Guest guest Posted July 5, 2003 Report Share Posted July 5, 2003 Butch Owen <butchbsi writes: > potatoes, tomatoes and the many plants that grow wild > in > the USA now but were once cultivated .. after being brought to the > New World by folks from Europe. I thought plants in the nightshade family (tomatoes, potatoes, peppers) were indigenous to the New World and taken to Europe . . . am I making this up? (don't think so, but then, I'm no expert . . .) Oh, and there are lots of traditional " Native American " folks who believe that they originated here, too. And there seems to be some genetic evidence that the Bering Strait migration theory is only applicable to a limited number of western hemisphere people (the northern folks - Inuit, Aleuts, Navajo [not northern now but genetically related and their own storeis say that they came from the north] - are genetically related to Siberian tribes). More contemporary anthropological theories posit that most western hemisphere folks may actually have been in what's now South America area before the land masses separated and migrated north. They're actually closer genetically to southern and eastern Asians than to the Siberians. Interesting stuff . . . rox ______________ The best thing to hit the internet in years - Juno SpeedBand! Surf the web up to FIVE TIMES FASTER! Only $14.95/ month - visit www.juno.com to sign up today! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 5, 2003 Report Share Posted July 5, 2003 Well, Butch...that was quite a ditty there with your interpretation of the meaning of wildcrafting. The way I seeze it is that it means harvesting a plant that is growing wild and not planted by mankind as far as you can tell. Like Jackie said, it could even be a dandelion growing in the city sidewalk...although I prefer the fresh air out here to find my goodies. And yes, we need to be responisible wildcrafters because some have just plundered whole areas like with the Native American Ginseng. Very rare to find anymore. I'm glad most people live in the city and haven't the foggiest idea of what it means. That said: I'm sure that some of the best plants are farmed with organic love for harvesting purposes. Gee, I'm fairly a newbie...what do I know. Diana of Dewberry Hill SBC DSL - Now only $29.95 per month! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 5, 2003 Report Share Posted July 5, 2003 , Butch Owen <butchbsi@s...> wrote: Hi Butch For some reason I didn't get this via email when you sent it to the group, but I saw some responses, so I meandered over here to the website, so I could post some comments .... > > Would love to have some more of that hydrosol and try the EO. > > And welcome to the group. > > > > Now, not meaning to be a snotty nosed kid, but how does one wildcraft > > herbs that aren't native to the region? > > David Roman > > How does one wildcraft anything? Seems to me if we get involved then it > ain't wild no more - huh? Yes, they are wild, you are entered the uncultivated area to collect them. Pretty much like if you were hunting and bagged an elk in the wild.. just because you 'got involved' doesn't mean the animal wasn't wildlife. Undomesticated. Non-farm. Butch responded. > On this " wildcrafting " .. long ago I searched for a defination of this term .. but can't find one that is legitimate .. if someone can give me some help it would be appreciated. Referencing someone's web site can't be considered legitimate - but y'all knew that - huh? I think it might be a term coined in Aromatherapy by some writer and it caught on .. maybe I'm wrong. No, Butch, it didn't come from aromatherapy, it came from herbalism, where wildcrafting was the original way to gather herbs and plants, and continues to this day. On every continent, to this day, elders teach their people about going out into the uncultivated areas to collect plants for healing. They may have their veggie garden, but for the most part, they still gather their medicines from the barks and roots and other plant parts. > give the impression that the plants were harvested with tender loving > care by virgins in long flowing veils whilst asking forgiveness from the > plants and chanting Hari Krishna. Now you're getting silly, Butch. And in some circles, like the Native American ones, where they offer prayers to the spirits of the plant before harvesting, you may be insulting them. Or, in my instance, when I have to hire a wildcrafter in Oregon to go out into the wastefields to gather 'weeds' and have them shipped at great expense, on ice, to me in Miami, they may be wearing overalls, drinking whiskey and eating a tuna fish sandwich between cutting the herbs. All wildcrafting means is that you're harvesting the plant from an area where it grows wild, not a farm, not a garden. Period. what is wild? I'm thinking that the only crafting we > will find involving wild plants is at the still .. I'm thinking that > wild is simply a plant or