Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org

Poor American Health Care

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Guest guest

Hello:

 

Here is a new study which indicates the generally poor

quality of health care in the US, no matter which

class of society one comes from.

 

Thus, it really is important for individuals to take

responsibility for their own health, as Vinod often

emphasizes. This news makes me appreciate even more

the work of Victoria and this group and thankful for

Chinese medicine for giving us alternatives.

 

Kind regards, Jack

 

Startling research from the biggest study ever of U.S.

health care quality suggests that Americans ¡ª rich,

poor, black, white ¡ª get roughly equal treatment, but

it's woefully mediocre for all.

 

" This study shows that health care has

equal-opportunity defects, " said Dr. Donald Berwick,

who runs the nonprofit Institute for Healthcare

Improvement in Cambridge, Mass.

 

The survey of nearly 7,000 patients, reported Thursday

in the New England Journal of Medicine, considered

only urban-area dwellers who sought treatment, but it

still challenged some stereotypes: These blacks and

Hispanics actually got slightly better medical

treatment than whites.

 

While the researchers acknowledged separate evidence

that minorities fare worse in some areas of expensive

care and suffer more from some conditions than whites,

their study found that once in treatment, minorities'

overall care appears similar to that of whites.

 

" It doesn't matter who you are. It doesn't matter

whether you're rich or poor, white or black, insured

or uninsured, " said chief author Dr. Steven Asch, at

the Rand Health research institute, in Santa Monica,

Calif. " We all get equally mediocre care. "

 

The researchers, who included U.S. Veterans Affairs

personnel, first published their findings for the

general population in June 2003. They reported the

breakdown by racial, income, and other social groups

on Thursday.

 

They examined medical records and phone interviews

from 6,712 randomly picked patients who visited a

medical office within a two-year period in 12

metropolitan areas from Boston to Miami to Seattle.

The group was not nationally representative but does

convey a broad picture of the country's health care

practices.

 

The survey examined whether people got the highest

standard of treatment for 439 measures ranging across

common chronic and acute conditions and disease

prevention. It looked at whether they got the right

tests, drugs and treatments.

 

Overall, patients received only 55 percent of

recommended steps for top-quality care ¡ª and no group

did much better or worse than that.

 

Blacks and Hispanics as a group each got 58 percent of

the best care, compared to 54 percent for whites.

Those with annual household income over $50,000 got 57

percent, 4 points more than people from households of

less than $15,000. Patients without insurance got 54

percent of recommended steps, just one point less than

those with managed care.

 

As to gender, women came out slightly ahead with 57

percent, compared to 52 percent for men. Young adults

did slightly better than the elderly.

 

There were narrow snapshots of inequality: An insured

white woman, for example, got 57 percent of the best

standard of care, while an uninsured black man got

just 51 percent.

 

" Though we are improving, disparities in health care

still exist, " said Dr. Garth Graham, director of the

U.S. Office of Minority Health.

 

Graham, who is black, pointed to other data showing

enduring inequality in care, including a large federal

study last year. He also said minorities go without

treatment more often than whites, and such people are

missed entirely by this survey.

 

Some experts took heart in the relative equality

within the survey. " The study did find some reassuring

things, " said Dr. Tim Carey, who runs a health service

research center at the University of North

Carolina-Chapel Hill.

 

But all health experts interviewed fretted about the

uniformly low standard. " Regardless of who you are or

what group you're in, there is a significant gap

between the care you deserve and the care you

receive, " said Dr. Reed Tuckson, who is black and a

vice president of United HealthGroup, which runs

health plans and sells medical data.

 

Health experts blame the overall poor care on an

overburdened, fragmented system that fails to keep

close track of patients with an increasing number of

multiple conditions.

 

Quality specialists said improvements can come with

more public reporting of performance, more uniform

training, more computerized checks and more

coordination by patients themselves.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Chinese Traditional Medicine , Herbee daLuvSlug <herbee

wrote:

>> My back pain has been controlled by a change of shoes, I

> am now wearing Barefoot technology (MBT) shoes, and they have made so

much OOPS - CHOPPED THIS OFF - LU BARLEY

 

Hi, Herbee. I am sorry about your mum; there are terrible statistics

on people killed by excessive drug-type medicines. I know of course

that it doesn't make you feel any better that she is " only " one of a

million.

 

But congrats to you on how far you have come on your own!

 

I wanted to ask about those MBT shoes. I don't have back pain except

that caused by working at quite hard physical labour 6 months of the

year, and all I have are the cheapest, worst boots and shoes

imaginable. Maybe those Barefoot shoes would help, so could you give

me some info, please? Tks! - Lu.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Herbee:

 

I used to conduct these types of surveys, and it is

amazing how little Americans know about their own

health care. Most place their faith in a doctor and

leave things at that, and many don't listen to the

doctor.

