Breast Cancer Treatment: Doctors admit chemo is wrong.

December 17, 2006

Less-toxic remedies gain in battle on breast cancerResearch sees promise in drug combinationshttp://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/chi-0612160200dec16,1,4416128.story?coll=chi-newsnationworld-hed & ctrack=1 & cset=trueBy Judy PeresTribune staff reporterPublished December 16, 2006 SAN ANTONIO -- New breast cancer findings support the idea that patients in the future may be treated with combinations of new, targeted medications that are kinder and gentler than conventional cancer drugs, researchers reported Friday.In one small study, women with advanced cancer that had already metastasized, or spread, to other parts of the body were given

two synthetic antibodies, Herceptin and Avastin, instead of the usual chemotherapy. More than half saw their tumors shrink dramatically, according to a paper presented at the annual San Antonio Breast Cancer Symposium. "The response rate was impressive for patients with metastatic breast cancer," said Dr. Mark Pegram of UCLA. "And they didn't lose their hair or develop anemia or suffer from nausea or vomiting."Pegram said that although most of the side effects were mild, investigators were carefully monitoring

cardiac safety after one patient developed heart problems. "It's not clear whether the heart problem is related to this treatment," he said, "but we're being careful."If the research proves successful, the next step likely will be to test the drug combination in earlier stages of breast cancer. Pegram said the approach could "open the door to all-biological therapies and allow us to get rid of chemo some day."Herceptin and Avastin are considered biological agents because they are antibodies to disease-causing proteins. Herceptin targets HER2, a protein that encourages cells to multiply out of control. Avastin inhibits VEGF, which stimulates the formation of blood vessels. When those two targets are shut down, tumors that depend on them cannot continue to grow."Combining different biological therapies is the wave of the future," said Dr. Harris Spiridonidis of Columbus, Ohio, who is not associated with the study. But he cautioned that the new agents

"are not innocent."With targeted therapies, which home in on cancer cells and spare most normal cells, "side effects are not common," he said, "but they can be devastating. Nausea passes after a few months. A stroke lasts for the rest of your life."Pegram's trial has included only 42 patients to date, so it's too early to draw firm conclusions. But it was just one of several studies presented at the influential four-day symposium that suggest a trend toward less-toxic treatment options.On Thursday researchers showed updated results of a large ongoing trial of Herceptin plus conventional chemo in women with early breast cancer. In the trial, chemotherapy was found to give patients the same life-prolonging benefit even if the chemo did not contain anthracyclines, a class of drugs known to cause heart problems.Another study Friday suggested that women with metastatic breast cancer may benefit from treatment with a combination of Avastin and

Xeloda, a pill that is much easier to tolerate than intravenous chemotherapy. Yet another raised the possibility that nine weeks of Herceptin treatment may be just as effective as the standard 52 weeks.More than 200,000 U.S. women are diagnosed with invasive breast cancer each year, and about 40,000 die of the disease. An estimated 20 to 25 percent of cases have extra copies of the HER2 gene, which makes the cancer especially aggressive.----------jperes 2006, Chicago Tribune "(Whatever situation we examine), the conclusion is in every case the same: that vaccination is a gigantic delusion; that it has never saved a single life; but that it has been the cause of so much disease, so many deaths,

such a vast amount of utterly needless and altogether undeserved suffering, that it will be classed by the coming generation among the greatest errors of an ignorant and prejudiced age, and its penal enforcement the foulest blot on the generally beneficent course of legislation during our century."-----Alfred Russel Wallace [book 1898] Vaccination A Delusion.