Can Carbs Cause Breast Cancer?

[Guest guest]

Today's Question

Can Carbs Cause Breast Cancer?

 

I thought a high-fat diet raised the risk of breast cancer. Now I

hear that a high-carb diet can be responsible. What's going on?

 

-- Stacy

 

 

Today's Answer (Published 10/15/2004)

I don't blame you for being confused. The issue of diet and breast

cancer is complex. We know that certain types of fats seem to be

protective and others seem to raise the risk. The protective ones

are monounsaturated fats such as olive oil and essential fatty acids

such as omega-3 fatty acids found in salmon, walnuts and flaxseeds.

The saturated fats from animal products and trans-fats (found in

partially hydrogenated oils) appear to raise the risk of breast

cancer, as they do for heart disease.

 

The latest news on diet and breast cancer comes from a study just

published in the August, 2004 issue of Cancer Epidemiology,

Biomarkers & Prevention. Results suggested that high-carbohydrate

diets might raise the risk of breast cancer. The study was conducted

in Mexico and was sponsored by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control

and Prevention, the Ministry of Health of Mexico and the American

Institute for Cancer Research. The researchers compared the diets of

475 Mexican women newly diagnosed with breast cancer with those of a

control group of 1,391 healthy women of the same age who had similar

risk factors for breast cancer as the women who developed the

disease.

 

They found that the women who got 62 percent or more of their

calories from carbs advertisement

 

2.2 times more likely to develop breast cancer than those whose carb

intake was lowest, 52 percent or less of their diets. Most American

women eat fewer carbs than the women in this study, and they eat

different carbs, too. The Mexican women were more likely to consume

corn-based carbohydrates like tortillas as well as soft drinks and

bread.

 

Nutritionally speaking, the Mexican diet may be less than optimal

for cancer prevention. For example, corn products sold there aren't

fortified with folate and other nutrients as are many grains and

cereals in the United States.

 

The study also showed that the breast cancer risk was somewhat lower

among women who ate the most insoluble fiber (found in whole grains,

fruits and vegetables).

 

This study certainly doesn't suggest that women should adopt low

carb diets in an effort to protect themselves against breast cancer.

If you do want to cut carbs, limit the ones high on the glycemic

index but be sure to include lots of healthy fruits and vegetables

in your diet, avoid trans-fats, reduce consumption of saturated fat,

and rely on (extra-virgin) olive oil. And be sure to include wild

Alaskan salmon, sardines, walnuts, and flaxseeds to get your omega-

3s.

 

Andrew Weil, M.D.

www.drweil.com