Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org

Opposite reactions to herbs

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Guest guest

Here's a puzzler:

 

48 y.o female Patient with hx of endometriosis, excruciating (though

regular) periods, pain both preceding and during. Hx. of sexual abuse. Light

smoker. Tends toward cold, both core and extremities, even in summer, though

gets night sweats. I have been treating her with AP and Craniosacral therapy

with great results for musculoskeletal and menstrual pain. DX: 1) KD Yang

Def. 2) Blood stagnation in lower warmer 3) Cold in uterus 4) Liver Qi

stagnation 5) Heart Blood deficiency 6) Sp Qi deficiency.

 

The issue: I have tried giving her herbs, unsuccessfully. First I tried

moving Liver Qi, mildly moving blood, and building Blood & Yin. Went with

Health Concerns' " Women's Balance " (Dan Zhi Xiao Yao San) and Jia Jian Ding

Xin Wan ( " Calm Spirit " - also includes enzymes for stress and digestion).

Combination caused gas and constipation, so switched her to a warmer formula

than Dan Zhi Xiao Yao San, one with Gotu Kola substituted for Chai Hu

( " Heavenly Water " ). This also produced gas, and less constipation, but still

difficult BM's. Decided to work on building blood by building up a possibly

deficient SP, so replaced Ding Xin Wan with Gui Pi Tang (Shen Gem from

Health Concerns). She took two pills, and vomited, then experienced lasting

lower right quadrant discomfort for two weeks.

Reevaluated, decided to go after the cold in the lower warmer. Also

postulated that she might be sensitive to the binders in the tablets, so

switched to tincture. Went with K'an " Women's Journey " , or Jia Jian Wen Jing

Tang:

(Mu Li Oyster Shell 12.3%

E Jiao (A Jiao) Gelatin 8.3%

Mu Dan Pi (Su) Moutan 8.3%

Mai Men Dong Ophiopogon 8.3%

Bai Shao Peony (White) 8.3%

Dang Gui (Shen) Tangkuei 8.3%

Sheng Jiang Ginger (Fresh) 5.6%

Wu Zhu Yu Evodia Fruit 5.6%

Gui Zhi Cinnamon Twigs 5.6%

Xian Mao Curculigo 4.2%

Sheng Di Huang Rehmannia (Fresh) 4.2%

Gan Cao Licorice 4.2%

Zhi Mu Anemarrhena 4.2%

Ren Shen Ginseng 4.2%

Ba Ji Tian Morinda 4.2%

Huang Bai (Chuan) Phellodendron Bark 4.2%

 

She took 8 drops 3x/day (minimum dosage, per manufacturer), and for five

days she wasn't warmer, but FREEZING COLD!

I can't get my head around how a formula with evodia, ginger, morinda,

curculigo, ginseng, and cinnamon could cool her off, and not warm her.

I have contacted the distributor - maybe the batch is bad (mislabled, wrong

ratio, etc). But is there a TCM (or other) explanation? Given her other

" opposite " reactions (Qi-moving herbs made her gassy and constipated, SP

building and middle-Qi moving made her vomit and her intestines spasm, and a

heavily warming formula made her freeze), could there be some kind of

psychoemotional/spiritual blockage to herbal substances? I do extremely mild

acupuncture with her, meridian-style with Seirin #1's, and she has a

" spiritual journey " each time.

 

Any thoughts?

 

Benjamin B. Hawes M.A.O.M., Lic. Ac.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Hi, Benjiman,

Have you tried clearing up her digestive system? How is her food absorption?

Perhaps addressing this first may help.

Constipation can be not wanting to let go of something (sexual abuse is very

difficult to treat, even if the pt thinks it's in the past and been dealt

with already).

Food for thought, Pam Price

 

> Here's a puzzler:

>

> 48 y.o female Patient with hx of endometriosis, excruciating (though

> regular) periods, pain both preceding and during. Hx. of sexual abuse.

Light

> smoker. Tends toward cold, both core and extremities, even in summer,

though

> gets night sweats. I have been treating her with AP and Craniosacral

therapy

> with great results for musculoskeletal and menstrual pain. DX: 1) KD Yang

> Def. 2) Blood stagnation in lower warmer 3) Cold in uterus 4) Liver Qi

> stagnation 5) Heart Blood deficiency 6) Sp Qi deficiency.

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Just a thought. Have you considered Si Ni San, perhaps with

modifications? Perhaps she's experiencing so much stagnation that

she's unable to perfuse the extremities?

