Home made colloidal/ionic silver versus commercial

[Guest guest]

I won't disagree with you at all - I think that the better home

generators produce products that are equal to, and sometimes superior

to, many of the commercial products.

 

When it comes to the products of Utopia Silver, the difference in

particle size is vast and thus even the very best homemade silver is

still far inferior to that product because of the much larger surface

area you get from smaller particle sizes.

 

Look at it this way - if you fill a 50 gallon can with basketballs, or

even softballs you will not get but a fraction of the surface area you

would get from filling the same container with BB's.

 

If you take the chart and figure that 90 to 95% of the surface area

was not taken into account, then you can multiply the surface area and

efficiency figures by either 10 or 20 and you will find they still

fall far short of the best figures on the chart (the ones for

Mesosilver and the ones that should be published for Utopia Silver).

 

BTW, from what I understand most quality home generators produce a

product that is about 85% ionic and 15% colloidal - which I think is

actually better than a higher ionic content if the silver is going to

be used for anything other than topical use and uses that do not

require the silver to pass through the digestive system.

 

 

oleander soup , " Norton, Steve "

<stephen.norton wrote:

>

> Just FYI. The reason that the Home Brewed is rated so low in the

> evaluation is because only the silver particle portion of the Home

> Brewed ionic silver was considered in the evaluation. In actuality,

> silver ions, which make up roughly 80 - 95 percent of the brew, are

> individual atoms and would provide the highest particle surface area of

> all. There are other issues relative to silver ions but Home Brewed

> ionic silver performs much better than the comparison states.

> - Steve

>

>

> ________________________________

>

> oleander soup oleander soup

> On Behalf Of bbanever

> Wednesday, November 12, 2008 7:18 AM

> oleander soup

> Re: [!! SPAM] Mesosilver

>

>

>

> simonflynn22,

>

> No, your premise is wrong. What destroys pathogens are silver ions,

> not particles. Mesosilver is made from silver particles that carry no

> charge. Ions are positively charged silver particles (very small

> nanoparticles) that get attracted to negatively charged microbes. It is

> true that silver particles become ions in the body, but IMO not to the

> extent that you need. In my own experience, I used Mesosilver to try and

>

> rid myself of a sinus infection to no avail. The next time I got the

> infection (it was chronic) I used ionic silver that I made myself. It

> cleared the infection in a day and a half. I no longer get it at all

> thanks to using ionic silver as a nasal wash two or three times a week

> for

> about 6 months. Put it in my waterpik and added a nasal irrigation

> attachment.

>

> Bob

> -

> " simonflynn22 " <simon041082

> <simon041082%40hotmail.com> >

> <oleander soup

> <oleander soup%40> >

> Wednesday, November 12, 2008 6:01 AM

> [!! SPAM] Mesosilver

>

> I was looking at the following table which compares various types of

> colloidal silver and it seems that Mesosilver has the highest

> particle surface area and efficiency index, does this mean it is

> superior to Utopia Silver? I dont want to ruffle any feathers here

> but shouldnt people use the best available product?

>

> Product Name (P.S.A.*) [Eff.*]

> Home Brewed w/ SG-7 (0.024) [1.64]

> Silver Shield Colloidal Silver (0.027) [0.19]

> Silver Biotics 10 (0.035) [03.2]

> ASAP 10 (0.112) [10.2]

> Sovereign Silver 10 (0.217) [22.3]

> Ultra Pure Col. Silver 35 (0.225) [13.6]

> Argentyn 23 (0.355) [22.6]

> ASAP 22 (0.587) [26.3]

> Futurebiotics Adv. Col. Silver 30 (0.591) [61.6]

> Int.Pharm.Invive 50 (0.621) [04.4]

> Electra Clear Col. Silver 10 (0.662) [25.1]

> Source Naturals Col. Silver 30 (0.881) [24.3]

> Kelly Colloidal Silver 20 (1.420) [12.2]

> Utopia Advanced. Col. Silver 20 (12.20) [92.4]

> Innovative Natural Products 500 (12.39) [20.5]

> MesoSilver® 20 (104.7) [5235]

>

> P.S.A = Particle Surface Area

> Eff. = Efficiency Index

>

> ---

>

>