Guest guest Posted September 14, 2004 Report Share Posted September 14, 2004 Hi Mike, & All, Mike Liaw wrote: > Dermot, It's not weird. I share the same experience in using Qi > Gong in acupuncture. I do take caution when facing someone with > extremely negative Qi. (You will see what I mean when you encounter > one, if you haven't already run into it.) Mike L. Mike, (and others interested), could you elaborate, please? The topic of handling (being able to protect oneself from) strong negative Qi is relevant for colleagues on LIKEMList (a sister-List). May I have your permission to cross-post your reply there? Best regards, Email: < WORK : Teagasc Research Management, Sandymount Ave., Dublin 4, Ireland Mobile: 353-; [in the Republic: 0] HOME : 1 Esker Lawns, Lucan, Dublin, Ireland Tel : 353-; [in the Republic: 0] WWW : http://homepage.eircom.net/~progers/searchap.htm Chinese Proverb: " Man who says it can't be done, should not interrupt man doing it " Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 14, 2004 Report Share Posted September 14, 2004 Phil, One of the first things you should learn when studying Medical Qigong is how to avoid invasion of Shi Qi (Evil Qi/Negative Qi) from patients. In some texts they talk about the Wu Zang Meditation to help achieve this protection. Here is more info I've drawn together about this... - Medical Qigong and the Acupuncture Clinic Avoiding Qi Depletion in the Acupuncture or Medical Qigong Clinic Because therapy consumes energy, as long as the practitioner's quantity of energy is higher than that of the patient's, the doctor can transmit energy into the patient with no ill effect. If however, the practitioner is very tired or depleted and tries to treat a patient, the energy of the practitioner may become weaker than that of the patient. This same principle applies to both acupuncturists and Qigong practitioners alike. It is important to note that energy currents flow from high to low (much like water). Therefore, the practitioner may if in a weakened state, absorb the Turbid or Evil (Shi) Qi or disease energies from the patient. Any imbalance in the practitioner's organ system can increase the doctor's vulnerability to foreign pathogens. These pathogenic sensations may also be transmitted into the body of healthy people, or other patients as well. When treating patients the Qigong or Acupuncture practitioner receives and diagnoses information from the six windows of the body - eyes, ears, nose, tongue, body, Spirit. Through this action of diagnosis, the practitioner naturally depletes Qi. Any imbalance due to organ depletion will cause the doctor to absorb Evil Qi from the patient. This Evil Qi can move within the doctor's body causing Qi deviations, especially if it mixes with the doctor' s Clear Qi. 1. If the Upper Dantian is invaded symptoms of mental fatigue, dizziness and headaches will arise. 2. If the Middle Dantian is invaded symptoms of emotional fatigue and discomfort in the Middle Jiao region will arise. 3. If the Lower Dantian is invaded the symptoms will include physical fatigue, cold in the extremities, discomfort in the lower abdomen will arise. This is why Chinese Doctors should constantly refill and rebalance themselves energetically. It has been observed that when the Qigong or Acupuncture practitioner has ingested the patient's pathogens, and a Qi deviation has resulted, no Western doctor, acupuncturist, or herbalist can help and it is only the practitioner with the Qi deviation who can change the Evil Qi back into Clear Qi by using divine energy and purging the body's Shen, Qi and finally Jing. This supports the practitioner's Righteous Qi and fights the invasions of the patient's pathogens. If the Qigong or Acupuncture practitioner recognises that they are in a state of depletion they should avoid the possibility of Evil Qi invasion. This will involve: · Treating less patients · Maintaining a consistently healthy diet · Receiving frequent exposure to fresh air and sunlight · Performing Regulating and Organ Strengthening Qigong exercises between patients · Washing hands between patients in room temperature water o Cold water is harmful to Wei Qi fields as it shocks the system o Hot water opens the channels and can drive Evil Qi deeper into the body · If the practitioner senses Evil Qi invasion during treatment - usually entering through Du 20, CV 17, GB 20, Yintang, or Kd 1 they should stop treatment and perform a " closing " by flicking the fingers, wrists and shaking the arms until all sensation of discomfort has been eliminated Wu Zang (Five Organ) Meditation for Energetic Protection The Yellow Emperor's Classics on Internal Medicine states that before treating patients of any kind, the doctor should first perform the Wu Zang Energy Meditation. It encouraged doctors to practice this meditation before treating patients in a clinical environment and before entering the treatment room, because it surrounds them with a strong field of protective Qi (Wei Qi) The focus of the meditation is to extend each of the five organs' energy far into the horizon to gather Qi. 1.. Start by focusing on the centre of the body. Imagine opening the Baihui point (at the top of the head) and begin to pull in the Qi from the Heavens. Imagine the divine light as a bright shining white light, illuminating and filling your entire body through the Baihui. Feel the body radiating this divine white light energy. Next imagine this white light energy coalescing into the body's centre core, forming an energetic tube of Heavenly Energy that extends from the Baihui point down to the Huiyin point. The centre core vibrates and resonates with the Divine white light energy. 