 

Regards, Shanna

 

Chinese Medicine , " Benjamin

Hawes " <ben_laura@n...> wrote:

> Here's a puzzler:

>

> 48 y.o female Patient with hx of endometriosis, excruciating

(though

> regular) periods, pain both preceding and during. Hx. of sexual

abuse. Light

> smoker. Tends toward cold, both core and extremities, even in

summer, though

> gets night sweats. I have been treating her with AP and

Craniosacral therapy

> with great results for musculoskeletal and menstrual pain. DX: 1)

KD Yang

> Def. 2) Blood stagnation in lower warmer 3) Cold in uterus 4)

Liver Qi

> stagnation 5) Heart Blood deficiency 6) Sp Qi deficiency.

>

> The issue: I have tried giving her herbs, unsuccessfully. First I

tried

> moving Liver Qi, mildly moving blood, and building Blood & Yin.

Went with

> Health Concerns' " Women's Balance " (Dan Zhi Xiao Yao San) and Jia

Jian Ding

> Xin Wan ( " Calm Spirit " - also includes enzymes for stress and

digestion).

> Combination caused gas and constipation, so switched her to a

warmer formula

> than Dan Zhi Xiao Yao San, one with Gotu Kola substituted for Chai

Hu

> ( " Heavenly Water " ). This also produced gas, and less constipation,

but still

> difficult BM's. Decided to work on building blood by building up a

possibly

> deficient SP, so replaced Ding Xin Wan with Gui Pi Tang (Shen Gem

from

> Health Concerns). She took two pills, and vomited, then

experienced lasting

> lower right quadrant discomfort for two weeks.

> Reevaluated, decided to go after the cold in the lower warmer. Also

> postulated that she might be sensitive to the binders in the

tablets, so

> switched to tincture. Went with K'an " Women's Journey " , or Jia

Jian Wen Jing

> Tang:

> (Mu Li Oyster Shell 12.3%

> E Jiao (A Jiao) Gelatin 8.3%

> Mu Dan Pi (Su) Moutan 8.3%

> Mai Men Dong Ophiopogon 8.3%

> Bai Shao Peony (White) 8.3%

> Dang Gui (Shen) Tangkuei 8.3%

> Sheng Jiang Ginger (Fresh) 5.6%

> Wu Zhu Yu Evodia Fruit 5.6%

> Gui Zhi Cinnamon Twigs 5.6%

> Xian Mao Curculigo 4.2%

> Sheng Di Huang Rehmannia (Fresh) 4.2%

> Gan Cao Licorice 4.2%

> Zhi Mu Anemarrhena 4.2%

> Ren Shen Ginseng 4.2%

> Ba Ji Tian Morinda 4.2%

> Huang Bai (Chuan) Phellodendron Bark 4.2%

>

> She took 8 drops 3x/day (minimum dosage, per manufacturer), and

for five

> days she wasn't warmer, but FREEZING COLD!

> I can't get my head around how a formula with evodia, ginger,

morinda,

> curculigo, ginseng, and cinnamon could cool her off, and not warm

her.

> I have contacted the distributor - maybe the batch is bad

(mislabled, wrong

> ratio, etc). But is there a TCM (or other) explanation? Given her

other

> " opposite " reactions (Qi-moving herbs made her gassy and

constipated, SP

> building and middle-Qi moving made her vomit and her intestines

spasm, and a

> heavily warming formula made her freeze), could there be some kind

of

> psychoemotional/spiritual blockage to herbal substances? I do

extremely mild

> acupuncture with her, meridian-style with Seirin #1's, and she has

a

> " spiritual journey " each time.

>

> Any thoughts?

>

> Benjamin B. Hawes M.A.O.M., Lic. Ac.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Hi,

 

I've seen a situation like this, and circulating the lung qi seemed

to be the key to warming her up. She also had been a smoker, and I

thought that had something to do with it. There seems to be a

combination of insubstantial phlegm with lung dryness and both qi

deficiency and stagnation, so you have to be sure and use herbs that

are not drying. Consider adding Bai Bu or Xing Ren or Zi Wan to the

formula. That's what did the trick for her.

 

Laura

 

 

Chinese Medicine , " shannahickle "

<shannahickle> wrote:

> Just a thought. Have you considered Si Ni San, perhaps with

> modifications? Perhaps she's experiencing so much stagnation that

> she's unable to perfuse the extremities?

