Guest guest Posted December 10, 2001 Report Share Posted December 10, 2001 In a message dated 12/9/01 3:43:40 PM Pacific Standard Time, mindy writes: > Hmm...I was under the impression that animals *do* stop to drink water. Any > of > you raise animals that can tell us for sure? Don't cows generally have to > live > near ponds & such? > > Hmm...I'm not exactly sure what you mean by " stop " to drink water? Unlike humans animals have no specific goals that requires them to face a fast-paced lifestyle, other than surviving and, yes, if water if provided they will drink when they feel the urge to do so. I don't claim to be an expert on animals but I do work in the field that enables me to be surrounded by them. The strongest instinct is to survive and water is one tool to that means. And on another note to Lynn. Thank you. I have never even heard of " wolfberries " until now. Thought it was quite interesting. Wonder if they might be implicated in Asian diets as a main food staple as heart disease seems to be much lower on the Eastern side of the globe. Kandi Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2001 Report Share Posted December 11, 2001 Let me repeat for the third time, that my comment about the water-drinking habits of the other animals besides humans, was that they did not stop in response to a natural urge, to drink water VERY OFTEN......I never suggested that they didn't stop to drink water. The notion that we ought to be drinking huge amounts of water, in divided doses, all day long, is extremely controversial. If, as some on this list have indicated, they are drinking around 160 ounces of water a day (approx. 20 cups of water), and did so in 4 oz. increments; they'd have to stop to drink water 40 times a day! - <kandi59274 Monday, December 10, 2001 5:10 AM Stopping To Drink Water -- And Wolfberries > In a message dated 12/9/01 3:43:40 PM Pacific Standard Time, > mindy writes: > > > > Hmm...I was under the impression that animals *do* stop to drink water. Any > > of > > you raise animals that can tell us for sure? Don't cows generally have to > > live > > near ponds & such? > > > > > > Hmm...I'm not exactly sure what you mean by " stop " to drink water? Unlike > humans animals have no specific goals that requires them to face a fast-paced > lifestyle, other than surviving and, yes, if water if provided they will > drink when they feel the urge to do so. I don't claim to be an expert on > animals but I do work in the field that enables me to be surrounded by them. > The strongest instinct is to survive and water is one tool to that means. > > And on another note to Lynn. Thank you. I have never even heard of > " wolfberries " until now. Thought it was quite interesting. Wonder if they > might be implicated in Asian diets as a main food staple as heart disease > seems to be much lower on the Eastern side of the globe. > > Kandi > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2001 Report Share Posted December 11, 2001 In a message dated 12/10/01 6:47:06 PM Pacific Standard Time, counterpnt writes: > The notion that we ought to be drinking huge amounts of water, in divided > doses, all day long, is extremely controversial. If, as some on this list > have indicated, they are drinking around 160 ounces of water a day (approx. > 20 cups of water), and did so in 4 oz. increments; they'd have to stop to > drink water 40 times a day! > Thank you for repeating. I did try to find the introduction on this topic but lost track somehow. I do agree with what you noted (above). I feel that drinking too much water that is not needed by the body is dangerous, even if done in divided doses. Over-hydrating the body upsets the sodium balance which can lead to death. Kandi Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2001 Report Share Posted December 11, 2001 In a message dated 11/12/01 17:32:27 GMT Standard Time, counterpnt writes: I think I may well try this as 'fasting' menu for a week every couple of months, it looks good. Marianne > fresh fruit, large amounts, and > maximum variety, of fresh vegetables in two large salads a day, a few oz's > of nuts and seeds, fresh celery and/or carrot (combined, if I wished, with > fresh juiced apple), and some steamed veggies, etc., Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2001 Report Share Posted December 11, 2001 Morning Kandi, >I do agree with what you noted (above). I feel that drinking too much water >that is not needed by the body is dangerous, even if done in divided doses. >Over-hydrating the body upsets the sodium balance which can lead to death. Your thinking parallels that of others. When I first started drinking more water than the normal amount....... Two nurses told me exactly the same thing. Several months after I started this, and observes a number of posititive changes, I had a blood analysis and my sodium was very near the top of the normal range. So..... here is what I told them. " You have underestimated the ability of the body to take care of itself " . And I think we all do that to some degree. The body is such a genius system, if it is given a half chance, it will accomplish miracles. However, even though I am doing differently than Johns thinking, I still agree with his logic which is exactly my observations relative to wild and domestic animals. Wayne Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2001 Report Share Posted December 11, 2001 Morning John, At 06:41 PM 