Guest guest Posted February 8, 2004 Report Share Posted February 8, 2004 Good Morning! Is Acupuncture Effective In The Treatment of Fibromyalgia? Literature Journal Review by Andrew Pacholyk, L.Ac. MSTOM Purpose/Rationale The rationale behind this literature review is to take a look at the current research that has been done on the topic of fibromyalgia, in particular, the treatment of acupuncture on this disorder. This review will take a comprehensive look at the research; current trends in treatment for these symptoms and express the need for continued work in this most timely area of research. Fibromyalgia is a chronic disorder characterized by widespread musculoskeletal pain, fatigue, and multiple tender points. " Tender points " refers to tenderness that occurs in precise, localized areas, particularly in the neck, spine, shoulders, and hips. People with this syndrome may also experience sleep disturbances, morning stiffness, irritable bowel syndrome, anxiety, and other symptoms. The Merck Manual defines Fibromyalgia as used to describe several related disorders. Various alternative terms for these disorders have been used, including generalized fibromyalgia, which is 7 times more common in women than in men, the pain and stiffness are widespread, occurring throughout the body. Primary fibromyalgia syndrome is the most common variation of generalized fibromyalgia; it usually occurs in young or middle-aged women who have no associated or contributing underlying disorder. Secondary fibromyalgia syndrome is a type of generalized fibromyalgia and refers to fibromyalgia symptoms in a person who has another underlying disorder that is causing the fibromyalgia symptoms, such as hypothyroidism. Other disorders, such as systemic lupus erythematosus or rheumatoid arthritis, may be associated with fibromyalgia, but not be the underlying cause. Localized fibromyalgia expresses as pain and stiffness occurring in a particular area, or at a few sites, such as the jaw, neck, and/or shoulder muscles. Localized fibromyalgia is somewhat more likely to occur in men, possibly because they are more likely to engage in more physically muscular activities in occupational or sports situations. Sometimes, localized fibromyalgia gradually spreads to become generalized fibromyalgia. Myofascial pain syndrome is a type of localized or regional fibromyalgia which may occur in various sites and differentiated as temporomandibular type and myofascial pain syndrome. Previously, these disorders were collectively called fibrositis or fibromyositis syndromes, but because inflammation is not present, the " itis " suffix was dropped. Both Eastern and Western medicine agree that insomnia is a key to fibromyalgia. Western doctors prescribe sleeping pills. Chinese medicine aims to nourish the Heart and Liver, which are the two most important internal organs in regards to sleep, and to bring them into balance with the Spleen. With Heart blood deficiency, people find it difficult to fall asleep. With Liver Qi stagnation, sleep becomes restless, with intense dreams and a tendency to wake up early in the morning. Spleen and Heart deficiency would express as lying awake at night worrying about job, children, finances…. In the morning one would feel fatigued, with stiff, painful muscles. In treating these conditions, the goals are to regulate and move Liver Qi, harmonize the Liver and nourish the Spleen so it can do its job of transformation and transportation. This is done with acupuncture treatments combined with herbal formulas. Shu Gan Wan is a formula, which breaks up Liver Qi stagnation. Xiao Yao Wan is a formula used when a dysfunctional Liver is affecting the Spleen. An herbal formula called Gui Pi Wan, is specifically designed for Spleen and Heart deficiency. Calming exercise such as Tai Chi QiQong or yoga can also promote balance and health. The length of time it takes to see results from treatment depends on how serious the symptoms are, but most people notice improvement after six to eight treatments.