 

Most doctors are simply under the influence of the

pharmaceuticals, so its " a pill for this, a pill for

that. "

 

My mother, a retired nurse, was taking eleven

different pills daily a few years ago, don't know how

many per day she is up to now.

 

If a drug has side effects, you have to question what

it is doing to your body. Have you considered Chinese

medicine treatments for your conditions?

 

Kind regards, Jack

 

--- Herbee daLuvSlug <herbee wrote:

 

> This is something I just recently have

> discovered...I have to take my own

> health responsibility. I was on so many pills that

> I looked like a

> pharmacy. If I went to the doctor with another

> complaint, mostly I know

> now, was because of some medicine interaction, she

> gave me another pill.

> When I began to shake, and lost a lot of muscle

> control, I started to look

> up my meds, and my statin drugs I have been taking,

> can cause this,

> especially in high doses...which I was on, I told

> her, she switched the med

> to a different one, still a statin...finally I

> refused to take them. I told

> her that I knew it was them. Within 2 days, I

> stopped dropping things, and

> shaking. She basically said she could do nothing

> for me, if I refused to

> take the medication she prescribed for me. Since

> then, I have been

> prescribed a natural drug for reducing cholesterol,

> a lot of oolong tea, and

> I had a blood test day before yesterday, and my bad

> cholesterol is down more

> than it has been for years. Granted the niacin

> causes a little livable side

> effect, which is itching, and breaking into a sweat,

> for about 5 minutes,

> after taking the evening pill.

>

> I am now down to 2 prescription drugs, which I am

> afraid not to

> take...mainly because I lived with depression all my

> life, and panic

> attacks, and the Prozac and xanex have controlled

> this, and I have not been

> plagued with those two problems for 2 years now. My

> headaches continue, but

> are also livable. My back pain has been controlled

> by a change of shoes, I

> am now wearing Barefoot technology (MBT) shoes, and

> they have made so much

> difference, I cannot believe it.

>

> Just to know there is a way to take care of yourself

> without pissing off a

> doctor and taking things into your own hands, is

> great. I just wish I had

> known these things before my mom died. She was also

> on heavy does of statin

> drugs, and was told she had a pre Parkinson's

> condition. In my heart I

> really believe all her medications are what killed

> her.

>

> Thanks for reading me,

> Herbee

>

>

> On 3/16/06 12:31 AM, " Jack Sweeney "

> <mojavecowboy wrote:

>

> > Hello:

> >

> > Here is a new study which indicates the generally

> poor

> > quality of health care in the US, no matter which

> > class of society one comes from.

> >

> > Thus, it really is important for individuals to

> take

> > responsibility for their own health, as Vinod

> often

> > emphasizes. This news makes me appreciate even

> more

> > the work of Victoria and this group and thankful

> for

> > Chinese medicine for giving us alternatives.

> >

> > Kind regards, Jack

> >

> > Startling research from the biggest study ever of

> U.S.

> > health care quality suggests that Americans ¡ª

> rich,

> > poor, black, white ¡ª get roughly equal treatment,

> but

> > it's woefully mediocre for all.

> >

> > " This study shows that health care has

> > equal-opportunity defects, " said Dr. Donald

> Berwick,

> > who runs the nonprofit Institute for Healthcare

> > Improvement in Cambridge, Mass.

> >

> > The survey of nearly 7,000 patients, reported

> Thursday

> > in the New England Journal of Medicine, considered

> > only urban-area dwellers who sought treatment, but

> it

> > still challenged some stereotypes: These blacks

> and

> > Hispanics actually got slightly better medical

> > treatment than whites.

> >

> > While the researchers acknowledged separate

> evidence

> > that minorities fare worse in some areas of

> expensive

> > care and suffer more from some conditions than

> whites,

> > their study found that once in treatment,

> minorities'

> > overall care appears similar to that of whites.

> >

> > " It doesn't matter who you are. It doesn't matter

> > whether you're rich or poor, white or black,

> insured

> > or uninsured, " said chief author Dr. Steven Asch,

> at

> > the Rand Health research institute, in Santa

> Monica,

> > Calif. " We all get equally mediocre care. "

> >

> > The researchers, who included U.S. Veterans

> Affairs

> > personnel, first published their findings for the

> > general population in June 2003. They reported the

> > breakdown by racial, income, and other social

> groups

> > on Thursday.