2.. Now imagine a golden yellow mist of Qi arising from under the Earth and filling your body and connecting with the Spleen organ. Next, feel this golden light Earth energy envelop the centre core of the divine white light energy, merging together and synergising. This represents the energy of your Yi (Intention), to root and stabilise your power. 3.. Begin to focus to your Heart and imagine a portal opening and the Qi flowing out of your Heart like a red swirling wind in front of you, full of power, protecting you with your Shen and the fire of a red phoenix. This represents your inate spirit, alive, graceful yet powerful. 4.. Focus your attention on your back and the Kidneys and Mingmen area. Imagine a portal opening and the Qi flowing out of your Mingmen behind you like water. Out of this water grows an enormous dark blue turtle, whose shell protects you like a mighty shield. This represents the energy of your Zhi (Will power), and the Jing and Zhi of all your ancestors, backing you and supporting you. 5.. Place your attention on your Lungs and visualise a portal opening on the right side of your body, under the right ribs. Imagine the Lung Qi flowing out of to the right side of your body like steam, forming a white tiger, as strong as steel. This represents the Po and the body's animal nature, the guards and protects you with an animal passion for survival. 6.. Next, place your attention on your Liver and visualise a portal opening on your left side under the left ribs. Imagine the Liver Qi flowing out of to the left of your body like steam, forming a green dragon, sinewy and resilient as bamboo. This represents the Hun and the body's divine nature, guarding and protecting you with a spiritual passion for victory. 7.. Each animal begins to rotate to the left, protecting, stalking, and defending the previous animal's position. Slowly begin to circle these energies, then increase their speed (like a mighty wind) counterclockwise around your body, blending these colours together - red, green, blue, white to form an energy bubble. After forming a protective rainbow hue around your body, draw the energies back in the Baihui point and return the energy of each organ colour back to its origin (the colour red returns back to the Heart, dark blue to the Kidneys, white to the Lungs, and green back to the Liver). As the colours return back to their organ of origin, imagine steam (white light) flowing out of the pores and filling up the energy bubble created by the animal rotation. This forms a solid connection between the body's internal organs and the body's external field of energy. When the protection of the body with the Five Elements is done, imagine that there are many sparkling lights like a halo above your head. Then you can enter the clinical room knowing that you are safe and protected. Kind regards Dermot - " " < <Chinese Medicine > Tuesday, September 14, 2004 1:44 PM Take caution when facing someone with extremely negative Qi > Hi Mike, & All, > > Mike Liaw wrote: > > Dermot, It's not weird. I share the same experience in using Qi > > Gong in acupuncture. I do take caution when facing someone with > > extremely negative Qi. (You will see what I mean when you encounter > > one, if you haven't already run into it.) Mike L. > > Mike, (and others interested), could you elaborate, please? > > The topic of handling (being able to protect oneself from) strong > negative Qi is relevant for colleagues on LIKEMList (a sister-List). > > May I have your permission to cross-post your reply there? > > > > Best regards, > > Email: < > > WORK : Teagasc Research Management, Sandymount Ave., Dublin 4, Ireland > Mobile: 353-; [in the Republic: 0] > > HOME : 1 Esker Lawns, Lucan, Dublin, Ireland > Tel : 353-; [in the Republic: 0] > WWW : http://homepage.eircom.net/~progers/searchap.htm > > Chinese Proverb: " Man who says it can't be done, should not interrupt man doing it " > > > > http://babel.altavista.com/ > > and adjust accordingly. > > If you , it takes a few days for the messages to stop being delivered. > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 14, 2004 Report Share Posted September 14, 2004 Hi, There are two things that I have been taught to do in order to protect myself from absorbing " negative " qi (waste qi) from a client. The first thing I do is " clear " the negative qi from the client using a couple of different techniques. It is sort of like pulling " cold qi " from the client. This is in preparation for " sharing " qi. Optimally, the " cold qi " should feel " warmer " before qi is shared. This is an indication that the client's negative qi has been