(ii) Epidemiology, Morbidity, Cost According to the American College of Rheumatology, it's estimated that 3 million to 6 million Americans are living with this musculoskeletal disorder two thirds of them women, most of them white and most between 20 and 60 years old when first affected. Generalized fibromyalgia is 7 times more common in women than in men. (i) Insomnia seems to be the most common thread between the majorities of cases. Suffering from pain day in and day out, all over the body plus fatigue, anxiety and depression are problems that are encountered. There is no firm physical evidence of disease that can be detected by blood tests or X rays. Doctors diagnose fibromyalgia by testing 18 " tender points, " starting between the shoulders. People complain they are tender all over the body, but these areas, all where muscles attach to ligaments or bones, tend to have pain with just the pressure of a thumb. A major epidemiological study (iii) was conducted utilizing the administrative claims data of a Fortune 100 manufacturer, which were used to quantify direct (i.e., medical and pharmaceutical claims) and indirect (i.e., disability claims and imputed absenteeism) costs associated with fibromyaglia. A total of 4699 patients with at least one fibromyaglia claim between 1996 and 1998 were contrasted with a 10% random sample of the overall beneficiary population. Employee- only subsets of both samples also were drawn. Medical utilization, receipt of prescription drugs, and annual total costs were proportionately similar yet significantly greater among fibromyaglia claims than the overall sample (with a proportional value of p < 0.0001). Total annual costs for fibromyaglia patients were $5945 versus $2486 for the typical beneficiary (with a proportional value of p < 0.0001). 6% of these costs were attributable to fibromyaglia - specific claims. The prevalence of disability was twice as high among fibromyaglia employees than overall employees. For every dollar spent on fibromyaglia -specific claims, the employer spent another $57 to $143 on additional direct and indirect costs. Hidden costs of disability and co-morbidities greatly increase the true burden of fibromyaglia. Regardless of the clinical understanding of fibromyaglia, when a claim for fibromyaglia is present, considerable costs are involved. Impact of Conventional Health Care The burden of side effects from allopathic drugs is as numerous as the types of drugs that are prescribed for fibromyalgia. Patients who often take medications often experience side effects such as nausea, drowsiness, or lightheadedness. Analgesics are pain killers and can include over-the-counter medicines such as aspirin and acetaminophen, or prescription-strength pain pills like narcotics (opiates), codeine, Vicodin, Darvocet, Oxycontin and Percocet. These medications do not alter the fibromyalgia, but they can help take the edge off of pain. Narcotic medications have potential for adverse side effects including drowsiness, difficulty with concentrating, and addiction. Many people with fibromyalgia are sensitive to codeine medicines, which can cause nausea or an allergic reaction. Ultram can cause allergic reactions in people sensitive to codeine, and a small number of people taking Ultram have seizures. Anti-inflammatory medicines include aspirin, nonsteroidal anti- inflammatories (NSAIDs) such as ibuprofen, Naprosyn, Lodine, Daypro, and the newer Cox-II inhibitors, and corticosteroids such as prednisone or dexmethasone. The major side effect of the anti- inflammatory drugs is bleeding from gastrointestinal ulcers. This problem is more common the longer the medicine is taken. The antidepressant medicines include tricyclics (Amitriptyline, Nortriptyline, Doxepin, and Trazodone), and selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (Prozac, Zoloft, Paxil, Effexor, Serzone, and Celexa). Zoloft and Paxil can cause sexual dysfunction. Some of the newer medicines, Effexor and Serzone, for example, do not inhibit sexual function. These medicines can treat pain and alter sleep and mood disturbances seen in fibromyalgia. The tricyclic medicines are effective, but frequent side effects include dry mouth and drowsiness, extreme sedation and morning hangover. The most common reported concern about using sleep modifiers, especially benzodiazepams, is the habit-forming potential. Ambien is reported to be less habit-forming but can cause rebound insomnia when it's stopped. Some people report nightmares with these medicines. Anxiety is a common problem in fibromyalgia and contributes to pain, muscle tension, and irritability. It can make depression and insomnia worse. Various medicines including antidepressants and muscle relaxants treat anxiety. Benzodiazepines such as Klonopin, Ativan, and Xanax, are commonly used medicines. Possible side effects include depression and decreased memory. Sometimes it is hard to determine whether symptoms are due to fibromyalgia or are side effects of medication. (iv) Controversies In Research Publications The following are a review of the most appropriate studies done on the effects of acupuncture and fibromyalgia. The most apparent study that kept coming up in viewing the research on this topic and the studies and reviews most often referred to, is this study by Deluze, et al, " Is acupuncture effective in the treatment of fibromyalgia? " [1], which