> >

> > They examined medical records and phone interviews

> > from 6,712 randomly picked patients who visited a

> > medical office within a two-year period in 12

> > metropolitan areas from Boston to Miami to

> Seattle.

> > The group was not nationally representative but

> does

> > convey a broad picture of the country's health

> care

> > practices.

> >

> > The survey examined whether people got the highest

> > standard of treatment for 439 measures ranging

> across

> > common chronic and acute conditions and disease

> > prevention. It looked at whether they got the

> right

> > tests, drugs and treatments.

> >

> > Overall, patients received only 55 percent of

> > recommended steps for top-quality care ¡ª and no

> group

> > did much better or worse than that.

> >

> > Blacks and Hispanics as a group each got 58

> percent of

> > the best care, compared to 54 percent for whites.

> > Those with annual household income over $50,000

> got 57

> > percent, 4 points more than people from households

> of

> > less than $15,000. Patients without insurance got

> 54

> > percent of recommended steps, just one point less

> than

> > those with managed care.

> >

> > As to gender, women came out slightly ahead with

> 57

> > percent, compared to 52 percent for men. Young

> adults

> > did slightly better than the elderly.

> >

> > There were narrow snapshots of inequality: An

> insured

> > white woman, for example, got 57 percent of the

> best

> > standard of care, while an uninsured black man got

> > just 51 percent.

> >

> > " Though we are improving, disparities in health

> care

> > still exist, " said Dr. Garth Graham, director of

> the

> > U.S. Office of Minority Health.

> >

> > Graham, who is black, pointed to other data

> showing

> > enduring inequality in care, including a large

> federal

> > study last year. He also said minorities go

> without

> > treatment more often than whites, and such people

> are

> > missed entirely by this survey.

> >

> > Some experts took heart in the relative equality

>

=== message truncated ===

 

 

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

I have an appointment tomorrow with a local Chinese doctor, that comes

highly recommended, and also had to wait quite some time to get in to see

her. They are however the ones who recommended the oolong tea, only leaf,

no bags, and the cholesterol lowering meds, until they could see me. I have

to continue to be seen by a conventional doctor, or my insurance won¹t pay

for alternative. I also had an acupuncture treatment this week for my

headaches. I am working on it.

 

Herbee

 

 

On 3/16/06 5:58 PM, " Jack Sweeney " <mojavecowboy wrote:

 

> Herbee:

>

> I used to conduct these types of surveys, and it is

> amazing how little Americans know about their own

> health care. Most place their faith in a doctor and

> leave things at that, and many don't listen to the

> doctor.

>

> Most doctors are simply under the influence of the

> pharmaceuticals, so its " a pill for this, a pill for

> that. "

>

> My mother, a retired nurse, was taking eleven

> different pills daily a few years ago, don't know how

> many per day she is up to now.

>

> If a drug has side effects, you have to question what

> it is doing to your body. Have you considered Chinese

> medicine treatments for your conditions?

>

> Kind regards, Jack

>

> --- Herbee daLuvSlug <herbee wrote:

>

>> > This is something I just recently have

>> > discovered...I have to take my own

>> > health responsibility. I was on so many pills that

>> > I looked like a

>> > pharmacy. If I went to the doctor with another

>> > complaint, mostly I know

>> > now, was because of some medicine interaction, she

>> > gave me another pill.

>> > When I began to shake, and lost a lot of muscle

>> > control, I started to look

>> > up my meds, and my statin drugs I have been taking,

>> > can cause this,

>> > especially in high doses...which I was on, I told

>> > her, she switched the med

>> > to a different one, still a statin...finally I

>> > refused to take them. I told

>> > her that I knew it was them. Within 2 days, I

>> > stopped dropping things, and

>> > shaking. She basically said she could do nothing

>> > for me, if I refused to

>> > take the medication she prescribed for me. Since

>> > then, I have been

>> > prescribed a natural drug for reducing cholesterol,

>> > a lot of oolong tea, and

>> > I had a blood test day before yesterday, and my bad

>> > cholesterol is down more

>> > than it has been for years. Granted the niacin

>> > causes a little livable side

>> > effect, which is itching, and breaking into a sweat,

>> > for about 5 minutes,

>> > after taking the evening pill.

>> >

>> > I am now down to 2 prescription drugs, which I am

>> > afraid not to

>> > take...mainly because I lived with depression all my

>> > life, and panic

>> > attacks, and the Prozac and xanex have controlled

>> > this, and I have not been

>> > plagued with those two problems for 2 years now. My

>> > headaches continue, but

>> > are also livable. My back pain has been controlled

>> > by a change of shoes, I

>> > am now wearing Barefoot technology (MBT) shoes, and

>> > they have made so much

>> > difference, I cannot believe it.