critter that is growing without help from > human critters. I'm thinking there is no need to complicate this. We > have enough words for it now .. feral and such .. them that were once > wild were tamed and then returned to the wild. Yes, now you're on the right track. I snipped the stuff about 'peasants', as most of the world is 'peasants' who try to make a living anyway they can, as you noted. My harvester isn't a peasant according to his definition, he's a 'burned out old hippie'. I agree. > > How long does it take for a plant to be considered " native? " Native or introducted species.. has nothing to do with the definition 'wildcrafted.' Just wanted to add that. h > origins but when does it become native to a particular region .. same > for bananas, potatoes, tomatoes and the many plants that grow wild in > the USA now but were once cultivated .. after being brought to the New World by folks from Europe. OK, now I think you've been hanging with the 'burned out hippie' wildcrafter :-) You flipped the continents... Solanaceae plants came from the New World and travelled back to Europe. But you knew that, you were just having a brain burp. Happens to the best of us! Anya Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 5, 2003 Report Share Posted July 5, 2003 Excuse the typos and such in my previous post on this subject.. just woke up, and the type on the website is smaller than my mailreader, hence the lack of good proofing. " Introducted " for sure.. anyway, I think my thoughts and comments still made sense, unless otherwise contradicterated! ha.http://member.newsguy.com/~herblady © Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 5, 2003 Report Share Posted July 5, 2003 Butch, Anya, Diana and David This discussion has been an education for me. I have to laugh as I am a Native American Choctaw. We also have Native American Irish and I do not harvest my plants with tender loving care. I just use common sense as to where, what and how much I harvest to insure they are there again for next season. I also find the promotion of being Native American or having some spiritual insight into to this as offensive when it comes to your profit margin. I do not sell my heritage or way of life. I have not sold my herbs to date as they are for family use. My view of the " craft " is, much of what I harvest and how I harvest it was taught to me by my grandmother. I knew no one else who knew what she did so I viewed it as a craft or a real gift. I was asked to be part of a producers group starting in this area for essential oil production. They wanted me to share my knowledge of our wild herbs and those I grew. They will be growing the herb on river bottom land here. They will not be producing essential oil from wild herbs. I agreed and thought I would join this list to learn more on essential oil. I thought I might try to use some of my wild herbs for essential oil. I have a still being made for me to use at home. If you feel there is a better suited list for me to join to learn about essential oil, send it to me. I have not taken offense to what has been said, just a little bewildered by the response I got when joining. I guess the next time I join a list I should consider my wording of who I am a little better. Jackie Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 6, 2003 Report Share Posted July 6, 2003 Hey Anya, > Hi Butch > For some reason I didn't get this via email when you sent it to the > group, but I saw some responses, so I meandered over here to the > website, so I could post some comments .... Stuff happens on the I-Net. > > > Now, not meaning to be a snotty nosed kid, but how does one > > > wildcraft herbs that aren't native to the region. > > > > How does one wildcraft anything? Seems to me if we get involved > > then it ain't wild no more - huh? > > Yes, they are wild, you are entered the uncultivated area to collect > them. Pretty much like if you were hunting and bagged an elk in the > wild.. just because you 'got involved' doesn't mean the animal wasn't > wildlife. Undomesticated. Non-farm. The term and its origin has been adequately explained .. in any industry or occupation folks define their own terms and as long as folks in that industry or occupation understand them it works But I don't think we have yet extended the term to include the bagging (harvesting) of wild game. ;-p > Butch responded. > > On this " wildcrafting " .. long ago I searched for a defination of > > this term .. but can't find one that is legitimate .. if someone can > > give me some help it would be appreciated. Referencing someone's > > web site can't be considered legitimate - but y'all knew that - huh? > > I think it might be a term coined in Aromatherapy by some writer and > > it caught on .. maybe I'm wrong. > > No, Butch, it didn't come from aromatherapy, it came from herbalism, > where wildcrafting was the original way to gather herbs and plants, > and continues to