Furious Chinese acupuncturists declare war on Ontario government over bill

[Guest guest]

http://www.cbc.ca/cp/health/061123/x112304A.html

Furious Chinese acupuncturists declare war on Ontario government over bill

Published: Thursday, November 23, 2006 | 4:15 PM ET

Canadian Press: COLIN PERKEL

TORONTO (CP) - Furious Chinese acupuncturists are threatening to mobilize

half-a-million people against Ontario's Liberal government over legislation

making their profession self-regulating.

 

The bill, which had final reading Thursday, entrenches " quackery " and puts the

public at risk, critics said. " Bill 50 discriminates against the Chinese

medicine profession and against the Chinese community and is a second head tax, "

said Stephen Liu, co-chairman of the Canadian Society of and

Acupuncture.

 

" We will fight to the last. "

 

The reference to the hated tax once imposed on Chinese immigrants indicates the

depth of anger over the legislation among many of Ontario's 3,000 practitioners

of traditional Chinese medicine.

 

Critics say they find it offensive that the legislation allows other groups of

health professionals - such as physiotherapists, massage therapists or

chiropractors - to continue using acupuncture under standards set by their own

regulating bodies.

 

Liu said Chinese acupuncturists opposed to the legislation will call on their

patients, their families, friends, relatives and members of their churches -

500,000 people in all - to fight the Liberal party in next year's provincial

election.

 

Dr. Stanley Shyu, a Chinese-trained doctor of traditional medicine who has

practised in Canada for 32 years, said it's ludicrous to allow others to perform

acupuncture without rigorous training.

 

Doing so waters down a profession that can cure a wide range of ailments when

done by properly trained experts, but harms patients when done improperly, he

said.

 

" You don't let laymen stick needles in people and call it acupuncture, " Shyu

said.

 

" That's called needling. "

 

Health Minister George Smitherman, who introduced the bill almost a year ago,

acknowledged divisions over the legislation.

 

However, he said there was reason to stop other medical professionals from

performing acupuncture.

 

" Each of those colleges will be looking to work together in terms of making sure

that there is a consensus that the standard is consistent and appropriate, "

Smitherman said.

 

Proponents say the college that will regulate the profession when it's up and

running, likely in about two years, will set high standards, protect the public,

and enhance the overall credibility of the profession.

 

Quebec, Alberta and British Columbia along with close to 50 American states

already regulate Chinese medicine.

 

Critics also railed against the legislation because practitioners of traditional

Chinese medicine would no longer be able to prescribe and dispense herbal

formulas and compounds.

 

Naturopaths could get the exclusive right to do so, even though they might have

less training.

 

" Where is the fairness in this? " said Marylou Lombardi, president of the Ontario

Association of Acupuncture and Traditional .

 

Opposition Leader John Tory said he supported the legislation because it at

least imposes a regulatory framework.

 

" We're hopeful that as the college is set up that some of the issues that have

not been adequately addressed might be addressed at that time, " Tory said.