U.S. HAS CONTINGENCY PLANS FOR A DRAFT OF MEDICAL WORKERS

[Guest guest]

U.S. HAS CONTINGENCY PLANS FOR A DRAFT OF MEDICAL WORKERS

By Robert Pear

New York Times

October 19, 2004

 

http://www.nytimes.com/2004/10/19/politics/19draft.html

 

WASHINGTON - The Selective Service has been updating its contingency plans

for a draft of doctors, nurses and other health care workers in case of a

national emergency that overwhelms the military's medical corps.

 

In a confidential report this summer, a contractor hired by the agency

described how such a draft might work, how to secure compliance and how to

mold public opinion and communicate with health care professionals, whose

lives could be disrupted.

 

On the one hand, the report said, the Selective Service System should

establish contacts in advance with medical societies, hospitals, schools of

medicine and nursing, managed care organizations, rural health care

providers and the editors of medical journals and trade publications.

 

On the other hand, it said, such contacts must be limited, low key and

discreet because " overtures from Selective Service to the medical community

will be seen as precursors to a draft, " and that could alarm the public.

 

In this election year, the report said, " very few ideas or activities are

viewed without some degree of cynicism. "

 

President Bush has flatly declared that there will be no draft, but Senator

John Kerry has suggested that this is a possibility if Mr. Bush is

re-elected.

 

Richard S. Flahavan, a spokesman for the Selective Service System, said

Monday: " We have been routinely updating the entire plan for a health care

draft. The plan is on the shelf and will remain there unless Congress and

the president decide that it's needed and direct us to carry it out. "

 

The Selective Service does not decide whether a draft will occur. It would

carry out the mechanics only if the president and Congress authorized a

draft.

 

The chief Pentagon spokesman, Lawrence T. Di Rita, said Monday: " It is the

policy of this administration to oppose a military draft for any purpose

whatsoever. A return to the draft is unthinkable. There will be no draft. "

 

Mr. Di Rita said the armed forces could offer bonus pay and other incentives

to attract and retain medical specialists.

 

In 1987, Congress enacted a law requiring the Selective Service to develop a

plan for " registration and classification " of health care professionals

essential to the armed forces.

 

Under the plan, Mr. Flahavan said, about 3.4 million male and female health

care workers ages 18 to 44 would be expected to register with the Selective

Service. From this pool, he said, the agency could select tens of thousands

of health care professionals practicing in 62 health care specialties.

 

" The Selective Service System plans on delivering about 36,000 health care

specialists to the Defense Department if and when a special skills draft

were activated, " Mr. Flahavan said.

 

The contractor hired by Selective Service, Widmeyer Communications, said

that local government operations would be affected by a call-up of emergency

medical technicians, so it advised the Selective Service to contact groups

like the United States Conference of Mayors and the National Association of

Counties.

 

Doctors and nurses would be eligible for deferments if they could show that

they were providing essential health care services to civilians in their

communities.

 

But the contractor said: " There is no getting around the fact that a medical

draft would disrupt lives. Many familial, business and community

responsibilities will be impacted. "

 

Moreover, Widmeyer said, " if medical professionals are singled out and other

professionals are not called, many will find the process unfair, " and health

care workers will ask, " Why us? "

 

In a recent article in The Wisconsin Medical Journal, published by the state

medical society, Col. Roger A. Lalich, a senior physician in the Army

National Guard, said: " It appears that a general draft is not likely to

occur. A physician draft is the most likely conscription into the military

in the near future. "

 

Since 2003, the Selective Service has said it is shifting its preparations

for a draft in a national crisis toward narrow sectors of specialists,

including medical personnel.

 

Colonel Lalich, citing Selective Service memorandums on the subject, said

the Defense Department had indicated that " a conventional draft of untrained

manpower is not necessary for the war on terrorism. " But, he said, " the

Department of Defense has stated that what most likely will be needed is a

'special skills draft,' " including care workers in particular.

 

That view was echoed in a newsletter circulated recently by the Selective

Service System, which said the all-volunteer force had " critical shortages

of individuals with special skills'' that might be needed in a crisis.

 

The Selective Service and Widmeyer held focus groups this summer to sample

public opinion toward registration and a possible draft including medical

personnel. People from a variety of professions, including doctors and

nurses, were questioned.

 

The report summarized the findings this way:

 

- " There was substantial resistance to the notion of a call-up of civilian

professionals that would send draftees to foreign soil. "

 

- A draft of civilian professionals was seen as unworkable because " training

would be inadequate to transform groups of people who had never worked

together into cohesive units. "

 

- People are apprehensive about the length of service that might be

required. The " occupation of Iraq has proved more costly, in terms of

dollars and lives, than most Americans expected. " Members of the National

Guard are " serving tours of duty far longer than many ever anticipated. "

 

- People believe the government has the ability to " find whomever it needs "

in a crisis, by using a " master database " if necessary.

 

President Bush and Mr. Kerry have said they oppose a draft. " Forget all this

talk about a draft, " Mr. Bush said at the second presidential debate, on

Oct. 8 in St. Louis. " We're not going to have a draft so long as I'm the

president. "

 

But Mr. Kerry said, " You've got a backdoor draft right now " because " our

military is overextended " as a result of policies adopted by Mr. Bush.

 

Bryan G. Whitman, a spokesman for the Defense Department, said: " The

all-volunteer force has been working very well for 30 years. There is

absolutely no reason to go back to a draft. "

 

 

 

 

Sonya PLoS Medicine

The open-access general medical journal from the Public Library of Science

Inaugural issue: Autumn 2004 Share your discoveries with the world.

http://www.plosmedicine.org

 

 

 

 

 

______________________

______________________