>

> Regards, Shanna

>

> Chinese Medicine , " Benjamin

> Hawes " <ben_laura@n...> wrote:

> > Here's a puzzler:

> >

> > 48 y.o female Patient with hx of endometriosis, excruciating

> (though

> > regular) periods, pain both preceding and during. Hx. of sexual

> abuse. Light

> > smoker. Tends toward cold, both core and extremities, even in

> summer, though

> > gets night sweats. I have been treating her with AP and

> Craniosacral therapy

> > with great results for musculoskeletal and menstrual pain. DX: 1)

> KD Yang

> > Def. 2) Blood stagnation in lower warmer 3) Cold in uterus 4)

> Liver Qi

> > stagnation 5) Heart Blood deficiency 6) Sp Qi deficiency.

> >

> > The issue: I have tried giving her herbs, unsuccessfully. First I

> tried

> > moving Liver Qi, mildly moving blood, and building Blood & Yin.

> Went with

> > Health Concerns' " Women's Balance " (Dan Zhi Xiao Yao San) and Jia

> Jian Ding

> > Xin Wan ( " Calm Spirit " - also includes enzymes for stress and

> digestion).

> > Combination caused gas and constipation, so switched her to a

> warmer formula

> > than Dan Zhi Xiao Yao San, one with Gotu Kola substituted for

Chai

> Hu

> > ( " Heavenly Water " ). This also produced gas, and less

constipation,

> but still

> > difficult BM's. Decided to work on building blood by building up

a

> possibly

> > deficient SP, so replaced Ding Xin Wan with Gui Pi Tang (Shen Gem

> from

> > Health Concerns). She took two pills, and vomited, then

> experienced lasting

> > lower right quadrant discomfort for two weeks.

> > Reevaluated, decided to go after the cold in the lower warmer.

Also

> > postulated that she might be sensitive to the binders in the

> tablets, so

> > switched to tincture. Went with K'an " Women's Journey " , or Jia

> Jian Wen Jing

> > Tang:

> > (Mu Li Oyster Shell 12.3%

> > E Jiao (A Jiao) Gelatin 8.3%

> > Mu Dan Pi (Su) Moutan 8.3%

> > Mai Men Dong Ophiopogon 8.3%

> > Bai Shao Peony (White) 8.3%

> > Dang Gui (Shen) Tangkuei 8.3%

> > Sheng Jiang Ginger (Fresh) 5.6%

> > Wu Zhu Yu Evodia Fruit 5.6%

> > Gui Zhi Cinnamon Twigs 5.6%

> > Xian Mao Curculigo 4.2%

> > Sheng Di Huang Rehmannia (Fresh) 4.2%

> > Gan Cao Licorice 4.2%

> > Zhi Mu Anemarrhena 4.2%

> > Ren Shen Ginseng 4.2%

> > Ba Ji Tian Morinda 4.2%

> > Huang Bai (Chuan) Phellodendron Bark 4.2%

> >

> > She took 8 drops 3x/day (minimum dosage, per manufacturer), and

> for five

> > days she wasn't warmer, but FREEZING COLD!

> > I can't get my head around how a formula with evodia, ginger,

> morinda,

> > curculigo, ginseng, and cinnamon could cool her off, and not warm

> her.

> > I have contacted the distributor - maybe the batch is bad

> (mislabled, wrong

> > ratio, etc). But is there a TCM (or other) explanation? Given her

> other

> > " opposite " reactions (Qi-moving herbs made her gassy and

> constipated, SP

> > building and middle-Qi moving made her vomit and her intestines

> spasm, and a

> > heavily warming formula made her freeze), could there be some

kind

> of

> > psychoemotional/spiritual blockage to herbal substances? I do

> extremely mild

> > acupuncture with her, meridian-style with Seirin #1's, and she

has

> a

> > " spiritual journey " each time.

> >

> > Any thoughts?

> >

> > Benjamin B. Hawes M.A.O.M., Lic. Ac.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Benjamin,

 

I think there two issues here. One is the accuracy of the content information

on the labels/inserts. Because you are not using raw herbs, you have to rely on

the accuracy of the information that is provided on the label or inserts to

ascertain the contents in the herb. I believe that the information provided on

the label is reliable for the most part, but the reality can vary. For

instance, the formula you provided below could have much greater percentage of

Mai Meng Dong and smaller percentage than reported for the warmer herbs. Labels

are always the same, but the herbal contents can vary from one lot to another

depending on how consistently quality control is carried out in the production

facility. Nevertheless, if you give the same batches of herbs (with the same

lot number) to other patients and they reacted with the treatment effect that

you expected, it is more likely that the problem lies with the patient. You

might want to ask her what kind of liquid (hot or cold) did

she drink to taker her prescription.