12/10/2001 -0800, you wrote: >Let me repeat for the third time, that my comment about the water-drinking >habits of the other animals besides humans, was that they did not stop in >response to a natural urge, to drink water VERY OFTEN......I never suggested >that they didn't stop to drink water. I am glad you have the patience to tell us something " three times " . An old friend who was a scholar, defined a genius as " anyone whom you only have to tell something 3 times " . So.... maybe some of us fit that description. ( others call this thick-headed) >The notion that we ought to be drinking huge amounts of water, in divided >doses, all day long, is extremely controversial. If, as some on this list >have indicated, they are drinking around 160 ounces of water a day (approx. >20 cups of water), and did so in 4 oz. increments; they'd have to stop to >drink water 40 times a day! I know.... but some people stop and drink coffee and cokes 40 times per day. I don't have to stop 40 times because I drink water 16 and 20 ounces at a time. It may be hard to believe, but even though I drink much more than most people, I will still become thirsty, extremely thirsty. Very likely I have something wrong inside. Maybe some of those 24 and 30 inch worms are using up all my water. Protein uses up water in its digestions, does it not? Possibly the more protein one gets the more water he needs. In the distant past, I read something about a disorder that caused one to drink large amounts of water. One think for sure, I am open minded and don't claim my system to be correct and the only one that works. Within the last year, I have been able to grow all new toenails on one foot. A year ago, these were thick and fungus toenails. I take so much stuff, I have not a clue what was responsible for this. ( I suspect the protein drink, green food, and flaxoil ) The problem is, my new system of eating a few selected foods and avoiding others, seems to be working so well .... I am afraid to change anything. Some doctor stated that 1/3 of the food we eat keeps us alive, the other 2/3 is what keeps your doctor alive. So...... substitute the 2/3 with water..... Why not? Wayne Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2001 Report Share Posted December 11, 2001 The best health practitioner I've gone to in my life, placed me on a simple natural diet consisting of modest amounts of fresh fruit, large amounts, and maximum variety, of fresh vegetables in two large salads a day, a few oz's of nuts and seeds, fresh celery and/or carrot (combined, if I wished, with fresh juiced apple), and some steamed veggies, etc., in the evening. He told me, on one of my few visits to him, that if I tried to remain true to his general dietary suggestions, I'd be able to rely on my natural urge for water, and not have to coax myself to drink it. He didn't have much regard for supplements; but I believe his view in this matter, was unjustified. In any case, when I followed his diet, I experienced a level of well-being, strength and vitality, I didn't believe was possible. - " Wayne Fugitt " <wayne Tuesday, December 11, 2001 8:19 AM Re: Stopping To Drink Water -- And Wolfberries > Morning John, > > At 06:41 PM 12/10/2001 -0800, you wrote: > >Let me repeat for the third time, that my comment about the water-drinking > >habits of the other animals besides humans, was that they did not stop in > >response to a natural urge, to drink water VERY OFTEN......I never suggested > >that they didn't stop to drink water. > > I am glad you have the patience to tell us something " three times " . > > An old friend who was a scholar, defined a genius as " anyone whom you only > have to tell something 3 times " . > > So.... maybe some of us fit that description. ( others call this thick-headed) > > > >The notion that we ought to be drinking huge amounts of water, in divided > >doses, all day long, is extremely controversial. If, as some on this list > >have indicated, they are drinking around 160 ounces of water a day (approx. > >20 cups of water), and did so in 4 oz. increments; they'd have to stop to > >drink water 40 times a day! > > I know.... but some people stop and drink coffee and cokes 40 times per day. > > I don't have to stop 40 times because I drink water 16 and 20 ounces at a time. > > It may be hard to believe, but even though I drink much more than most > people, I will still become thirsty, extremely thirsty. > > Very likely I have something wrong inside. Maybe some of those 24 and 30 > inch worms are using up all my water. > > Protein uses up water in its digestions, does it not? Possibly the more > protein one gets the more water he needs. > > In the distant past, I read something about a disorder that caused one to > drink large amounts of water. > > One think for sure, I am open minded and don't claim my system to be > correct and the only one that works. > > Within the last year, I have been able to grow all new toenails on one > foot. A year ago, these were thick and fungus toenails. I take so much > stuff, I have not a clue what was responsible for this. ( I suspect the > protein drink, green food, and flaxoil ) > > The problem is, my new system of eating a few selected foods and avoiding > others, seems to be working so well .... I am afraid to change anything. > > Some doctor stated that 1/3 of the food we eat keeps us alive, the other > 2/3 is what keeps your doctor alive. > > So...... substitute the 2/3 