was a high quality study conducted in 1992 in Geneva, Switzerland. This randomized controlled trial was out to examine whether fibromyalgia patients got relief from real electroacupuncture versus sham acupuncture. The sham acupuncture was designed to mimic real acupuncture, but using nonacupuncture points and more superficial needling insertion. The real acupuncture group found significantly more relief (with a probability value of P < .05, Mann- Whitney test) than the sham acupuncture group based on 5 of 8 outcomes that were measured. The main outcome measures used were: pain threshold, number of analgesic tablets used, regional pain score, pain recorded on visual analogue scale, sleep quality, morning stiffness and patient and physician's evaluating appreciation. The Mann-Whitney test is used in place of a two-sample t-test when the populations are being compared, are not normal. The mean age range of the patients was 48 years old. The mean duration of a fibromyalgia diagnosis was 10.7 years. The inclusion criteria for these patients were all under the 1990 guidelines of the American College of Rheumatology. Out of the 70 participants, approximately 25% had no benefit, 50% experienced satisfactory benefit and the remaining 25% had unexpectedly large improvements with almost complete remissions. These percentages changed with intention-to- treat analysis. 42% had no benefit, 39% had satisfactory benefit and 19% had unexpectedly large benefit. Only one individual in the sham acupuncture had an unexpectedly large benefit. It is not known which factors predisposed the individual to improvement. 15 patients (21%) dropped out of the study. Those who dropped out, 11 were related to the acupuncture procedure- 6 experienced symptoms of exacerbation, 1 experienced transient ankle edema, 4 were uncomfortable from the needle insertions. The remaining 4 who dropped out, did not leave due to the acupuncture procedure. There was no difference in reason or rate of dropouts as to whether real or sham acupuncture was used. Also, dropouts did not differ from those who completed the study on any baseline measures. The experimental treatment consisted of 2 real electroacupuncture sessions (2-99Hz) 2 times per week for 3 weeks. The controlled treatments with sham acupuncture consisted of 2 sham electroacupuncture sessions, 2 times per week for 3 weeks. The study evaluated patients immediately after the 3-week course of therapy and did not have a long term follow up. A randomized controlled study was conducted in 1989 by Lautenschlager et al [2, 9] in 1989 in Basel, Switzerland. The experimental treatment consisted of 6 acupuncture treatments. The controlled treatments consisted of 6 sham acupuncture sessions with an inactive laser. The study evaluated patients immediately after the course of therapy and found that the 3 patients who had had the real acupuncture had significant improvement in 3 of the outcomes measured, compared to the placebo group who received the sham acupuncture. Outcome measurements showing improvement included pain intensity, (with the probability value as P = .03 based on the Wilcoxon test which is a test to see whether the values in two samples differ in size), localized pain (with the probability value as P = .009, Wilcoxon test) and pain threshold (with the probability value as P = .008, t test). Three-month follow up data was presented which included data from a nonrandomized pilot study. It was determined that no significant difference between acupuncture and the placebo group could be determined at a 3 month follow up. Chen et al [9,10] performed a high-quality randomized controlled study with a combination of low and high frequencies with electroacupuncture, consistent with laboratory data suggesting that optimal pain relief is achieved by combining low (2-4 Hz) and high (50-100 Hz) frequencies. The combined frequencies are believed to complement each other (ie, low-frequency acupuncture is associated with endorphin release and cumulative effects, and high-frequency acupuncture is associated with serotonin release and short-lived effects). For a syndrome such as fibromyalgia, where the cumulative as well as serotonergic effects are extremely helpful, the long term effects should be studied in order to sustain the outcome measurements related to the pain associated with this disorder. A prospective cohort study conducted by Sprott et al [3] in 1996 in Germany looked at 29 patients with fibromyalgia to examine whether the biochemical as well as clinical, indicators could be improved with the use of acupuncture. The mean age range of the patients was 48 years old. The mean duration of a fibromyalgia diagnosis was 6.1 years. The inclusion