reduced to a " safe " level. The second thing I do is begin " full body breathing " so that the direction (intent) of qi is from the " outside " of my own body into the direction of the client. I practice " full body qigong breathing " on a daily basis. I do not really try to " emit " qi. I allow the client to " draw " as much as the client desires and the client stops whenever there is enough. The qi is coming from the outside of my body, into my body (where it is transformed) and then can be drawn upon by my client. The purpose of this approach is to " jump start " the qi, since the " cold qi " has been removed, and get it moving again. I am not trying to " balance " anything. I am merely facilitating the unblocking of energetic obstructions (the cold qi) and assisting my client in moving warm qi through my client's body again. I allow my client to his/her natural energetic balance as it may exist at that time. While I have very strong qi, because of my 20 years qigong and taiji practice, there have been a couple of times when the negative qi has 'backed up " into me. It was because I did not fully follow this procedure because I was in haste. Each time I learn a lesson. :-) Once, my body broke out in a short spontaneous sweat which automatically cleared the negative qi from my body. If the " cold qi " is cleared, the potential for negative qi entering my body is much, much less. Even my teacher forgets sometimes. :-) But that is how he learns. Regards, Rich Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 14, 2004 Report Share Posted September 14, 2004 Phil, Sorry about the short reply but I have really limited time. Fortunately, what Dermot has here is excellent! It's extremely close to what I practice. Thanks, Dermot, for answering Phil's question. A few comments: - Besides fresh air and sun light, I also look for pine trees. Doing Qi Gong exercise along side these trees with longevity potential are considered good for health. This is almost common knowledge among the Chinese. - About Evil Qi: I am not sure which character " Shi " Qi refers to in Chinese, but I thought it should be " Xie Qi. " What Rich often refers to as " Cold " Qi is only one type of Xie Qi. - If one is already very tired, do NOT do any treatment before having a few minutes of breaks to " refill " and rebalance oneself. Usually 3 ~ 10 minutes is enough. A better strategy is to be always on the guard and replenish while giving Qi away, but even a very experienced practitioner may forget and run into this. - If one does not know how to expel the Evil Qi out of one's own body, better not treat others with " Intent " or Qi Gong. I don't mind your forwarding to other lists for what I wrote as I didnt' really contribute whole lot, but you'll have to check with Dermot for his contribution here. Mike L. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 15, 2004 Report Share Posted September 15, 2004 Thank you Mike.....no problem if you want to forward this to the other list Phil. Regards Dermot - " Mike Liaw " <mikeliaw <Chinese Medicine > Tuesday, September 14, 2004 9:07 PM Re: Take caution when facing someone with extremely negative Qi > Phil, > > Sorry about the short reply but I have really limited time. > > Fortunately, what Dermot has here is excellent! It's extremely close > to what I practice. Thanks, Dermot, for answering Phil's question. > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 15, 2004 Report Share Posted September 15, 2004 Hi Mike, > What Rich often refers to as " Cold " Qi is only one type of Xie Qi. I think of " qi " as either one type or an infinite types. In the continuum, it can be anywhere from " not moving " (the apex of the pendulum) to moving very fast (just before the apex). As qi becomes more " still " , it can be said to be " colder " - sort of like water turning to ice). As qi increases in movement it can be said to become " warmer " . This of course is the yin/yang aspects of qi. So the " cold " and " warm " qi is relative and there are an infinite number of gradations of these two qualities. One can call each of these " gradations " by a different name if one wishes - for example cool qi, cold qi, very cold, frozen, etc - but the way I look at it they are essentially all the same. There is only one qi and it can relatively " colder " (less movement) or " warmer " (more movement). I also, try not to put additional quality aspects to qi such as " evil " . I just think of it as " cold " (relative to myself) or warm (relative to myself) since this is all that I can really experience. Now it is possible for " cold qi " to enter into my body and make my qi cooler, and therefore create obstructions - just like ice from one body of water can enter into another. My mind can either prevent the cold qi from entering (with a strong and warm Wei Qi barrier) or it can expel the cold qi once it gets into my body, assuming that my qi is fast enough (warm enough) to do this before the cold qi can do harm and cause further blockages. Using the above reasoning, it is not necessary in the model I use to create any more variations of qi. However, I recognize it may be helpful in other