with water..... Why not? > > Wayne Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2001 Report Share Posted December 11, 2001 - <kandi59274 Tuesday, December 11, 2001 8:51 AM Re: Stopping To Drink Water -- And Wolfberries > In a message dated 12/10/01 6:47:06 PM Pacific Standard Time, > counterpnt writes: > > > The notion that we ought to be drinking huge amounts of water, in divided > > doses, all day long, is extremely controversial. If, as some on this list > > have indicated, they are drinking around 160 ounces of water a day (approx. > > 20 cups of water), and did so in 4 oz. increments; they'd have to stop to > > drink water 40 times a day! > > > Thank you for repeating. I did try to find the introduction on this topic > but lost track somehow. > > I do agree with what you noted (above). I feel that drinking too much water > that is not needed by the body is dangerous, even if done in divided doses. > Over-hydrating the body upsets the sodium balance which can lead to death. > > Kandi > I carry a jug of water with me wherever I go. I have done so for the past 8 years. I find that by drinking water whenever I wanted (as opposed to drinking " thirst quenching " drinks every few hours) my general mood improved greatly. My water intake grew over the years. Last summer it was up to 2 gallons a day. But I discovered I had diabetes. Once I got my blood sugar levels under control, my water use dropped. I still carry my jug with me everywhere. I still like to take a slug or 2 of water 3-5 times an hour. But my daily consumption is down to about 70 ounces a day in winter. I suspect it will go up some in summer due to perspiration loss as I live in New Orleans where it is hot & I work outside at night. Alobar Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2001 Report Share Posted December 11, 2001 We need well designed research into this matter of how much water is desirable for people under varied circumstances. But the mere fact that people can grow accustomed to drinking water all day, doesn't mean any more, for all we know, than that they can grow accustomed to drinking booze all day long. Increased water consumption is probably called for in the case of certain disease conditions, but it may be a mistake in other circumstances. In any case, the actual need for water, on an individual basis, probably varies enormously. - " Alobar " <alobar Tuesday, December 11, 2001 10:38 AM Re: Stopping To Drink Water -- And Wolfberries > > - > <kandi59274 > > Tuesday, December 11, 2001 8:51 AM > Re: Stopping To Drink Water -- And Wolfberries > > > > In a message dated 12/10/01 6:47:06 PM Pacific Standard Time, > > counterpnt writes: > > > > > The notion that we ought to be drinking huge amounts of water, in > divided > > > doses, all day long, is extremely controversial. If, as some on this > list > > > have indicated, they are drinking around 160 ounces of water a day > (approx. > > > 20 cups of water), and did so in 4 oz. increments; they'd have to stop > to > > > drink water 40 times a day! > > > > > Thank you for repeating. I did try to find the introduction on this topic > > but lost track somehow. > > > > I do agree with what you noted (above). I feel that drinking too much > water > > that is not needed by the body is dangerous, even if done in divided > doses. > > Over-hydrating the body upsets the sodium balance which can lead to death. > > > > Kandi > > > > I carry a jug of water with me wherever I go. I have done so for > the past 8 years. I find that by drinking water whenever I wanted (as > opposed to drinking " thirst quenching " drinks every few hours) my general > mood improved greatly. My water intake grew over the years. Last summer > it was up to 2 gallons a day. But I discovered I had diabetes. Once I > got my blood sugar levels under control, my water use dropped. I still > carry my jug with me everywhere. I still like to take a slug or 2 of water > 3-5 times an hour. But my daily consumption is down to about 70 ounces a > day in winter. I suspect it will go up some in summer due to perspiration > loss as I live in New Orleans where it is hot & I work outside at night. > > Alobar > > > > > Getting well is done one step at a time, day by day, building health > and well being. > > To learn more about the Gettingwell group, > Subscription and list archives are at: > Gettingwell > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 11, 2001 Report Share Posted December 11, 2001 I love water, and drink between 3 liters to just over a gallon a day. I notice a huge difference on days when I don't drink much water. I do give attention to water soluble vitamins and electrolytes, making sure my diet is rich in nutrients. There's a lot of research out there regarding water, plus and minus. I couldn't imagine drinking any less, I just love it. To each his/her own. Ken >We need well designed research into this matter of how much water is >desirable for people under varied circumstances. But the mere fact that >people can grow accustomed to drinking water all day, doesn't mean any more, >for all we know, than that they can grow accustomed to drinking booze all >day long. Increased water consumption is probably called for in the case of >certain disease conditions, but it may be a mistake in other circumstances. >In any case, the actual need for water, on an individual basis, probably >varies enormously. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.