criteria for these patients were all under the American College of Rheumatology. After acupuncture, the outcome measures of pain relief, pain threshold, including sleep quality, improved (with a probability value of < .01, statistical test was non specific), as did the biochemical markers of serum serotonin and serum substance P. Sprott et al determined in the results that the biochemical improvements confirm the involvement of pain modulating molecules in fibromyalgia. This study had only an immediate follow up done. No other parameters of the treatment experiment were reported. Many patients with fibromyalgia often experiment with several different healing modalities as well as many pharmacological drugs. Antidepressants are often prescribed to patients with fibromyalgia. Passotti et al [4, 9] designed a prospective cohort study with multiple arms in 1990 in Italy utilizing three groups of fibromyalgia patients. One group received acupuncture alone. Another group received acupuncture plus Amitriptyline, an antidepressant. Yet another group received conventional physiatry. Equivalence between groups was neither intended or achieved; therefore, the study was classified as a prospective cohort study with multiple arms. Patients with the most severe fibromyalgia symptoms were placed in the acupuncture plus antidepressant group. Manual acupuncture alone was given every 5 days for 8-10 treatments in both the acupuncture alone group and the second group who received acupuncture plus Amitriptyline. After the treatments, the outcome measures of pain relief and tender points were statistically better in the acupuncture alone group and second group who received acupuncture plus the antidepressant (with a probability value of < .05, t-test) versus the conventional physiatry group. The treatments within the conventional physiatry group were not reported in this study. There was an immediate follow up as well as a 1, 3, 6 and 9-month summary. At the 6-month follow up, the acupuncture alone group continued to remain with better results (with a probability value of < .05, t-test) than the conventional physiatry group on the outcome measures of pain measurements as well as psychological measures of depression, hostility, anger and somatatization. At the 6-month follow up for the acupuncture plus the antidepressant (with a probability value of < .05, t-test) versus the conventional physiatry group, only significant improvement remained on the outcome measure of pain threshold, not on any psychological index. A variety of symptoms can often be associated with fibromyalgia patients. A group of 35 patients with a specific diagnosis of trapezius fibromyositis were studied by Radaelli et al. [5, 9] in Italy in a prospective cohort study in 1978. These 35 patients were given 5 sessions of electroacupuncture using between 50-70 Hz on alternate days. The mean age range between these patients was between 19-72 years old. All these patients had used different healing modalities as well as many pharmacological drugs, none of which were specified as to which drugs or which modalities were used on the past. After an average of 5 sessions of electroacupuncture, 29 (82.8%) patients received sufficient pain relief to terminate therapy. 3 (8.6%) patients received initial relief but later returned to therapy because of relapses. 2 (5.7%) patients reported only mild relief of symptoms while 1 (2.9%) reported no relief. The outcome measurements most improved were that of pain relief and range of motion. Follow up was only reported immediately after the study was complete. In 1977 at the Riverside Methodist Hospital in Ohio, Waylonis et al [6] performed a retrospective cohort study by sending out a postal survey to fibromyalgia patients whom had a variety of therapeutic modalities at their clinic. These modalities included acupuncture, medications, cortisone injections, physical therapy, whirlpool treatments, ultrasound, diathermy and manipulation. A total of 62 people were sent the survey poll and 39 patients responded. The mean age of the patients was 39 years old. Their mean length of follow up time at the completion of the survey poll was an average of 19.6 months. More than half of the survey responders had between 4-10 therapeutic modalities. Patients were asked to specify which therapeutic modalities (a) gave them the best results, (b) the longest lasting results, © the estimated duration of benefits and (d) the least results. Acupuncture was rated as providing the best and the longest pain relief by 29 (46%) of the responding patients. Patients were asked to evaluate the extent of the relief specifically from acupuncture. Here, 8 (20.5%) reported total relief, 18 (46.2%) reported partial relief of 50%-90% improvement, 5 (12.8%) patients reported borderline relief of 10%-40% improvement, 7 (17.9%) patients had no relief and 1 (2.6%) patient had aggravated symptoms. The duration of relief from acupuncture varied from less than a day, which was in 7 patients, to 10 months or longer which was seen in 6 patients. Collagen and muscle pathology in fibromyalgia patients has been looked at in several studies. There is some research suggesting that there is a disorder of collagen metabolism in fibromyalgia patients. The first of two studies I found, were conducted by Gronemann ST et al [7] in 2003. Their objective was to measure collagen concentration and search for muscle pathology in muscle non-tender-point areas from fibromyalgia patients. Muscle biopsies were obtained from m. vastus lateralis of 27 selected, female fibromyalgia patients, and from 8 age-matched female control subjects. Amino acids were determined by a high- performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) and electron microscopy was performed. The studied results showed patients had lower hydroxyproline and lower total concentration of the major amino acids of collagen than the control group. No significant difference was seen in the concentration of the major amino acids of myosin or of total protein. Electron microscopy showed no significant differences between fibromyalgia patients and controls although atrophied muscle fibrils occurred in fibromyalgia patients only, but frequencies were not significantly different. They determined that fibromyalgia patients had a significantly lower amount of intramuscular collagen. This may lower the threshold for muscle micro-injury and result in non-specific signs of muscle pathology. The second of these studies on collagen was researched by Sprott et al [8] to determine if abnormal collagen metabolism is a characteristic of fibromyalgia. Skin biopsies were taken from the trapezius area of 8 patients with fibromyalgia. All patients had the diagnosis of fibromyalgia according to the American College of Rheumatology criteria. Urine was collected under standardized conditions from 55 control subjects and 39 patients with fibromyalgia, and serum was obtained from 17 controls and 22 patients with fibromyalgia. Pyridinoline (Pyd), an indicator of connective tissue disease, and deoxypyridinoline (Dpyd), an indicator of bone degradation, both of which represent products of lysyl oxidase— mediated crosslinking in collagen, were analyzed by ion-paired and gradient high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) methods with fluorescence detection. Levels of hydroxyproline (Hyp), a collagen turnover marker, were also measured. The findings were related to creatinine levels, and the Pyd:Dpyd ratio was determined. Highly ordered cuffs of collagen were observed around the terminal nerve fibers by electron microscopic examination of biopsy tissue from all 8 patients with fibromyalgia, but were not observed in any of the control skin samples. The Pyd:Dpyd ratios in the urine and serum and the Hyp levels in the urine were significantly lower in patients with fibromyalgia than in the healthy control group. Summary The reviewed studies reveal that acupuncture is a therapeutic modality that has shown good benefits in the outcome measurements of pain relief for fibromyalgia. Electroacupuncture had shown even greater results with pain threshold, regional pain scoring and sleep quality. A combination of both high frequencies, associated with serotonin release - short-term effects and low frequencies, associated with endorphin release - cumulative effects is optimal for pain relief. The results of one high quality study suggest that real acupuncture is more effective than sham acupuncture. Further high quality studies need to be researched in order to show more long-term clinical benefits of acupuncture. Annotated Bibliography 1.Deluze C, Bosia L, Zirbs A, et al. Electroacupuncture in fibromyalgia: results of a controlled trial. BMJ 1992;305(6864):1249– 52. The real acupuncture group found significantly more relief than the sham acupuncture group based on 5 of 8 outcomes that were measured. The study evaluated patients immediately after the 3-week course of therapy and did not have a long term follow up. 2. Lautenschlager J, Schnorrengerger CC, Muller W. Fibromyalgia Syndrome. Dtsch ZschrAkup 1989; 6:122-8 The controlled treatments consisted of 6 sham acupuncture sessions with an inactive laser. The study evaluated patients immediately after the course of therapy and found that the 3 patients who had had the real acupuncture had significant improvement in 3 of the outcomes measured, compared to the placebo group who received the sham acupuncture. 