models. Regards, Rich Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 15, 2004 Report Share Posted September 15, 2004 >Dermot O'Connor <dermot wrote:It has been >observed that when the Qigong or Acupuncture practitioner has >ingested the patient's pathogens, and a Qi deviation has >resulted, no Western doctor, acupuncturist, or herbalist can >help and it is only the practitioner with the Qi deviation who >can change the Evil Qi back into Clear Qi by using divine >energy and purging the body's shen, Qi and finally Jing. This >supports the practitioner's Righteous Qi and fights the >invasions of the patient's pathogens. Dear Dermot, I knew it could happen, and it is just as you say. This dialog could take place on a magician's list. This has happened to me for the first time in my life, just a month ago. It was a combination of being over-extended, too little sleep, not enough personal prayerful energy gathering and smoothing and giving time , and ignoring my intuition about the natures of the energies hiding in the person and treating them anyway. These things resemble a subconcious sorcerer's duel sometimes. I should go into retreat, but now I have to retrain the leg channel. Nothing else is working. My inner 'gods' won't operate without the offering of awareness. One interesting thing is that this injury is leading me deeper into the junction of will, qi, peace or clarity of mind, and motor movement. It is a revelation, but with a big price. It is that way often I guess. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 15, 2004 Report Share Posted September 15, 2004 In a message dated 9/15/04 1:24:17 AM, rfinkelstein writes: << I also, try not to put additional quality aspects to qi such as " evil " . >> This is an idea I think we all should adopt. To use terms like " evil " not only makes us sounds terribly antiquated, but also is an inanppropriate label (IMO) to apply to a patient (or their qi). ---roseanne Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 15, 2004 Report Share Posted September 15, 2004 In a message dated 9/15/04 10:33:33 AM, zrosenbe writes: << Sorry, But this is what Chinese medicine says about any qi that violates a person's zheng qi/correct or upright qi. Xie qi/evil (or pathogenic) qi describes processes caused by exposures to conditions that compromise a person's health. It does not describe the person as an entity. >> Z'ev, I understand the concept, and I don't have a problem with using the terminolgy " pathogenic " . But I don't think " evil " is the best terminology in this day and age. we may understand the limits of how we are using the word " evil " but the rest of the world may not. -roseanne Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 15, 2004 Report Share Posted September 15, 2004 I don't believe that any Qi is evil....just sometimes harmful and lest there is any confusion I never applied the label evil to a patient. Kind regards Dermot - <ra6151 <Chinese Medicine > Wednesday, September 15, 2004 12:43 PM Re: Take caution when facing someone with extremely negative Qi > > In a message dated 9/15/04 1:24:17 AM, rfinkelstein writes: > > << I also, try not to put additional quality aspects to qi such as > > " evil " . >> > > This is an idea I think we all should adopt. To use terms like " evil " not > only makes us sounds terribly antiquated, but also is an inanppropriate label > (IMO) to apply to a patient (or their qi). > > ---roseanne Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 15, 2004 Report Share Posted September 15, 2004 Dear Roseanne and Dermot, I agree. I believe that there is only one " qi " and it can take many forms like the waves in the ocean. Some waves may be moving faster (warmer) than others (colder). Some may be causing greater harm to other waves :-) and need to be modulated (regulated) and integrated (harmonized)with other waves. And different tools (modalities) can be used to create different waves. It's like children playing in the ocean. Regards, Rich Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 15, 2004 Report Share Posted September 15, 2004 Sorry, But this is what Chinese medicine says about any qi that violates a person's zheng qi/correct or upright qi. Xie qi/evil (or pathogenic) qi describes processes caused by exposures to conditions that compromise a person's health. It does not describe the person as an entity. On Sep 15, 2004, at 4:43 AM, ra6151 wrote: > << I also, try not to put additional quality aspects to qi such as > > " evil " . >> > > This is an idea I think we all should adopt. To use terms like " evil " > not > only makes us sounds terribly antiquated, but also is an > inanppropriate label > (IMO) to apply to a patient (or their qi). > > ---roseanne > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 15, 2004 Report Share Posted September 15, 2004 Rich, First of all, Xie Qi is used extensively in Nei Jing. Z'ev's note said all I wanted to say. (Thanks, Z'ev!) We are discussing in a medical context here. On " cold " Qi, I have to disagree that the cold-warm gradation is the only dimension to Xie Qi, unless you expanded the meaning of " cold. " Let me try it in a different way to