Guest guest Posted November 1, 2002 Report Share Posted November 1, 2002 > of what TCM says about it. I find out more > and more all the time as do most PWC's (I'll adopt > Victoria's term) who do the research. I can't take credit for the term. It's been in widespread use in the literature on CFS/ CFIDS since way before I was diagnosed. " People with (fill-in-the-blank) " frequently is abbreviated as PW (initial(s)). It saves a lot of typing and space. Victoria Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 1, 2002 Report Share Posted November 1, 2002 > 2. I see no reason why each of us cannot add our own > experience and understanding to the monolithic CM > literature and system, and participate in its > /unfolding/, /self-recognition/ and advancement. Hugo, you just summed up one of the biggest strengths of TCM. Its ability to evolve and grow to meet new challenges while remaining true to foundations that work. This is quite a balancing act, and for the most part the Chinese have pulled it off beautifully throughout the ages. Honor and respect the old while allowing for expansion. In general, TCM and the Chinese are not paradigm-rigid. Individual Chinese can be as paradigm-rigid as the paradigm-rigid individuals of any race, country, etc., but overall, this has not been the predominate influence on TCM. At least not for long. TCM is concerned with what is happening as opposed to what should be happening according to some model. When they do encounter something that doesn't fit the current model, instead of chucking the model (like true believers in search of one holy grail), they expand the model to be able to account for the situations that don't fit. The classic example being the 6 Stages of Cold-Induced Illnesses. As the Chinese started to suffer from infectious illnesses that the 6 Stages could not explain and manage, instead of tossing the 6 Stages model, they added a Virulent Heat model. Which was wise because some infectious illnesses still are better explained and respond better to the 6 Stages of Cold-Induced Illnesses model than to the Virulent Heat model. An analogy in the West is what happened once antibodies (and other anti-drugs) became the " true " " magic bullet " model of how to treat illness. Western medicine forgot about and no longer practiced many of the basic, simple, and inexpensive healing techniques that had helped so much in the past. They were at best " old-fashioned and not important " to " superstition " at worst. The irony is that some of the basic, simple, and inexpensive healing techiques often are the only things that bring relief to some sufferers of some medical conditions, and the " magic bullet " approach makes them sicker. > 3. If you find there to be a limitation to CM, it is > important to express it and discuss it rather than > toss it out as an aside. If we toss that sort of > comment off as an aside, it seems to me that we > devalue the absolutely tremendous depth of > understanding and > cultural/emotional/physical/mental/spiritual cohesion > which CM represents. Which is a big part of the reason why TCM has been able to evolve, grow, and remain so viable. The ability of so many practitioners of TCM to recognize limitations and to seek solutions that do work. If one is in the rigid framework of believing one has THE One True answer, one is not going to be searching for something that does work. One does not seek to improve that which one believes is already perfect. Or even the only thing there is that could possibly help. > Every TCM doctor (including those trained in western > med) I've asked has stated that it is beneficial to > learn both, but that CM should be learned first, > because the thinking is so subtle and easily overcome > by the brute force of modern science. It is possible to learn the Western science and medicine first and still be able to grasp the subtleties of TCM. But one has to be willing to realize that Western medicine is not The One and Only Truth and that something else is needed. One also must be willing and able to adopt new frameworks and perspectives. I got forced into it in a manner of speaking. It was a situation of Western medicine not only not working and my getting steadily sicker, but of many of the Western treatments making me sicker. Clearer something else was needed. Long before I discovered TCM, I already had figured out the magic bullet thing not only was not working, it was making me sicker a lot of the time. I began to discover new ways of looking at healing and alternative things that did help. By the time I discovered TCM, the underlying concepts were not that alien to me and made perfect sense. The treatment also got some dramatic results - even better than I had hoped for. I sometimes think I got a healing education the hard way - through being sick! It doesn't have to be that way for others. If they will just listen when their clients or patients say something is not working and try to figure out why as well as figuring something that does work, they too can appreciate and use TCM. When they are honest enough to admit to themselves that the magic bullet approach (or any other approach) does not always work (in fact the magic bullet apprach does not work more times than it does work), they will start to grasp at least some of those subtleties in a hurry. > movement! (plus practice of course) CM is a > compilation of human experience. It is so deep and > vibrant, and we can easily recognise it if we can only > do what the old ones did which is to pay extreeeemely > close attention to ourselves. We have a ready-set > system to stand on and guide us, so that each of us > can a) achieve what our forebears did, and b) see and > travel further. But we can't do that if we don't know > how to use the system! This sums it up very well, especially the achieving what our forebears did and see and travel further than they did. Thanks, Victoria Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.