 

The second issue here is the patient. I had a wonderful female patient who came

in with a hip injury from a fall. She, like your patient, is extremely cold

physically from the core to the extremities. I remember giving her Jing Kuei

Shen Qi Wan to treat her frequent urination problem, and it took a month and a

half of continuous consumption before the pills took effect. After that, it was

great and her urination problem was under control. What I have learned from her

is that when you encounter a patient like her, you have to think warm thoughts.

I was using needles to treat her, but I was only getting minimal results

(meaning slightly better than placebo) at best. Then, out of frustration and

much contemplation (in calm), I decided to replace all needles with moxa, which

means where I would normally use the needles I burn moxa instead. From that

point on, the treatment effects starts to improve dramatically, and I was

getting the results I wanted for her. I was happy. She

was happy. Everybody was happy.

 

Given the cold nature of her body, she might be extremely sensitive to cold

herbs as I suspect the that vomiting, the gas, and constipation, etc., are all

reactions to herbs that are cold. In her case, raw herbs may actually be better

for you, because you would have control of the contents. Your prescriptions and

diagnosis are very good. The only suggestion I have would be to minimize or

eliminate any content that is cold or slightly cold from your herbal formula

prescription and see if she still reacts the same way.

 

Hope this rambling helps.

 

Sincerely,

 

Ming

 

Benjamin Hawes <ben_laura wrote:

Here's a puzzler:

 

48 y.o female Patient with hx of endometriosis, excruciating (though

regular) periods, pain both preceding and during. Hx. of sexual abuse. Light

smoker. Tends toward cold, both core and extremities, even in summer, though

gets night sweats. I have been treating her with AP and Craniosacral therapy

with great results for musculoskeletal and menstrual pain. DX: 1) KD Yang

Def. 2) Blood stagnation in lower warmer 3) Cold in uterus 4) Liver Qi

stagnation 5) Heart Blood deficiency 6) Sp Qi deficiency.

 

The issue: I have tried giving her herbs, unsuccessfully. First I tried

moving Liver Qi, mildly moving blood, and building Blood & Yin. Went with

Health Concerns' " Women's Balance " (Dan Zhi Xiao Yao San) and Jia Jian Ding

Xin Wan ( " Calm Spirit " - also includes enzymes for stress and digestion).

Combination caused gas and constipation, so switched her to a warmer formula

than Dan Zhi Xiao Yao San, one with Gotu Kola substituted for Chai Hu

( " Heavenly Water " ). This also produced gas, and less constipation, but still

difficult BM's. Decided to work on building blood by building up a possibly

deficient SP, so replaced Ding Xin Wan with Gui Pi Tang (Shen Gem from

Health Concerns). She took two pills, and vomited, then experienced lasting

lower right quadrant discomfort for two weeks.

Reevaluated, decided to go after the cold in the lower warmer. Also

postulated that she might be sensitive to the binders in the tablets, so

switched to tincture. Went with K'an " Women's Journey " , or Jia Jian Wen Jing

Tang:

(Mu Li Oyster Shell 12.3%

E Jiao (A Jiao) Gelatin 8.3%

Mu Dan Pi (Su) Moutan 8.3%

Mai Men Dong Ophiopogon 8.3%

Bai Shao Peony (White) 8.3%

Dang Gui (Shen) Tangkuei 8.3%

Sheng Jiang Ginger (Fresh) 5.6%

Wu Zhu Yu Evodia Fruit 5.6%

Gui Zhi Cinnamon Twigs 5.6%

Xian Mao Curculigo 4.2%

Sheng Di Huang Rehmannia (Fresh) 4.2%

Gan Cao Licorice 4.2%

Zhi Mu Anemarrhena 4.2%

Ren Shen Ginseng 4.2%

Ba Ji Tian Morinda 4.2%

Huang Bai (Chuan) Phellodendron Bark 4.2%

 

She took 8 drops 3x/day (minimum dosage, per manufacturer), and for five

days she wasn't warmer, but FREEZING COLD!

I can't get my head around how a formula with evodia, ginger, morinda,

curculigo, ginseng, and cinnamon could cool her off, and not warm her.