see if helps. If you were not to use the hands or body's sense of temperature to diagnose the patient (E.g, Four Diagnosis without the last, to touch or sensing temperature without touching) will you be able to detect Xie Qi? Mike L. Rich <rfinkelstein wrote: Hi Mike, > What Rich often refers to as " Cold " Qi is only one type of Xie Qi. I think of " qi " as either one type or an infinite types. In the continuum, it can be anywhere from " not moving " (the apex of the pendulum) to moving very fast (just before the apex). As qi becomes more " still " , it can be said to be " colder " - sort of like water turning to ice). As qi increases in movement it can be said to become " warmer " . This of course is the yin/yang aspects of qi. So the " cold " and " warm " qi is relative and there are an infinite number of gradations of these two qualities. One can call each of these " gradations " by a different name if one wishes - for example cool qi, cold qi, very cold, frozen, etc - but the way I look at it they are essentially all the same. There is only one qi and it can relatively " colder " (less movement) or " warmer " (more movement). I also, try not to put additional quality aspects to qi such as " evil " . I just think of it as " cold " (relative to myself) or warm (relative to myself) since this is all that I can really experience. Now it is possible for " cold qi " to enter into my body and make my qi cooler, and therefore create obstructions - just like ice from one body of water can enter into another. My mind can either prevent the cold qi from entering (with a strong and warm Wei Qi barrier) or it can expel the cold qi once it gets into my body, assuming that my qi is fast enough (warm enough) to do this before the cold qi can do harm and cause further blockages. Using the above reasoning, it is not necessary in the model I use to create any more variations of qi. However, I recognize it may be helpful in other models. Regards, Rich Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 15, 2004 Report Share Posted September 15, 2004 However Dark the oppressive qi of someone else, it is always one's own, scattered or in tatters, at a low ebb, in disarray, which makes one vulnerable. By the nature of the Soul, which the LV forgets more than it remembers, and the LU remembers more than it forgets, nothing can intrude which is external to the skin. It is an unnatural situation, not factored in when the Form was made, which allows a lacuna to open, and intrusion to come about. The cost of that is that we are no more ourselves. Dr. Holmes Keikobad MB BS DPH Ret. DIP AC NCCAOM LIC AC CO & AZ www.acu-free.com - 15 CEUS by video. NCCAOM reviewed. Approved in CA & most states. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 15, 2004 Report Share Posted September 15, 2004 Hi Mike, > > First of all, Xie Qi is used extensively in Nei Jing. Z'ev's note said all I wanted to say. We can all translate words in the way we want. Is a " poison " (as used in herbs or homeopathy) that cures a person " evil " ? Evil to one - beneficial to another. When one gets sick because one's Wei Qi is low is it " evil " or beneficial " ? Does it not warn the person that he/she has a problem with their physical/mental/spiritual body? Is " sickness " (which I view as the merging of " waves of qi " ) " evil " or a " gift of nature " - a generous warning? Other translations for Xie are " irregular " and " heretical " . (Who Can Ride the Dragon?) Who am I to say which is correct? How am I to know what what is the mind of the person who first wrote down this word thousands of years ago? Interpretation and translation across cultures and time is quite imprecise and subjective. It can be discussed - but I believe it is ultimately quite subjective. > On " cold " Qi, I have to disagree that the cold-warm gradation is the only dimension > to Xie Qi, unless you expanded the meaning of " cold. " Let me try it in a different > way to see if helps. If you were not to use the hands or body's sense of temperature > to diagnose the patient (E.g, Four Diagnosis without the last, to touch or sensing > temperature without touching) will you be able to detect Xie Qi? As others have mentioned in other threads, they can detect Xie Qi using senses other than touch. I can move my hand over a client and feel the " cold qi " without touching. Just like pulse diagnosis which takes training and skills, so does training of other senses. Some people are apparently born with it. There is much in this world that I haven't experienced, but I accept the possibility that it exists, because I myself am discovering new things every day. Did they exist before I discovered them - or only when I discovered them? An interesting question for epistomologists. Do other people have abilities that you do not understand simply because you have not experienced them yet? That is a question you can answer for yourself. I have answered it for myself. But to continue the conversation along the lines that you suggest. Can you tell me exactly and precisely how many different types of Xie Qi there are and how your arrived at the categorization of types? Do you agree