3. Sprott H, Franke S, Kluge H, Hein G. Pain treatment of fibromyalgia by acupuncture. Rheumatol Int 1998;18:35–6. After acupuncture, the outcome measures of pain relief, pain threshold, including sleep quality, improved as did the biochemical markers of serum serotonin and serum substance P. Sprott et al determined in the results that the biochemical improvements confirm the involvement of pain modulating molecules in fibromyalgia. 4. Pasotti D, Montanarri E, Capobianchi B. Acupuncture and Primary Fibromyalgia Syndrome. G Ital Riflessot Agopunt 1990; 2:23-31 After the treatments, the outcome measures of pain relief and tender points were statistically better in the acupuncture alone group and second group who received acupuncture plus the antidepressant versus the conventional physiatry group. The treatments within the conventional physiatry group were not reported in this study. 5. Radaelli E, Buzzi GP. Treatments of Acupuncture for Trapezius Fibromyalgia. Min Med 1978; 69:3017-9 After an average of 5 sessions of electroacupuncture, 29 patients received sufficient pain relief to terminate therapy. 3 patients received initial relief but later returned to therapy because of relapses. 2 patients reported only mild relief of symptoms while 1 reported no relief. 6. Waylonis GW. Long-term follow-up on patients with fibrositis treated with acupuncture. Ohio State Med J 1977;73:299–302. Patients were asked to evaluate the extent of the relief specifically from acupuncture. Here, 8 reported total relief, 18 reported partial relief of 50%-90% improvement, 5 patients reported borderline relief of 10%-40% improvement, 7 (17.9%) patients had no relief and 1 patient had aggravated symptoms. The duration of relief from acupuncture varied from less than a day, which was in 7 patients, to 10 months or longer which was seen in 6 patients. 7. Gronemann ST, Ribel-Madsen S, Bartels EM, Danneskiold-Samsoe B, Bliddal H Collagen and muscle pathology in fibromyalgia patients. Rheumatology (Oxford). 2003 Jul 16 The Parker Institute, Department of Rheumatology, Frederiksberg Hospital, H:S University Hospital. Fibromyalgia patients had a significantly lower amount of intramuscular collagen. This may lower the threshold for muscle micro-injury and thereby result in non-specific signs of muscle pathology. 8. Haiko Sprott, Andreas Muller, and Hartmut Heine, Collagen Crosslinks In Fibromyalgia - Arthritis & Rheumatism, Lippincott- Raven Publishers Vol. 40, No. 8, August 1997, The American College of Rheumatology. Highly ordered cuffs of collagen were observed around the terminal nerve fibers by electron microscopic examination of biopsy tissue from all 8 patients with fibromyalgia, but were not observed in any of the control skin samples. The Pyd:Dpyd ratios in the urine and serum and the Hyp levels in the urine were significantly lower in patients with fibromyalgia than in the healthy control group. 9. Berman BM, Ezzo J, Hadhazy V, Swyers JP. Is acupuncture effective in the treatment of fibromyalgia? Complementary Medicine Program, University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore 21207, USA. J Fam Pract. 1999 Mar;48(3):213-8. The limited amount of evidence suggests that real acupuncture is more effective than sham acupuncture for improving symptoms of patients with fibromyalgia. However, because this conclusion is based on a single high-quality study, further high-quality randomized trials are needed to provide more data on effectiveness. 10. Chen XH, Guo SF, Chang CG, Han JS. Optimal conditions for eliciting maximal electroacupuncture analgesia with dense and disperse mode of stimulation. Am. Journal Acupuncture 1994; 22: 47- 57 Electroacupuncture had shown even greater results with pain threshold, regional pain scoring and sleep quality. A combination of both high frequencies, associated with serotonin release - short-term effects and low frequencies, associated with endorphin release - cumulative effects is optimal for pain relief. i. Fibromyalgia Syndromes. The Merck Manual of Medical Information-- Second Home Edition Sec 5, Ch.74 ii. Fybromyalgia -The American Academy of Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine. www.aaaom.org iii. Economic cost and epidemiological characteristics of patients with fibromyalgia claims. J Rheumatol. 2003 Jun;30(6):1318-25. Robinson RL, Birnbaum HG, Morley MA, Sisitsky T, Greenberg PE, Claxton AJ. Eli Lilly and Company, Indianapolis, Indiana, USA. PMID: 12784409 [PubMed - in process] iv. Pellegrino, Mark, MD; Prescribed Medications for Fibromyalgia: 2001 Mark J. Pellegrino, M.D., and Anadem Publishing, Inc. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.