I have contacted the distributor - maybe the batch is bad (mislabled, wrong

ratio, etc). But is there a TCM (or other) explanation? Given her other

" opposite " reactions (Qi-moving herbs made her gassy and constipated, SP

building and middle-Qi moving made her vomit and her intestines spasm, and a

heavily warming formula made her freeze), could there be some kind of

psychoemotional/spiritual blockage to herbal substances? I do extremely mild

acupuncture with her, meridian-style with Seirin #1's, and she has a

" spiritual journey " each time.

 

Any thoughts?

 

Benjamin B. Hawes M.A.O.M., Lic. Ac.

 

 

 

 

 

Membership requires that you do not post any commerical, swear, religious, spam

messages,flame another member or swear.

 

 

http://babel.altavista.com/

 

 

and adjust

accordingly.

 

If you , it takes a few days for the messages to stop being

delivered.

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Hi, can I give my two pennies here?

 

> Benjamin Hawes <ben_laura wrote:

> DX: 1) KD Yang

> Def. 2) Blood stagnation in lower warmer 3) Cold in

> uterus 4) Liver Qi

> stagnation 5) Heart Blood deficiency 6) Sp Qi

> deficiency.

 

I might view her dx from the info provided as

follows:

1) K Yang Deficiency

2) Qi Deficiency

3) K Yin Deficiency

4) Blood STASIS in the lower warmer / Liver merid.

(due to cold? congestion? deficiency?)

etc

 

> (Mu Li Oyster Shell 12.3%

> E Jiao (A Jiao) Gelatin 8.3%

> Mu Dan Pi (Su) Moutan 8.3%

> Mai Men Dong Ophiopogon 8.3%

> Bai Shao Peony (White) 8.3%

> Dang Gui (Shen) Tangkuei 8.3%

> Sheng Jiang Ginger (Fresh) 5.6%

> Wu Zhu Yu Evodia Fruit 5.6%

> Gui Zhi Cinnamon Twigs 5.6%

> Xian Mao Curculigo 4.2%

> Sheng Di Huang Rehmannia (Fresh) 4.2%

> Gan Cao Licorice 4.2%

> Zhi Mu Anemarrhena 4.2%

> Ren Shen Ginseng 4.2%

> Ba Ji Tian Morinda 4.2%

> Huang Bai (Chuan) Phellodendron Bark 4.2%

 

The overall impression I'm getting as well as my

clinical experience suggest that the Mu Li is a major

problem for her, with the sheng di huang coming in

second. The Mai Dong and Zhi Mu I would also delete. I

might try Shu Di instead of Sheng Di.

 

> days she wasn't warmer, but FREEZING COLD!

 

Mu Li and maybe Sheng Di as well.

Remember the Heart fire is closely connected to the

Kidney yang. Put one out, put the other out.

 

> " opposite " reactions (Qi-moving herbs made her gassy

> and constipated, SP

> building and middle-Qi moving made her vomit and her

> intestines spasm,

 

My idea here is the secondary dx of Qi deficiency

from my pov. I would tend to not move qi around since

that will consume qi.

In cases like hers I've used used acupuncture / moxa

/ TDP lamp (boost k yang, boost qi, boost yin) to

start, for at least 1 month, then I start with a very

low dose of zhi bai (hollow heat / yin deficiency). I

stay away from all cold herbs, _especially those that

pacify the heart_.

 

I'm looking up the Gui Pi tang from health concerns

that you mentioned ...

AAAAAAAAAAAAA that formula has Dan Shen / salvia in

it!!! Bitter and Cold!!! Invigorates blood and breaks

blood stasis!

So anyway, in terms of my diagnosis, that woudl eb a

problem.

 

I'd be interested in a fuller picture of her Heart

function, see if any of what I've said adds up.

 

My final advice, and the only one I'll stand by is

that with patients who are very weak, I very slowly

build them up with acupuncture, making the important

changes to their diet (remove damaging foods), and

then I very carefully start them on a very basic

_classical_ formula. Something for yang, yin, blood,

you know? I don't do any complicated energetic stuff

with them, that means no formulas that have complex

energetic movements to them. Straightforward and basic

seems to work for me. I deal with a lot of geriatric

cases and it's just to complicated. I try to get a

really good idea of what the roots are, and then treat

that gently and simply.

 

 

 

I hope this helps and makes sense. Ask if you have

any questions.

 

Bye!

Hugo

 

 

 

 

 

 

_________ALL-NEW

Messenger - sooooo many all-new ways to express yourself

http://uk.messenger.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

>Message: 3

 

>Mon, 12 Jul 2004 10:04:32 -0700 (PDT)

 

> " Ming H. Lee " <aceqihealer

 

>Re: Opposite reactions to herbs

 

 

 

>I think there two issues here. One is the accuracy of the content

information on the labels/inserts.