with Zhuang Zi who wrote: " Throughout the world there is only one Qi. " ? (Who Can Ride the Dragon) If there is only one Qi, what makes it Evil? Is the Qi of Arsenicum " good " or " evil " ? Regards, Rich Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 15, 2004 Report Share Posted September 15, 2004 Hi Roseanne, > I understand the concept, and I don't have a problem with using the > terminolgy " pathogenic " . But I don't think " evil " is the best terminology in this day > and age. we may understand the limits of how we are using the word > " evil " but the rest of the world may not. > -roseanne My own preference for the time being is " irregular " as a direct translation of of Xie since I think this best describes the " event " where an " irregular qi waveform " is created that causes a blockage that is obstructing the natural flow of qi in a body. It doesn't even have to be a human body though I recognize that this would be its most common usage. The reason I do not use the word evil is because in many ways it is a natural warning to the human body and mind that something is wrong that is affecting its ability to exist - e.g. inadequate Wei Qi. Regards, Rich Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 15, 2004 Report Share Posted September 15, 2004 Rich, I don't mind which way it's translated, which is why I use Xie Qi here. The important thing is if the idea gets communicated clearly. I will not get involved in the translation beyond that. On the " cold " Qi, the intention of my question is to illustrate that there are other aspect of Xie Qi that cannot be described by the " coldness " alone. I am sorry that the question lead you to a different dimension. Yes, one can sense the Qi without touching, but what about just eliminate moving your hands completely? There are people who can sense the Xie Qi even with their hands tied to the back. They use only their eyes at a distance. The Qi detected in this way is beyond coldness, IMO. That's all I am trying to say. Your quoting Zhuang Zi, where the discussion is at a philosophical, to use it in a more concrete level is not something I would engage to discuss here. Mike L. Rich <rfinkelstein wrote: Hi Mike, > > First of all, Xie Qi is used extensively in Nei Jing. Z'ev's note said all I wanted to say. We can all translate words in the way we want. Is a " poison " (as used in herbs or homeopathy) that cures a person " evil " ? Evil to one - beneficial to another. When one gets sick because one's Wei Qi is low is it " evil " or beneficial " ? Does it not warn the person that he/she has a problem with their physical/mental/spiritual body? Is " sickness " (which I view as the merging of " waves of qi " ) " evil " or a " gift of nature " - a generous warning? Other translations for Xie are " irregular " and " heretical " . (Who Can Ride the Dragon?) Who am I to say which is correct? How am I to know what what is the mind of the person who first wrote down this word thousands of years ago? Interpretation and translation across cultures and time is quite imprecise and subjective. It can be discussed - but I believe it is ultimately quite subjective. > On " cold " Qi, I have to disagree that the cold-warm gradation is the only dimension > to Xie Qi, unless you expanded the meaning of " cold. " Let me try it in a different > way to see if helps. If you were not to use the hands or body's sense of temperature > to diagnose the patient (E.g, Four Diagnosis without the last, to touch or sensing > temperature without touching) will you be able to detect Xie Qi? As others have mentioned in other threads, they can detect Xie Qi using senses other than touch. I can move my hand over a client and feel the " cold qi " without touching. Just like pulse diagnosis which takes training and skills, so does training of other senses. Some people are apparently born with it. There is much in this world that I haven't experienced, but I accept the possibility that it exists, because I myself am discovering new things every day. Did they exist before I discovered them - or only when I discovered them? An interesting question for epistomologists. Do other people have abilities that you do not understand simply because you have not experienced them yet? That is a question you can answer for yourself. I have answered it for myself. But to continue the conversation along the lines that you suggest. Can you tell me exactly and precisely how many different types of Xie Qi there are and how your arrived at the categorization of types? Do you agree with Zhuang Zi who wrote: " Throughout the world there is only one Qi. " ? (Who Can Ride the Dragon) If there is only one Qi, what makes it Evil? Is the Qi of Arsenicum " good " or " evil " ? Regards, Rich Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 15, 2004 Report Share Posted September 15, 2004 Rich, 1) first of all, evils are categorized as vacuity evils, repletion evils, destroyer evils, pestilence, epidemic qi, etc. A vacuity evil is what you describe, caused by vacuity of correct qi. Repletion evil is caused by harsh winds, severe cold or heat, etc. Anyone who has lived through hurricanes, tornados, earthquakes knows that sometimes natural forces can lead to great devastation. 