this day. On every continent, to this day, elders > teach their people about going out into the uncultivated areas to > collect plants for healing. They may have their veggie garden, but for > the most part, they still gather their medicines from the barks and > roots and other plant parts. I understand what indigenous folks do world-wide .. wrote a long post on that a few years ago on Idma .. course I reckon all my posts are sorta long. ;-) And though I'm not into herbalism I was forced to help my grandmother collect wild plants when I was young .. I always thought she was a witch .. probably was. I guess the term " wildcrafting " is fine for English speakers as long as they all agree on use of the term. :-) > > give the impression that the plants were harvested with tender > > loving care by virgins in long flowing veils whilst asking > > forgiveness from the plants and chanting Hari Krishna. > > Now you're getting silly, Butch. Not really. Check a few more sites. There are some that get real close to that. When someone sells an essential oils produced from plants that were harvested with tender loving care I think it is hogwash! I went to an extreme to explain a marketing technique used in some circles. > And in some circles, like the Native American ones, where they offer > prayers to the spirits of the plant before harvesting, you may be > insulting them. That's not possible Anya! First, they aren't collecting many tons of aromatic materials .. secondly, I am very familiar with the REAL Native Americans .. I mentioned briefly what my religious leanings were. I just don't try to commercialize my beliefs like some white folks and even some Indians. Yep .. Indians. That is, until the American Indian Movement (AIM) decides to call itself the NAM. > Or, in my instance, when I have to hire a wildcrafter in Oregon to go > out into the wastefields to gather 'weeds' and have them shipped at > great expense, on ice, to me in Miami, they may be wearing overalls, > drinking whiskey and eating a tuna fish sandwich between cutting the > herbs. Understand .. but this appears to be an incomplete sentence .. I cut it from the one on Native Americans so I guess the flow of your suggestion was intended to apply here too. ;-p > All wildcrafting means is that you're harvesting the plant from an > area where it grows wild, not a farm, not a garden. Period. OK .. I can live with that. But I will continue to list my EOs that are distilled from wild grown plants as: WG: Wild-grown - Self-propagating - uncultivated - harvested by hand in the wild. Because I don't think there was any crafting involved in their harvest. > > what is wild? I'm thinking that the only crafting we will find > > involving wild plants is at the still .. I'm thinking that wild is > > simply a plant or critter that is growing without help from human > > critters. I'm thinking there is no need to complicate this. We > > have enough words for it now .. feral and such .. them that were > > once wild were tamed and then returned to the wild. > > Yes, now you're on the right track. I snipped the stuff about > 'peasants', as most of the world is 'peasants' who try to make a > living anyway they can, as you noted. My harvester isn't a peasant > according to his definition, he's a 'burned out old hippie'. I agree. Hawhawhaw .. here and in most countries that recognize a peasant class, the peasant is as proud of being that class as an Irishman is of being Irish or a Suthran boy of being Suthran. Its certainly not seen in as a negative term of description. In fact, the politicians like to boast of their peasant upbringing, etc. ;-p > > How long does it take for a plant to be considered " native? " > > Native or introducted species.. has nothing to do with the definition > 'wildcrafted.' Just wanted to add that. Makes all kinds of sense that does. Still, I wonder how long it takes for something to be considered native. Maybe if we substitute the term indigenous for native it might be easier .. cause everything that grows wild in the USA is native .. that is, if it is the offsping of a parent. > > origins but when does it become native to a particular region .. > > same for bananas, potatoes, tomatoes and the many plants that grow > > wild in the USA now but were once cultivated .. after being brought > > to the New World by folks from Europe. > > OK, now I think you've been hanging with the 'burned out hippie' > wildcrafter :-) You flipped the continents... Solanaceae plants came > from the New World and travelled back to Europe. But you knew that, > you were just having a brain burp. Happens to the best of us! > Anya Yep .. I knew that .. and its the reason I split the sentence with what I thought was a sufficient break in though .. and the many plants. But I don't think I could deal with burned out or live wire hippies. ;-p Y'all keep smiling, Butch http://www.AV-AT.com Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.