 

 

 

>.Given the cold nature of her body, she might be extremely sensitive to

cold herbs as I suspect the that vomiting, the >gas, and constipation, etc.,

are all reactions to herbs that are cold. In her case, raw herbs may

actually be better for >you, because you would have control of the contents.

Your prescriptions and diagnosis are very good. The only >suggestion I have

would be to minimize or eliminate any content that is cold or slightly cold

from your herbal formula >prescription and see if she still reacts the same

way.

 

 

 

I am assuming for the point of argument that the percentages the

manufacturer gives are accurate. They use HPLC testing, etc. to insure

consistency. The potency of the herbs batch to batch could be an issue, but

the same could be said of raw herbs. She only drinks warm liquids, so that

plays no part.

 

 

 

However, looking back at the patent formula, it does seem to be much colder

than the original Wen Jing Tang - the ratios are nearly reversed! I don't

know why a manufacturer - under the direction of Ted Kaptchuk, no less! -

would take a warming formula and turn it into a potentially cooling formula.

It seems irresponsible, especially since they don't list percentages on

their packaging (Crane Herbs, a distributor, provided that info).

 

 

 

> (Mu Li Oyster Shell 12.3%

 

> E Jiao (A Jiao) Gelatin 8.3%

 

> Mu Dan Pi (Su) Moutan 8.3%

 

> Mai Men Dong Ophiopogon 8.3%

 

> Bai Shao Peony (White) 8.3%

 

> Dang Gui (Shen) Tangkuei 8.3%

 

> Sheng Jiang Ginger (Fresh) 5.6%

 

> Wu Zhu Yu Evodia Fruit 5.6%

 

> Gui Zhi Cinnamon Twigs 5.6%

 

> Xian Mao Curculigo 4.2%

 

> Sheng Di Huang Rehmannia (Fresh) 4.2%

 

> Gan Cao Licorice 4.2%

 

> Zhi Mu Anemarrhena 4.2%

 

> Ren Shen Ginseng 4.2%

 

> Ba Ji Tian Morinda 4.2%

 

> Huang Bai (Chuan) Phellodendron Bark 4.2%

 

 

 

>Message: 4

 

> Mon, 12 Jul 2004 19:58:40 +0100 (BST)

 

> Hugo Ramiro <subincor

 

>Re: Opposite reactions to herbs

 

 

 

> The overall impression I'm getting as well as my

 

>clinical experience suggest that the Mu Li is a major

 

>problem for her, with the sheng di huang coming in

 

>second. The Mai Dong and Zhi Mu I would also delete. I

 

>might try Shu Di instead of Sheng Di.

 

 

 

>Mu Li and maybe Sheng Di as well.

 

> Remember the Heart fire is closely connected to the

 

>Kidney yang. Put one out, put the other out.

 

 

 

>I'm looking up the Gui Pi tang from health concerns

 

>that you mentioned ...

 

>AAAAAAAAAAAAA that formula has Dan Shen / salvia in

 

>it!!! Bitter and Cold!!! Invigorates blood and breaks

 

>blood stasis!

 

> So anyway, in terms of my diagnosis, that woudl eb a

 

>problem.

 

 

 

You both have pointed out how theory and practice may differ widely when

employing patent medicines, especially with hypersensitive patients. Like

the Wen Jing Tang, Gui Pi Tang should be a nourishing, overall warm formula,

but the manufacturer added moving, cooling herbs and transformed it into a

different formula. A lesson for me in reading the fine print and not

assuming a formula listing itself with a particular name actually reflects

the original formula.

 

 

 

Unfortunately, because of cost (I practice 4.5 hours from the closest city

among skeptical ranchers and farmers), I don't work with raw herbs / custom

powders. But I'll be sure to select the patents more carefully (i.e.

companies like Mayway, which do traditional, but GMP, formulas).

 

 

 

I think, then, that maybe this case is relatively simple, but the formulas,

as chosen, were incorrect, and this patient's reactions to the mismatch were

more dramatic than most. I am grateful for such discriminating patients -

they teach me so much.

 

 

 

Benjamin Hawes, MAOM, Lic. Ac.,

 

 

 

 

CORTEZ FAMILY ACUPUNCTURE

 

1430 E. Main Street, Suite #4

 

Cortez, CO 81321

 

(970) 565-0230

 

 

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...