>> >

>> > Just to know there is a way to take care of yourself

>> > without pissing off a

>> > doctor and taking things into your own hands, is

>> > great. I just wish I had

>> > known these things before my mom died. She was also

>> > on heavy does of statin

>> > drugs, and was told she had a pre Parkinson's

>> > condition. In my heart I

>> > really believe all her medications are what killed

>> > her.

>> >

>> > Thanks for reading me,

>> > Herbee

>> >

>> >

>> > On 3/16/06 12:31 AM, " Jack Sweeney "

>> > <mojavecowboy wrote:

>> >

>>> > > Hello:

>>> > >

>>> > > Here is a new study which indicates the generally

>> > poor

>>> > > quality of health care in the US, no matter which

>>> > > class of society one comes from.

>>> > >

>>> > > Thus, it really is important for individuals to

>> > take

>>> > > responsibility for their own health, as Vinod

>> > often

>>> > > emphasizes. This news makes me appreciate even

>> > more

>>> > > the work of Victoria and this group and thankful

>> > for

>>> > > Chinese medicine for giving us alternatives.

>>> > >

>>> > > Kind regards, Jack

>>> > >

>>> > > Startling research from the biggest study ever of

>> > U.S.

>>> > > health care quality suggests that Americans ¡ª

>> > rich,

>>> > > poor, black, white ¡ª get roughly equal treatment,

>> > but

>>> > > it's woefully mediocre for all.

>>> > >

>>> > > " This study shows that health care has

>>> > > equal-opportunity defects, " said Dr. Donald

>> > Berwick,

>>> > > who runs the nonprofit Institute for Healthcare

>>> > > Improvement in Cambridge, Mass.

>>> > >

>>> > > The survey of nearly 7,000 patients, reported

>> > Thursday

>>> > > in the New England Journal of Medicine, considered

>>> > > only urban-area dwellers who sought treatment, but

>> > it

>>> > > still challenged some stereotypes: These blacks

>> > and

>>> > > Hispanics actually got slightly better medical

>>> > > treatment than whites.

>>> > >

>>> > > While the researchers acknowledged separate

>> > evidence

>>> > > that minorities fare worse in some areas of

>> > expensive

>>> > > care and suffer more from some conditions than

>> > whites,

>>> > > their study found that once in treatment,

>> > minorities'

>>> > > overall care appears similar to that of whites.

>>> > >

>>> > > " It doesn't matter who you are. It doesn't matter

>>> > > whether you're rich or poor, white or black,

>> > insured

>>> > > or uninsured, " said chief author Dr. Steven Asch,

>> > at

>>> > > the Rand Health research institute, in Santa

>> > Monica,

>>> > > Calif. " We all get equally mediocre care. "

>>> > >

>>> > > The researchers, who included U.S. Veterans

>> > Affairs

>>> > > personnel, first published their findings for the

>>> > > general population in June 2003. They reported the

>>> > > breakdown by racial, income, and other social

>> > groups

>>> > > on Thursday.

>>> > >

>>> > > They examined medical records and phone interviews

>>> > > from 6,712 randomly picked patients who visited a

>>> > > medical office within a two-year period in 12

>>> > > metropolitan areas from Boston to Miami to

>> > Seattle.

>>> > > The group was not nationally representative but

>> > does

>>> > > convey a broad picture of the country's health

>> > care

>>> > > practices.

>>> > >

>>> > > The survey examined whether people got the highest

>>> > > standard of treatment for 439 measures ranging

>> > across

>>> > > common chronic and acute conditions and disease

>>> > > prevention. It looked at whether they got the

>> > right

>>> > > tests, drugs and treatments.

>>> > >

>>> > > Overall, patients received only 55 percent of

>>> > > recommended steps for top-quality care ¡ª and no

>> > group

>>> > > did much better or worse than that.

>>> > >

>>> > > Blacks and Hispanics as a group each got 58

>> > percent of

>>> > > the best care, compared to 54 percent for whites.

>>> > > Those with annual household income over $50,000

>> > got 57

>>> > > percent, 4 points more than people from households

>> > of

>>> > > less than $15,000. Patients without insurance got

>> > 54

>>> > > percent of recommended steps, just one point less

>> > than

>>> > > those with managed care.

>>> > >

>>> > > As to gender, women came out slightly ahead with

>> > 57

>>> > > percent, compared to 52 percent for men. Young

>> > adults

>>> > > did slightly better than the elderly.

