recorded

by the WHO, which now stands at 11,168 in 42 countries on every continent except

Africa. So far just 86 deaths have been ascribed to the disease, all of them in

North and Central America, including 75 in Mexico.

 

Britain has the most official cases in Europe, at 122, with another 169 under

investigation. But the figure, put out by the HPA, is increasingly coming to be

seen as unrealistic. And it is certainly rising extraordinarily slowly, merely

increasing from 82 a week ago and 39 the week before that, while normally the

numbers affected by an infectious disease multiply rapidly.

 

In Japan - which now has the most confirmed cases outside North America - the

official numbers have shot up from four to 294 in a week.

 

Professor Andrew Pekosz, of John Hopkins University in Baltimore, in the US,

told the Associated Press late last week: " It's odd that we have not seen more

cases in Britain, " adding that after the first ones " a relatively wide outbreak "

would be expected.

 

" The numbers in Britain are not really telling the story, " added Professor

Michael Osterholm, one of the world's top flu experts and an adviser to the US

government. He called the official figures " meaningless " and said that, while

the authorities were not hiding cases, they were not hunting very hard for H1N1.

 

The agency says that the numbers are low because it has been successful in

containing the spread of the disease by giving the antiviral drug Tamiflu to all

those in contact with anyone found to have it.

 

But Professor Osterholm says that the disease spreads too fast for this to work,

adding: " It's like trying to maintain the integrity of a submarine with screen

doors. "

 

Britain may be missing cases because it is testing people with flu-like symptoms

only if they have been in Mexico and the US in the previous week or have been in

contact with a " probable or confirmed case " of the disease.

 

The spread of H1N1 in Japan, after the Americas, would normally have been enough

to justify the WHO declaring a pandemic, under criteria established in April

this year. But Britain, Japan and other countries last week persuaded it not to

do so, in order to prevent panic, border closures and disruption to trade.

 

However, the UN body continues to warn that the disease may come back in a much

more deadly form in the autumn.

 

 

 

 

E-mail message checked by Internet Security (5.5.0.212)

Database version: 5.12450

http://www.pctools.com/uk/internet-security/