2) In China, like other great civilizations, there were massive epidemics that decimated large populations. Texts such as the Shang Han Lun and the Wen Bing corpus were written and applied to save lives with medical treatment. There was a battle, and there were weapons, used to save lives. Being 'politically correct' by interpreting according to what one finds more pleasant obscures the historical use of the term, which we must respect. There are different contexts for treating sickness, but to eliminate an important meaning of a term oversimplifies Chinese medicine and limits its utility. On Sep 15, 2004, at 10:16 AM, Rich wrote: >> First of all, Xie Qi is used extensively in Nei Jing. Z'ev's note > said all I wanted to say. > > We can all translate words in the way we want. Is a " poison " (as used > in herbs or homeopathy) that cures a person " evil " ? Evil to one - > beneficial to another. When one gets sick because one's Wei Qi is low > is it " evil " or beneficial " ? Does it not warn the person that he/she > has a problem with their physical/mental/spiritual body? Is " sickness " > (which I view as the merging of " waves of qi " ) " evil " or a " gift of > nature " - a generous warning? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 15, 2004 Report Share Posted September 15, 2004 If you want to make this case, simply look at the modern day Chinese medical literature, which uses terms such as xie qi/evil qi in quite precise ways, to describe diseases and their treatment. I don't think you can use this argument to dismiss how the Chinese practice their medicine. On Sep 15, 2004, at 10:16 AM, Rich wrote: > Other translations for Xie are " irregular " and " heretical " . (Who Can > Ride the Dragon?) Who am I to say which is correct? How am I to know > what what is the mind of the person who first wrote down this word > thousands of years ago? Interpretation and translation across cultures > and time is quite imprecise and subjective. It can be discussed - but > I believe it is ultimately quite subjective. > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 15, 2004 Report Share Posted September 15, 2004 I mentioned a few types of evil qi in my last posting. Zhuang Zi is speaking in terms of Chinese cosmology. We are discussing Chinese medicine. Different context. Arsenic/xiong huang is a du/toxin, not an evil. Different term. It is employed in Chinese medicine according to the principle " yi du yao gong xie " employ toxic medicinals to attack disease " . On Sep 15, 2004, at 10:16 AM, Rich wrote: > But to continue the conversation along the lines that you suggest. Can > you tell me exactly and precisely how many different types of Xie Qi > there are and how your arrived at the categorization of types? Do you > agree with Zhuang Zi who wrote: " Throughout the world there is only > one Qi. " ? (Who Can Ride the Dragon) If there is only one Qi, what > makes it Evil? Is the Qi of Arsenicum " good " or " evil " ? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 15, 2004 Report Share Posted September 15, 2004 On Sep 15, 2004, at 1:18 PM, Mike Liaw wrote: > I don't mind which way it's translated, which is why I use Xie Qi here. > The important thing is if the idea gets communicated clearly. I will > not get involved > in the translation beyond that. Translations of technical terms are context-specific. If we are talking Chinese medicine as opposed to Taoist metaphysics, use of " xie " will be different. > > On the " cold " Qi, the intention of my question is to illustrate that > there are other > aspect of Xie Qi that cannot be described by the " coldness " alone. I > am sorry > that the question lead you to a different dimension. Yes, one can > sense the Qi without touching, but what about just eliminate moving > your hands > completely? There are people who can sense the Xie Qi even with their > hands > tied to the back. They use only their eyes at a distance. The Qi > detected in this > way is beyond coldness, IMO. That's all I am trying to say. Cold qi as a concept may be appropriate within the practice of a specific style/lineage of Qi Gong. The problem here as I see it is trying to use concepts from a specific Qi Gong lineage in a discussion group largely composed of professionals practicing Chinese herbal medicine and acupuncture. Sometimes, the concepts are not sufficient, broad enough or explained in sufficient detail to address the various diagnostic and treatment models that are the core of Chinese medicine. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 16, 2004 Report Share Posted September 16, 2004 Folks, I am enjoying this thread, but just wanted to point out that I will not be able to reply or participate in any discussions on this list until sunday, 9/19, because of Jewish holidays. Shana tovah, On Sep 15, 2004, at 1:49 PM, wrote: > Translations of technical terms are context-specific. If we are > talking Chinese medicine as opposed to Taoist metaphysics, use of " xie " > will be different. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 16, 2004 Report Share Posted September 16, 2004 Thank you all on this and related groups for not only this topic, but all the shared wisdom. From the poetic to the clinically succinct, it is a humdinger of a joyful wisdom circle. My opinion on treating the effects of a harmful lingering exposure to negative chi has changed over the course of my life. From protective spheres of light, emanating guardians, doubles of one's self, talismans, charms, hand gestures, collecting universal holyqi from presence of non dual transparent awareness, martial play, sticking a sword in the ground, and many more practices that are often idiosyncratic and valid and even indispensible at times, I would have to say the important defense I have now (altho I let my qi work lapse a little too much recently and got hurt), is to try not to let my love retreat, and let reality defend itself. Love others as yourself, Tong Lin. Face it, there's a prize in every box for everybody sooner or later. In giving chi gung, we're ultimately just channelling it, just as we are channeling food, yuan qi, breathe, ancestors qi, etc. When I'm not afraid of loosing anything, my peace and power is best. ( I guess you could say that the other way around too.) Again and again, harsh seeming situations turn more sweet if my own negativity is gone like vapor. I know and agree that to treat another being, one must be strong in the way, but then be careful/mindful, the stronger and more in tune with reality you get, just the smallest impurity in your mind, and a sneeze can bring a snowstorm. When we play with energies so deep in our being we are unraveling now-automatic processes, so, elders' experience is sought.(there wasn't one response where someone didn't look back in some way) Part of my situation is that many times I develop a malady identicle to the one someone will seek help with soon, before I meet them. The leg channel problem is getting better with mindfulness #1, but also massage, herb, acup, bleeding, prayer. And last week, in walks someone, an elderly woman who describes the same complaint I had. Dang. What is going on? Sorry to be a poor wordsmith, but thanks to all for this. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 16, 2004 Report Share Posted September 16, 2004 mystir: Part of my situation is that many times I develop a malady identicle to the one someone will seek help with soon, before I meet them. The leg channel problem is getting better with mindfulness #1, but also massage, herb, acup, bleeding, prayer. And last week, in walks someone, an elderly woman who describes the same complaint I had. Dang. What is going on? Sorry to be a poor wordsmith, but thanks to all for this. > > If the 'clone' illness manifests in someone before the patient comes, something is ajar in his or her 'tomorrow'. If it manifests in after the patient has arrived, something is ajar in the 'yesterday'. In both cases the integrity of the soul matrix is compromised. The day is not far when someone with a tumor growing in their skull decides to seek out a specific person for the purpose of Malevolent Spirit Transfer. One must be Full in the Red Qi, and steady in the Dark, a Warrior by the Waft of the Winds, the Holder of the haft of the Two Edged Sword, and the Lover of the Core in the Earth, to be able to accost such a one, and make certain they harm none, and live by their own maladies. Such a one is the truest of the True Healers, one of the ancient Emerald People. [From The Slaughter Stigmata by Arya of the Hills. C'right TruSelf Inc. 2000. Quoted by Courtesy] Dr. Holmes Keikobad MB BS DPH Ret. DIP AC NCCAOM LIC AC CO & AZ www.acu-free.com - 15 CEUS by video. NCCAOM reviewed. Approved in CA & most states. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted September 16, 2004 Report Share Posted September 16, 2004 If the 'clone' illness manifests in someone before the patient comes, something is ajar in his or her 'tomorrow'. If it manifests in after the patient has arrived, something is ajar in the 'yesterday'. In both cases the integrity of the soul matrix is compromised. - Dr. Holmes K. I love the poetry of all this; however, can you be more specific about how you would address a problem of " yesterday " or " tomorrow " ? I see this often too... not sure how to respond to it. Thanks. Pat ============================================================================== NOTE: The information in this email is confidential and may be legally privileged. If you are not the intended recipient, you must not read, use or disseminate the information; please advise the sender immediately by reply email and delete this message and any attachments without retaining a copy. Although this email and any attachments are believed to be free of any virus or other defect that may affect any computer system into which it is received and opened, it is the responsibility of the recipient to ensure that it is virus free and no responsibility is accepted by Cadwalader, Wickersham & Taft LLP for any loss or damage arising in any way from its use. ============================================================================== Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.