>>> > >

>>> > > There were narrow snapshots of inequality: An

>> > insured

>>> > > white woman, for example, got 57 percent of the

>> > best

>>> > > standard of care, while an uninsured black man got

>>> > > just 51 percent.

>>> > >

>>> > > " Though we are improving, disparities in health

>> > care

>>> > > still exist, " said Dr. Garth Graham, director of

>> > the

>>> > > U.S. Office of Minority Health.

>>> > >

>>> > > Graham, who is black, pointed to other data

>> > showing

>>> > > enduring inequality in care, including a large

>> > federal

>>> > > study last year. He also said minorities go

>> > without

>>> > > treatment more often than whites, and such people

>> > are

>>> > > missed entirely by this survey.

>>> > >

>>> > > Some experts took heart in the relative equality

>> >

> === message truncated ===

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

> Post message: Chinese Traditional Medicine

> Subscribe: Chinese Traditional Medicine-

> Un: Chinese Traditional Medicine-

> List owner: Chinese Traditional Medicine-owner

>

> Shortcut URL to this page:

> /community/Chinese Traditional Medicine

>

>

>

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

http://www.walkerswarehouse.com/fitness_cat/shoes/mbt_shoes_by_swiss_masai.a

sp

 

http://www.swissmasaius.com/

 

The first site is the best for purchasing them, the second one explains the

technology...and I am living proof they work.

 

Herbee

 

 

 

On 3/16/06 2:16 PM, " Mrs. Barley " <chosenbarley wrote:

 

> Chinese Traditional Medicine , Herbee daLuvSlug <herbee

> wrote:

>>> >> My back pain has been controlled by a change of shoes, I

>> > am now wearing Barefoot technology (MBT) shoes, and they have made so

> much OOPS - CHOPPED THIS OFF - LU BARLEY

>

> Hi, Herbee. I am sorry about your mum; there are terrible statistics

> on people killed by excessive drug-type medicines. I know of course

> that it doesn't make you feel any better that she is " only " one of a

> million.

>

> But congrats to you on how far you have come on your own!

>

> I wanted to ask about those MBT shoes. I don't have back pain except

> that caused by working at quite hard physical labour 6 months of the

> year, and all I have are the cheapest, worst boots and shoes

> imaginable. Maybe those Barefoot shoes would help, so could you give

> me some info, please? Tks! - Lu.

>

 

> Post message: Chinese Traditional Medicine

> Subscribe: Chinese Traditional Medicine-

> Un: Chinese Traditional Medicine-

> List owner: Chinese Traditional Medicine-owner

>

> Shortcut URL to this page:

> /community/Chinese Traditional Medicine

>

>

>

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Chinese Traditional Medicine , Herbee daLuvSlug <herbee

wrote:

>

>

http://www.walkerswarehouse.com/fitness_cat/shoes/mbt_shoes_by_swiss_m

asai.a

> sp

>

> http://www.swissmasaius.com/

>

> The first site is the best for purchasing them, the second one

explains the

> technology...and I am living proof they work.

>

> Herbee

>

>

>

>-Thank you very much, Herbee. They are a bit on the pricey side for

shoes, aren't they...I wear $8.00 running shoes made out of canvas

and this will take a bit of saving up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

What were the " 439 measures " that the participants'

care in this study were judged by?

 

Penel

who isn't satisfied being told of a symptom

and wants to know the etiology of disfunction

 

<snip>

> The survey examined whether people got the highest

> standard of treatment for 439 measures ranging across

> common chronic and acute conditions and disease

> prevention. It looked at whether they got the right

> tests, drugs and treatments.

>

> Overall, patients received only 55 percent of

> recommended steps for top-quality care ¡ª and no group

> did much better or worse than that.

>

> Blacks and Hispanics as a group each got 58 percent of

> the best care, compared to 54 percent for whites.

> Those with annual household income over $50,000 got 57

> percent, 4 points more than people from households of

> less than $15,000. Patients without insurance got 54

> percent of recommended steps, just one point less than

> those with managed care.

>

> As to gender, women came out slightly ahead with 57

> percent, compared to 52 percent for men. Young adults

> did slightly better than the elderly.

>

> There were narrow snapshots of inequality: An insured

> white woman, for example, got 57 percent of the best

> standard of care, while an uninsured black man got

> just 51 percent.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

Yes they are, but they have a lifetime guarantee...which makes it worth it.

I think, and yes, I did have to save up for them, and now am saving for some

sandals for summer, if we ever get any.

 

Herbee

 

 

>

>> >

>> >

>> >-Thank you very much, Herbee. They are a bit on the pricey side for

> shoes, aren't they...I wear $8.00 running shoes made out of canvas

> and this will take a bit of saving up.

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...